Our priest said in a sermon that in the past the amount of time devoted to prayer each day would be:
Cloistered Religious – 8 hours
Secular Religious (e.g. parish priest) – 4 hours (due to the recitation of all the hours)
Laity – 2 hours.
If we were to get back this balance the world would be a much different place.
I think your priest had an idealized idea of what monastic life (cloistered religious) was like.
The abbey I’m associated with, on a normal feria (weekday), has the following schedule:
5-5:50 am Vigils 50 minutes + Angelus
Lectio
7:30-8:05 am, Lauds 35 minutes
Work
9:45-9:55 am, Terce 10 minutes
Work
11:00-11:50 am, weekday Mass 50 minutes
12:00-12:10 pm, Sext + None + Angelus 10 minutes
Lunch, brief siesta, work
5:00-5:35 pm, Vespers 35 minutes
Dinner & recreation
7:45-8:05 pm, Compline + Angelus 20 minutes.
Grand Silence (sleep time) is from 9 pm until 5 am (8 hours exactly)
Total time in liturgical prayer, 210 minutes or 3.5 hours. They use a psalm schema that does all 150 psalms in a week for the Divine Office.
Lauds, Mass and Vespers are sung in Gregorian chant. The rest is in French plainchant, recto-tono (monotone chant) for Vigils, Terce and Sext. Add in the lectio time and you could say that they spend a total of 5 hours in prayer. In all of that they need to attend to personal needs, run the monastery and in this case, run their cheese factory and cider factory.
It’s probably true that in the pre-Vatican II days monks spent 8 hours in prayer. The calendar was much more complicated with more feasts, octaves, etc. than today, with elaborate liturgies to go with it, with very ornate chant (longer, more melismatic antiphons, etc.).
What effect did this have on monastic life? For starters, it resulted in the need to divide monks into choir monks, where the better-educated and more intellectual brothers were directed into choir to become eventually priests. Monks with little education became lay brothers. They had separate Offices. They had very little interaction between each other. They in fact led very separate lives.
This was so far from the ideal of the Benedictine’s founder, St. Benedict, that by Vatican II monastic life looked little like what the Rule of St. Benedict intended it to be. Whereas the Rule calls for a balanced life for all, monasteries achieved “balance” by in fact dividing monks into two classes. In the Rule, the only “caste” was to be the order in which one arrived at the monastery (seniority).
In short, immediately before Vatican II, monastic life little resembled what it was meant to be. Vatican II restored that balance. In our abbey, in the 1980s, the lay brother caste was abandoned, and all “lay brothers” became formally professed monks. All monks, regardless of clerical status, became obligated to choir, priest or otherwise. Now if you attend say, Vespers, all monks will be dressed in their black habit regardless of clerical status (unless it is a feast or solemnity when one priest-monk will be in chasuble to preside).
Clearly then, in today’s context it would not be possible for all monks to spend 8 hours in choir and still keep the place going. St. Benedict intended that monasteries live off the fruits of their own labour. He never intended that monks would be divided into a clerical caste, and a servant caste. All were to chip in and run the place. St. Benedict himself, the first abbot, wasn’t even a priest.
I think one has to be careful about presenting an idealized portrait of what one thinks is “tradition” but is in fact nostalgia for a specific point in time, and a point in time that had its own problems, and in the case of monasticism, had strayed so far from the founder’s ideals that it had little resemblance to what he intended a monastery to be. If you read the rule, it is clear that St. Benedict intended monks to do about 6-8 hours of physical labour per day. Clearly that wouldn’t be possible with 8 hours of prayer as well; taking away an hour for meals and personal needs, and some time for rest and recreation, it would leave monks less than 7 hours of sleep per day.
The community I’m affiliated to is a cloistered community. Many communities also have external apostolates such as running colleges, which is why today Benedictines are only bound to a psalm schema that spreads the psalter over 2 weeks instead of 1 week (and in some rare cases the 4-week LOTH is allowed), although many do continue to use 1-week schemas.
Diocesan priests have their own constraints and realities today with diminishing vocations. The simplification of the LOTH for them in fact began with Pius X in 1910 who reduced their load from the monastic 250 psalms per week to 150.