Priests: Conflicting Views

  • Thread starter Thread starter William777
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
W

William777

Guest
This is probably one of the most frustrating issues I’ve encountered in our faith.

Sometimes I take the same spiritual issue to several different people in our faith, and I get many different (even contrary) answers. This is not uncommon amongst Priests.

The matter then becomes who or what to heed? And how does one know?

Sinner that I am… sometimes I feel as if I fail the same test over and over again…
 
It might help to be specific, so I can explain the depth of the problem.

I go to a Priest with a sinful problem “X” - which is a personality flaw I will always have, as my Pastoral Counselors have explained to me… and which I have reluctantly come to accept as a permanent problem, and which I think could only be overcome via a miracle… I don’t place all that much faith in psychology, but I do place faith in God’s healing powers - and from what the psychologists tell me there’s not much they can do anyway…

So - it’s a problem that I don’t know how to handle, and I take it to church… I go to one priest in confession, and he’ll say “Oh, that’s nothing…” Then another Priest, and he’ll call the problem a gift… Then a third Priest, and he might view the matter as grave… But the question I am asking here isn’t even concerned with the problem I just mentioned… because a second issue arises in light of the first…

Due to a lack of unanimous agreement - I try to take a highly conservative view, and I hold myself responsible for it as a grievous sin… This creates a second problem… specifically, if I want to go to communion, then I have to go to confession to receive worthily…

I consider the problem such that - the moment I walk out of church, I am back to sinning, and it’s most likely that - if I want to go to communion at a mass, then I have to go to confession before every mass I attend…

This has been extremely difficult to do… There’s not as many Priests as there used to be, and it’s hard to find someone willing to hear confessions on such a regular basis… It became difficult to ask Priests for a moment to speak before mass, and many were getting tired of hearing the same thing over and over again…

So I then resorted to not going to confession unless the church scheduled them regularly for everyone in a blind confessional in advance… and, then, I also had to stop going to communion so frequently…

Some Priests say this is too scrupulous, and, if I am genuinely sorry in my heart, then that is enough to go to communion… even without confession… But others say I should go to confession beforehand…

The division has driven me back to more “liturgically correct” churches, where I can go to confession more frequently, and I feel I can make a more valid confession before mass… But this isn’t always practical, and, when I have to go elsewhere, I am kind of stuck trying to figure out what to do… And, ultimately, I end up relying on the CCC… and I just dont go to communion… but it’s terribly hard not to go to communion, especially when everyone else is going and apparently not really paying it much mind, but I’ve kind of grown used to it…

I guess I am posting this question here and now because… I dont know why… I guess because I am hoping maybe some kind of information will be drummed up to help the situation… I get so many conflicting opinions on the matter - I’m not sure what to do, so I just end up relying on what I’ve read in the CCC… but, then, how do I really know if I am doing the right thing?
 
If the priest absolves you in confession, your sins are forgiven.

Without knowing the details (and I don’t need to know) it is difficult to determine if your particular issue may be approached by spiritual and/or psychological points of view. Some priests have more experience in one than another. Also, remember that priests are human – not spiritual “robots” that simply repeat the party line. They bring their own unique gifts, talents, and personalities to every situation. Those are the very qualities God uses in their vocation.

I am more concern about your need to keep going to various priests and churches for your answer. Is it because you feel dis-satisfied, or is it because they don’t say what you want them to say? Those are different reasons.

Maybe there is no clear consensus on your issue, and could be viewed from different legitimate perspectives. Again, I don’t know and I don;t want to know. That is your private issue. If that is the case, then you need to follow the path that brings you the greatest spritual ease and comfort.
 
Hi! 🙂

The priests may have varied position/ assessments on some issues/sins confessed to them. For example, I confessed to priest that I have thrown a piece of garbage in an improper place. Priest X says that it is a “sin” (let’s just be generic on this case since this is just hypothetical) because that single garbage can contribute to the destruction of the environment, which is part of God’s creation, hence the need for confession. Then I got absolved then go. The next time, I’ve done it again and after thorough examination of conscience, I felt like I need to confess it. I go to priest Y and he told me that it’s okay not to confess it and that I should just correct my ways. Then I go and got absolved. In that scenario, it’s not their view about the confessed “sin” or whether it should be confessed or not that matters, but the absolution (as stated earlier). If you’re absolved and your confession is sincere, then no worries, you are forgiven. 😉
 
I can relate to the OP - I get varied answers from priests too, and my sins can be quite serious, at least according to my own knowledge of mortal sin and its grip upon me. I don’t think it’s scrupulous to want a definitive answer. This is where some spiritual guidance can come in handy - seeing a priest or a qualified spiritual advisor on a regular basis, and getting that black and white answer and figuring out a strategy for dealing with the sin.

But one thing that strikes me, OP. If this sin is really so ingrained that it seems you will have it for your entire life, then IS IT REALLY a mortal sin? I mean, if you believe that you cannot change it, then you are not really consenting to it, thus, it’s not something you do with full consciousness, but more a part of your make-up. If any priests tell you that this is a gift, I think you need to explore this further. NO PRIEST has ever told me that any part of my sinning is a gift. I don’t think even the most heterodox of priests would call a mortal sin a “gift.”

Are you talking about psychic abilities?
 
But one thing that strikes me, OP. If this sin is really so ingrained that it seems you will have it for your entire life, then IS IT REALLY a mortal sin? I mean, if you believe that you cannot change it, then you are not really consenting to it, thus, it’s not something you do with full consciousness, but more a part of your make-up. If any priests tell you that this is a gift, I think you need to explore this further. NO PRIEST has ever told me that any part of my sinning is a gift. I don’t think even the most heterodox of priests would call a mortal sin a “gift.”
So as not to offend anyone’s sensibilities, the closest I can say is that it’s like being gay, except I am neither bi-, nor homosexual. It’s also nothing illegal. I refer to homosexuality because I tend to think a lot of homosexuality is natural, or it can become so ingrained in a person it may as well be second nature. In any case, an eccentric sexual identity exists, and the shrinks (including my Pastoral Counselors) say it is something one carries throughout one’s life. I also tend toward having a lot of homosexual friends (both male and female), and, while I do not engage in any homosexual or bisexual activities, I nevertheless understand the problem they confront with their sexual identity more than most strictly heterosexuals, and I will proactively extend whatever compassionate conservatism I can to them.

Clinically, it’s identified as a disability with Asperger’s, but what I actually see in my mind is highly disturbing to me. I’ve been in therapy for it for twenty five years or so. The past ten years I have exclusively seen Pastoral Counselors, Faith Healers and Spiritual Directors for the healing. Psychologists tend to have varied opinions, but we believe in one God, so I tend to look for the unifying truths of our faith. I guess that’s why varying opinions from Priests have started to confuse me. I’ve gone deeper into Catholicism with age, and, while I recognize we all have our unique gifts, I nevertheless encounter various opinions that do contradict one another.

Some people think the visions I see define me as a Priest myself, others a wounded healer, and others just a flat out heretic.

Asperger’s seems the most generic and appropriate way to describe it. Asperger’s is a form of Autism - high functioning Autism. I can talk and speak and function, but it is as if parts of my mind still idle, like a kid rocking back and forth. How to snap out of it is the question. Generally, Asperger’s sufferers don’t like change, but change is natural, and, yet, when change snaps me out of my contemplations - it can produce some adverse effects.

In terms of Scripture, I have a thorn in my side, and an angel that beats me daily. St Paul knew it. It’s why he said “I don’t do what I want - I do what I hate!” Some Priests see it as a gift; others see the thorn as a source of adversity. A lot of the time it depends on how I phrase my words when I speak in the confessional, and then at others it doesn’t matter. It depends on how the thorn has been affecting me, and whether I have responded in faith or wandered in sin with respect to it. Sometimes I see the thorn itself as a sin, or as if I must have done something wrong to deserve it.

I don’t think I must be making much sense here. It seems inappropriate to address certain ideas here, so I haven’t and won’t go into specifics.

I just was hoping maybe to understand some way of making sense of all this when Priests say things which are patently contrary to one another. We’re supposed to believe in One God - an absolute truth that transcends all reality. Recognizing the diversity of opinions does help, thank you, but, when the divisions become too contrary, then what does one do?
 
If you feel uncomfortable being specific about this issue, feel free to PM me about it. No one can give you advice on this without actually knowing what you’re talking about.
 
You made sense; don’t worry. I understand better now. Your situation is one that most people will not understand, and that includes priests. It’s not simple at all. You really do have a thorn or a cross to bear. As you describe it, I would have a hard time hearing that this is a “gift.” “Wounded healer” sounds quite new-age to me; it is the type of language I used and believed in before I returned to the Church. But then again, you didn’t say what you do for a living - you could be a psychologist or other medical professional for all I know.

This problem is a lot more complicated than my simple advice can help…All I can say is that it sounds as though you have been wrestling with it for a long time, and surely God sees your efforts. Does this have your full consent? Just from what you’ve said, it seems as though you do not consent and would want to be healed of your affliction. (As an aside, I think Blessed John Paul II needs another miracle to be a saint!) I do not believe that affliction is sin. I could be wrong.

You will be in my prayers.
 
If you feel uncomfortable being specific about this issue, feel free to PM me about it. No one can give you advice on this without actually knowing what you’re talking about.
Some people (the first to respond) seemed to suggest they didn’t want to know the details. 🤷

I actually agreed with this at the outset. The question is more about how to reconcile one’s thinking to the one, holy, absolute and universal truth when Getting contrary information from Priests.

What/who or what interpretation is an ailing soul to trust?
 
You really do have a thorn or a cross to bear. As you describe it, I would have a hard time hearing that this is a “gift.”
While I do struggle with it - it’s important to remember the thorn begets perfection in the end… God willing…

As per comparing the thorn to the cross… I guess that’s just the irony of the cross… It was a horrible way to go, but it was also a gift of grace…
You will be in my prayers.
Thank you. 🙂
 
I actually agreed with this at the outset. The question is more about how to reconcile one’s thinking to the one, holy, absolute and universal truth when Getting contrary information from Priests.
It might be that you’re not able to, unfortunately. Based on what you’ve said though, it sounds as if you do not have full control over your faculties. As such, you are not able to stop yourself, but you are also not giving consent to the action; so, from my understanding of the requirements for something to be a mortal sin, I do not think that this fits the category, so I do not think that particular priest was correct. (Or… well… it is a grave matter, but due to your lack of consent, it isn’t a mortal sin.)

As to the priest who called it a gift, it may be that he views all suffering as a gift, because it brings us closer to our Lord.

And for the one who basically called it no big deal, I’d say he’s being a little too passive about it. If it is a grave matter, you need to be aware of that, even if you aren’t actually committing a mortal sin. If you’re not aware, then your could fall into complacency and acceptance, and begin to actively engage in the sin, at which point it would become mortal.

Good luck to you, I’ll include you in my rosary this afternoon.
 
Some people (the first to respond) seemed to suggest they didn’t want to know the details. 🤷

I actually agreed with this at the outset. The question is more about how to reconcile one’s thinking to the one, holy, absolute and universal truth when Getting contrary information from Priests.

What/who or what interpretation is an ailing soul to trust?
I am glad that you provided some details as it helps a bit in focusing the response. However I understand your desire to have the core question answered and not to get distracted by particular details.

The first thing I would suggest is that the problem of differing takes by the priests may be less a matter of conflicting views so much as a matter of addressing different aspects of the problem based on how well they know you, how the problem was described (and how they understood) and what they felt, at that particular time to be the best way to move forward.
When we are dealing with a deep and difficult sin - or flaw / fault - there are various aspects to be considered and overcoming the fault is a journey. The priest who says it’s “no big thing” can be addressing the idea that one should not despair over the matter. That time and prayer are necessary but to be patient with yourself. Of course if one is not careful, such a view can lead to sloth and presumption.
The Priest who says it is serious matter, may be speaking to this. It is serious and needs to be considered and addressed.
The Priest who speaks of it as a “gift”…That can be a more difficult thing to embrace, but I have found that in our sufferings is almost always a lesson that God wishes us to learn. So here too there may be truth in this priest’s take on the matter.

So - I would suggest that you take these things to the Lord in prayer and mediation. Consider the many aspects of the problem and you desire to reduce it, minimize it and eventually to perhaps even overcome it.

Hope this helps a little.

Peace
James
 
Some people (the first to respond) seemed to suggest they didn’t want to know the details. 🤷

I actually agreed with this at the outset. The question is more about how to reconcile one’s thinking to the one, holy, absolute and universal truth when Getting contrary information from Priests.

What/who or what interpretation is an ailing soul to trust?
I only asked for details so I could give you advice. Knowing as little as I know, I can’t help you.
 
You have been given some good advice. I just wanted to add that you are doing well to check what the CCC says especially if you are hearing conflicting answers from priests. The Catechism is a sure guide to what the Church actually believes and teaches.

God is good and when we continue to try to battle our weaknesses and sins, He will, in HIs good time, step in to help us overcome. Know that God loves you and sees your sincere efforts to live a life pleasing to Him.

You are in my prayers.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top