Pope Benedict XVI's Decision - An Orthodox Perspective

  • Thread starter Thread starter ByzCathCantor
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

ByzCathCantor

Guest
An interesting commentary, and there are sure to be others:

Metropolitan Hilarion of Volokolamsk comments on reports about Pope
Benedict XVI’s retirement
Print This Post

11.02.2013 · Inter-Christian relations, DECR Chairman

On February 11, 2013, the chairman of the Moscow Patriarchate’s
department for external church relations, Metropolitan Hilarion of
Volokolamsk, made comments to ITAR-TASS news agency concerning that
coming reports about the retirement of the head of the Roman Catholic
Church, Pope Benedict XVI.

Reports about the retirement of Pope Benedict XVI have proved to be
unexpected even for his closest associates. Cardinal Sodano described
it as ‘a thunder out of a clear sky’. Really, there have been no
precedents of this kind in the modern history of the Roman Catholic
Church. Pope John Paul II remained in office to the end despite his
serious health problems.

Meanwhile, the office of the Roman Pontiff, just as that of any head
of a Church, presupposes active work. It is not a ceremonial office.
If one’s age and health prove to be an obstacle for effective work,
the head of a Church may decide to retire. In recent years, the
Catholic Church has come to face very serious challenges which require
new incentives to come from the See of Rome. Perhaps, precisely this
has made the pope to give way to a younger and more dynamic prelate to
be elected by the conclave of cardinals. The Pope Benedict XVI’s
decision to leave his office in the present situation may be seen as
an act of personal courage and humbleness.

We are grateful to Pope Benedict XVI for his understanding of the
problems which impede the full normalization of Orthodox-Catholic
relations, especially in such regions as western Ukraine. Only
yesterday I spoke about Pope Benedict XVI in my talk on Russia-24 TV
network with the new Russian ambassador to the Holy See, A. A.
Avdeyev. I pointed out that relations between the Russian Orthodox
Church and the Roman Catholic Church have acquired positive dynamic
after his ascension to the See of Rome. He enjoys great respect in the
Christian world. He is a prominent theologian, who is well versed in
the tradition of the Orthodox Church while having the sensitivity that
makes it possible for him to build relations with Orthodox Church on
due level.

My personal meetings and talks with Pope Benedict XVI remain memorable
for me. There have been three meetings since I was appointed chairman
of the DECR. In my talks with the pontiff I was always amazed by his
calm and thoughtful reaction, his sensitivity to issues we raised, his
desire to solve together the problems arising in our relations.
Specifically, I set forth in detail to the pope my vision of the
problems we have encountered in pan-Orthodox – Catholic dialogue (I
made a report about these problems to the recent Bishops’ Council, and
it made appropriate decisions). My attitude to the progress of this
dialogue is very critical, which I frankly stated to the pope and he
always showed understanding.

Even before his ascension to the See of Rome, Cardinal Ratzinger
declared war on ‘the dictatorship of relativism’ so typical for the
Western society today. It immediately made him unpopular in the eyes
of secular politicians and journalists. Pope Benedict XVI is not a
media star. He is a man of the Church. In the mass media, he is
continuously criticized for traditionalism and conservatism, but
precisely these merits of his are of credit for millions of
Christians, both Catholic and non-Catholic, those who seek to preserve
traditional Christian spiritual and moral values.

It remains only to hope that his successor will continue walking along
the same path and that Orthodox-Catholic relations will continue
developing progressively for the common good of the whole Christendom.

DECR Communication Service
 
An interesting commentary, and there are sure to be others:
👍

Wonderful, and not unexpected, affirmation from Metropolitan Hilarion of HH Benedict XVI.

Also from the Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew.

I know many of our Orthodox brother and sisters share our sadness for the end of this pontificate. Pope Benedict has moved forward relations between our Churches in so many ways. May this movement forward continue.
 
I’m glad you posted this since I’m sick of reading other articles using this opportunity to negatively publicize the Church. This was a breath of fresh air.
 
Its very sad. But he obviously cannot do it anymore. He said he looked at his own conscience, so he must have seen that he could not live up to what he thought he should do as Pope. We should all continue to pray for him. I read he will be going to a cloistered Monastery after his resignation. He will surely be very missed. 😦
 
Its very sad. But he obviously cannot do it anymore. He said he looked at his own conscience, so he must have seen that he could not live up to what he thought he should do as Pope. We should all continue to pray for him. I read he will be going to a cloistered Monastery after his resignation. He will surely be very missed. 😦
:amen: I agree, Papa B16 will definitely be missed!
 
I don’t think that it’s okay to criticize the previous Pope for NOT resigning in an effort to support the perfectly legal decision of Pope Benedict.

But that’s just me.
 
His desire for dialogue towards reunion has been a breath of fresh air in East/West relations, and we pray for a like minded successor. I hope he continues to write, as I have enjoyed a number of his books. How about a successor from one of the Eastern Churches?
 
I’d say this is an excellent summation by the good metropolitan. I do hope that Pope Benedict continues to write. I have read several of his books up to this point, and find him a very erudite and serious man. May God grant the Church of Rome a worthy successor to continue along the path he set before his retirement. I am sure he will be a blessing to the monastery to which he is retiring.
 
His desire for dialogue towards reunion has been a breath of fresh air in East/West relations, and we pray for a like minded successor. I hope he continues to write, as I have enjoyed a number of his books. How about a successor from one of the Eastern Churches?
What if he’s quiting to become Orthodox? I highly doubt it, but what-if?
 
His desire for dialogue towards reunion has been a breath of fresh air in East/West relations, and we pray for a like minded successor. I hope he continues to write, as I have enjoyed a number of his books. How about a successor from one of the Eastern Churches?
What if he’s quiting to become Orthodox? I highly doubt it, but what-if?
 
I don’t think that it’s okay to criticize the previous Pope for NOT resigning in an effort to support the perfectly legal decision of Pope Benedict.

But that’s just me.
Perhaps being witness to JP-II is what also influenced Benedicts decision along with age and heath. I see it as a positive action in preparation with regards to the Church.
 
Perhaps being witness to JP-II is what also influenced Benedicts decision along with age and heath. I see it as a positive action in preparation with regards to the Church.
That seems to be a common speculation. Although I don’t think Pope Benedict mentioned his predecessor by name when discussing this topic, Benedict has long expressed that a pope has a responsibility and duty to step down if unable physically, mentally or spiritually fulfill the duties of pontiff.

A news photo from 2002 of Pope John Paul II celebrating mass in St. Peter’s Basilica, with Cardinal Ratzinger looking on.

(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)
 
What if he’s quiting to become Orthodox? I highly doubt it, but what-if?
:confused: Why on Earth would he do that? I see no logic in changing rites. If you are talking about abandoning his faith altogether, that indeed is weird.
 
What if he’s quiting to become Orthodox? I highly doubt it, but what-if?
What if he’s quitting to become Batman? What if he’s quitting to tour the world as the replacement vocalist for Thin Lizzy? It’s a very remote chance, but really, WHAT IF? :rolleyes:😛
 
What if he’s quitting to become Batman? What if he’s quitting to tour the world as the replacement vocalist for Thin Lizzy? It’s a very remote chance, but really, WHAT IF? :rolleyes:😛
Considering Batman isn’t real, that’s outside the bounds of possibility.

Replacement vocalist for who? I don’t know he could sing? But that would be a scandle.
 
:confused: Why on Earth would he do that? I see no logic in changing rites. If you are talking about abandoning his faith altogether, that indeed is weird.
Er, and just to point out, becoming Orthodox would involve a lot more than just “changing rites”.
 
Probably I shouldn’t say this, and I hate the very thought of it, but what if he (or his doctor) has recognized early signs of oncoming dementia? If so, he would be doing the absolutely right thing, no matter what.
 
Er, and just to point out, becoming Orthodox would involve a lot more than just “changing rites”.
Then someone is messing up. This is not a forum for those not in communion with Rome, but Eastern Catholics. If what was meant that he join like some Orthodox not in communion with Rome, I would say that is he is a man of educaton and intelligence and such a scenario is not possible. Why not speculate him becoming a Muslim? It makes as much sense.
 
Then someone is messing up. This is not a forum for those not in communion with Rome, but Eastern Catholics. If what was meant that he join like some Orthodox not in communion with Rome, I would say that is he is a man of educaton and intelligence and such a scenario is not possible. Why not speculate him becoming a Muslim? It makes as much sense.
Wow, really? Even though the thread is called “Pope Benedict XVI’s decision - an Orthodox perspective”, Orthodox are not welcome here, and are uneducated and unintelligent, and might as well be Muslims? Look, I know we prostrate a lot and Orthodox women wear headcoverings, but…well, okay, if that’s how you really feel… 🤷

I guess this is what happens when you start a thread on here with the word “Orthodox” in the title, even if it is overwhelmingly positive. Oh well. I like Pope Benedict XVI. Just my uneducated, unintelligent, quasi-Islamic opinion. (Because you know if there’s one thing that comes to mind when you think of the outgoing Pope of Rome, it’s the massive amount of love shown to him by the world’s Muslim community… :rolleyes:)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top