Probe after passenger throws fare-dodger off train

  • Thread starter Thread starter LemonAndLime
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I disagree. Listening to the dialog they weren’t going to start the train because the kid was going to ride to the next stop and then run away. There’s no pressing reason to refrain from using force to evict him, and I don’t see anything especially wrong with a passenger volunteering to enforce the conductor’s authority to remove the perp either.

It’s a symptom of our lawyer-plagued, post-modern era that every problem needs to resolved by either tolerating a provocateur or having the police come arrest someone.
  • Marty Lund
I have physically bounced many unruly people from establishments, young, old, male and female. I fail to see the issue.
The main issue would be he assaulted another passenger rather than let the conductor or police deal with it. I am sure if that was a 70 year old woman it would cause outrage, and rightly so
 
The main issue would be he assaulted another passenger rather than let the conductor or police deal with it. I am sure if that was a 70 year old woman it would cause outrage, and rightly so
You say he assaulted another person.
 
You say he assaulted another person.
The guys face says so too. Although even if he didn’t get hurt, I still think the passenger was in the wrong. Will have to wait and see what comes of it, if anything.
 
I disagree. Listening to the dialog they weren’t going to start the train because the kid was going to ride to the next stop and then run away. There’s no pressing reason to refrain from using force to evict him, and I don’t see anything especially wrong with a passenger volunteering to enforce the conductor’s authority to remove the perp either.

It’s a symptom of our lawyer-plagued, post-modern era that every problem needs to resolved by either tolerating a provocateur or having the police come arrest someone.
  • Marty Lund
The police have now received a complaint from the ‘yoof’ who was thrown off the train. Think he might press charges.
 
The police have now received a complaint from the ‘yoof’ who was thrown off the train. Think he might press charges.
In a sane world the police would be bringing the ‘yoof’ up on charges and he’d receive a speedy judgment from a magistrate sentencing him to some community service.
  • Marty Lund
 
If it were up to me, he’d get thrown off for the bad language, never mind any fare dodging, and then hauled infront of the nearest judge for a public order offense.
 
I don’t think the student was an innocent victim, I think he is an inconsiderate idiot. However, he should have been dealt with by the proper authorities and given the maximum fine if appropriate. I disagree with the passenger taking it upon himself to basically assault him by throwing him off. He and the fare dodger should be dealt with and the conductor given more training perhaps. If the student refuses to get off, have the police take him off at the next stop.
Perhaps conductors could be authorized to “deputize” passengers so that the “good samaritan” would be acting as a lawful agent of some sort.

I guess … the passengers on that airliner over Detroit could be sued by the passenger who tried to blow up the airplane. I mean the other passengers kind of like used force.

[Didn’t the airline crew ask the other passengers to keep an eye on the suspected terrorist?]

[Doesn’t a train crew have the authority to request assistance from the passengers in an situation that is threatening or difficult or disorderly?]
 
The police have now received a complaint from the ‘yoof’ who was thrown off the train. Think he might press charges.
I thought the word was pronounced: “yoot” … or … “yout”.

Or perhaps, “yute”.

[with the diacriticial mark designating a short “u”.]

I’m sorry. Just getting a little punchy here.
 
In a sane world the police would be bringing the ‘yoof’ up on charges and he’d receive a speedy judgment from a magistrate sentencing him to some community service.
  • Marty Lund
The judge could find the ‘yoof’ in contempt of court.

Or … in contempt of train.

[Me go now.]
 
Well I don’t agree with students, pensioners or anyone being assaulted by a fellow passenger and thrown off a train without their belongings. You think that is what should happen and I am sure lots of people agree as it is an issue that divides opinion.
I don’t agree with someone who is either trying to scam by knowingly fare evading, or at best too stupid to check that he had the correct ticket before boarding, who think’s it’s perfectly okay to swear at a conductor and make an entire trainfull of passengers suffer delays when the consequences of his cheating or stupidity catch up with him.
 
Perhaps conductors could be authorized to “deputize” passengers so that the “good samaritan” would be acting as a lawful agent of some sort.

I guess … the passengers on that airliner over Detroit could be sued by the passenger who tried to blow up the airplane. I mean the other passengers kind of like used force.

[Didn’t the airline crew ask the other passengers to keep an eye on the suspected terrorist?]

[Doesn’t a train crew have the authority to request assistance from the passengers in an situation that is threatening or difficult or disorderly?]
This could possibly be a good idea, and may not even be necessary if the fare dodger was being violent. I would applaud the passenger for stepping in if that were the case.

There is probably a small difference though between a young, possibly drunk, idiot with a wrong ticket using foul langauge but no physical threat to anyone on the train, than a group of suicide bombers on a plane.
 
I don’t agree with someone who is either trying to scam by knowingly fare evading, or at best too stupid to check that he had the correct ticket before boarding, who think’s it’s perfectly okay to swear at a conductor and make an entire trainfull of passengers suffer delays when the consequences of his cheating or stupidity catch up with him.
Either do I.
 
Funny story, and there was no violence involved thankfully. Scottish or not, it does not give this passenger the right to do what he did. I am sure if the fare dodger was his own size he would have just stayed in his seat.
Yeah, but I think more of us should be involved. If waiting for the authorities meant hanging the train up half an hour with all those people on board for one interloper, then what was the harm done? He wasn’t assaulted, he was picked up and moved off the train.

Now I’ll tell you about one time I was taking the bus to work. A young man comes on the bus arguing with a young lady. The argument escalates, and the young man hauls off and slaps the girl hard. Everyone on the bus just sat there, tried to look away with their mouth gaped open. I was mad…REALLY MAD. I jump up from my seat pick the young man up by the lapels of his jacket, throw him down on the aisle of the bus, sit on his chest and thumping his chest screaming, “YOU DON’T HIT WOMEN! YOU DON’T HIT WOMEN!!!” I picked him up off the floor of the bus and pushed him into a seat and sat next to him.

He tried to make another move towards the young girl, but I blocked him, and he gave me the gangsta cut eye.
His 2 mates when I got off the bus followed me a block or two, trying to goad me into a confrontation, to which I turned to them and looked them straight and said, “It could’ve been your mother, or your sister, and if it was, then you’d better hope somebody like me is around.”

I’m a peace loving man. But I would not say I’m a total pacifist.

What is that’s said… Evil thrives when good people do nothing in the face of evil?
 
I was initially upset because I thought the train was moving at the time.

[seriously]

[no, really, just from reading the title. :rotfl: silly me. ]

youtube.com/watch?v=FZLxAlTrhPA
Like something from Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade (When Indy throws the NAZI out of the zepplin) or the homage to that when in Dogma Silent Bob (aka Kevin Smith) throws the angels off the train and says to the other passengers, “No ticket.” lol
 
Yeah, but I think more of us should be involved. If waiting for the authorities meant hanging the train up half an hour with all those people on board for one interloper, then what was the harm done? He wasn’t assaulted, he was picked up and moved off the train.

Now I’ll tell you about one time I was taking the bus to work. A young man comes on the bus arguing with a young lady. The argument escalates, and the young man hauls off and slaps the girl hard. Everyone on the bus just sat there, tried to look away with their mouth gaped open. I was mad…REALLY MAD. I jump up from my seat pick the young man up by the lapels of his jacket, throw him down on the aisle of the bus, sit on his chest and thumping his chest screaming, “YOU DON’T HIT WOMEN! YOU DON’T HIT WOMEN!!!” I picked him up off the floor of the bus and pushed him into a seat and sat next to him.

He tried to make another move towards the young girl, but I blocked him, and he gave me the gangsta cut eye.
His 2 mates when I got off the bus followed me a block or two, trying to goad me into a confrontation, to which I turned to them and looked them straight and said, “It could’ve been your mother, or your sister, and if it was, then you’d better hope somebody like me is around.”

I’m a peace loving man. But I would not say I’m a total pacifist.

What is that’s said… Evil thrives when good people do nothing in the face of evil?
I would not call having the wrong ticket as evil. As I said before, the normal course of action was not to delay the other passengers and get him removed at the next stop. He was not violent, just an inconsiderate idiot.
 
If the student really did have a ticket … then the conductor could have collected it … even if it was not exactly the right ticket … and the railroad would have got its money.

But, the description of the incident is different … no ticket.

“Theft of services”.

I have been on trains when passengers had the “wrong ticket” and the conductor either accepted and punched the “wrong ticket” and/or collected the difference between the right ticket and the wrong ticket.

If the “wrong ticket” is worth more than the “right ticket”, either the passenger forfeits the difference, or sometimes the conductor can issue a “ticket” that can be redeemed at the office.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top