in Mark 1:4, who does Mark say those, who were being baptized, turned to for forgiveness? I’m like some other non-catholics; I haven’t found anything in the sayings of Christ, that tell us Christians to confess sins to a priest?
This makes very good sense. I think it is a very common conclusion among those whose Revelation from the Apostles is limited to the bible.
Perhaps you dont’ realize that the word “priest” is a truncation of the word “presbyter” in the NT. The modern day Catholic (and Orthodox) priest has the same duties as the NT presbyter, because that is the origin of the office. Given that, I am curious how you understand the passage in James.
James 5:14-17
14 Is any among you sick? Let him call for the elders of the church, and let them pray over him, anointing him with oil in the name of the Lord; 15 and the prayer of faith will save the sick man, and the Lord will raise him up; and if he has committed sins, he will be forgiven. 16 Therefore confess your sins to one another, and pray for one another, that you may be healed. The prayer of a righteous man has great power in its effects.
This is the earliest recording of what the Latin Rite has called “extreme unction” or the sacrament of the healing of the sick.
Would you not agree that elders are called because one of the reasons they are elders is their experience and walk in the Lord, and hopefully, their holiness of life? This is why the reference to “the prayer of the righteous man”.
It seems clear from the passage that the candidate for annointing confesses his sins. The belief of the Apostles is that hidden sin produces sickness. Now, if you were going to confess your sins for another, why would you not confess them to the person that Jesus had authorized to forgive them in His name?
Code:
I do see in 1John 1:9, that he says(John), For IF we confess our sins unto HIM, He is faithful to forgive us, and cleanse us of all wickedness:thumbsup:And I can't speak for all non-catholics, but I do not believe that IF we confess our sins to each other(James 5:16), that they are forgiven! only God can forgive sins.
People can forgive sins too, because if we could not, Jesus would not have instructed us to do so in the Lord’s prayer, and otherwise. However, I think we will be in agreement that this forgiveness is between people, not between ourselves and God directly. God only can forgive offenses against Himself, though every offense against “the least of my brethren” is also an offense against Him.
Jesus gave the power to forgive sins to the Apostles and they to their successors. If you reject this, then some flipping and dancing around scripture is needed, and also more flipping and dancing around history. If Jesus did not intend for the Apostles to forgive sins, why did He tell them they had that authority? Also, if Jesus did not intend for them to pass this authority on to their successors, why didn’t He prevent them, or correct them from doing so?
If I share with fellow Christians, about a sin, it is to receive mercy, and support, instead of judgement or condemnation!
Is this what you believe happens in the sacrament of reconciliation? judgement and condemnation?
But usually, by the time I confess a sin to a fellow believer, I have already confessed to God! I should have actually said that Jesus is my middle man; He pleads my case before the Father, when I enter the throneroom of grace!
Yes, the priest acts " in the person of Christ" or literally “in the face of Christ” (prosopon) = with God’s face.
think as far as the topic of the crucifix, or no crucifix, we are now beginning to beat a “horse”, that appears to be on life support

You believe in wearing a crucifix, I do not! The empty Cross to me, shouts V-I-C-T-O-R-Y!!! Every time I see it, it reminds me that my Saviour defeated death, and sin! We are no longer slaves to sin, and have victory over death! But, if it is the doctrine of the catholic church, to wear a crucifix, or to have one displayed in the sanctuary, then that is their choice! You do not have the authority to tell others, that they have no unity with the Cross, because they choose not to wear a crucifix:thumbsup:
It is great that you feel solidarity with the cross. Catholics wear it because the power is in the crucifixion. To cross, no crown. Jesus instructs us to pick up our cross daily, this is a phrase used of a condemned person. There was no amnesty once a person has picked up their cross. They were dead to the world,a nd the world to them. That is probably a topic for another thread.
Gal 3:1-2
3:1 O foolish Galatians! Who has bewitched you, before whose eyes Jesus Christ was publicly portrayed as crucified?
The Church from the Apostles has publicly portrayed Christ as crucified since the beginning. It is a grievious image, indeed, but it is effective in getting across the message that “Greater love has no man than this, that a man lay down his life for his friends.” John 15:12-13
This is a message that just does not get across quite as well with an “empty” cross.