POLL: Secular priest or traditional priest?

  • Thread starter Thread starter 7discerning7
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
7

7discerning7

Guest
Hi,

I recently found out from a priest friend that there are priests out there who like to dress secular and sing some secular songs (even starting their own all-priest rock band). Lets call them the secular priests.

Then there are the priests who prefer normal priest clothing as to secular, contemporary clothing. They love to sing songs for God — appealing to the youth of today or not. We’ll call them the traditional priests.

This question goes to members of all ages: What kind of priest do you prefer? Secular or traditional? Why?

Thanks!
7discerning7
 
Traditional.

You are either Hot or Cold for the faith, if you’re lukewarm, Jesus will spit you out!
 
Faithful, obedient and loyal and to the traditions and teachings of the Catholic Church is what all priests should be.
 
First, this question is very unfair- just because a priest dresses in “regular clothes” and likes rock music, it does not make him “less traditional”.

Second, you are using words incorrectly. About 80% of all priests are “secular”- meaning they do not belong to an Order (regular). They are attached to a diocese, and make promises of celibacy & obedience to their Bishop and his successors. This is what most of us are used to.

A “regular” priest who be someone who belongs to an Order (the Jesuits, Franciscans, Dominicans, etc.) The make solemn vows of poverty, celibacy (chastity) and obedience to their Superior.

As far as clothing is concerned, a “secular priest” is not regulated as to what he wears, unless he is performing a liturgical or para-liturgical function, and only if his Bishop has made such mandates.

I will never understand why people want to “pigeon hole” priests. We should be praying for them, not judging them. And we wonder why we have a vocations crisis in the US. :mad:
Hi,

I recently found out from a priest friend that there are priests out there who like to dress secular and sing some secular songs (even starting their own all-priest rock band). Lets call them the secular priests.

Then there are the priests who prefer normal priest clothing as to secular, contemporary clothing. They love to sing songs for God — appealing to the youth of today or not. We’ll call them the traditional priests.

This question goes to members of all ages: What kind of priest do you prefer? Secular or traditional? Why?

Thanks!
7discerning7
 
First, this question is very unfair- just because a priest dresses in “regular clothes” and likes rock music, it does not make him “less traditional”.

Second, you are using words incorrectly. About 80% of all priests are “secular”- meaning they do not belong to an Order (regular). They are attached to a diocese, and make promises of celibacy & obedience to their Bishop and his successors. This is what most of us are used to.

A “regular” priest who be someone who belongs to an Order (the Jesuits, Franciscans, Dominicans, etc.) The make solemn vows of poverty, celibacy (chastity) and obedience to their Superior.

As far as clothing is concerned, a “secular priest” is not regulated as to what he wears, unless he is performing a liturgical or para-liturgical function, and only if his Bishop has made such mandates.

**I will never understand why people want to “pigeon hole” priests. We should be praying for them, not judging them. And we wonder why we have a vocations crisis in the US. **:mad:
AND want to criticize priests constantly – he may have brought a coffee cup out of the confessional, he accidentally skipped one word in the absolution, he sings secular songs . . .

What clothes a priest wears doesn’t prove what kind of person he is. Kind of like the rest of us, you know?
 
First, this question is very unfair- just because a priest dresses in “regular clothes” and likes rock music, it does not make him “less traditional”.

Second, you are using words incorrectly. About 80% of all priests are “secular”- meaning they do not belong to an Order (regular). They are attached to a diocese, and make promises of celibacy & obedience to their Bishop and his successors. This is what most of us are used to.

A “regular” priest who be someone who belongs to an Order (the Jesuits, Franciscans, Dominicans, etc.) The make solemn vows of poverty, celibacy (chastity) and obedience to their Superior.

As far as clothing is concerned, a “secular priest” is not regulated as to what he wears, unless he is performing a liturgical or para-liturgical function, and only if his Bishop has made such mandates.

I will never understand why people want to “pigeon hole” priests. We should be praying for them, not judging them. And we wonder why we have a vocations crisis in the US. :mad:
👍
 
AND want to criticize priests constantly – he may have brought a coffee cup out of the confessional, he accidentally skipped one word in the absolution, he sings secular songs . . .

What clothes a priest wears doesn’t prove what kind of person he is. Kind of like the rest of us, you know?
Unfortunately, that’s what a lot of posts seem to be about lately. I worry that sort of thing can cause confusion and doubt to those non-Catholics looking at the site, let alone those Catholics on here who already have doubts.
 
First, this question is very unfair- just because a priest dresses in “regular clothes” and likes rock music, it does not make him “less traditional”.

Second, you are using words incorrectly. About 80% of all priests are “secular”- meaning they do not belong to an Order (regular). They are attached to a diocese, and make promises of celibacy & obedience to their Bishop and his successors. This is what most of us are used to.

A “regular” priest who be someone who belongs to an Order (the Jesuits, Franciscans, Dominicans, etc.) The make solemn vows of poverty, celibacy (chastity) and obedience to their Superior.

As far as clothing is concerned, a “secular priest” is not regulated as to what he wears, unless he is performing a liturgical or para-liturgical function, and only if his Bishop has made such mandates.

I will never understand why people want to “pigeon hole” priests. We should be praying for them, not judging them. And we wonder why we have a vocations crisis in the US. :mad:
Agreed! 👍

Jim
 
Unfortunately, that’s what a lot of posts seem to be about lately. I worry that sort of thing can cause confusion and doubt to those non-Catholics looking at the site, let alone those Catholics on here who already have doubts.
It once again has to do with the ego-identity which is attached to religion. The religion must conform to the ego’s demands because it’s an identity which individual is presenting to others. A perception of being less Catholic equals less ego driven image being sought.

It has little to do with growing toward union with Jesus Christ.

Jim
 
First, this question is very unfair- just because a priest dresses in “regular clothes” and likes rock music, it does not make him “less traditional”.

Second, you are using words incorrectly. About 80% of all priests are “secular”- meaning they do not belong to an Order (regular). They are attached to a diocese, and make promises of celibacy & obedience to their Bishop and his successors. This is what most of us are used to.

A “regular” priest who be someone who belongs to an Order (the Jesuits, Franciscans, Dominicans, etc.) The make solemn vows of poverty, celibacy (chastity) and obedience to their Superior.

As far as clothing is concerned, a “secular priest” is not regulated as to what he wears, unless he is performing a liturgical or para-liturgical function, and only if his Bishop has made such mandates.

I will never understand why people want to “pigeon hole” priests. We should be praying for them, not judging them. And we wonder why we have a vocations crisis in the US. :mad:
Yeah!! :yup:
 
First, this question is very unfair- just because a priest dresses in “regular clothes” and likes rock music, it does not make him “less traditional”.

Second, you are using words incorrectly. About 80% of all priests are “secular”- meaning they do not belong to an Order (regular). They are attached to a diocese, and make promises of celibacy & obedience to their Bishop and his successors. This is what most of us are used to.

A “regular” priest who be someone who belongs to an Order (the Jesuits, Franciscans, Dominicans, etc.) The make solemn vows of poverty, celibacy (chastity) and obedience to their Superior.

As far as clothing is concerned, a “secular priest” is not regulated as to what he wears, unless he is performing a liturgical or para-liturgical function, and only if his Bishop has made such mandates.

I will never understand why people want to “pigeon hole” priests. We should be praying for them, not judging them. And we wonder why we have a vocations crisis in the US. :mad:
Could not agree more. This is simply a GOTCHA type question that shows what happens when someone throws terminology about and buzzwords just to get a reaction.

From my observation there have been a great amount of threads recently that seem to leave a “nasty taste” in my mouth of let’s play “let’s catch the priest” doing something, no matter how small (coffee cup in the confessional is a perfect example) and try to nail this priest to the wall.

These questions are not, “oh, I just want to know”… in my eyes they have an agenda to disparage priests
 
Yeah, OP, as others have pointed out, there’s a problem with your question, in that the term “Secular” priest already has a definition within the church that Catholics shoud be aware of, a Secular priest is any priest, traditional clothing or not, who belongs to a Diocese or other institution that doesn’t profess any Solemn religious vows. For example the FSSP is a fraternity of priests who dress in cassock and offer the traditional latin mass and other EF rites, but they’re considered secular priests. So you might want to reword your question.
 
First, this question is very unfair- just because a priest dresses in “regular clothes” and likes rock music, it does not make him “less traditional”.

Second, you are using words incorrectly. About 80% of all priests are “secular”- meaning they do not belong to an Order (regular). They are attached to a diocese, and make promises of celibacy & obedience to their Bishop and his successors. This is what most of us are used to.

A “regular” priest who be someone who belongs to an Order (the Jesuits, Franciscans, Dominicans, etc.) The make solemn vows of poverty, celibacy (chastity) and obedience to their Superior.

As far as clothing is concerned, a “secular priest” is not regulated as to what he wears, unless he is performing a liturgical or para-liturgical function, and only if his Bishop has made such mandates.

I will never understand why people want to “pigeon hole” priests. We should be praying for them, not judging them. And we wonder why we have a vocations crisis in the US. :mad:
Hello,

I understand your viewpoint of my first post on this thread. I’m sorry if I had misworded some things. When I said “secular”, I had meant to describe youth today who dress like “wannabes” and “emos”.

I am not judging them. I am simply asking a question from members of CAF what kind of priest they’d prefer and why.

I’m sure we all pray for priests and I’m sure that most people don’t judge them. Most people that I know (including me) pray for more vocations and don’t judge.

-7discerning7
 
Could not agree more. This is simply a GOTCHA type question that shows what happens when someone throws terminology about and buzzwords just to get a reaction.

From my observation there have been a great amount of threads recently that seem to leave a “nasty taste” in my mouth of let’s play “let’s catch the priest” doing something, no matter how small (coffee cup in the confessional is a perfect example) and try to nail this priest to the wall.

These questions are not, “oh, I just want to know”… in my eyes they have an agenda to disparage priests
Hello,

Again, I apologize. I hope you understand that it was my mistake for wording things differently-I just couldn’t think of another word o use instead of “secular” and “traditional”.

That is NOT my agenda. I would just like to know what kind of priest (if its okay to put it that way) CAF members prefer.

-7discerning7
 
Yeah, OP, as others have pointed out, there’s a problem with your question, in that the term “Secular” priest already has a definition within the church that Catholics shoud be aware of, a Secular priest is any priest, traditional clothing or not, who belongs to a Diocese or other institution that doesn’t profess any Solemn religious vows. For example the FSSP is a fraternity of priests who dress in cassock and offer the traditional latin mass and other EF rites, but they’re considered secular priests. So you might want to reword your question.
Yes, thank you. I didn’t know that there was such a term already being used in the Church.
Thank you very much for letting me know that nicely.
I couldn’t think of another way to rephrase my question. 🤷
 
That is NOT my agenda. I would just like to know what kind of priest (if its okay to put it that way) CAF members prefer.

-7discerning7
I would bet that, in general, CAF members prefer holy, knowledgeable, faithful priests. And you can’t tell that by how they dress or whether they like to sing secular music. 🙂
 
I would bet that, in general, CAF members prefer holy, knowledgeable, faithful priests. And you can’t tell that by how they dress or whether they like to sing secular music. 🙂
Thank you.

I too cannot tell by how they dress but I’d like to know from other CAF members what kind of priest they’d like basing on what they already know about a priest. I was just using how they dress as an example.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top