Protestant friend wants to know

  • Thread starter Thread starter Byzman
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

Byzman

Guest
My best friend who is protestant wants to know what would happen if the Pope is wrong about something…for instance if the Pope changed his mind on the teaching of birth control and allowed the use of it…what would then happen?

Of course I tried to follow up with infallibility of the Pope and the Church…but given that he is a Protestant he doesnt believe in either or. Even with Scripture thrown in his face such as 1 Timothy 3:15…he still says the church can err. So he wants to know what would happen if the Pope were wrong…and I cant find another follow up other than the infallibility is guaranteed by the Holy Spirit.

He is using this to try to prove his point that the Pope one day could in fact be the false prophet bringing in the end times. Now I counter this with the Church cannot form an alliance with the Devil and so forth…Matthew 16:18 plays a part in my argument and most especially gates of hell, hades, powers of death, etc…not prevailing against the Church.
 
My best friend who is protestant wants to know what would happen if the Pope is wrong about something…for instance if the Pope changed his mind on the teaching of birth control and allowed the use of it…what would then happen?

Of course I tried to follow up with infallibility of the Pope and the Church…but given that he is a Protestant he doesnt believe in either or. Even with Scripture thrown in his face such as 1 Timothy 3:15…he still says the church can err. So he wants to know what would happen if the Pope were wrong…and I cant find another follow up other than the infallibility is guaranteed by the Holy Spirit.

He is using this to try to prove his point that the Pope one day could in fact be the false prophet bringing in the end times. Now I counter this with the Church cannot form an alliance with the Devil and so forth…Matthew 16:18 plays a part in my argument and most especially gates of hell, hades, powers of death, etc…not prevailing against the Church.
Tell your Protestant friend that the Pope can’t be wrong about a doctrine concerning faith and morals when he speaks ex cathedra, because the Holy Spirit won’t permit him to do so. As you say, Matthew 16 :18 establishes that the gates of Hell cannot prevail against the Church Christ founded, and so to argue that the Pope is capable of being wrong about a doctrine when speaking ex cathedra essentially means that one is questioning either God’s integrity (by implying that Jesus is lying when He says that the gates of Hell will not prevail against His Church) or His power (by implying that He lacks the ability to keep the promise that His Church will remain free of error).

Ask your friend why he questions Jesus’ power and honesty. Also ask why Jesus would create a Church that couldn’t be depended upon to issue correct doctrine. Insist that he come up with Scripture to support his position and explain exactly how the Scriptures you referenced do not contradict his claims. Remind him gently that arguments built upon crazy what-if’s are flimsy at best, and people simply cannot answer questions about impossible scenarios (such as, “What would happen if the sun started orbiting the Earth?”). To Catholics, the Pope being wrong when speaking ex cathedra is just such an impossible scenario.
 
The Pope and the Magisterium can be wrong on many things, just not about matters of Faith or Morals (that is where infallability kicks in). So if the Pope was wrong or changed their mind about another matter, then they just changed their mind.

Now, here is an easy one for your boyfriend. In the +/- 2,000 years we have had a Pope, which one has taught in error on Faith and Morals and changed their mind? Which one has previously said contraception is OK and then changed their mind? Go ahead, I’ll wait…
 
Tell your Protestant friend that the Pope can’t be wrong about a doctrine concerning faith and morals when he speaks ex cathedra, because the Holy Spirit won’t permit him to do so. As you say, Matthew 16 :18 establishes that the gates of Hell cannot prevail against the Church Christ founded, and so to argue that the Pope is capable of being wrong about a doctrine when speaking ex cathedra essentially means that one is questioning either God’s integrity (by implying that Jesus is lying when He says that the gates of Hell will not prevail against His Church) or His power (by implying that He lacks the ability to keep the promise that His Church will remain free of error).

Ask your friend why he questions Jesus’ power and honesty. Also ask why Jesus would create a Church that couldn’t be depended upon to issue correct doctrine. Insist that he come up with Scripture to support his position and explain exactly how the Scriptures you referenced do not contradict his claims. Remind him gently that arguments built upon crazy what-if’s are flimsy at best, and people simply cannot answer questions about impossible scenarios (such as, “What would happen if the sun started orbiting the Earth?”). To Catholics, the Pope being wrong when speaking ex cathedra is just such an impossible scenario.
I love that last comparison, “What would happen if the sun started orbiting the Earth?” Because I tried so much to tell him that the Pope cannot be in error when speaking ex cathedra…but even more so…that the Holy Spirit would not permit the Pope to change doctrine.

I will have to bring that up to him about the “what if” arguments.
 
My best friend who is protestant wants to know what would happen if the Pope is wrong about something…for instance if the Pope changed his mind on the teaching of birth control and allowed the use of it…what would then happen?

Of course I tried to follow up with infallibility of the Pope and the Church…but given that he is a Protestant he doesnt believe in either or. Even with Scripture thrown in his face such as 1 Timothy 3:15…he still says the church can err. So he wants to know what would happen if the Pope were wrong…and I cant find another follow up other than the infallibility is guaranteed by the Holy Spirit.

He is using this to try to prove his point that the Pope one day could in fact be the false prophet bringing in the end times. Now I counter this with the Church cannot form an alliance with the Devil and so forth…Matthew 16:18 plays a part in my argument and most especially gates of hell, hades, powers of death, etc…not prevailing against the Church.
I would respond…that how God would react is the God’s decision alone…we are not privy to how God would react or what He would do…to know would be saying we are also God or above God.

In 2000 years and 265 popes…there has been no error…so what makes your friend think there would suddenly be error?

And in addition, we do not know how God would react because there is no precedence…no pope in 2000 years has taught error on faith and morals…so if your friend know of such error, have him supply it to you…and examine what happened to the pope to get an idea of God’s reaction.

Otherwise, we do not know.
 
The Pope does not base doctrine off of his own oppinion He bases it off of the word of God. So he can never be wrong.
 
My best friend who is protestant wants to know what would happen if the Pope is wrong about something…for instance if the Pope changed his mind on the teaching of birth control and allowed the use of it…what would then happen?

Of course I tried to follow up with infallibility of the Pope and the Church…but given that he is a Protestant he doesnt believe in either or. Even with Scripture thrown in his face such as 1 Timothy 3:15…he still says the church can err. So he wants to know what would happen if the Pope were wrong…and I cant find another follow up other than the infallibility is guaranteed by the Holy Spirit.

He is using this to try to prove his point that the Pope one day could in fact be the false prophet bringing in the end times. Now I counter this with the Church cannot form an alliance with the Devil and so forth…Matthew 16:18 plays a part in my argument and most especially gates of hell, hades, powers of death, etc…not prevailing against the Church.
Protestants claim that the two verses: “So when you see the abomination of desolation spoken of by the prophet Daniel, standing in the holy place then let those who are in Judea flee to the mountains” (Matthew 24:15-16).
&
“But when you see the abomination of desolation standing where it ought not to be, then let those who are in Judea flee to the mountains” (Mark 13:14).

are about the false prophet. They argue that it means when the anti-Christ sits in Peter’s chair, or something along the lines of that.
 
As formerly stated, the Pope is bound by Sacred Scripture, Church Tradition, and the Magisterium (of which he is a part). He can not contradict any official doctrine or dogma of the Church. Church Doctrines have developed over 2000 years, but never recanted or contradicted.

To say that the Pope could teach error while speaking ex cathedra is to call God a liar. It’s simply untrue and furthermore, impossible. Ask your friend how much faith he has in the promises of Christ - then remind him of the promise Christ made to Peter in Matthew 16:18.

God Bless,
CSJ
 
=Byzman;8964995]My best friend who is protestant wants to know what would happen if the Pope is wrong about something…for instance if the Pope changed his mind on the teaching of birth control and allowed the use of it…what would then happen?
Of course I tried to follow up with infallibility of the Pope and the Church…but given that he is a Protestant he doesnt believe in either or. Even with Scripture thrown in his face such as 1 Timothy 3:15…he still says the church can err. So he wants to know what would happen if the Pope were wrong…and I cant find another follow up other than the infallibility is guaranteed by the Holy Spirit.
He is using this to try to prove his point that the Pope one day could in fact be the false prophet bringing in the end times. Now I counter this with the Church cannot form an alliance with the Devil and so forth…Matthew 16:18 plays a part in my argument and most especially gates of hell, hades, powers of death, etc…not prevailing against the Church.
CANNOT HAPPEN and here why:

Matt.16:15 to 19

He said to them, “But who do you say that I am?” Simon Peter replied, “You are the Christ, the Son of the living God.” And Jesus answered him, "Blessed are you, Simon Bar-Jona! For flesh and blood has not revealed this to you, but my Father who is in heaven. [Meaning Pter and the Popes are Chosen and guarded by God] And I tell you, you are Peter, and on this rock I will build my church, and the powers of death shall not prevail against it.
I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven, and whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven"

John.14:16 to 17
“And I will pray the Father, and he will give you another Counselor, to be with you for ever, even the Spirit of truth, whom the world cannot receive, because it neither sees him nor knows him; you know him, for he dwells with you, and will be in you” … Fulfilled: John 20:221-22 " Jesus said to them again, “Peace be with you. **As the Father has sent me, even so I send you.” ** And when he had said this, he breathed on them, and said to them, “Receive the Holy Spirit”.

And ONLY our Popes; the Magisterium have BOTh the HS and Jesus Himself as Persoanl warranty of AN ABSOLUTE IMPOSSIBILITY OF TEACHING AN UNTRUTH ON ALL MATTERS OF MORALS AND ALL MATTERS THAT MUST BE ACCEPTED AND LIVED IN FAITH BELIEF AND PRACTICE.

JOHN 17:15-19 "[15 “I do not pray that thou shouldst take them out of the world, but that thou shouldst keep them from the evil one. Sanctify them in the truth; thy word is truth. As thou didst send me into the world, so I have sent them into the world. ** And for their sake I consecrate myself, that they also may be consecrated in truth.” AMEN! 👍

God Bless,
Pat
 
Who will try to explain the usury? Was there a change or not?
…
the 12th canon of the First Council of Carthage (345) and the 36th canon of the Council of Aix (789) have declared it to be reprehensible even for laymen to make money by lending at interest. The canonical laws of the Middle Ages absolutely forbade the practice. This prohibition is contained in the Decree of Gratian, q. 3, C. IV, at the beginning, and c. 4, q. 4, C. IV; and in 1. 5, t. 19 of the Decretals, for example in chapters 2, 5, 7, 9, 10, and 13. These chapters order the profit so obtained to be restored; and Alexander III (c. 4, “Super eo”, eodem) declares that he has no power to dispense from the obligation. Chapters 1, 2, and 6, eodem, condemns the strategems to which even clerics resorted to evade the law of the general councils, and the Third of the Lateran (1179) and the Second of Lyons (1274) condemn usurers. In the Council of Vienne (1311) it was declared that if any person obstinately maintained that there was no sin in the practice of demanding interest, he should be punished as a heretic (see c. “Ex gravi”, unic. Clem., “De usuris”, V, 5).
 
Does your Protestant friend know that all Christian denominations were unanimous in teaching that artificial birth control was gravely sinful and forbidden by God prior to 1930? The Anglican/Episcopalian Lambeth Conference that year approved it only in very limited circumstances, but 1930 was the beginning of the avalanche of denominations that approved ABC in any circumstance, led again by the Anglicans/Episcopalians. Your friend can see what happens when Christian institutions flip-flop on moral issues. Some Anglicans/Episcopalians have gone on to become militant supporters of abortion, and many other denominations have followed the same path to destruction. This is what happens with man-made institutions. Today the Catholic Church alone upholds the Truth; even the Orthodox have caved in to the contraceptive culture.

The Catholic Church, thank God, will never face that dilemma. The Holy Spirit protects Christ’s Church against such folly – as it was in the beginning, is now, and ever shall be, world without end, Amen – 2,000 years and counting.
 
My best friend who is protestant wants to know what would happen if the Pope is wrong about something…for instance if the Pope changed his mind on the teaching of birth control and allowed the use of it…what would then happen?

Of course I tried to follow up with infallibility of the Pope and the Church…but given that he is a Protestant he doesnt believe in either or. Even with Scripture thrown in his face such as 1 Timothy 3:15…he still says the church can err. So he wants to know what would happen if the Pope were wrong…and I cant find another follow up other than the infallibility is guaranteed by the Holy Spirit.
Well you now know the reason why the Church cannot change its stance on birth control (or even perhaps things like polygenism)
 
Well you now know the reason why the Church cannot change its stance on birth control (or even perhaps things like polygenism)
Polygenism?..the theory of evolution? I have yet to of heard the Church accept any such view.
 
My best friend who is protestant wants to know what would happen if the Pope is wrong about something…for instance if the Pope changed his mind on the teaching of birth control and allowed the use of it…what would then happen?
Conditions that must be met for a papal teaching to be infallible

• Must teach or in some way clarify
• Can’t contradict previous infallible teachings
• Must involve faith and morals
• To be held by all
• Statement made of his own free will (not forced by others)
• He must invoke the full authority of his office

By knowing the above, it is not difficult to know whether a teaching is or is not infallible, even if the pope wrongly said so.
 
Polygenism?..the theory of evolution? I have yet to of heard the Church accept any such view.
Well it seems to have accepted the theory of evolution - and it will have to accept polygenism since that is scientific fact too
 
Well it seems to have accepted the theory of evolution - and it will have to accept polygenism since that is scientific fact too
Since when did polygenism become scientific fact? and when did the Church accept the theory of evolution?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top