S
Sky_River
Guest
It’s very confusing to me.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
- Status
- Not open for further replies.
S
Sky_River
Guest
Do you understand my confusion?Surely you have your own concept of marriage, yes?
What do you mean when you use the term marriage?
P
PRmerger
Guest
Sky, you’ve been asked at least 4 times to give your definition of marriage.Do you understand my confusion?
Why don’t you do this first and then we can chat further?
Do you see why we are confused about why you won’t answer this?
S
Sky_River
Guest
The definition says diverse forms of interpersonal union.Sky, you’ve been asked at least 4 times to give your definition of marriage.
Why don’t you do this first and then we can chat further?
Do you see why we are confused about why you won’t answer this?
G
goout
Guest
We don’t know what your confusion is.Do you understand my confusion?
You answer questions with evasive one liners.
That’s not a discussion.
S
Sky_River
Guest
What are the evasive one liners?We don’t know what your confusion is.
You answer questions with evasive one liners.
That’s not a discussion.
G
goout
Guest
It’s a fun game.What are the evasive one liners?
H
Hoosier_Daddy
Guest
What are the evasive one liners?
H
Hoosier_Daddy
Guest
I’m just wondering sky, if you think you have ever influenced someone on the boards to whatever view against the church you think you present?
P
PRmerger
Guest
So nuns in a convent have a marriage?The definition says diverse forms of interpersonal union.
A father and son living together have a marriage?
Fraternity brothers living in their frat house are married to each other?
M
MarkInOregon
Guest
In my experience–Sky refuses to answer any question asked of him–his usual response is to just ask more questions.Sky, you’ve been asked at least 4 times to give your definition of marriage.
Why don’t you do this first and then we can chat further?
Do you see why we are confused about why you won’t answer this?
The peace of Christ,
Mark
S
Sky_River
Guest
So the things that exist today are a substitute to the union in Eden?So nuns in a convent have a marriage?
A father and son living together have a marriage?
Fraternity brothers living in their frat house are married to each other?
What does your comment have to do with mine?
G
goout
Guest
I stayed in a Holiday Inn last night.So the things that exist today are a substitute to the union in Eden?
What does your comment have to do with mine?
P
PRmerger
Guest
Is this true, Sky?In my experience–Sky refuses to answer any question asked of him–his usual response is to just ask more questions.
The peace of Christ,
Mark
O
oldgraymare2
Guest
You’re not the only one who has been seeing this, Mark. And, not only that, takes various threads off-topic by bringing in other questions and comments to derail and disrupt threads, too.In my experience–Sky refuses to answer any question asked of him–his usual response is to just ask more questions.
The peace of Christ,
Mark
P
PRmerger
Guest
In my experience–Sky refuses to answer any question asked of him–his usual response is to just ask more questions.
The peace of Christ,
Mark
I just did a search of all your posts, Sky. And the evidence is incontrovertible.Is this true, Sky?
90% of your posts end with a question mark.
And that means you are not really engaging in discussions, nor are you answering questions posed to you.
I suggest you change your modus, and invest in dialogue a bit more.
Otherwise, I’m sure you will be reported.
It’s good for you to be here and in dialogue with knowledgeable Catholics, so please show some good faith that you are actually here to dialogue.
H
Hoosier_Daddy
Guest
Sky is not catholic but refuses to change his/her profile.I just did a search of all your posts, Sky. And the evidence is incontrovertible.
90% of your posts end with a question mark.
And that means you are not really engaging in discussions, nor are you answering questions posed to you.
I suggest you change your modus, and invest in dialogue a bit more.
Otherwise, I’m sure you will be reported.
It’s good for you to be here and in dialogue with knowledgeable Catholics, so please show some good faith that you are actually here to dialogue.
Also common is the phrase " I read somewhere" but a refusal to support where.
They clearly have an agenda but won’t honestly dialogue.
I wonder if it’s CARM related…
H
Hope_Philomena
Guest
If only you could truly reply to things, then your point would be understood better.So the things that exist today are a substitute to the union in Eden?
What does your comment have to do with mine?
If you’re going to continue playing this cat and mouse game, nobody is going to continue to answer your questions. You’ve already derailed this thread enough, a thread about a woman who is hurting and needs advice. And for whatever reason, you have elected to ask the questions that we all know are utterly pointless.
Whatever point you’re trying to get across with your endless questioning of the most useless things, it’s not getting across.
How bothersome.
S
Sky_River
Guest
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?p=14487592#post14487592Why would 2 people living together who aren’t engaged in sex, who don’t love each other romantically, but are friends who want to deed property to each other be a marriage?
http://33.media.tumblr.com/afe0aca0f61fce5ca37be8275cd7d07f/tumblr_inline_noasel3qbT1r79k32_500.gif
S
Sky_River
Guest
everyculture.com/North-America/Baffinland-Inuit-Marriage-and-Family.htmlWhy don’t you tell us what your definition of marriage is?
What does joining mean?Marriage. Traditionally, marriage took place through an arrangement made for children by adults when the two Children were young. Since the rigors of life could not guarantee the eventual joining of these individuals, it was not uncommon for parents to create such an arrangement just prior to the marriage. Men usually moved to the village of the wife’s parents. The duration of this depended on the social position and economic circumstances of the two families and on the overall availability of either eligible males or females. Polygamous unions existed, and there could be unions that represented significant age differences between the partners.
- Status
- Not open for further replies.