But one thing that strikes me, OP. If this sin is really so ingrained that it seems you will have it for your entire life, then IS IT REALLY a mortal sin? I mean, if you believe that you cannot change it, then you are not really consenting to it, thus, it’s not something you do with full consciousness, but more a part of your make-up. If any priests tell you that this is a gift, I think you need to explore this further. NO PRIEST has ever told me that any part of my sinning is a gift. I don’t think even the most heterodox of priests would call a mortal sin a “gift.”
So as not to offend anyone’s sensibilities, the closest I can say is that it’s like being gay, except I am neither bi-, nor homosexual. It’s also nothing illegal. I refer to homosexuality because I tend to think a lot of homosexuality is natural, or it can become so ingrained in a person it may as well be second nature. In any case, an eccentric sexual identity exists, and the shrinks (including my Pastoral Counselors) say it is something one carries throughout one’s life. I also tend toward having a lot of homosexual friends (both male and female), and, while I do not engage in any homosexual or bisexual activities, I nevertheless understand the problem they confront with their sexual identity more than most strictly heterosexuals, and I will proactively extend whatever compassionate conservatism I can to them.
Clinically, it’s identified as a disability with Asperger’s, but what I actually see in my mind is highly disturbing to me. I’ve been in therapy for it for twenty five years or so. The past ten years I have exclusively seen Pastoral Counselors, Faith Healers and Spiritual Directors for the healing. Psychologists tend to have varied opinions, but we believe in one God, so I tend to look for the unifying truths of our faith. I guess that’s why varying opinions from Priests have started to confuse me. I’ve gone deeper into Catholicism with age, and, while I recognize we all have our unique gifts, I nevertheless encounter various opinions that do contradict one another.
Some people think the visions I see define me as a Priest myself, others a wounded healer, and others just a flat out heretic.
Asperger’s seems the most generic and appropriate way to describe it. Asperger’s is a form of Autism - high functioning Autism. I can talk and speak and function, but it is as if parts of my mind still idle, like a kid rocking back and forth. How to snap out of it is the question. Generally, Asperger’s sufferers don’t like change, but change is natural, and, yet, when change snaps me out of my contemplations - it can produce some adverse effects.
In terms of Scripture, I have a thorn in my side, and an angel that beats me daily. St Paul knew it. It’s why he said “I don’t do what I want - I do what I hate!” Some Priests see it as a gift; others see the thorn as a source of adversity. A lot of the time it depends on how I phrase my words when I speak in the confessional, and then at others it doesn’t matter. It depends on how the thorn has been affecting me, and whether I have responded in faith or wandered in sin with respect to it. Sometimes I see the thorn itself as a sin, or as if I must have done something wrong to deserve it.
I don’t think I must be making much sense here. It seems inappropriate to address certain ideas here, so I haven’t and won’t go into specifics.
I just was hoping maybe to understand some way of making sense of all this when Priests say things which are patently contrary to one another. We’re supposed to believe in One God - an absolute truth that transcends all reality. Recognizing the diversity of opinions does help, thank you, but, when the divisions become too contrary, then what does one do?