Pro and Cons of Priests being married

  • Thread starter Thread starter Life4Christ
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
40.png
mercygate:
Note also that the married converts who have been ordained as Priests in the Catholic Church are among the staunchest and most vocal proponents of the rule of celibacy. Ray Ryland is among the most articulate. But so is the former Anglican Bishop of London, Fr. Graham Leonard.
As one who has a lot of personal experience with married Catholic clergy, I can attest that all the married clergy I know stand in awe of their celibate brothers in the cloth for the magnificent donation of self they are able to make to their flock, that is really impossible for a man who also has the responsibility of a wife and children. There is a (very limited) place in the Church for married priests, but the higher calling is to the celibate priesthood.
 
The catholic priest is a representative of christ dully obligated to offer sacrifice on be half of the people. No matter how we justify it the fact remains that as a lay man or married man there are so many obligation required, if the married priest is dedicated to duty and christ like in action what of the attitude of the wife? can she in her own way as a priest wife practice humility and show love to the congregation? what of the children at the age of 18 which one of them can keep to the law "Thou shall not committ adultry/fornication. Christ is perfect and those who represent him on the alter are to work towards perfection.
 
A pro to a priest being married is the ability to do marriage counseling on a different level. If they haven’t been married, how can they possibly do marriage counseling without knowing exactly what transpires in a marriage. Sure they hear stories, both good and bad, but unless you experience first hand…you don’t have a clue. Anybody can take classes on it, but that doesn’t make you an expert.

A con would be that it would take away from his personal devotion and commitment to Christ. Instead of being focused on Him, the priest would have to take “time out” for family matters.
 
In regards to celibacy of church leaders, in 1 Corinthians chapter 7, the Apostle Paul teaches, “An unmarried man is concerned about the Lord’s affairs — how he can please the Lord. But a married man is concerned about the affairs of this world — how he can please his wife— and his interests are divided” (1 Corinthians 7:32-34). In some instances, celibacy has a positive impact on ministry. If a church leader is free from spousal and familial responsibilities, he can better focus on ministering to others. Jesus mentions some becoming “eunuchs” for the kingdom of God (Matthew 19:12). Celibacy is definitely allowed for church leaders, and to a certain degree, it is encouraged. However, Scripture nowhere requires celibacy for those serving in positions of church leadership.
 
Let’s face reality.

The priest is married to the Church, as he should be. He is on call at all hours. He spends regular hours every day of the week celebrating Mass, sometimes more than once. He hears confessions on regular times and upon appointments. He counsels people, he teaches, he is an administrator. He responds to complaints and compliments, and in all of that he needs time for prayer, reflection, retreat, and time to focus on the Lord all by himself.

Speaking as a woman, the reality is that I would not want to be married to the priest. If I were the wife of one man, I want to be first in his life, not last on the list behind everyone else in the Church. I would need my provider, I would need a shoulder to cry on when I get home from work, and if that work is the parish, then I would need my husband to spend time being my husband.

Jesus said that we cannot serve two masters, and indeed, marriage is a “master” because it is a covenant with God. Holy Orders is a covenant with God. How can we force one human being to choose between his God and his wife?

Simple…we don’t give him that choice because it would tear him apart.

The priesthood is not a career…it is a way of life. Priests die to the world in favor of service to God, wheras a husband and wife die to others in order to be of service to each other in cooperation with God.

The fruit of the marriage between the Church and the priest is the growing spirit of the individual parishes, the children brought up properly in the sacraments, etc.

The Church is the wife of the priest, and in the sacrament of Holy Orders we see the marriage ceremony before our eyes and understand that the new priest is married to US, the laity. He is our spiritual father, he is our earthly shepherd and in order for him to fulfill his vows, he needs both our support and prayers (we his spiritual family) and to NOT have the complication of a wife.

Marriages in which the wife comes second to the job don’t last. Usually the person who gives his life to his career is called a “workaholic”. That’s why the priesthood is not just a job. It’s not a 8-5 deal. It is a calling and a serious committment.

I have a friend who is a pastor for a Protestant denimination, and says he was called. However, although he now does teh occasional wedding and funeral, he is no longer in active ministry nor is he the pastor of any church. He complained about the calls at all hours and having to be at the service of others constantly. He became tired of it and decided to pick and choose when he would serve the Lord.

So is he “Called” or is it the man who gave his vows to God alone and who serves for life, like it or not?

Marriage and Holy Orders are similar sacraments with the same basic principal.

God bless our Priests and leave them alone! Believe it or not, they are happy in their celibacy, even when it is difficult!
👍 👍
 
The catholic priest is a representative of christ dully obligated to offer sacrifice on be half of the people. No matter how we justify it the fact remains that as a lay man or married man there are so many obligation required, if the married priest is dedicated to duty and christ like in action what of the attitude of the wife? can she in her own way as a priest wife practice humility and show love to the congregation? what of the children at the age of 18 which one of them can keep to the law "Thou shall not committ adultry/fornication. Christ is perfect and those who represent him on the alter are to work towards perfection.
Agreed Completely Of What You Said. If I Were A Priest, I Would Focus My Work On Christ By Building His Kingdom Instead Of Getting Married Or Being Married In The First Place.

I Have A Question What Does Persona Christi Mean ? 🤷
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top