Protestants, what's holding you back from coming to the Catholic Church?

  • Thread starter Thread starter A_G
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

A_G

Guest
Is it because you don’t agree with Catholic Church teaching, morals, traditions, worship, etc…?

Or…

Is it something like *“I don’t have a Catholic Church near me”, “I never really thought about it”, “I’m born a non-Catholic so I’m not comfortable with change”, *etc… ?
 
From my experience and searching for Truth, the claims of the Catholic church do not meet up to historical scrutiny…and it’s understanding of the Gospel of Jesus Christ concerning it’s ‘sacrificial priesthood’ employed.

I do not begrudge the Catholic church it’s “faith story”…each of our respective faith communities have them…“heroes of the faith”…examples of Christian bravery and faith.

Each of us must gather around us those beliefs and rituals that assist us to 'make sense of the world and assists our faith Journey"…As a Friend, I’m not saying your way isn’t valid…it’s just that I have found a faith that speaks to my deepest longings and hopes.
 
From my experience and searching for Truth, the claims of the Catholic church do not meet up to historical scrutiny…and it’s understanding of the Gospel of Jesus Christ concerning it’s ‘sacrificial priesthood’ employed.

I do not begrudge the Catholic church it’s “faith story”…each of our respective faith communities have them…“heroes of the faith”…examples of Christian bravery and faith.

Each of us must gather around us those beliefs and rituals that assist us to 'make sense of the world and assists our faith Journey"…As a Friend, I’m not saying your way isn’t valid…it’s just that I have found a faith that speaks to my deepest longings and hopes.
If you don’t mind me asking, were you part of an organized church before you found the Friends?
 
I was raised in the Church of the Nazarene…with a smattering of Pentacostal from my mom’s sister.🙂
 
Is it because you don’t agree with Catholic Church teaching, morals, traditions, worship, etc…?

Or…

Is it something like *“I don’t have a Catholic Church near me”, “I never really thought about it”, “I’m born a non-Catholic so I’m not comfortable with change”, *etc… ?
While I am a life-long Lutheran and am comfortable where I am, the issue that would need to be resolved for me is the east-west disagreement over ecclesiology. IOW, what is the nature of the power and primacy of the Bishop of Rome, in light of the early Church. Were that issue resolved, there would be little to keep me out of a reunited Church.

Jon
 
While I am a life-long Lutheran and am comfortable where I am, the issue that would need to be resolved for me is the east-west disagreement over ecclesiology. IOW, what is the nature of the power and primacy of the Bishop of Rome, in light of the early Church. Were that issue resolved, there would be little to keep me out of a reunited Church.

Jon
Do you believe LC-MS Lutheran is compatible with either Catholic or Orthodox ecclesiology? When I was Lutheran and studied St. Ignatius of Antioch it was clear to me that no matter which direction I went, Catholic or Orthodox, I could no agree with the Lutheran teaching on bishops, and even less Walther’s.
 
Do you believe LC-MS Lutheran is compatible with either Catholic or Orthodox ecclesiology? When I was Lutheran and studied St. Ignatius of Antioch it was clear to me that no matter which direction I went, Catholic or Orthodox, I could no agree with the Lutheran teaching on bishops, and even less Walther’s.
Well, no. The confession’s view of apostolic succession is different, in that we see it as human made, and not divinely. Its a good thing, but a human tradition. That said, the question was what holds me back. Ecclesiology keeps me from both because of the disagreement, especially on Nicea canon 6. If that were solved, I would see no reason not to be part of the reunited Church.

Jon
 
From my experience and searching for Truth, the **claims of the Catholic church do not meet up to historical scrutiny…**and it’s understanding of the Gospel of Jesus Christ concerning it’s ‘sacrificial priesthood’ employed.

I do not begrudge the Catholic church it’s “faith story”…each of our respective faith communities have them…“heroes of the faith”…examples of Christian bravery and faith.

Each of us must gather around us those beliefs and rituals that assist us to 'make sense of the world and assists our faith Journey"…As a Friend, I’m not saying your way isn’t valid…it’s just that I have found a faith that speaks to my deepest longings and hopes.
I beg your pardon? I have the slighest idea what you have read in the past to come to such a false conclusion?
 
Is it because you don’t agree with Catholic Church teaching, morals, traditions, worship, etc…?

Or…

Is it something like *“I don’t have a Catholic Church near me”, “I never really thought about it”, “I’m born a non-Catholic so I’m not comfortable with change”, *etc… ?
A G,

Its none other than disobedience on their part whether you are a Protestant, Muslim, Buddhist, etc…etc… either consciously or subconsciously it all adds up to being disobedient to Jesus Christ and the Catholic Church.

Perhaps many here will say that I am putting the “Christian Protestants” in the same category as Muslims and Buddhist, etc… I’m not, if they are against the Catholic Church and don’t agree with its teachings, they put themselves in this category with their disobedience to Jesus Christ and His Catholic Church.

Ufam Tobie
 
Is it because you don’t agree with Catholic Church teaching, morals, traditions, worship, etc…?

Or…
That’s an interesting question.

My guess would be pride, prejudice, and marriage issues would be the biggest stumbling blocks.

In my opinion, you either follow a pope or you are one 😃

Peace
David
 
Is it because you don’t agree with Catholic Church teaching, morals, traditions, worship, etc…?

Or…

Is it something like *“I don’t have a Catholic Church near me”, “I never really thought about it”, “I’m born a non-Catholic so I’m not comfortable with change”, *etc… ?
Unfortunately the list can be very long as to why one is not Catholic. Many have been outside the CC from the get-go and will continue. Many Jews were outside Christ flock and many still are today. 😦
 
The final epiphany to convince me once and for all and that the Orthodox Church is not the true Church…

That, and Catholic arrogance.
 
Hi there!

You have a great question that caught my eye right away. Growing up in a household that was Protestant since the day I was born, Catholicism wasn’t brought upon me ever. It wasn’t until last year or so that I finally began researching and began having beliefs of my very own… I don’t think there is anything holding me back other than the fact I truly don’t have a ride to mass… (sadly!) And that if anything happens, it would be when I move out, which will be in about two years, or maybe a bit earlier.

BUT, on the bright side, I continue my research with Catholicism on my alone time, and it seems to be getting more and more revealing each day. It sure is nice to “begin” having your own beliefs!!

God bless you 🙂
Melani
 
if they are against the Catholic Church and don’t agree with its teachings, they put themselves in this category with their disobedience to Jesus Christ and His Catholic Church.

Ufam Tobie
I hear this a lot. Although you could substitute some kind of orthodox church or lutheran church where you write catholic.

There’s a joke us sbc types say when asked why more people aren’t southern baptist. “It’s because of all the baptists.” Perhaps this applies? 👍
 
The confession’s view of apostolic succession is different, in that we see it as human made, and not divinely. Its a good thing, but a human tradition.
Hmm, I see a Scriptural (i.e. divinely inspired) pattern:

God the Father (the superior authority) is the source of this mission and authority. He sends Jesus Christ “…these very works which I am doing, bear me witness that the Father has sent me.” (John 5:36)

Jesus, in turn, passes it on – along with “all authority” to act “in my name” – to the Apostles (“as the Father has sent me, * so I send you,” “go and make disciples”)

The Apostles (who are the only ones in Scripture who are “entrusted” with the care of the Gospel message – see Gal. 2:7, 2 Cor. 5:19, 1 Tim. 1:11, 1 Thess. 2:4, 1 Tim. 6:20, 2 Tim. 1:14 – and who are also the only ones in Scripture who refer to the Gospel message as their own personal possession – see Rom. 2:16, Rom. 16:25, 2 Tim. 2:8, 1 Thess. 1:5, 2 Thess. 2:13-14) pass the mission and authority on to men like St. Timothy and St. Titus (“with all authority,” Tit 2:15).

The second apostolic generation is expected to entrust the mission to the next generation, ad infinitum – “…and what you second generation] have heard from me [first gen.] before many witnesses entrust to faithful men [third gen.] who will be able to teach others [fourth gen.] also.” (2 Tim. 2:2)

There can be no other reason why St. Paul would leave his two spiritual “sons” (Sts. Titus and Timothy) explicit instructions about the qualifications for overseers, elders, bishops, etc. (see 1 Tim 3:1-7, Tit. 1:5-9), than that he expects them to confer apostolic authority on new men who meet those requirements.

Speaking of sons… When God created Adam, He was fathering a son in His own image and likeness. Note that God, in the act of fathering his first human son, breathes on the Man, at which point the Man receives his living spirit. (Gen. 1:27, 2:7)

Compare this to Jesus and the Apostles: “Jesus said to them again, ‘Peace be with you. As the Father has sent me, even so I send you.’ And when he had said this, he breathed on them, and said to them, ‘Receive the Holy Spirit.’” (John 20:21-22)

In the context of conferring His authority on the Apostles, commissioning them to go in His name to build and govern His Church, Jesus does the very same thing His Father did to the First Adam: He breathes upon them, gives them the Spirit, and “fathers” them, spiritually speaking.

This is why the Apostles then turn around and “father” new sons (bishops, etc., with apostolic authority) – because this is what Jesus did to them. The Apostles didn’t take it upon themselves, of their own initiative, to start shepherding God’s flock; they were called to their office by a superior authority.

This is why I don’t believe that a congregation’s vote can suffice, Scripturally speaking, to appoint a man as pastor, since the congregation (of inferior authority) cannot confer superior authority upon a man.*
 
The final epiphany to convince me once and for all and that the Orthodox Church is not the true Church…
That, and Catholic arrogance.
Fabius,

Arrogance? I’m Sorry its to overbearing for you to understand, Pray that you will understand, so that you will no longer be a “lapsed, seeking Christian”.

You either agree with the Catholic Church or you don’t, plain and simple. God gave you free will, if you want to be outside the Catholic Church looking in, that is totally up to you, However, I sure hate to be in your shoes, when it is snowing outside or whatever the wind may bring. lol

Ufam Tobie
 
Fabius,

Arrogance? I’m Sorry its to overbearing for you to understand, Pray that you will understand, so that you will no longer be a “lapsed, seeking Christian”.

You either agree with the Catholic Church or you don’t, plain and simple. God gave you free will, if you want to be outside the Catholic Church looking in, that is totally up to you, However, I sure hate to be in your shoes, when it is snowing outside or whatever the wind may bring. lol

Ufam Tobie
It seems to me that, although I don’t agree with rejecting Christ’s Church because of Judas, we could all use a dose of humility. Us Catholics as a whole often do a poor job of displaying to the world the wonderful gifts that God has given us, most of all in the Eucharist. We can’t force others to join the Church, we can only love them and pray that the Lord softens their hearts and strengthens their minds for a journey with the Lord to his Church.
 
From my experience and searching for Truth, the claims of the Catholic church do not meet up to historical scrutiny…
well said
…and it’s understanding of the Gospel of Jesus Christ concerning it’s ‘sacrificial priesthood’ employed.
There are a number of doctrines that I would reject on the basis that (from the historical record) they appear to be man made innovations (eg the Catholic Marian doctrines). There are also a number of doctrines that I would reject b/c they simply don’t make any sense (to me) and they appear (from the historical record) to be man made innovations (the real bodily presence and the idea that grace can be earned, stored and doled out for two examples).
I do not begrudge the Catholic church it’s “faith story”…each of our respective faith communities have them…“heroes of the faith”…examples of Christian bravery and faith.
Each of us must gather around us those beliefs and rituals that assist us to 'make sense of the world and assists our faith Journey"…As a Friend, I’m not saying your way isn’t valid…it’s just that I have found a faith that speaks to my deepest longings and hopes.
again, well said
 
Publisher and Radical:

Would you mind listing three “claims of the Catholic Church that do not meet up to historical scrutiny”? I’m just curious what both of your examples would be. If you don’t have three, feel free to just name one or two. If you have more than three, please pick the three strongest examples. Thanks in advance!
 
I’m still contemplating about joining the Catholic Church, but the main thing that’s holding me back is that I don’t know if I can trust the traditions such as the Marian dogmas, purgatory, etc. I don’t know if they are true or if they are just man made.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top