Problem of non-belief

  • Thread starter Thread starter Future_Prodigy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
F

Future_Prodigy

Guest
Is anyone familiar with this argument? What are its shortcomings in relation to the catholic notion of GOD!?
 
It’s a relative of the problem of evil. Idea is, if there is a deity who wants everyone to be saved, why are there unbelievers?

It’s not as strong as the PoE, which basically forces one to admit that a hypothetical omnipotent God has a rather odd idea of benevolence from a human standpoint. The problem of non-belief assumes that salvation must needs be more important to God than free will, which is not a position held by most theologians – universalists aside, for whom the point is moot anyway: everybody is saved, faith or no faith.
 
mirdath is correct in his summary of it, but an important component is its relation to God’s hiddenness as well. Mirdath, how do you personally make sense of the problem in relation to your faith?!
 
i just read your profile, your a agnostic, so it might not be the best to ask you how you make sense of it in relaiton to your faith. However, have you read of any catholic response to such a problem? I have only come across evangelical responses and was wondering how the cahtolic notion of God, which is different, makes sense of this argument.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top