Polygamy;tell me why some men go for it

  • Thread starter Thread starter odhiambo
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
O

odhiambo

Guest
All our locals today is carrying the story of the death of this man called Ancentus Akuku Ogwela, nicknamed Akuku Danger .Why he is allover the newspapers is that he is a polygamist , and what a polygamist! He left behind 46 widows and hundreds of children.
At one point in his long life he claimed he had 130 wives. His elder son says the exact number of children sired by his father is not known. In 1999 he had 110 sons and 305 daughters with 150 of them having born children.
All this information is from “The Star” of Monday October 4, 2010 Page 9
Question.
If polygamy was allowed , as indeed it was in the Old Covenant, would you go for it and why? I would really love to understand this.
Thank you.
 
Jesus,our Lords peace be whit You.
It is a good question. I think that,and I am man,divoced happily,that some of us can love many whit equal ammount of love and affection and even be good spouses. I see no other ansver. One thing I have never heard or seen,and that makes my wonder,is it only men that do it.
Blessings,Totterman
 
God forbid! One wife - trouble. Two wives - double trouble! :eek: 😃

OK, that was a half-joke. But I am reminded of the passage in the Gospel where the Apostles realize that, given the serious obligations of marriage, chiefly among them being the indissolubility of marriage, it is not worth for someone to get married. To which Jesus replies, not everyone can take this teaching. But let the one who can, take it. So, if you are going to get married for a lifetime, and not the way some Muslims do it, who can easily divorce their wives (in Malaysia, they can let them go by a text message on the cellphone, when they find a younger and more exciting hottie, and when they lose interest in their current wife, that’s how their Sharia law is applied) - if marriage is truly indissoluble, I’m not sure that having multiple wives is such a great idea, on the practical level.

When I was working as an assistant at a university, we had many Muslim students from all over the world, including the Arabic countries, Pakistan, India, African countries (Sudan, Nigeria etc) and so on. I remember discussing the issue with an Arabic student. He told me, the reason why they can have four wives is that your one wife may not always be willing or able to sleep with you. Then, if you desire to have more sex than would be possible with a single wife, the way to go is polygamy. :o Just out of politeness (he brought up the whole issue, and I didn’t feel like confronting him) I didn’t ask him, “What if your wife wants to have more sex? Can she take multiple husbands?”

In the New Testament, where we understand that Jesus established one, holy, Catholic, and apostolic Church, and also that marriage between man and wife is a reflection of the covenant between Jesus Christ and his Church, I think there’s no wiggle room left for polygamy, from the theological side. Since Christ’s bride is the Church, and Christ only established one Church, a man should also take only one wife in order to mirror, through his marriage, the relationship between Christ and his Church.
 
I can see why some men would go for it; lust. Seriously, could Solomon really have loved all those wives? Along with his concubines he would never have really gotten to know any of them on any meaningful level.
 
Jesus,our Lords peace be whit You.
It is a good question. I think that,and I am man,divoced happily,that some of us can love many whit equal ammount of love and affection and even be good spouses. I see no other ansver. One thing I have never heard or seen,and that makes my wonder,is it only men that do it.
Blessings,Totterman
Thankyou, Totterman for your frank opinion.
So one reason I now have is that some men can" love" many women equally without feeling that special love for one particular woman.
 
God forbid! One wife - trouble. Two wives - double trouble! :eek: 😃

OK, that was a half-joke. But I am reminded of the passage in the Gospel where the Apostles realize that, given the serious obligations of marriage, chiefly among them being the indissolubility of marriage, it is not worth for someone to get married. To which Jesus replies, not everyone can take this teaching. But let the one who can, take it. So, if you are going to get married for a lifetime, and not the way some Muslims do it, who can easily divorce their wives (in Malaysia, they can let them go by a text message on the cellphone, when they find a younger and more exciting hottie, and when they lose interest in their current wife, that’s how their Sharia law is applied) - if marriage is truly indissoluble, I’m not sure that having multiple wives is such a great idea, on the practical level.

When I was working as an assistant at a university, we had many Muslim students from all over the world, including the Arabic countries, Pakistan, India, African countries (Sudan, Nigeria etc) and so on. I remember discussing the issue with an Arabic student. He told me, the reason why they can have four wives is that your one wife may not always be willing or able to sleep with you. Then, if you desire to have more sex than would be possible with a single wife, the way to go is polygamy. :o Just out of politeness (he brought up the whole issue, and I didn’t feel like confronting him) I didn’t ask him, “What if your wife wants to have more sex? Can she take multiple husbands?”

In the New Testament, where we understand that Jesus established one, holy, Catholic, and apostolic Church, and also that marriage between man and wife is a reflection of the covenant between Jesus Christ and his Church, I think there’s no wiggle room left for polygamy, from the theological side. Since Christ’s bride is the Church, and Christ only established one Church, a man should also take only one wife in order to mirror, through his marriage, the relationship between Christ and his Church.
Thank you Joseph for your candid reply.
But IF it was allowed by the Church to have many wives, would YOU go for it and if yes, then what would be your reasons
 
All our locals today is carrying the story of the death of this man called Ancentus Akuku Ogwela, nicknamed Akuku Danger .Why he is allover the newspapers is that he is a polygamist , and what a polygamist! He left behind 46 widows and hundreds of children.
At one point in his long life he claimed he had 130 wives. His elder son says the exact number of children sired by his father is not known. In 1999 he had 110 sons and 305 daughters with 150 of them having born children.
All this information is from “The Star” of Monday October 4, 2010 Page 9
Question.
If polygamy was allowed , as indeed it was in the Old Covenant, would you go for it and why? I would really love to understand this.
Thank you.
Absolutely not! Even if allowed by the Church, the practical reasons alone would be enough to scare me away from the idea, especially in today’s society. Forgetting for the moment the love that only occurs within a monogamous relationship, can one ever be wealthy enough to support 100 wives plus children? What about the child support and alimony which will certainly occur when wives leave due to the competition which would certainly come about? Special occasions like birthdays and anniversaries will have little or no meaning since they would be happening weekly if not daily. And one mustn’t forget… and guys, you know what I am talking about… football on Sundays will most certainly be interrupted! And you know how much you enjoy having to go to the mall “clothes shopping”… multiply that by 50!!! And I don’t care how big a man’s ego is, there is no possible way to keep 10, 20, 30 or more women happy.

All kidding aside, I would think that a man who was married to many wives would find the arrangement extremely lonely. Even if he sincerely attempted to love each and every one of them the way they deserved to be loved. The women would certainly feel like they were being robbed of a REAL relationship and no one would be happy.

This comes from a man who was unable to meet the expectations of a single wife and now finds himself divorced and in the middle of the annulment process.
 
All our locals today is carrying the story of the death of this man called Ancentus Akuku Ogwela, nicknamed Akuku Danger .Why he is allover the newspapers is that he is a polygamist , and what a polygamist! He left behind 46 widows and hundreds of children.
At one point in his long life he claimed he had 130 wives. His elder son says the exact number of children sired by his father is not known. In 1999 he had 110 sons and 305 daughters with 150 of them having born children.
All this information is from “The Star” of Monday October 4, 2010 Page 9
Question.
If polygamy was allowed , as indeed it was in the Old Covenant, would you go for it and why? I would really love to understand this.
Thank you.
why do men go for it? not all men are for it. but the ones that are in my opinion can never stay faithful to one person for life. they are oversexed, and want a variety of women so they don’t get bored. thats my 2 cents worth on plygamist type men. its a sin for them to have more than one wife, and its also adultery. :mad:
 
I can see why some men would go for it; lust. Seriously, could Solomon really have loved all those wives? Along with his concubines he would never have really gotten to know any of them on any meaningful level.
I agree Nameless. This is why I am trying to get at the real reason why polygamy seems to be "alive and well " in many societies.
The two reasons that have emerged so far is:
1: A man is able to love many women equally.
2: A man may need to have more sex than one woman is able to cope with.
Let us wait for other reasons. .
 
Absolutely not! Even if allowed by the Church, the practical reasons alone would be enough to scare me away from the idea, especially in today’s society. Forgetting for the moment the love that only occurs within a monogamous relationship, can one ever be wealthy enough to support 100 wives plus children? What about the child support and alimony which will certainly occur when wives leave due to the competition which would certainly come about? Special occasions like birthdays and anniversaries will have little or no meaning since they would be happening weekly if not daily. And one mustn’t forget… and guys, you know what I am talking about… football on Sundays will most certainly be interrupted! And you know how much you enjoy having to go to the mall “clothes shopping”… multiply that by 50!!! And I don’t care how big a man’s ego is, there is no possible way to keep 10, 20, 30 or more women happy.

All kidding aside, I would think that a man who was married to many wives would find the arrangement extremely lonely. Even if he sincerely attempted to love each and every one of them the way they deserved to be loved. The women would certainly feel like they were being robbed of a REAL relationship and no one would be happy.

This comes from a man who was unable to meet the expectations of a single wife and now finds himself divorced and in the middle of the annulment process.
Very pertinent points you have brought out Tietjen, especially about the financial constraints that is bound to arise. Maybe someone will come up with a solution to that.One thing is for sure. You would not go for polygamy.
Thank you for your post
 
why do men go for it? not all men are for it. but the ones that are in my opinion can never stay faithful to one person for life. they are oversexed, and want a variety of women so they don’t get bored. thats my 2 cents worth on plygamist type men. its a sin for them to have more than one wife, and its also adultery. :mad:
Thank You MerryCatholic for your opinion.
 
All
If polygamy was allowed , as indeed it was in the Old Covenant, would you go for it and why? I would really love to understand this.
Thank you.
society at least in the US already has de facto polygamy enabled and even encouraged by family law and the welfare system. Even in CCD, with the supposedly “good Catholic families” at least half the children are in families where the mothers have children by more than one father who is still living. The culture promotes and the law enables men to have several concurrent or serial “relationships” with different women, and women likewise with several men, and let the fate of the children rest on the goodwill of the next unrelated adult who hooks up with their parent. The cases of prominent sports figures who have relationships and children with multiple women are highly publicized acknowledgment of a settled fact in our culture which is indeed a scandal and incidentally a direct cause of poverty among women and children.
 
I can think of several reasons, depending on the nature of the society in question.

In a society where having many children was advantageous. Where large families prospered - so one where a lot of labour was important.

In some cases having many wives could be a sign of wealth and or power.

If we believe that many men are inclined to have multiple partners, being married to them could actually help ensure that they are well cared for, as are the resulting children.

In a society where women outnumber men, and social groups are small and travel restricted, it could result in more genetic variation, and would mean each woman would have a husband to care for her.

I think it is important to remember that historically, even in the Christian world, relationships between spouses could often be more “professional” than anything else. Yes, some were very loving, but not all, and most were probably not terribly romantic. One could argue that romance is not as good an indication that a marriage will be successful as a professional attitude.

None of which is to say that I believe in polygamy as a Christian, but I don’t find it totally far out and impossible to understand.
 
I can think of several reasons, depending on the nature of the society in question.

In a society where having many children was advantageous. Where large families prospered - so one where a lot of labour was important.

In some cases having many wives could be a sign of wealth and or power.

If we believe that many men are inclined to have multiple partners, being married to them could actually help ensure that they are well cared for, as are the resulting children.

In a society where women outnumber men, and social groups are small and travel restricted, it could result in more genetic variation, and would mean each woman would have a husband to care for her.

I think it is important to remember that historically, even in the Christian world, relationships between spouses could often be more “professional” than anything else. Yes, some were very loving, but not all, and most were probably not terribly romantic. One could argue that romance is not as good an indication that a marriage will be successful as a professional attitude.

None of which is to say that I believe in polygamy as a Christian, but I don’t find it totally far out and impossible to understand.
Thank you Bluegoat.From your reply I take it that as you see it, romantic love is most probably lacking in a polygamous relationship. Practical considerations taking centre stage.
 
I think this is a simple divide among humans…

Those who believe we are *just *animals and not created in the image of God. If you look at the farming communities, a farmer will buy one bull to breed many cows. He will buy one Stallion to breed many mares. >> So to think like an animal why not have one man with many wives…

To think like God, man is to love one wife as Christ loved the Church.
 
I think this is a simple divide among humans…

Those who believe we are *just *animals and not created in the image of God. If you look at the farming communities, a farmer will buy one bull to breed many cows. He will buy one Stallion to breed many mares. >> So to think like an animal why not have one man with many wives…

To think like God, man is to love one wife as Christ loved the Church.
Hi Will. You mean something like " the new cow" theory in the movie “someone like you”?
I see your point. Thanks for your opinion.
 
Do I understand the appeal? Sure! A certain portion of me loves the idea. But it’s the same portion of me that wants to eat the WHOLE bag of cookies instead of two, watch TV all day Saturday instead of just an hour as a break, to have the latest gadgets and fast cars, etc… I’ve learned that part of me ain’t too helpful! 😊

The downsides aren’t practical. A polygamist family could navigate this modern world quite well. Imagine if they were a man with three wives and each wife had two kids. If that meant three professional incomes and one full time stay at home mom, they could afford quite a nice three wing home comfortably (visit parts of Utah for example!)

The downsides are spiritual. Without the exclusivity, there is no true intimacy. Men are fools to give that up just to get three times the bedroom attentions.
 
Thank you Joseph for your candid reply.
But IF it was allowed by the Church to have many wives, would YOU go for it and if yes, then what would be your reasons
No, I wouldn’t go for it, even if it was allowed. To me, on an emotional level, marriage is a whole different category, different than, let’s say, friendship or the love for children. I have a few (more than 5) very good friends, and I do not feel that my friendships suffer from the fact that I have more than 1 friends. Likewise, I have 2 nephews/nieces (1 nephew plus 1 niece), and I don’t feel like my love for them is diminished compared to the hypothetical scenario of having only one nephew or niece to love. Also, I have a sister, and I feel like our mother loves both of us fully. It’s not like my mom loves me less, because she has two children to love, instead of one. But, when it comes to marriage, frankly I don’t think that I would be able to love two women at the same time. If I would choose to marry, I would marry one (1) woman, and give all my love, care, and affection to her. No place for a second woman in the equation of marriage - at least as far as I am concerned.
 
Thank you Bluegoat.From your reply I take it that as you see it, romantic love is most probably lacking in a polygamous relationship. Practical considerations taking centre stage.
Well, I don’t think one could have a romance with more than one wife at a time. But I may be wrong about that - it can be hard to imagine beyond one’s own experience of such things. My point was more that romance is not really a necessary part of marriage, or even a common one really.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top