Protestants Who Became Catholic

  • Thread starter Thread starter Robbinson
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
R

Robbinson

Guest
If you were a Protestant who became Catholic, I’d love to hear your story (what motivated you to make the change and what issues you faced). Feel free to PM me if you are more comfortable doing that. I am sincerely interested in hearing your perspective as this is something I’m seriously thinking about (though, to be candid, I expect this will be a multiyear journey and don’t know where that journey will ultimately lead).

Blessings,

Brian
 
Raised Southern Baptist. Joined the Church four years ago, receiving First Communion at the same Mass as did my son. We even had matching suits.

As a child, my faith as a Southern Baptist waxed and waned, largely to the extent that my parents’ involvement in their church did. When my parents were active and eager to attend church and Sunday school, so was I. Like a child, mostly I just accepted what I was taught on faith. These were adults, including my parents; therefore, they knew more and better than I did.

In high school, my parents gradually stopped attending church, largely due to the perceived hypocrisy of others. It was the old, “The church is full of hypocrites. I don’t need them. I can worship God at home.” Since they stopped going to church, so did I. I still read the Bible every now and then. I would still attend church once in a while with friends, especially if that friend was a pretty girl.

At seventeen, I joined the Army. Removed from the context of home and friends, going to church just somehow became irrelevant. I would attend church if home during the holidays or going to some special event like a wedding, but otherwise God and worship sort of faded from my life. I still read a bit of theology, philosophy, and an increasingly large amount of history that touched on Christianity.

I left the Army about eight years later to get married to Katrina, who is a cradle Catholic. The first years of our marriage were a gradual return to the Baptist church. Faith was important to her; therefore, it ought to be important to me. I also enrolled at the University of St. Thomas and started to study Catholic philosophy, theology, and history in earnest. I even bought books for courses I wasn’t taking.

Perhaps the first thing I realized was that very little of what I’d been told while a child about Catholics or early Church history was accurate. Some of it was downright false. This was especially true regarding Marian doctrine. Years before I converted, I came to realize that Catholic Marian doctrine is a true, good, and beautiful complement to biblical Christology. I was undoubtedly the only Baptist Sunday school teacher at my church who prayed the Rosary and defended Marian teachings.

I credit my eventual conversion to a few things:
  1. The constant prayers of my wife, my father- and mother-in-law, and one of my wife’s aunts for my conversion.
  2. The intercession of the Blessed Virgin.
  3. A growing realization on my part that I have a very real, unavoidable moral obligation to raise my children Catholic.
  4. The slow realization that, while being Southern Baptist didn’t mean I was not Christian, it did mean I was part of an incomplete Christianity.
So, after about ten years of study and reflection, I was received into the Church. I have no regrets, nor any doubts that I made the wrong decision.

– Mark L. Chance.
 
I am a layperson who’s been actively involved in Protestantism for the last 28 years. The first seven years I was involved with Pentecostalism, three of them in a Jesus Only (Oneness) Pentecostal Church. I joined the Assemblies of God when I accepted the doctrine of the Trinity. Three years later, I became a Reformed Baptist when I studied the reform doctrine of election, know as T.U.L.I.P. During my time as a Reformed Baptist, I was a regular guest on a local radio talk show, called the Bible Answer Man not to be confused with C.R.I.
I read John Calvin, “ Institutes of the Christian Religion” and other reformed writers and then I became a Presbyterian. My study in early Christian and Jewish liturgy gave me an appreciation of public worship. Realizing how beautiful the Liturgy of the Church was I then became an Anglican. I was introduced to Martin Luther’s theology and I was fascinated with his view on the Law and the Gospel. This then led me to join the Lutheran Church Missouri Synod 18 years ago. However, in the last 2 years I began to read the Fathers of the Church and I noticed that they were not Protestant in their thinking. For this reason I was compelled to look at the Eastern Orthodox Churches and the last place that I wanted to go in my religious step was to the Catholic Church. I didn’t want to be Catholic because I believed like many Protestants that she was the Mother of Harlots, recorded in the book of Revelations. After much prayer and researching, I became a Roman Catholic on the Easter Vigil, 2008. I made the journey to the Catholic Church along with several of my Protestant friends.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top