Protestant England is Dead

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ahimsa
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
40.png
teresas1979:
I’m sorry that the BBC boards have shown such disrespect to you.
.
.
.
I guess I should be saying sorry for any finger pointing I may have done of my own.
We can each apoligize for our own little role in the condition of our world - “what I have done and what I have failed to do”.

But all of us at least recognize being a minority in our beautiful faith. For those who feel like even more of a minority, all the more accolades - we know that you are you, not the vicinity you live in, so please feel all the more welcome at this site.
 
Ani
I’m also sorry you experienced rudeness on the BBC Boards.
However,i think you must have been on the English Boards,as i have tried to persuade people to help me out on the BBC’s Scottish Soapbox and i have failed miserably.There have been North Americans on this Board,but not to defend Catholicism.
There are sometimes posts from people who have some catholic sympathies,but they are not in tune with all the Church Teachings.
We have recently had some posts from the British equivalent of the Ku Klux Klan.I have to laugh at the way these guys can draw the lefties out of the woodwork.Of course,the reverse equally applies if you visit a right-wing website.Even if you are a Capitalist,
you only need to say something slightly to the Left of Adolf Hitler.
I hope the link below works:-
bbc.co.uk/cgi-perl/h2/h2.cgi?state=threads&board=talkscotland.soapbox&&sort=T

QUOTE=teresas1979]Hi Ani

I’m sorry that the BBC boards have shown such disrespect to you. I have never been able to access them and largely prefer it here anyway;) It just gets irritating when people judge what they (generally) do not know about and I was highlighting Terri as a reason NOT to judge the US even though many people will. It is difficult to keep an open mind about what happens elsewhere when the news and statistics present a bias but when (Catholic) people with first hand experience say that it is not the case I would tend to believe them over those with an agenda in the media.

I did not mean to infer that people here are any less judgemental, but that we ought to be and that as Christians we should be wary of pointing the finger too soon. Personally, I find Catholicism to be pretty strong here (less so where I am actually living now) so I find the stats people show to be misleading at best.

I guess I should be saying sorry for any finger pointing I may have done of my own. I am sad that people have an IMO warped view of a country I love and I feel compelled to defend it. The city in which I was raised was destroyed in WWII and it was the Irish Catholic immigrants who rebuilt her. These are my roots of which I am very proud so I guess I have over reacted because I felt this was being threatened.:o
 
Hi burnside. I think I will decline to go to the Scottish BBC just to chat but, if you can come up with some election questions during the English election, then I will go over and give a hand. Glad to. In fact probably a small group of us can go over. Now you have your own parliament, so the coming elections: how do they affect you? What are the ‘official’ election questions? Who determined what they are?
 
protestant England is not dead in East Anglia
in my town there are protestant churches of several denominations some larger and better attended than others. there is a particularly strong methodist tradition here and many active christians:)
 
Ani Ibi:
Ok Teresas and David. Let us not linger in the problem but have faith that we can help each other with the solution. We have problems in Canada, the U.S., and Britain. As we have seen during the Fight for Terri, we can work on the same team. It is critical that we work on the same team.

There are enough differences in the culture and in government between the three countries to be exquisitely useful to us. It gives us flexibility and helps us to think outside the box. 😃 We share a common enemy: secular humanism aka the culture of death. My friend Pondero likes to point out the many old village churches in England which remind us of a once faithful people.

England has an election soon and so does Canada. You American posters can help us both by giving us support, prayer, advice, and by deluging the discussion boards and the media. We are God’s citizens first and citizens of king and country second. Let us be good soldiers in the battle to protect the sanctity of life.

Agreed?
In the immediate, there is only one political solution in Britain and Canada: The Labour Party (Britain) and the Liberal Party (Canada) have got to go. Based on the Canadian polls, presuming you all have an election some time in the next month or two (which is a possibility) there will be no trouble getting the Liberals out. As Ani knows better than I do, however, a Conservative government will not initially be a stable one. It will be a minority government, and present polls are so close that there is a serious possibility for a hung Parliament…I am less fully aware of the present electoral situation in Britain…When will there be a vote at this point? How do the polls look?

Most importantly, I should ask, how can we help here? Can you keep us updated (per the “In the News” forum etc.) as to what’s happening in the coming elections?

Ani is right that England was “once faithful.” Canada was “once faithful (What on earth is happening to the Church up there…is orthodoxy to be found among the Canadian episcopacy nowadays at all?)” The U.S. is well on it’s way to becoming “once faithful.” The root of the problem is a spiritual one. We must restore the faith.
 
40.png
teresas1979:
I’m 100% agreed Ani. It’s voting where we can make the single biggest difference the easiest. I am not allowed to vote in Sheffield :mad: because of a mistake leaving us off the electoral roll until it was too late (mid Feb they closed the lists and wrote to us after the deadline to let us know :confused: )but it looks like I will now be in Coventry (where I presume I still can vote) on election day. I will look into it this weekend but I think I must be on the electoral roll there still because that’s the last place I voted.
**I kind of miss the old politics forum because it would have afforded me the opportunity to comment on this more in-depth…but I have always found the British and Canadian election systems to be fascinating and quite entertaining (in a very good way). **

Not having grown up with a Parliamentary system, I have a great respect for a system that causes the rise and fall of governments to be dependent on party control within the legislature. This sort of arrangement is especially effective when out-of-control courts need to be reigned in (per Terri Schiavo). It also preserves political diversity within the legislature.

On the other hand, a check-and-balance system has its advantages too…there is nothing to stop an out-of control Parliament from doing great damage if one party has huge numbers, as both the Liberals and Labour do now. An immediate check on Parliament could stop some of the worst legislation from being enacted.
 
David Oatney said:
Teresas;
I’ll agree that there are more PRACTICING Catholics in England than PRACTICING Protestants. In this sense, there is certainly hope that at some point in the (distant) future, there is a chance for a rebirth of Catholic England…with a Catholic majority in Parliament and a Catholic crown. (While we’re at it, maybe we ought to demand our beautiful Abbey back that the Protestants have desecrated.)

Realistically, England is presently neither Catholic nor Protestant, it is a saecular state. Any nation that would allow the things which Britain has allowed in law cannot rightly be called Christian. In the U.S. on the other hand, Congress passed no law legalizing abortion. They would not have dared to do so. Abortion was made legal only because of a court decision.


**Historically, England has been Protestant for the last 500 years. Many years ago, people went to church, people cared. They sang hymns and they read bibles, and God was very real to them. My experiences with many Englishmen now have included meeting several who called themselves C of E who didn’t believe in Hell and at least two who denied that Christ literally, physically rose from the dead. Such seems to be the state of British religion. **

Catholics don’t seem to mind condemning Protestantism on anecdotal evidence - but they hate having the same standard applied to them. Fair comment ?​

As a Catholic, I am very glad that we have a Protestant Crown - long may it so continue.
The trouble with having a Catholic monarch, is that a largely non-Catholic population would be saddled with a Catholic ruler for the forseeable future, because the CC frowns on change of religion. And a Catholic would be answerable to the Pope, who is a foreign ruler - which would be directly contrary to the 39 Articles of Religion. It was to avoid such disputes, and unrest from Catholics with a claim to the throne, that the 1701 Act of Succession was enacted. It’s no more unfair to have a Protestant monarch in the U.K., than it is to have a Catholic in Belgium or Spain. If people wanted a Catholic Premier in the U.K, they could elect one - just as Italians, Spaniards, or Belgians could elect a Protestant as President, if they wanted one. IOW - the Act of Succession wrongs no Catholics, so occasional complaints about its “unfairness” can be ignored. ##

**
Sadly, the Catholic Church in England isn’t doing much to win souls en masse. That I can see from my limited view, there is not an organized effort to bring secular, churchless Britain home to Rome. Sure, some people are converting…but I think it is a fair question to ask: Why isn’t the Church in Britain trying to win over the ENTIRE country…why are they merely allowing the Muhammedians (and others) to march in without, in charity, challenging them?
**I want you to know that I don’t say these things to pick on merry old England, and I’d be willing to bet that most others here aren’t either. Indeed, I recognize that in terms of evangelization, the Church in America has many of the same challenges that the Church in Britain has. I believe that in both cases, the Church needs to stand up for what is true. Rather than just talk about “tolerating” everyone else, we have to stand for the reality that Christ is truly “the way, the truth, and the life.” ****

The difficulty with that verse is that it can be interpreted in many different ways - which is why a recent Vatican document, from the International Theological Commission, discusses these several ways, in a discussion of the relation of other religions to Christ, the Spirit, & the Church. Sad to say, the document is not yet on-line.​

Which is how it is possible to accept that passage, without being energetically missionary. ##

**
If we believe that Christ is the way to salvation, if this is our faith, and it is…then we need to proclaim the Gospel as if the souls of our nations depended on it. After all, they do
.**
 
This royal throne of kings, this scepter’d isle,
This earth of majesty, this seat of Mars,
This other Eden, demi-paradise,
This fortress built by Nature for herself
Against infection and the hand of war,
This happy breed of men, this little world,
This precious stone set in the silver sea,
Which serves it in the office of a wall,
Or as a moat defensive to a house,
Against the envy of less happier lands,
This blessed plot, this earth, this realm, this England,
This nurse, this teeming womb of royal kings,
Fear’d by their breed and famous by their birth, -
For Christian service and true chivalry, -
As is the sepulchre in stubborn Jewry
Of the world’s ransom, blessed Mary’s son:
This land of such dear souls, this dear, dear land …
England, bound in with the triumphant sea.

Shakespeare, Richard II Act II

The Resurrection of Godwinstowe

In Old English, Godwinstowe means the holy place of the friend of God.

orthodoxengland.btinternet.co.uk/v05i4.htm


Icon of All Saints of the British Isles

http://us.f1.yahoofs.com/groups/g_1658606/Icons/British.Isles.All.Saints.jpg?bchGdYCBGSvJ77FA
 
theresas1979,

You still have not addressed the very real facts I laid out. Statistics are very real… that is why educated people in educated sciences use them with regularity. Are they absolute? No. But, they do point us to the truth. And the truth for Europe as a whole, and including merry old England, is very grave indeed.

You can not replenish your own numbers. You are already in the middle of negative population growth. It is only offset by immigration. Add to this the fact that church adherence, let alone attendance, is so low as to be negligible in many places… statistically speaking of course… and it is a recipe for disaster.

Do we really need to drag in the Vatican’s own insight on this of a year or so ago? Do not take my word for it. Look around you. You are, as a European Christian, a very small minority in your own continent and country. Soon (a few decades) Mohammedans will outnumber you and at that point you will be the minority to both European secularists – who are at a negative population growth – and European Mohammedans who are at a positive population growth.

The death throws for Europe will be between the European Secularists and the European Mohammedans. The European Christian – be they Prod, Dissenter, Evang, Non-denom, or CC – will be of so little consequence that it really will not matter in the overall life of Europe at that point.

Of course this is if all things remain the same. With God nothing is impossible and the true Europe – the Christian Europe – can make a comeback… but it does not look very good my friend. What Europe needs most – and I hate to say this, but there is historical evidence to back this – is a terrible calamity that forces it to come to grips with its own spiritual and physiological mortality before it is too late, which isn’t too far in the future at the rate of negative population growth that the whole of Europe is in the middle of.

Of course the more the Europeans place their collective heads in the sand and pretend it is all still what it once was the more things remain the same and the more true the statement of “Europe is dead” rings true - sadly. Until you and every man jack one of you starts recognizing your own mortality there is no hope. What Europe needs most in this world is open eyes, open minds, open hearts, and hope and that will only come at the hands of a calamity… the kind we have seen off and on historically in Europe for 2 millennium… or a major miracle of near Resurrection proportions. Extreme highs or lows are the only way that people are motivated to grow… sadly.

And, as I said already, America is heading down the same path as our European cousins. The only major difference is that you are further down the road than we are. So please do not think this is simply Euro-bashing. I long for a Christian Europe. It would be nice to see our cousins be true to their heritage…
 
40.png
dcmac:
I long for a Christian Europe. It would be nice to see our cousins be true to their heritage…
A Dhonnchadh, a chara,

You (as an Eastern Catholic) and I (as an Orthodox Christian) both know the answer to the woes of Europe and her faltering Christianity.

The answer lies in a prophecy of Saint Arsenios of Cappadocia:

“When the Church in the British Isles begins
to venerate her own saints, the Church will grow.”

People may say: how simplistic, how naive, but there it is. Not just Britain but all of Europe is overshadowed and protected by a huge “crowd of witnesses,” the masses of Saints who have lived and flourished in those lands and sanctified every village and town with their lives and their prayers. With their prayers Europe will be Christian again.

If Russia can arise from 80 years of communism, if Greece can arise after centuries under the yoke of Islam, then England can do it too. All that is needed is prayer to accomplish it.

One reason I put out the daily Lives of the Celtic and Old English Saints is to help bring about the prophecy of Saint Arsenios…

“When the Church in the British Isles begins
to venerate her own saints, the Church will grow.”

.
 
40.png
dcmac:
The death throws for Europe will be between the European Secularists and the European Mohammedans. The European Christian – be they Prod, Dissenter, Evang, Non-denom, or CC – will be of so little consequence that it really will not matter in the overall life of Europe at that point.
No need for pessimism, my dear brother. Christ is preparing for Europe a power which will glorify His Name and that of His holy Mother and ensure that He remains as the God of Europe. Pope John Paul was aware of this in his own prophetic way and he used to speak of it … the impact which Orthodoxy will have in the rejuvenation of Christianity in Europe.

See this article
"The EU and the Orthodox"
neweuropereview.com/English/The-Orthodox-Are-Coming.cfm

There is a thread on the Forum devoted to this also
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=45684

.
 
40.png
dcmac:
America is heading down the same path as our European cousins. The only major difference is that you are further down the road than we are. So please do not think this is simply Euro-bashing. I long for a Christian Europe. It would be nice to see our cousins be true to their heritage…
Hi dcmac -

While I will agree that much of America is secular (Who in thier right mind could disagree?), it is also true that Christianity is growing here, as well. I know first hand locally. A the Church I attend, each Mass is filled to overflowing. This after an expansion of the building ten years ago.

Much has to do with the changing demographics of America. For instance, the parish where I wed, St. Michael’s, was a profoundly Irish Catholic congregation 100 years ago. Now it is filled with people from Central America, Hmong (both Catholic & Bhuddist), and Islamists.

The same thing can be seen in large American cities such as Saint Louis. The Catholic diocese there recently anounced that it will be closing 15 parishes.

However, the suburban areas are growing, and so are the religious institutions that settle there. The Irish, Italian and other communities that populated the cities 100 years ago have moved on to the more prominant suburbs, taking thier religion with them.

Among the major christian religions, Catholic being the largest, there are the Protestants and thier breakoffs. Religions such as the Jehovah’s Witnesses and Mormons are growing, as well. In the small community where I work I see some very small independant gatherings, also. These assemblies may carry as little as 50 people, but they gather to worship God. How can this be viewed negatively?

As far as groups such as the Jehovah’s Witnesses are concerned, I would prefer to live next to a family of this group over a house filled with drug addicts anyday. They gather three times a week minimum in order to worship.

Here is an article that also links to recent statistics: adherents.com/misc/FACT.html

Religion is alive and well here in the states. A Sikh friend of mine has made this very clear. He is here with his family in order to not be persecuted as he was in his own country.

God bless,
Subrosa
 
If the New York Times had accurate information in its April 11th edition, Catholicism as a whole is growing outside of Europe, just as the Protestant Church is. My own United Methodist Church is growing by leaps and bounds in Africa.

In the conclave held in 1903, 98% of the Cardinals were from Europe (61% from Italy alone) and only 2% were from North America. In the conclave to be held in April 2005, 117 Cardinals will be eligible to vote. 50% will be from Europe with a 17% share from Italy. The Cardinals from North America will make up 12% of the total. Notice how the rest of the Cardinals cover the entire globe with 18% from Latin America, 9% from Asia, 9% from Africa, and 2% from Oceania.

Now… am I missing something? Or is the representation of cardinals not necessarily a representatiion of the Church’s presence?

O+
 
STIOFÁN:
Catholics in Northern Ireland were often held up by the British army and RUC, just long enough so we would miss Mass.
The tactics of the British Army in Ulster were appallingly stupid and counterproductive unless one decides that keeping the War going at all costs is productive. In any case, let’s continue to move on. Let’s not look back in anger.
 
Ani Ibi:
The tactics of the British Army in Ulster were appallingly stupid and counterproductive unless one decides that keeping the War going at all costs is productive. In any case, let’s continue to move on. Let’s not look back in anger.
Yes lets move on, and I’m willing, but when others bring it up how can it die off ?
Has the person that brought it up been persecuted for their faith ? we here in Ireland have.
And thats my last word on this Ani Ibi, I don’t want to hijack this thread with Irelands woes.
 
David Oatney:
In the immediate, there is only one political solution in Britain and Canada: The Labour Party (Britain) and the Liberal Party (Canada) have got to go.
With the Sponsorship Scandal in Canada, people will have trouble trusting the Liberals again. About a decade ago, Canadians had trouble trusting the Conservatives and reduced them to 2 seats in parliament when Chretien was first elected! 2 seats from a previous majority government!

Now the Conservatives have shucked and jived by reorganizing and redefining themselves. So we may see a resurgence of conservativism in Canada. That would be dumb because it would mean that we are just shifting weight from one leg to another while not actually walking forward.

The flipping infuriating possibility in all of this is the rise to power of the New Democrats (socialists) who are in no way new nor are they in any way democratic.

What I think needs to happen is the establishment of an international Culture of Life political party which is then adapted to the conditions in each nation.
David Oatney:
Most importantly, I should ask, how can
we help here? Can you keep us updated (per the “In the News” forum etc.) as to what’s happening in the coming elections?

The least and simplest thing we can all do is repeat what we did in the Terri Schiavo case:
  1. A bunch of us research like crazy.
  2. A bunch of us establish a friendly media list.
  3. A bunch of us feed information into our friendly media list.
That’s the minimum. Beyond that, we can organize ‘events’ with speakers. This can build on (1), (2), and (3). What we would need in addition is:
  1. A list of speakers.
  2. A list of venues.
On top of that we need to mobilize our churches. We need our priests to be keeping The Culture of Life in the homilies. We need to be organizing mass prayer vigils on Parliament Hill and in front of the provincial houses of parliament. We need to organize mass prayer parades.

We have Jesus in the City in Toronto which is a prayer parade establishing holy ground in Toronto. Unfortunately many of the speakers there pray soulishly for the demise of the priests of Rome. We also have Caribanna and the Gay Parade. We need to be out there celebrating Life.

Actually as I type, I remember a disabled man in my building asking me about 6 years ago to help him organize a disabled parade and I wasn’t knowledgeable enough at that time to follow through. But now I will take him up on it.

Essentially, however, the first step is to establish local and international Culture of Life think tanks.
 
STIOFÁN:
Yes lets move on, and I’m willing, but when others bring it up how can it die off ?
Has the person that brought it up been persecuted for their faith ? we here in Ireland have.
And thats my last word on this Ani Ibi, I don’t want to hijack this thread with Irelands woes.
I have no trouble at all giving attention to Ireland woes. The title of this thread is Protestant England is Dead. Ulster is part of Protestant England.

I did not mean to give the impression that we should FORGET the wrongs. We are a heroic people (yes my blood is green). It is our names and our honour which have been all but destroyed. This, as you know, is a capital crime in our culture and quite different from romantic cultures such as England.

The racist anti-Irish factions will always bring something up; they will always try to stir up the troubles again. But we ourselves cannot continue at war. This does not mean defeat. It means victory. Conditions have changed since a century ago. EU funds to Eire have revolutionized that country. Our language has been snatched from the jaws of death.

And it is clear that we are a culture which now spans continents. Critics often like to point out to me that American Irish funded the IRA to which I respond: ‘It wasn’t just the American Irish; take notes.’ I normally respond to people who try to stir things up again by telling them firmly that I am not going to fight anymore and then I underline that by leaving their company; shaking the dust, as it were.

There is no need for us to be defensive; we have paid our dues. Moreover we have paid quite a lot of other people’s dues while we were at it. Ani.
 
So my brothers and sisters, let us not bicker among ourselves over things which separate us. Britain was once a nation of the faithful. Scotland was once a nation of the faithful. And in Ireland, those dear monks just kept on copying Scripture while the rest of Europe was … well … what would you call that?

For quite some time now, we have not been able to see the forest for the trees. How be we open our eyes and, while we are at it, open our minds and our hearts?

We all know what the problem is (the culture of death). What is the solution? We can work together on this. Agreed?
 
This is off-topic for the thread, but I would like to respond:
Ani Ibi:
With the Sponsorship Scandal in Canada, people will have trouble trusting the Liberals again. About a decade ago, Canadians had trouble trusting the Conservatives and reduced them to 2 seats in parliament when Chretien was first elected! 2 seats from a previous majority government!
2 seats? - This is unlikely to happen to the Liberals in Canada. They are much more powerful than the Conservatives. Being a member of the Liberal party is comparable to being a member of the communist party in the former Soviet Union. They have been in power all but eight years since 1963. Its card-carrying members are very privileged, and there are enough of them to vote in governments, providing they split the opposition and ensure low voter turnout. They also have a massive advertising department called the CBC.
Ani Ibi:
Now the Conservatives have shucked and jived by reorganizing and redefining themselves. So we may see a resurgence of conservativism in Canada. That would be dumb because it would mean that we are just shifting weight from one leg to another while not actually walking forward.
The liberal-conservative analogy is similar to that of the US. The Conservative leader, Stephen Harper, is the George Bush of the north. He is not Catholic but he is not afraid to publicly stand against gay marriage and for other traditional issues. He has been attacked relentlessly by pro-abortionists. On the other side there’s the current Prime Minister Paul Martin, the John Kerry of the North who will not stand by his Catholic beliefs.
Ani Ibi:
The flipping infuriating possibility in all of this is the rise to power of the New Democrats (socialists) who are in no way new nor are they in any way democratic.
The New Democrats are an ultra left-wing party. They make the Liberals look like the center party. The Liberal party plays this up and successfully makes the Conservatives look like dangerous extremists.
Ani Ibi:
What I think needs to happen is the establishment of an international Culture of Life political party which is then adapted to the conditions in each nation.
This would take from the conservative vote and allow the Liberal party to return to power, endorsing further corruption.
 
Athair Ambróis,

I agree that each nation needs to look inward first. I agree that the first brothers and sisters they should pray to in hope of a new evangelization is their own… who else knows you better than those of your own household?

But, before any of this can happen, Europeans, Canadians, and even Americans need to first recognize the disease that is killing them.

As a Psy. D., I can tell you that you can not get better if you refuse to recognize you have a problem and finding out what exactly that problem is. As of yet, I do not see that in Europe.

I pray for the day that Europe will come about! I pray that the USA halts its march towards death! I just don’t think that people should bury their heads in the sand and pretend there is no problem and that Europe is still Christian, for, sadly it is not. Will it be? I pray so.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top