"prayer of quiet"

  • Thread starter Thread starter Monica4316
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

Monica4316

Guest
I came across this term… I’m just wondering, what is it?

thank you 🙂
 
Thank you! 🙂 well I’m just wondering how can this prayer be distinguished from simply feeling God’s presence, like sometimes people do after Communion? it seems similar I guess, but isn’t the “prayer of quiet” only for those who are very close to God?
 
Monica -

The important thing about “prayer states” - recollection, quiet and union - is that they’re fleeting and intermittent occurances. An individual might be a contemplative . . . but that doesn’t mean they’re always “in” contemplative prayer. These prayer states refer to the relative degree of interior silence, stillness or quietude in the soul at a given time of prayer. Generally speaking, the more the soul is thinking, feeling or analyzing . . . the further away it is from true contemplative prayer. What you mentioned in your previous post might possibly be called affective prayer . . . where our feelings and emotions are stirred to love. Not the same as infused contemplation.

I’ve posted this several times before. Hopefully this illustration will shed light (or make it even more confusing :)):
40.png
DBT:
Let’s try and describe this hypothetically. Let’s say someone is well grounded in their ascetic practices and serious about their faith. One day this individual decides to spend an hour of adoration. Let’s say their usual practice is to do some form of formalized meditation, the rosary or lectio.

At some point during this time of prayer, this individual “might” begin to feel the inner call to contemplation. The soul no longer feels any desire to think or ponder on the Lord, His mysteries and so on. He feels drawn to let it all go . . . to simply “be” . . . and rest in His presence in a wordless way . . . kind of like “I look at Him while He looks at me.”

This is called the prayer of recollection or sometimes the prayer of simplicity and we need to recognize the signs and go with the way the Lord is calling. Remember, the way He communicates is through silence . . . beyond thoughts, forms, words and ideas.

Perhaps this stillness might deepen. As St. Teresa describes in Mansion Four of “Interior Castle” the eyes begin to close and we feel a profound drawing inward as she says “like a turtle drawing it’s head inside it’s shell.” This is the prayer of recollection giving way to the prayer of quiet; the beginnings of infused contemplation.

What happens here is that our will (love) is completely captivated by our Lord but not in a way that is considered or analyzed in anyway. We’re not thinking “I love Him because . . .” or “I love Him for such and such a reason.” We just love in a wordless, thought-less way. All the while our intellect and memory might be roaming free like so many “wild horses” . . . but we have no desire to pay attention to any of these distractions. We’re aware of them . . . but we let them go by. To latch onto them is to “resist” the prayer being given, thereby bringing this passive prayer back to active ways (ie. meditation.)

Perhaps this inner stillness deepens even further. The distractions simply cease and intellect, will and memory are all completely suspended by God. This is the “pure” contemplation of the prayer of union which is no longer human (active) and entirely supernatural (passive).

The analogy to natural sleep is sometimes used to describe this progressive inner stillness . . . in fact, St. Teresa often used the term “sleep of the faculties.” Think of passive recollection like dozing off . . . we feel the inner pull to sleep and we either give in to it or resist. Let’s say we give in to the sleep. This next phase is “like” the prayer of quiet . . . when we’re down for the count but in a fitfull way. Part of us is asleep but not fully . . . we toss and turn . . . maybe even aware of random thoughts and mental images going through our mind . . . that we don’t dwell on or consider . . . they just flow by. The prayer of union, then, is “like” a deep, sound slumber . . . all is still and quiet . . . we’re not even aware of time or space.

This little analogy might help clarify . . . or make it worse. Again, so difficult to try and explain.

But keep in mind, all of this is at the time of prayer. And all of this is very short in duration. The entire timeframe from laying down our rosary, being interiorly drawn into the stillness of recollection and possibly quiet or union if He so wills is typically no more than 15-30 minutes from beginning to end. Longer suspensions are another of those “traps” the Saints describe that something is amiss.
Dave:)
 
Monica -

The important thing about “prayer states” - recollection, quiet and union - is that they’re fleeting and intermittent occurances. An individual might be a contemplative . . . but that doesn’t mean they’re always “in” contemplative prayer. These prayer states refer to the relative degree of interior silence, stillness or quietude in the soul at a given time of prayer. Generally speaking, the more the soul is thinking, feeling or analyzing . . . the further away it is from true contemplative prayer. What you mentioned in your previous post might possibly be called affective prayer . . . where our feelings and emotions are stirred to love. Not the same as infused contemplation.

I’ve posted this several times before. Hopefully this illustration will shed light (or make it even more confusing :)):

Dave:)
thanks Dave! 🙂 that helps! I found this as well:
Vocal Prayer, with attention to what one is saying or reading and God, whom one is addressing.
Discursive Meditation: consideration of a spiritual truth; application to oneself, and resolve to do something about it.
Affective Mental Prayer: one turns to “other,” namely, God, and prayer becomes “the language of love.”
Acquired Recollection: also called prayer of simplicity, prayer of simple regard, acquired contemplation, the loving awareness of God.
Infused Recollection: the first degree of infused, mystical contemplation.
Prayer of Quiet: the will is totally captivated by divine love; sometimes all the faculties are likewise captivated (sleep or ecstasy).
Prayer of Simple Union: both the intellect and the will are absorbed in God.
Prayer of Ecstatic Union: this is the “mystical espousal” or “conforming union.”
Prayer of Transforming Union: also called the “mystical marriage” because it is the most intimate union of the soul with God that is possible in this life.
I know very little about this topic…

I have a question too:
You said:
But keep in mind, all of this is at the time of prayer. And all of this is very short in duration. The entire timeframe from laying down our rosary, being interiorly drawn into the stillness of recollection and possibly quiet or union if He so wills is typically no more than 15-30 minutes from beginning to end. Longer suspensions are another of those “traps” the Saints describe that something is amiss.
do you mean that it takes 15-30 minutes to ‘transition’ into this state of prayer, or that it takes 15-30 minutes to ‘transition’ into it and then out of it again? can it ever occur rather quickly but last longer? (I’ve never experienced this anyway but I’m just wondering).

Here’s another question (sorry:o)
you mentioned affective prayer, where - I’m guessing - God helps the soul to love Him… should this also last a very short time? what if the person is just talking to God the whole time, and feels very close to Him and there’s more consolation than in discursive prayer. ? because - sometimes this happens to me after Communion, and it doesn’t last a long time but not just a couple minutes either. And then for the whole day I feel a lot of peace and find it easy to pray. Im just saying this cause - I hope I’m not getting deceived? But I don’t experience the prayer of quiet so maybe that rule doesn’t apply here. ?

I’m not entirely sure either what is meant by suspension of the will. Is it that the person feels that God is there and is entirely focused on Him, and also feels a lot of joy being near Him?

thanks 🙂
 
do you mean that it takes 15-30 minutes to ‘transition’ into this state of prayer, or that it takes 15-30 minutes to ‘transition’ into it and then out of it again? can it ever occur rather quickly but last longer? (I’ve never experienced this anyway but I’m just wondering).
This is the time frame St. Teresa gives us for an important reason. I think the basic point is that the experience of contemplative prayer is relatively short . . . 15 minutes, a half an hour . . . maybe an hour. Anything longer than that is probably not “true” contemplation. She sometimes witnessed suspensions lasting all day in some of her nuns . . . people walking around like dazed zombies. The explanation for that was typically natural (ie falling into a stupor from not eating enough) rather than supernatural. In everything mystical, there’s always a “false” side. And St. Teresa goes to great lengths to point out the true from false. Also, I think personal experience will show a short, fleeting experience is very much the norm . . . it’s the way God works and makes Himself known in the soul.
Here’s another question (sorry:o)
you mentioned affective prayer, where - I’m guessing - God helps the soul to love Him… should this also last a very short time? what if the person is just talking to God the whole time, and feels very close to Him and there’s more consolation than in discursive prayer. ? because - sometimes this happens to me after Communion, and it doesn’t last a long time but not just a couple minutes either. And then for the whole day I feel a lot of peace and find it easy to pray. Im just saying this cause - I hope I’m not getting deceived?
You’re not getting decieved. A spontaneous outpouring from the heart goes by many different names . . . affective prayer, prayer of the heart, mental prayer. How long it lasts isn’t so important. What is important is the peace that flows from it. That’s a sign of authenticity.
I’m not entirely sure either what is meant by suspension of the will. Is it that the person feels that God is there and is entirely focused on Him, and also feels a lot of joy being near Him?
Very, very hard to put into words. Experience is our teacher. Basically, if one is feeling . . . you’re not contemplating. If you’re thinking or meditating . . . you’re not contemplating. Suspension means a *temporary loss of awareness *of such things. That’s why it’s called the sleep of the faculties. On a purely natural level, think for a moment what it’s like when you’re asleep and how much awareness you have or don’t have. A poor analogy . . . but in my mind it accurately reflects the concept. Again, words fail in all matters mystical:o

Dave 🙂
 
This is the time frame St. Teresa gives us for an important reason. I think the basic point is that the experience of contemplative prayer is relatively short . . . 15 minutes, a half an hour . . . maybe an hour. Anything longer than that is probably not “true” contemplation. She sometimes witnessed suspensions lasting all day in some of her nuns . . . people walking around like dazed zombies. The explanation for that was typically natural (ie falling into a stupor from not eating enough) rather than supernatural. In everything mystical, there’s always a “false” side. And St. Teresa goes to great lengths to point out the true from false. Also, I think personal experience will show a short, fleeting experience is very much the norm . . . it’s the way God works and makes Himself known in the soul.

You’re not getting decieved. A spontaneous outpouring from the heart goes by many different names . . . affective prayer, prayer of the heart, mental prayer. How long it lasts isn’t so important. What is important is the peace that flows from it. That’s a sign of authenticity.

Very, very hard to put into words. Experience is our teacher. Basically, if one is feeling . . . you’re not contemplating. If you’re thinking or meditating . . . you’re not contemplating. Suspension means a *temporary loss of awareness *of such things. That’s why it’s called the sleep of the faculties. On a purely natural level, think for a moment what it’s like when you’re asleep and how much awareness you have or don’t have. A poor analogy . . . but in my mind it accurately reflects the concept. Again, words fail in all matters mystical:o

Dave 🙂
Hummm…I can not agree here…

There are various schools of thought on Contemplation…lots of ways to define it…and various different degrees…and lots of ink spilled over what is what…

but for instance one does not need a temporary loss of awareness …that can be a form a Contemplation …but Contemplation does not need to be so…and it can take place where the person has no clue that they have passed that thresehold…a kind of masked contemplation…which can be at the source of all their high charity…

here is one way to approach it…domcentral.org/study/aumann/st/st12.htm

here is another: ewtn.net/library/THEOLOGY/LITCOM.HTM#3

(though he did comment later that the one form of prayer he said was masked…was actually a kind of typical…see his notebooks)

(and of course Garrigou-Lagrange)
 
Hello Bookcat -

I am speaking specifcally about the infused states . . . the prayer of quiet giving way to the prayer of union. . . as regards to the brief experience of the suspension, absorption or sleep of the faculties. Sts. John and especially Teresa speak at great lengths about this. True, contemplation has many different meanings or connotations depending on where one is coming from. But the aspect of progressive inner stillness . . . the perception thoughts and feelings receeding into the background until they’re no longer noticed or recognized . . . is a basic element of what is meant by infused.

Again, words don’t do this justice and perhaps my words fail in this regard. But I responded to this thread because the OP specifically asked about the Prayer of Quiet and I communicated what is taught in Carmel with regard to this aspect of prayer states. Much, much more can be said about it . . . suspension of the faculties is just one part.

My best,
Dave 🙂

PS -

Just a few words from St. Teresa regarding the Prayer of Union . . .
Interior Castle:
Don’t think this union is some kind of dreamy state like the one I mentioned before (she was talking about daydreaming). I say “dreamy state” because it seems that the soul is as though asleep; yet neither does it really think it is asleep nor does it feel awake. There is no need here to use any technique to suspend the mind since all the faculties are asleep in this state – and truly asleep – to the things of the world and to ourselves (she means awareness of thoughts). As a matter of fact, during the time that the union lasts the soul is left as though without its senses, for it has no power to think even if it wants to. In loving, if it does love, it doesn’t understand how or what it is it loves or what it would want. In sum, it is like one who in every respect has died to the world so as to live more completely in God.
 
Hello Bookcat -

I am speaking specifcally about the infused states . . . the prayer of quiet giving way to the prayer of union. . . as regards to the brief experience of the suspension, absorption or sleep of the faculties.
as was I 🙂

Prayer of quiet …already is infused.

and for that matter…masked contemplation is also infused…yet the person may not even have a clue…

infused contemplation does not = only prayer of union.

it begins long before…
 
Hello Bookcat -. . the perception thoughts and feelings receeding into the background until they’re no longer noticed or recognized . . . is a basic element of what is meant by infused.

.
tis not a basic element of infused contemplation per se.

even during passive purification of the senses in the ‘dark night’…the person is already experiencing infused contemplation 🙂 …
 
This is the time frame St. Teresa gives us for an important reason. I think the basic point is that the experience of contemplative prayer is relatively short . . . 15 minutes, a half an hour . . . maybe an hour. Anything longer than that is probably not “true” contemplation.
St. Theresa of Jesus said regarding Prayer of the Quiet that it can go even for long periods of time…

and such was certainly true infused contemplation.

domcentral.org/study/aumann/st/st12.htm#poq

during the ‘dark night’ …infused contemplation. infused recollection is a kind of infused contemplation. prayer of the quiet is infused contemplation …etc

and infused contemplation can also be not ‘typical’ but ‘masked’ …
 
Hello again Bookcat -

I think we’re saying the same thing but in different ways. Of course there are degrees of infused prayer . . . that’s the whole point 🙂

Passive recollection, the prayer of quiet, the prayer of union . . . each are “degrees” of the same type of prayer. Passive recollection (Way of Perfection Chpts 28) is the initial “turning inward” that occurs when a soul feels drawn to let go it’s reflections and meditations. The Prayer of Quiet is simply a deepening of that where the will has been captivated by the Lord but the intellect and memory still roam free in the form of mental distractions. These, though, no longer interest the soul at the time of this prayer. The Prayer of Union is the point in time in which all distractions cease . . . intellect, will and memory have been totally suspended by God. Here and only here is it true what I said earlier that in this “pure” contemplation the soul has no ability to think, feel or even love for the duration of the prayer. St. Teresa’s description, not mine. 🙂 Ecstasies and raptures are a particular form of this type of suspension (though in the extraordinary realm and not the ordinary) . . . where the individual is left as though dead . . . breathing slows, limbs grow cold etc. But that’s another discussion entirely . . .

So, as you say, there are many levels (mansions) in all this and we move in and out of these rooms . . . even during the same time of prayer. Recollection is not an uncommon occurance and even the prayer of quiet, according to St. Teresa, is experienced by many. The Prayer of union much,much less so . . . .and even fewer for the extraordinary graces like ecstasy. Which is why talking about tends to fall apart . . .

I’m not sure the concern over “timeframes” . . . as, of course, there’s always variations in that. It’s St. Teresa herself who says - at least in the beginning - that infused prayer is very brief . . . perhaps as short as the time to say the Creed. It may occur once in a soul . . . or sporadically . . . or maybe never again. In some, though, infused prayer becomes a regular occurance and the length of time in this prayer increases . . . 15 minutes, half hour, hour . . . perhaps even longer. And, of course, recollection (in a pre-infused state) can go on for days or even longer. But this is not the case for the full suspension of the faculties. St. Teresa describes all these different timeframes and frequencies of occurance.at different points in her writing . . . tailored for the particular type of prayer she’s talking about at the time.

And I would agree with you about what I think you’re saying about masked contemplation. Like you say, with the onset of the passive night of sense . . . when the soul is first brought to contemplation . . . the soul is often very confused as to what’s going on. The initial effects of recollection and even quiet can be so subtle that the soul is not even aware of what’s happening. Far to often these individuals resist the grace . . . trying to return to their meditation . . . when they’re being led by God to inner stillness. The confusion, doubt and uncertainty about all this is a big part of why St. John calls this a “night.”

Good speaking with you and hoping we’re on the same page,
Dave 🙂
 
St. Teresa of Avila discusses the “prayer of quiet” in her Life chapter 14 and in the Interior Castle chapter IV.2.
 
Hello again Bookcat -

I think we’re saying the same thing but in different ways. Of course there are degrees of infused prayer . . . that’s the whole point 🙂

Passive recollection, the prayer of quiet, the prayer of union . . . each are “degrees” of the same type of prayer. Passive recollection (Way of Perfection Chpts 28) is the initial “turning inward” that occurs when a soul feels drawn to let go it’s reflections and meditations. The Prayer of Quiet is simply a deepening of that where the will has been captivated by the Lord but the intellect and memory still roam free in the form of mental distractions. These, though, no longer interest the soul at the time of this prayer. The Prayer of Union is the point in time in which all distractions cease . . . intellect, will and memory have been totally suspended by God. Here and only here is it true what I said earlier that in this “pure” contemplation the soul has no ability to think, feel or even love for the duration of the prayer. St. Teresa’s description, not mine. 🙂 Ecstasies and raptures are a particular form of this type of suspension (though in the extraordinary realm and not the ordinary) . . . where the individual is left as though dead . . . breathing slows, limbs grow cold etc. But that’s another discussion entirely . . .

So, as you say, there are many levels (mansions) in all this and we move in and out of these rooms . . . even during the same time of prayer. Recollection is not an uncommon occurance and even the prayer of quiet, according to St. Teresa, is experienced by many. The Prayer of union much,much less so . . . .and even fewer for the extraordinary graces like ecstasy. Which is why talking about tends to fall apart . . .

I’m not sure the concern over “timeframes” . . . as, of course, there’s always variations in that. It’s St. Teresa herself who says - at least in the beginning - that infused prayer is very brief . . . perhaps as short as the time to say the Creed. It may occur once in a soul . . . or sporadically . . . or maybe never again. In some, though, infused prayer becomes a regular occurance and the length of time in this prayer increases . . . 15 minutes, half hour, hour . . . perhaps even longer. And, of course, recollection (in a pre-infused state) can go on for days or even longer. But this is not the case for the full suspension of the faculties. St. Teresa describes all these different timeframes and frequencies of occurance.at different points in her writing . . . tailored for the particular type of prayer she’s talking about at the time.

And I would agree with you about what I think you’re saying about masked contemplation. Like you say, with the onset of the passive night of sense . . . when the soul is first brought to contemplation . . . the soul is often very confused as to what’s going on. The initial effects of recollection and even quiet can be so subtle that the soul is not even aware of what’s happening. Far to often these individuals resist the grace . . . trying to return to their meditation . . . when they’re being led by God to inner stillness. The confusion, doubt and uncertainty about all this is a big part of why St. John calls this a “night.”

Good speaking with you and hoping we’re on the same page,
Dave 🙂
Dave thanks for taking the time to write

Always distinguish…as the Thomists would say 🙂 Yes it seems the same or similar pages are appearing…

Though again too we must always remember that this particular understanding that emerged during the reflexive age is one way to approach the subject of Contemplation etc in the Church…there are those before this age…and of course other schools etc.

I think too you will find reading Jacques and Raissa Maritain’s sections on Infused Contemplation…particularly about masked contemplation (which is not to be confused with the dark night) in the above link very interesting…(though he does note in his in another work that one example he gives of masked contemplation is actually a typical one)
 
Yes it seems the same or similar pages are appearing…
Glad to hear it 👍
Though again too we must always remember that this particular understanding that emerged during the reflexive age is one way to approach the subject of Contemplation etc in the Church…there are those before this age…and of course other schools etc.
True. I’m a Carmelite, though, so perhaps my particular bias shows. 🙂
I think too you will find reading Jacques and Raissa Maritain’s sections on Infused Contemplation…particularly about masked contemplation (which is not to be confused with the dark night) in the above link very interesting…(though he does note in his in another work that one example he gives of masked contemplation is actually a typical one)
Thank you for the link. I look forward to reading. Masked contemplation is a term I’m not familiar with. Also, I appreciate your numerous references on these forums to Fr. Garrigou-LaGrange. His works are a towering achievement . . . adding a certain structure to Carmelite teaching that sometimes isn’t so readily apparent when reading them directly.

Dave 🙂
 
Glad to hear it 👍

True. I’m a Carmelite, though, so perhaps my particular bias shows. 🙂

Thank you for the link. I look forward to reading. Masked contemplation is a term I’m not familiar with. Also, I appreciate your numerous references on these forums to Fr. Garrigou-LaGrange. His works are a towering achievement . . . adding a certain structure to Carmelite teaching that sometimes isn’t so readily apparent when reading them directly.

Dave 🙂
Yes I have much of my “Carmelite” Spiritual Theology via theological works such as Garrigou-Lagrange…as well as Fr. Jordom Aumann OP (who follows him)…Jacques and Raissa Maritain…etc

Masked Contemplation was I believe coined by the Maritains…and picked up on by Garrigou Lagrange if I recall correctly (he was the Spiritual Director for their Thomistic Study Circles) …also this brings to mind the great little work which I highly recommend “Prayer and Intelligence” by the Maritains (it was written for their study circles)…

a little book on Mental Prayer which I recommend to all is:

“Time for God” …which I think will be helpful to all here…

frjacquesphilippe.com/books/time_for_god.html

frjacquesphilippe.com/

frjacquesphilippe.com/testimonials/interview.html
 
The mind is stilled not of one’s own volition or one may be able to move it to loving aspirations but with difficulty - there is inner Peace and Joy. It is nothing of one’s own acting, rather this state happens to one. Sometimes one is aware that it is happening, sometimes there is no reflection on this inner state at all at the time, although an awareness of what happened after. It may be rather fleeting, it may be prolonged - it may be prolonged in degrees. Undoubtedly the whole state has degrees in each aspect: the feeling of Peace and Joy, awareness of the state or lack of it, ability to make loving aspirations or not, time span.

TS
 
Masked Contemplation was I believe coined by the Maritains…and picked up on by Garrigou Lagrange if I recall correctly (he was the Spiritual Director for their Thomistic Study Circles) …also this brings to mind the great little work which I highly recommend “Prayer and Intelligence” by the Maritains (it was written for their study circles)…
This was a very interesting read, thank you! Only briefly scanned it . . . will read it more later.

My comments below are directed toward the discussion on “un-conscious” prayer (masked contemplation) since that’s what most stood out to me . . .

And this is where terminology can be so confusing. Could this properly be called contemplation? From an infused (Carmelite) viewpoint . . . probably not. However, I very definately see it as a fruit of infused contemplation. But again, as you say, threre’s many schools of thought on this.

I think a natural result of infused contemplation is the desire to be united with Christ in everything we do . . . all our thoughts, words and actions. The practical application of this is praying without ceasing which, I believe, often takes on the “un-conscious” aspect described in your link.

Often we will find that, when our minds are occupied with a particular task, we’re still praying in a very simplified form . . . in the background and not always aware we are doing so. Then, when our mind is freed from the task, our ongoing prayer comes back to the forefront of our mind. I view this as the natural ebb and flow that goes with continuous prayer. Personally, I view it very much a part of the prayer of simplicity . . . a pre-infused state that can become regular . . . even habitual.

I also (vaguely) recall a HUGE theological debate in years past regarding whether acquired contemplation in the manner I’m describing here can properly be described as contemplation. That is, can contemplation be something other than infused? Again, different schools of thought.

Is this the proper understanding of this concept? Again, I only briefly scanned . . .

Dave 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top