Proof That Going to Jesus Through Mary Isn't Wrong

  • Thread starter Thread starter gatewood1988
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
G

gatewood1988

Guest
I know I am a worry wart sometimes, I was cleaning out our religious bookshelf the other day and found on of those Chick comics on why Mary is crying. Apparently my husband found it in the Adoration Chapel at the Hospital when we went for holy hour. As I flipped through, not realizing exactly what it was I saw things in it that hint to Mary never wanting us to go to her for help, but straight to her son. I had my husband rip it up and throw it out with the garbage, but I cannot get out of my mind the things that were in the comic and I feel like I may be wrong in going to Mary. I have been having a hard time praying the rosary now and am having a hard time focusing my attention on the Lord and asking for the intercession of the saints. I am so afraid of going to hell. Is there true solid proof that Mary is an intercessor for us? I am worried because I also came across a scripture that says no one other than Jesus is a mediator to the Father for us. How does Mary and the saints fit into this? Please help a confused Catholic put her doubts to rest.😦
 
In the book of revelations it speaks of the angels offering up in golden bowls the prayers of the saints (believing Christians) as incense to God. We see this in Revelation 8:3-4 and he was given much incense to mingle with the **prayers of all the saints **upon the golden altar before the throne; and the smoke of the incense rose with the prayers of the saints from the hand of the angel before God.

We are all co-mediators along with the Virgin Mary in interceding for one another through prayer. Was not the prayer of Tobit heard by the Archangel Raphael and brought before the throne of God? We see this in the bible where it says in **Tobit 12:15 ** I am Raphael, one of the seven holy angels who presents the prayers of the saints and enter into the presence of the glory of the Holy One."

If our prayers are offered up in golden bowls of incense by the angels to the Lord Our God on our behalf, does it not also fit that the prayers of the saints in heaven also pray on our behalfs and that these prayers are also offered to the Lord? The saints in heaven are not dead but are alive in Christ. Again in the bible it says in Mark 12:27 “He is not God of the dead, but of the living”.

There is also the example of Moses and Elijah appearing on either side of Jesus when he was transfigured before the 3 apostles and shows that the Saints (Virgin Mary included) are not dead but alive. Matthew 17:3 And behold, there appeared to them Moses and Elijah, talking with Him.

So I see no problem in praying to the Blessed Virgin Mary and asking for her to interceded on our behalf…Continue in your prayers to the saints and in praying your rosary. Be at peace my friend.

God bless and Happy Easter!
 
For me it’s like this: If you were a kid who got very hurt, or really wanted a special favor, which of your parents would you go to first for comfort or help? Don’t most run to their mother? Maybe it’s a male-female thing, female being the kinder and gentler. She’s that kind of help for me. Since I began saying a rosary every day I’ve become much more devout in every way, not just Marian. Sinless Mary suffered much, yet never said a word in scripture after “Do whatever He tells you.” That’s an answer right there. She didn’t say, “Listen to me”, she pointed to Jesus.

It’s not wrong, just another Way, like praying to favorite saints, saints you feel understand you because they had similar problems when they were on earth, and whom you hope to be friends with after you die. I want all the help I can get. 🙂

I never saw those comics. Maybe the guy had issues with women. 🤷
 
First of all, realize the Chick tracts are very anti-Catholic. It seems like their intent is to demonize the Catholic church rather than bring souls to Christ. Jimmy Akin has some very good articles on catholic.com on the pure vile hatred in these. I strongly recommend everyone read them and see how scripture is twisted and the truth is bent to meet their agenda. Pray for them all.

Now to your specific question. When someone dies they do not cease to exist. Those who die in God’s grace are welcomed into heaven. Like TempleofTheSoul shows, scripture teaches He is the God of the living, not the dead. Those in heaven are indeed alive. They are part of what we call the Church Triumphant. Those who have died and are in need of a little bit more cleaning in Purgatory are called the Church Suffering. We living on earth today are the Church Militant.

The point is we are all part of Christ’s church. Death cannot separate us from Him. It joins us to Him in a more perfect way. We will always be a disciple of Him - for all of eternity. The church is the body of believers. So, those who believe and love Him are part of His church regardless of whether they are on earth or in heaven.

We are called in scripture to pray for each other. Several times Paul writes where he is praying for distant churches. Likewise, he asks for their prayers. Jesus told Peter that He was praying for him. So we can ask others to pray for us. No where in scripture does it say we can only ask for prayers from those here on earth. We can ask any believer, in any state, to pray for us. Asking saints to pray for us is as natural as asking the person in the pew next to you. But those in heaven are much closer to God and can reach him in ways we cannot. I’m not saying praying to saints is better, but it never hurts to get more believers interceding for you.

So now, why Mary? Of all the disciples, she is the most perfect of them all. She is closer to Jesus than any other saint. She knew Him before He was born. She nursed Him, nurtured Him, probably kissed His scrapes and bruises. She followed Him during His entire ministry. She never left His side, even from the cross to the tomb to the upper room. She was and is 100% devoted to Him. If she intercedes for us, He will probably give her requests special consideration. After all, Jesus honored His mother as taught in the commandments. By honoring her ourselves, we are following His example.

To be clear, we do not worship Mary or any other saints. Worship is for God alone. But we are instructed to pray for each other. This can be done by all members of His church - here or in heaven.
 
I know I am a worry wart sometimes, I was cleaning out our religious bookshelf the other day and found on of those Chick comics on why Mary is crying. Apparently my husband found it in the Adoration Chapel at the Hospital when we went for holy hour. As I flipped through, not realizing exactly what it was I saw things in it that hint to Mary never wanting us to go to her for help, but straight to her son. I had my husband rip it up and throw it out with the garbage, but I cannot get out of my mind the things that were in the comic and I feel like I may be wrong in going to Mary. I have been having a hard time praying the rosary now and am having a hard time focusing my attention on the Lord and asking for the intercession of the saints. I am so afraid of going to hell. Is there true solid proof that Mary is an intercessor for us? I am worried because I also came across a scripture that says no one other than Jesus is a mediator to the Father for us. How does Mary and the saints fit into this? Please help a confused Catholic put her doubts to rest.😦
We ask saints foe example Saint Anthony ,that ask God something forus,he is so closed with God that he know the right way to ask God
 
The wedding feast at Cana comes to mind. The bride and groom run out of wine, but it is Mary who brings the request before Christ not them. Mary interceded for the them, despite the fact that Jesus was physically right there.

Also, I highly doubt God would allow Mary to appear as often as she has recently if it were sinful to ask for her intercession (since she recommends that we do each time).

As a last thought, I remember a homily where the priest said that there was a time when the Church had more or less stopped praying for things like healing, and so Mary and the saints “took up the slack” (he was talking about the time that Mary led that one girl to a spring that has been involved in miraculous healings ever since). So you might, only might, be able to argue that if we were perfect at prayer, we wouldn’t need to go through the saints. But we aren’t, and they’ve got a bit more practice (and a better perspective on Who all prayers are directed to at the moment), so they help us out.
 
First of all, realize the Chick tracts are very anti-Catholic. It seems like their intent is to demonize the Catholic church rather than bring souls to Christ. Jimmy Akin has some very good articles on catholic.com on the pure vile hatred in these. I strongly recommend everyone read them and see how scripture is twisted and the truth is bent to meet their agenda. Pray for them all.

Now to your specific question. When someone dies they do not cease to exist. Those who die in God’s grace are welcomed into heaven. Like TempleofTheSoul shows, scripture teaches He is the God of the living, not the dead. Those in heaven are indeed alive. They are part of what we call the Church Triumphant. Those who have died and are in need of a little bit more cleaning in Purgatory are called the Church Suffering. We living on earth today are the Church Militant.

The point is we are all part of Christ’s church. Death cannot separate us from Him. It joins us to Him in a more perfect way. We will always be a disciple of Him - for all of eternity. The church is the body of believers. So, those who believe and love Him are part of His church regardless of whether they are on earth or in heaven.

We are called in scripture to pray for each other. Several times Paul writes where he is praying for distant churches. Likewise, he asks for their prayers. Jesus told Peter that He was praying for him. So we can ask others to pray for us. No where in scripture does it say we can only ask for prayers from those here on earth. We can ask any believer, in any state, to pray for us. Asking saints to pray for us is as natural as asking the person in the pew next to you. But those in heaven are much closer to God and can reach him in ways we cannot. I’m not saying praying to saints is better, but it never hurts to get more believers interceding for you.

So now, why Mary? Of all the disciples, she is the most perfect of them all. She is closer to Jesus than any other saint. She knew Him before He was born. She nursed Him, nurtured Him, probably kissed His scrapes and bruises. She followed Him during His entire ministry. She never left His side, even from the cross to the tomb to the upper room. She was and is 100% devoted to Him. If she intercedes for us, He will probably give her requests special consideration. After all, Jesus honored His mother as taught in the commandments. By honoring her ourselves, we are following His example.

To be clear, we do not worship Mary or any other saints. Worship is for God alone. But we are instructed to pray for each other. This can be done by all members of His church - here or in heaven.
this covers it all…amen
 
Thank you everyone, I feel alot better now. I also looked up alot on what Catholic Answers had said about Chick Publications before and what y’all posted too. I just can’t believe something like that made its way into the Perpetual Adoration Chapel and into my home. It makes me get a little steamed. It’s hard to be careful in the Buckle of the Bible Belt. 😛 I am constantly confronted with anti-Catholic literature and people. Mostly because I am not afraid to show that I am Catholic. I even have a bumper sticker that says I love the Pope. I guess I have to be on guard more as to what we bring into our home.
 
Thank you everyone, I feel alot better now. I also looked up alot on what Catholic Answers had said about Chick Publications before and what y’all posted too. I just can’t believe something like that made its way into the Perpetual Adoration Chapel and into my home. It makes me get a little steamed. It’s hard to be careful in the Buckle of the Bible Belt. 😛 I am constantly confronted with anti-Catholic literature and people. Mostly because I am not afraid to show that I am Catholic. I even have a bumper sticker that says I love the Pope. I guess I have to be on guard more as to what we bring into our home.
If these made it into the Perpetual Adoration Chapel, they may have been placed there by anti-Catholics. :eek:

Keep vigilant! Remember, if we are confronted it means we must be doing something right. Besides, it’s in the membership manual (see Matt 5:11-12). When confronted, remember 1 Peter 3:15,
“Always be ready to give an explanation to anyone who asks you for a reason for your hope, but do it with gentleness and reverence, keeping your conscience clear, so that, when you are maligned, those who defame your good conduct in Christ may themselves be put to shame.”
 
The evil one is out there trying to take you away from the truth with lies, even to the chruch’s elect if I choose to belive, he wins. So I humble myself, with love and an inner peace when I pray with Mary (she did stepped on the serpents head after all) and the Saints and Angels to carry my prayers to God in heaven.
Barthalomew is my favorite apostle so he is who i use as my mediator.
God Bless

jesus g
 
meditate on the story of the Wedding Feast at Cana, near the beginning of John’s gospel.

What does Mary say to anyone who asks for her help?

“Do whatever HE tells you.”

that is the answer you will ALWAYS get from Mary when you pray to her.

If non-Catholics reject Mary, they reject Jesus, and they reject the whole truth about Jesus, that he is truly human and truly divine.
 
If non-Catholics reject Mary, they reject Jesus, and they reject the whole truth about Jesus, that he is truly human and truly divine.
How does someone reject Jesus if they don’t pray to Mary?

The primary person is Jesus. I don’t see what praying or not praying to Mary has to do with rejecting Jesus or even Mary.
 
How does someone reject Jesus if they don’t pray to Mary?

The primary person is Jesus. I don’t see what praying or not praying to Mary has to do with rejecting Jesus or even Mary.
Many protestants, in an attempt to focus on Jesus (good), sideline Mary entirely essentially saying that she was completely unimportant (bad). The idea is that God often works through people and denying this and the times he has done so is to deny part of the nature and workings of God (bad). And he worked through the person who he chose to be his mother in a very real way.

That’s not to say that you have to have a strong Marian Devotion (even the current pope is known for his “Marian cool”), but denying her role in things entirely is… problematic.
 
Many protestants, in an attempt to focus on Jesus (good), sideline Mary entirely essentially saying that she was completely unimportant (bad). The idea is that God often works through people and denying this and the times he has done so is to deny part of the nature and workings of God (bad). And he worked through the person who he chose to be his mother in a very real way.

That’s not to say that you have to have a strong Marian Devotion (even the current pope is known for his “Marian cool”), but denying her role in things entirely is… problematic.
Her role is that she was obedient and did what was asked of her and all nations call her blessed. Protestants believe this.

If you believe that at minimum, I don’t see how that would be an insult to Jesus or to Mary?
 
The wedding feast at Cana comes to mind. The bride and groom run out of wine, but it is Mary who brings the request before Christ not them. Mary interceded for the them, despite the fact that Jesus was physically right there.

.
John, 2- 3-5
" And they ran out of wine, since the wine provided for the feast had all been used, and the mother of Jesus said to him, ‘They have no wine.’

Jesus said, ‘Woman, what do you want from me? My hour has not come yet.’

His mother said to the servants, ‘Do whatever he tells you.’ "

Note that Jesus says His hour has not come, so if Mary had not intervened, Christ would not have performed the miracle. I have always considered this when praying to Mary, that scripture does record that Christ’s first miracle is performed due to Mary’s intervention.
 
Her role is that she was obedient and did what was asked of her and all nations call her blessed. Protestants believe this.

If you believe that at minimum, I don’t see how that would be an insult to Jesus or to Mary?
You would need to believe at least in the defined dogmas such as the Immaculate Conception and the Assumption, and probably others that fall under the ordinary Magisterium. Not to do so would be an insult to Jesus because it would show that one does not trust the Church He founded.
 
How does someone reject Jesus if they don’t pray to Mary?

The primary person is Jesus. I don’t see what praying or not praying to Mary has to do with rejecting Jesus or even Mary.
why are you putting words in my mouth? read my post. I said “those who reject Mary” not “those who do not pray to Mary.” Those who reject Mary reject doctrine about Mary, and that doctrine is not about Mary, it is about Jesus, and was defined specifically to combat heresy about his divine and human nature. To reject all the Church teaches about Mary is to reject all that she teaches, in whole or in part, about Jesus Christ. A Christian can live a full spiritual life in relationship with Jesus Christ without ever once praying to Mary, but he cannot understand and accept the fullness of doctrine about Jesus if he rejects doctrine about Mary.

To answer OP’s question, if in the gospel one who appealed to Mary received a favor from Jesus, ergo that cannot now or ever be wrong, therefore it cannot now or ever be wrong to pray to Jesus through Mary.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top