Praying to saints more than asking intercession?

  • Thread starter Thread starter internetjoko
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Hello.

I understand the Catholic teaching is that when Catholics pray to saints, they are merely asking for their intercession, just as I would ask a friend to intercede for me. Ok, that is fine with me. How, then am I to understand this common Catholic prayer to St. Joseph and others like it that do not simply ask for intercession?

“Protect the Holy Father, our sovereign pontiff, and all bishops and priests united with him. Be the protector of all who labor for souls amid the trials and tribulations of this life, and grant that all peoples of the world may follow Christ and the Church he founded.”

This prayer is doing far more than asking for Joseph’s intercession. I would never ask a friend to “be the protector of all who labor for souls, and grant that all people of the world may follow Christ.” This is a prayer TO Joseph, not asking Joseph to pray for me.

Can anyone make sense of this for me?
My brother and friends watch over that which is valued by me all the time. When I’m sick they watch over me in my worst times.

As a saint, we recognize they went to heaven, and we connect with our saints, as you would with heros and beloved family members and friends. We connect with saints also because they have done what we struggle to do–enter heaven.

Now saints don’t necessarily know us, they aren’t necessarily aware of us per se like christ is. But, they long for us to join christ in heaven.
 
I think what is missing here is the concept of the Communion of Saints. That concept is, I find, either severely impaired or totally lacking in protestant denominations. We Catholics are familiar with the concept of ‘Patron Saints’ which protestants would have little, if indeed any, knowledge of. St. Joseph is the patron saint of fathers as well as carpenters. Just about every trade has a patron saint. Those Catholic old enough to remember the Tridentine Mass will remember the the “Prayers at the foot of the Altar” which included a prayer to St. Michael the Archangel which went as follows:

“Saint Michael the Archangel,
defend us in battle.
Be our protection against the wickedness and snares of the devil.
May God rebuke him, we humbly pray;
and do Thou, O Prince of the Heavenly Host -
by the Divine Power of God -
cast into hell, satan and all the evil spirits,
who roam throughout the world seeking the ruin of souls.”

This prayer was the result of a vision by Pope St. Leo XllI and was written in 1886. It was said at the end of every Mass up until Vatican II [1964]. It has been pointed out many times that it was only after this prayer ceased to be said by the faithful that the modern evils came into the church so that even Pope Paul VI in 1972 commented that the “smoke of Satan has entered the sanctuary”.

This prayer reflects the imagery depicted in the Book of Revelation when Lucifer was defeated by Michael. In 1994 Pope JPII urged that recitation of the prayer be continued. But that is only the short version. There is a longer one that is the original prayer as composed by Pope Leo XIII:

"“O Glorious Prince of the heavenly host, St. Michael the Archangel, defend us in the battle and in the terrible warfare that we are waging against the principalities and powers, against the rulers of this world of darkness, against the evil spirits. Come to the aid of man, whom Almighty God created immortal, made in His own image and likeness, and redeemed at a great price from the tyranny of Satan.

“Fight this day the battle of the Lord, together with the holy angels, as already thou hast fought the leader of the proud angels, Lucifer, and his apostate host, who were powerless to resist thee, nor was there place for them any longer in Heaven. That cruel, ancient serpent, who is called the devil or Satan who seduces the whole world, was cast into the abyss with his angels. Behold, this primeval enemy and slayer of men has taken courage. Transformed into an angel of light, he wanders about with all the multitude of wicked spirits, invading the earth in order to blot out the name of God and of His Christ, to seize upon, slay and cast into eternal perdition souls destined for the crown of eternal glory. This wicked dragon pours out, as a most impure flood, the venom of his malice on men of depraved mind and corrupt heart, the spirit of lying, of impiety, of blasphemy, and the pestilent breath of impurity, and of every vice and iniquity.

“These most crafty enemies have filled and inebriated with gall and bitterness the Church, the spouse of the immaculate Lamb, and have laid impious hands on her most sacred possessions. In the Holy Place itself, where the See of Holy Peter and the Chair of Truth has been set up as the light of the world, they have raised the throne of their abominable impiety, with the iniquitous design that when the Pastor has been struck, the sheep may be.

“Arise then, O invincible Prince, bring help against the attacks of the lost spirits to the people of God, and give them the victory. They venerate thee as their protector and patron; in thee holy Church glories as her defense against the malicious power of hell; to thee has God entrusted the souls of men to be established in heavenly beatitude. Oh, pray to the God of peace that He may put Satan under our feet, so far conquered that he may no longer be able to hold men in captivity and harm the Church. Offer our prayers in the sight of the Most High, so that they may quickly find mercy in the sight of the Lord; and vanquishing the dragon, the ancient serpent, who is the devil and Satan, do thou again make him captive in the abyss, that he may no longer seduce the nations. Amen.
V. Behold the Cross of the Lord; be scattered ye hostile powers.
R. The Lion of the tribe of Judah has conquered the root of David.
V. Let Thy mercies be upon us, O Lord.
R. As we have hoped in Thee.
V. O Lord, hear my prayer.
R. And let my cry come unto Thee.

Let us pray.
O God, the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, we call upon Thy holy Name, and as supplicants, we implore Thy clemency, that by the intercession of Mary, ever Virgin Immaculate and our Mother, and of the glorious St. Michael the Archangel, Thou wouldst deign to help us against Satan and all the other unclean spirits who wander about the world for the injury of the human race and the ruin of souls. Amen.”
 
Number one, your “common” prayer is so common that no one I asked about it has ever heard it. Are you making this up?

Even if your not, you have to have some basic understandings or you cannot possibly correctly understand what is going on. One fundamental understanding that must proceed trying to understand what anyone is saying is that the only thing that saints can do is pray for us. You mus start with this knowledge and proceed from there.
For example, If I the widow next door to protect my family when I go away on business, I certainly don’t expect her to come running over if there is a fire, I want her to call the fire department. You have to have these basic understanding as reflexively underlying anything that you think you see or you will fundamentally misunderstand it.

Yours in Christ.
THIS is why I am confused. You are saying “One fundamental understanding that must proceed trying to understand what anyone is saying is that the only thing that saints can do is pray for us.” Yet others are giving me examples of how friends actually do things for them on behalf of God through the power of God. This is the exact distinction I am still having trouble with. I am not accusing anyone of idolotry nor do I have a problem with the idea of communing with Saints, I am just trying to understand two points:
  1. When you pray to saints, are you asking them to pray with you OR are you asking them to be the answer to your prayer? Given the example of the prayer I listed, “St. Joseph…Be the protector of all who labor for souls amid the trials and tribulations of this life.”
  2. If, as you are saying here, you are ONLY asking St. Joseph to pray to God for the protection of all who labor for souls, because saints only pray for us, then why use the language “Be the protector of all…” which is obviously so misleading, given how each of you seem to be arguing for different understandings. One says you are only invoking Saints to pray, others saying Saints work with God to be the answer to prayer just a friend would etc.
Make sense? Still confused.
 
This is controversial, being the bible states explicitly that only Christ is a mediator between God and man. In addition Christ rebuked those who prayed to other than God or Christ.

Yes, I understand in Tradition praying to other than God and Christ is founded.
 
This is controversial, being the bible states explicitly that only Christ is a mediator between God and man. In addition Christ rebuked those who prayed to other than God or Christ.

Yes, I understand in Tradition praying to other than God and Christ is founded.
But what do you mean by prayer? To you, is prayer only worship or could it be a request?
 
Even if your not, you have to have some basic understandings or you cannot possibly correctly understand what is going on. One fundamental understanding that must proceed trying to understand what anyone is saying is that the only thing that saints can do is pray for us. You mus start
If I ask the widow next door to protect my family when I go away on business, I certainly don’t expect her to come running over if there is a fire, I want her to call the fire department. You have to start with the precondition of what she is capable of in order to understand what the words mean.
. One says you are only invoking Saints to pray, others saying Saints work with God to be the answer to prayer just a friend would etc.

Still confused.
Ok, in a nut shell, you have to get the basics right or you will misunderstand everything else. To find out what the actual and authentic Catholic Teaching is on this, start with a read through the Catechism of The Catholic Church. You will find the communion of saints explained in a great deal of detail. That is foundational and is the basis of all intecessory prayer, whether those praying with you and here on earth or perfectly united with Christ in heaven. And if folks here are saying what you say they are (and you are not misunderstanding them as you do with the prayer you cited (see my example of asking my neighbor to protect my family)) then they need to read the Catechism as well. The saints in heaven absolutely do not come now here and do anything in the material world. A belief that they do is contrary to Catholic teaching.

Actually, having the Catechism is probably better than posting here because it is a sure norm for finding the Authentic teachings of The Catholic Church from The Catholic Church.

May God guide you and richly bless you for seeking the truth.

Your brother in Christ.
 
Ok, but don’t you see how that language is misleading? How is the common man supposed to understand that when you say, “St. Joseph, grant that… (insert anything here)…” He is really saying “St. Joseph, pray with me that God will grant that… (insert anything).” Why not just use clear communication?
The language barrier is defiantly a problem! I think that the new media of evangelization should focus heavily on properly defining Catholic terms to Protestants. I think that people inside the Catholic Tradition know the lingo, like a soldier knows all those Government acronyms. Many people from the Evangelical Tradition have their own lingo as well, nothing I think points that out more than the Jesus>Religion (Jesus Hates Religion poem on youtube) Catholics find that poem to be completely foreign to them, while the Evangelical crowd loved it.

There have been a great many Converts to the Catholic faith, much of them can be seen on EWTN with Marcus Grodi 👍 Catholics need to engage the Converts, Reverts and those that are still in protest on the issue of language, to be more effective in ecumenical dialog and or conversion! Thats my 2 cents anyways!
 
If I ask the widow next door to protect my family when I go away on business, I certainly don’t expect her to come running over if there is a fire, I want her to call the fire department. You have to start with the precondition of what she is capable of in order to understand what the words mean.

Ok, in a nut shell, you have to get the basics right or you will misunderstand everything else. To find out what the actual and authentic Catholic Teaching is on this, start with a read through the Catechism of The Catholic Church. You will find the communion of saints explained in a great deal of detail. That is foundational and is the basis of all intecessory prayer, whether those praying with you and here on earth or perfectly united with Christ in heaven. And if folks here are saying what you say they are (and you are not misunderstanding them as you do with the prayer you cited (see my example of asking my neighbor to protect my family)) then they need to read the Catechism as well. The saints in heaven absolutely do not come now here and do anything in the material world. A belief that they do is contrary to Catholic teaching.

Actually, having the Catechism is probably better than posting here because it is a sure norm for finding the Authentic teachings of The Catholic Church from The Catholic Church.

May God guide you and richly bless you for seeking the truth.

Your brother in Christ.
Ok so final, definitive word. The ONLY thing Catholics do when praying to saints is asking saints to intercede for them or for the world or for whatever it may be… to intercede… ?
The language barrier is defiantly a problem! I think that the new media of evangelization should focus heavily on properly defining Catholic terms to Protestants. I think that people inside the Catholic Tradition know the lingo, like a soldier knows all those Government acronyms. Many people from the Evangelical Tradition have their own lingo as well, nothing I think points that out more than the Jesus>Religion (Jesus Hates Religion poem on youtube) Catholics find that poem to be completely foreign to them, while the Evangelical crowd loved it.
There have been a great many Converts to the Catholic faith, much of them can be seen on EWTN with Marcus Grodi Catholics need to engage the Converts, Reverts and those that are still in protest on the issue of language, to be more effective in ecumenical dialog and or conversion! Thats my 2 cents anyways!
I listen to each journey home episode…

This evangelical didn’t like the video… check out my blog about it here: obiwankologes.blogspot.com/

In fact allow me to apologize on behalf of evangelicals everywhere for the arrogance and dismissiveness the video displays towards the Catholic Church. I’m sorry we are so thankless for a world without communism, for a bible, for the saints, for your defense of life and moral teaching through the ages. I think I will go make this into it’s own thread…
 
Ok so final, definitive word. The ONLY thing Catholics do when praying to saints is asking saints to intercede for them or for the world or for whatever it may be… to intercede… ?
Now you’ve got it! If they are doing anything more, then they are going contrary to what The Church teaches. If you’d still like further clarification, you might want to try the Ask An Apologist section on this forum here: forums.catholic-questions.org/forumdisplay.php?f=4.

God bless.
 
Ok so final, definitive word. The ONLY thing Catholics do when praying to saints is asking saints to intercede for them or for the world or for whatever it may be… to intercede… ?
It’s certainly the only thing I do, because I am a former Protestant and that is what I am most comfortable with.

It is possible that the saints, like the angels, have been given power to help directly in certain situations. Prayers like the one you quoted seem to assume that is the case. I don’t believe it’s something the Church either teaches as definitely true or condemns as definitely false.

In any case, of course, any power the saints have would be coming from God and used for His purposes. Whether it’s Michael booting Lucifer out of Heaven, Moses parting the waters, Elijah raising the dead, or Peter, Paul, and other apostles healing, we have plenty of examples of servants of God wielding even obvious divine power because He gave it to them, usually in response to their prayers. Even Jesus, in His earthly life, most often prayed to the Father before performing His miracles. So it’s possible that in many cases, “praying for us” and “actually doing stuff for us” are two sides of the same coin.

Usagi
 
It does a bit. I guess I am just confused. The wording sounds like you are asking St. Joseph to DO something in and of his own accord. Which, is fine, if that is what you are doing, but doesn’t seem to be what Catholic apologists explain. But are you telling me you are not asking St. Joseph to DO anything, you are just asking him to pray this alongside of you? If yes, it just sounds misleading.

In my admittedly very protestant thinking, I see a large difference between saying to my friend Frank, “Frank, please pray that God will grant me and all Christians everywhere peace…” and saying “Frank, grant me and all christians everywhere peace.”

Am I making false distinctions?
No, you’re not, not to my thinking. I think the prayer is misleading in some sense, as, properly, as it is only asking for intercession but is worded poorly (I’ve never seen it before) - it is asking for Joseph to do what he can in Heaven to make these petitions come about in actuality.

The standard “Saint Prayers” are the Ave Maria (asking Mary to pray for us) or the Sancte Michael (asking Michael the Archangel to defend us from Satan). Michael is still a creature: we are asking him to do what he can - what God allows him and commands him to do - in order to defend us (because the Angels, as Saints, do only the will of God: thus, the will of an Angel or a Saint is the will of God, or it is better to say the will of God is the will of an Angel or a Saint: “your wish is my command”, as they are completely obedient).

Now comes the second part where I’ll probably receive some flames from other Catholics: there are Catholics out there who do worship the saints or Mary, and do not make the proper distinctions between dulia, hyperdulia and latria: they give adoration to creatures that is due to God alone (although I don’t think any Catholics at all worship statues, as Lorraine Boettner claims: the standard analogy in this place is that the Protestant doesn’t worship the Bible by praying while holding it, thus the Catholic doesn’t worship the statue, mutatis mutandis: there’s quite a lot of iconodule theology surrounding this, and if you’re interested, learn about Nicaea II Council of 786-787: there are several good books available on it, one of the best being the second book of Jaroslav Pelikan’s five-part series on the history of Christian doctrine).

However, the fact that some Catholics lapse in to folk religion where Mary actually is worshiped with adoration that should be reserved to God alone reflects not on the teaching of Catholicism, nor on the Catholic religion: it reflects on folk religion and poor catechesis. If someone does something or worships in such a way as prohibited by the Church, it has nothing to do with the teaching of the Church - it has to do with the rejection of it. The Catholic who adores Mary doesn’t shine a light on Catholic theology in any way, as that person is giving worship in a way that is prohibited by the Church.

Much the same as there are some Protestants (the guy who wrote the Dake Bible comes to mind) who are heretics without knowing it, thinking themselves orthodox. It doesn’t have to do so much with obstinacy, as with lack of knowledge, as the generational passing-on of the faith drifts further and further away, without proper Church oversight to correct it using Church teaching. Now, I hold that the number of Catholics who do this are very small, but it is undoubted that some do (as I have met all too many Christians who don’t know what the Trinity viz ousia and hypostases is, and don’t know if they worship one God or three, like the Mormons, or have a flawed understanding of the nature of Jesus and his divinity, or a flawed knowledge of soteriology - I would say a majority of nominal Christians, Catholic and Protestant, fail on one of these points).
 
Ok so final, definitive word. The ONLY thing Catholics do when praying to saints is asking saints to intercede for them or for the world or for whatever it may be… to intercede… ?

Yes…and leave the answer to our prayers to the divine will and providence of God…He may choose to act through the saint we are asking intercession to…and it is for His glory, not ours.
I listen to each journey home episode…
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top