please help, im lost

  • Thread starter Thread starter theagnosticcath
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

theagnosticcath

Guest
right i have a question but the question comes at the end of a long story so please read this and bear with me

Me and my now ex girlfriend were coming up to our second year anniversary and well i don’t really know how we got this far but anyway. In December was our biggest fall out we properly hated each other well i say hate, i didn’t hate her but she hated me, 12 hours after we broke up she slept with someone (put the religion to the side for the moment this is purely about love) she then hoped into bed with another guy and then another guy, she went to see her family in America during late December and her ceiling caved in her flat so even though i knew what she had done i put my feelings aside and my time and helped out with the flat even when she wasn’t there, arranged for most things to get done.

She comes back from her holiday on december 31st and she then proceeded to tell me that she loved me, i was sneaky and knew this wasnt quite true so in the morning of the 1st of january i checked her phone (against my better judgment) and found lurid sex texts she had sent to one of the guys she had been sleeping with, the texts where sent while she was telling me she loved me, i forgave her because i loved her and i thought she loved me

in march i think it was the 17th we had a fight and i went in a mood and walked away, i came back and tried to repair it and we did, but because of the earlier incident above i checked her phone again and again there was texts sent that night while we had been fighting to one of the guys (same type of text), i forgave her as she said it would never happen again

Since January for her i had started trying to learn about catholicism as not only did i think that it could make me a better person, i thought it would bring me closer to her, i went to mass and i went to bible study (although mass did freak me out a couple of times i persisted) i made friends with people from the church because i thought it would make her happy. I’ve never had religion in my life properly before so to sit and actually open myself up was a big step for me and a big step for most people, i started praying and i have breifly started to worship, although i can’t accept mass yet, i have fully immersed myself into understanding what the church is about and i am in all honesty thinking of becoming catholic, not for her but because i want to and i know it will be of great benefit to my life and (maybe) my future generation

about 3 weeks ago i found on her facebook some messages of the same type as above with one of the guys from before, while i was away working in Inverness (we live in Edinburgh), i had been phoning her all that weekend because i had been missing her and i couldn’t wait to see her when i got home and she was acting as if everything was ok, i forgave her as she said it would never happen again

last night we had a fight, i told her it was over in a fit of anger, literally about 5 mins after i tried phoning her to say sorry, she wasn’t picking up her phone, she then turned off her phone so i went out my way to go to hers and sit and wait outside, i sat outside her flat for 3 and a half hours just waiting so i could say sorry, she turns up fondling another man, i left

after i left i went home and i emailed her work colleague about an incident that happened during january, she had faked getting pregnant with her work colleagues brother and then faked an abortion and i kept it quiet because i loved her and i knew that if i told anyone that would be her work over and she would effectively had to leave, i feel absolutely terrible about it, not so much the covering it up (if you loved someone as much as i loved her you would do ANYTHING to make it work) it’s the fact that now i have betrayed her trust and i have told her most deepest and darkest secret

i feel numb, i feel betrayed, i feel sick to my stomach but at the same time i want to apologize and i want to forgive

i quote from Mark 11:25
“And when you stand praying, if you hold anything against anyone, forgive him, so that your Father in heaven may forgive you your sins.”
and Micah 7 - 18:19
“Who is a God like you, who pardons sin and forgives the transgression of the remnant of his inheritance? You do not stay angry forever but delight to show mercy. You will again have compassion on us; you will tread our sins underfoot and hurl all our iniquities into the depths of the sea.”

I Haven’t been the perfect person through out relationship infact i was a horrible person for about a year, i had to learn that a relationship is give and take and you can’t just do what you want and i have, she was pregnant with our child, and when i found out everything became real and i ran away from the relationship, until i realised what an utter and complete fool i was, how anyone could do that is beyond me, but i done it and i came running back, it was 4 days of self reflecting on how much i was not an actual person but just this being, it’s not all about me, i have a relationship that meant more to me than anything in the world and a fruit of that relationship was already growing, how could i have been such a fool as to do that? I have opened up to something that i never knew existed in myself not acceptance of the lord but acceptance that religion is not just religion, it installs amazing values in everyday life and can bring a man back from the brink of no hope, it can change a person, it changed me for the better.

And before you ask She is a cradle catholic but she has lost her way and i will have to take some of the blame for that

So at the end of all this i ask one simple question

Do i forgive or just walk away?

thank you for taking time to read my post
 
Dear Agnostic (soon to be Catholic).

After reading your post I strongly believe you need to forgive her and walk away. Dating is about finding a spouse in which you enter into the sacramental bond of marriage. Your girfriend has a very serious problem with fidelity and it will not go away once you are married. So although you love her she is not right for you and will only cause you a lifetime of grief. There are many beautifu single Catholic women out there who would return your love and be faithful to you. You want to enter matrimony with a woman of strong mature faith and character who you can share your life and faith with. Please continue to persue God and His Church. Develop a strong devoted life to knowing Christ and reading scripture. Scripture is a type of sacrament because we meet Jesus real presense in scripture. It is scripture where God speaks to us and reveals himself to you on a personal level. Go to mass often and go through RCIA prayerfully and diligently with the intent to fully emerse yourself in God’s presense. Pray daily and often and ask God to help you find a wife and to help prepare you for the vocation of marriage. Then trust God that in His time he will bring it to pass and heal your wounds.

Peace,
David
 
Do i forgive or just walk away?
Both. Forgive her for hurting you, and then walk away. What you’ve described is a lifetime of relationship drama for the typical person; for you and your ex it’s only two years’ worth. Seriously, this relationship ain’t healthy. If what you’ve described is accurate, you’re both better off apart.

Good luck.
 
Hi there,

I was wondering what happened to you two, since the last time you were posting. I’m sorry things haven’t worked out.

I have to say I agree with the above: forgive her and walk away. Doing that doesn’t mean you hate her and hold a grudge. No- it means you are not a doormat. It sounds like she has serious issues with men and trust me, you don’t want to be having these kind of problems in your life. There are so many young women who would respect you and treat you well. Don’t settle for anything less.

I think it is great that you are seriously looking into the Catholic faith. It is not an easy step to make, but so, so worth it. (another convert here - never regretted it). I wish you all the best. God bless.
 
  1. And before you ask She is a cradle catholic but she has lost her way and i will have to take some of the blame for that
So at the end of all this i ask one simple question
  1. Do i forgive or just walk away?
thank you for taking time to read my post
Dear theagnosticcath,
  1. being Catholic does not guarantee holiness.
2 (a) Yes you need to forgive her - Ask The Almighty to help you - forgiveness in this case is a process, a daily battle, until you are healed within yourself. You will find that as your healing takes place, it becomes easier to lay aside memories and feelings until you come to a place in your life where you can look back and feel OK about all that’s happened.

2 (b) In order for this to take place you need to walk away!

(c) You need to confess, receive Gods forgiveness, your own forgiveness, and lay aside the past in order to receive the blessings of a new clear future.
 
I disagree with the others. I say forgive and RUN away.
 
she sounds like a person desperately in need of professional help. Even without the religious or moral proscriptions a woman who behaves this way is not well balanced. Encourag her to get it, but under no circumstances is she a candidate for a partner in any healthy relationship right now.
 
“After reading your post I strongly believe you need to forgive her and walk away.”

This.

There has been a lot of good advice given in this thread. If I may add, I was told that God answers prays in three ways: 1) yes, 2) not yet, or 3) I have something better for you.

I suggest you pray about this and hope for number 3.
 
Dear Friend,

I think you are mistaking need for love. This young lady is not loving you by repeatedly betraying you with other men. And you say you are quick to forgive her and pretend that these things never happened…but these are serious problems. She has been sexual with other men and shows no sign of stopping. There are consequences to that level of sin.

I think you need to do some very serious thinking about your future and whether this really is what you want for yourself. There are other people in the world, other than this individual. I believe that you should get some counseling for yourself, to see why you would still be willing to expose yourself to someone who has sex with other men out of revenge. You have broken up with her multiple times but as you describe it, you two are in a relationship of co-dependency, not love.

As far as the Catholic Church, place that in a separate category. If you can break your unhealthy relationship with this young woman, you may find that God is leading you toward His Church, and there you will find peace and solace. After all, when we get into these dependencies on people, what we are always yearning for is a closer relationship with God. Fill that hole with what fits inside it and you will no longer be driven into these destructive dramas.
 
Do not walk away. RUN!! As far and as fast as you can from this very distructive relationship. There is no way that this girl will ever make you a loving and faithful wife. She has major issues that you can’t fix, and no happiness will ever come from you two staying together. You will spend the rest of your life sneaking around checking her cell phone and email, wondering where she is, who she is with ,and what she is doing with some other guy. Some couples just bring out the worst, not the best in each other. Is she pregant now? I am unclear about that, but if she is, you have an obligation to support the child and be a positive father role model in their life. (In view of her history, I would demand a paternity test first). If you feel you are called to become Catholic, please keep up with your studies, you can get this behind you, and move on a better, wiser you. :o
 
Agnosticath,

Indeed, RUN! Don’t even look back. Forgive her shallowness as soon as you can (the sooner, the better), enjoy the single life, and find a nice girl at your new church.

When we say forgive, remember, it does not mean forget the wrongs another person did, it does not mean we are to act as a doormat for them. When we turn the other cheek, we are challenging the wrongdoer to ante up. So be honest with her (and more importantly yourself!), but move on with your life – you have better things to do, and you clearly deserve someone better.
 
OP, you were not clear about this, and sort of hid it within all of your other writing. I only went back and noticed it because another poster asked.

she was pregnant with our child, and when i found out everything became real and i ran away from the relationship, until i realised what an utter and complete fool i was,

Did you or did you not get her pregnant, is she pregnant now? What has happened to the baby? You need to tell us because it’s very important - if we tell you to get away from this young woman, and she’s pregnant with your baby, you can’t do that because you have a responsibility to the child. I do not think you should marry her, but you need to be responsible for your own child if she is pregnant.
 
OP, you were not clear about this, and sort of hid it within all of your other writing. I only went back and noticed it because another poster asked.

she was pregnant with our child, and when i found out everything became real and i ran away from the relationship, until i realised what an utter and complete fool i was,

Did you or did you not get her pregnant, is she pregnant now? What has happened to the baby? You need to tell us because it’s very important - if we tell you to get away from this young woman, and she’s pregnant with your baby, you can’t do that because you have a responsibility to the child. I do not think you should marry her, but you need to be responsible for your own child if she is pregnant.
Juliane, I missed that too. Enormous factor to be considered!

Thanks to you for noticing
it and for mentioning it!
 
Dear Friend,

I think you are mistaking need for love. This young lady is not loving you by repeatedly betraying you with other men. And you say you are quick to forgive her and pretend that these things never happened…but these are serious problems. She has been sexual with other men and shows no sign of stopping. There are consequences to that level of sin.

I think you need to do some very serious thinking about your future and whether this really is what you want for yourself. There are other people in the world, other than this individual. I believe that you should get some counseling for yourself, to see why you would still be willing to expose yourself to someone who has sex with other men out of revenge. You have broken up with her multiple times but as you describe it, you two are in a relationship of co-dependency, not love.

As far as the Catholic Church, place that in a separate category. If you can break your unhealthy relationship with this young woman, you may find that God is leading you toward His Church, and there you will find peace and solace. After all, when we get into these dependencies on people, what we are always yearning for is a closer relationship with God. Fill that hole with what fits inside it and you will no longer be driven into these destructive dramas.
Agree,

There are consequences to that level of sin. For yourself and for your children in marriage.
 
Dear Friend,

I think you are mistaking need for love. This young lady is not loving you by repeatedly betraying you with other men. And you say you are quick to forgive her and pretend that these things never happened…but these are serious problems. She has been sexual with other men and shows no sign of stopping. There are consequences to that level of sin.

I think you need to do some very serious thinking about your future and whether this really is what you want for yourself. There are other people in the world, other than this individual. I believe that you should get some counseling for yourself, to see why you would still be willing to expose yourself to someone who has sex with other men out of revenge. You have broken up with her multiple times but as you describe it, you two are in a relationship of co-dependency, not love.

As far as the Catholic Church, place that in a separate category. If you can break your unhealthy relationship with this young woman, you may find that God is leading you toward His Church, and there you will find peace and solace. After all, when we get into these dependencies on people, what we are always yearning for is a closer relationship with God. Fill that hole with what fits inside it and you will no longer be driven into these destructive dramas.
Agree,

There are consequences to that level of sin. For yourself and for her and for your children in marriage should you marry her.
 
Do you honestly think i would be doing this if she was pregnant, no, I’d suck it up and make it work for the child
The child would have been 4 months old and growing quite fast into a wee person, there is not a day goes by where i don’t think what could have been
 
Are you sure it was your kid to begin with brother? Did you have a test? By her resume that girl’s a wild cat. I wouldn’t be taking her words as truthful. If you had the test good if you didn’t you can’t possibly know for sure if the kid was yours or not. Probably she lied.

She used you to repair her flat, tried to marry a colleague of hers through fraud-pretending she was pregnant (if I understand the bit about she and her colleague correctly) and many other things you don’t know of surely! Plus all the men she slept with! I think she knows she has you hooked up and treats you as the guy she can go back to when she decides that she’s had enough of “having fun with other people”, needs things. In short she uses you and exploits the love you have for her to her own advantage. She’s in control and knows it!

Forgive her. And tell her “I forgive you for all the bs you’ve done to me now its over I’m moving on”. Whether you mean it or not to forgive her is irrelevant. She will feel taken aback to say the least. Like:“What? The guy is leaving ME?” Be superior. And show it to her! You are. If it were the other way round she wouldn’t have forgiven you for even looking at another woman. And then move on. What you really should do is FORGET HER!

You deserve better! Its a blessing. Maybe you don’t know that yet but losing such a woman is. In time you’ll laugh at all this and say:“Boy was I a fool to even fall in love with such a person”.

Trust me.

Stop thinking you have faults in this relationship. The faults are one-sided in this one and they’re all on her side!
 
Do you honestly think i would be doing this if she was pregnant, no, I’d suck it up and make it work for the child
The child would have been 4 months old and growing quite fast into a wee person, there is not a day goes by where i don’t think what could have been
What happened then, to the baby? Perhaps you feel guilty and that is why you can’t let her go?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top