Prove that Catholicism is wrong and I will stop going to mass.

  • Thread starter Thread starter pjn6444
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

pjn6444

Guest
I am a convert to Catholicism. I can just as easily leave as I came. So, if anyone can fully prove that the Catholic Church is wrong I will stop being Catholic. If anyone can prove that the Catholic Church is not what it claims to be then I will stop going to mass.
 
it’s impossible to prove anything for sure. it all comes down to interpretation and opinion. i have no desire to “disprove” the claims of catholicism. i have some issues with a few things in catholicism but nothing that i would say is a dealbreaker for me or anyone else.
 
I am a convert to Catholicism. I can just as easily leave as I came. So, if anyone can fully prove that the Catholic Church is wrong I will stop being Catholic. If anyone can prove that the Catholic Church is not what it claims to be then I will stop going to mass.
Is there a particular reason or concern that prompted this question?

James
 
I am a convert to Catholicism. I can just as easily leave as I came. So, if anyone can fully prove that the Catholic Church is wrong I will stop being Catholic. If anyone can prove that the Catholic Church is not what it claims to be then I will stop going to mass.
I think it is against the rules to try to convert people.
 
I am a convert to Catholicism. I can just as easily leave as I came. So, if anyone can fully prove that the Catholic Church is wrong I will stop being Catholic. If anyone can prove that the Catholic Church is not what it claims to be then I will stop going to mass.
LOL…why would anyone on a Catholic forum want to prove to you that the Catholic Church is wrong?

If you really wanted to be challenged on that issue you’d post that question elsewhere (a non-Cathlolic site).
 
it’s impossible to prove anything for sure. it all comes down to interpretation and opinion. i have no desire to “disprove” the claims of catholicism. i have some issues with a few things in catholicism but nothing that i would say is a dealbreaker for me or anyone else.
If the Catholic Church can be proven wrong I would say that Jesus himself also lied so I would cease to be a Christian… and claim to have no religion…
 
I am a convert to Catholicism. I can just as easily leave as I came. So, if anyone can fully prove that the Catholic Church is wrong I will stop being Catholic. If anyone can prove that the Catholic Church is not what it claims to be then I will stop going to mass.
If you can prove to me that the Moon is made of blue cheese, I will not go there someday.
 
First, I posted this has a response to threads with such themes as, “prove Catholicism and I’ll convert”. These people do not actually go through with what they say. People give them valid reasons rich with logic. Then the OP will say it is not enough. Of course, the person had no intention of converting. So, I have posted a challenge to them. To Prove that Catholicism is wrong and I will stop going to mass. Or in other words no longer be catholic. I posted this in the non-Catholic religions section for the very reason someone mentioned about this being a catholic site. So, I would say truly why do people that do not believe in Catholicism or have a true interest in it frequent this site, and antagonize people? So, anyone who is up to the challenge only has to show that the Catholic faith does not have logical cohesiveness, or show a valid case of the Church contradicting itself on a matter of faith and doctrine. And hopefully people will see how ridiculous such threads are. Those of prove something and I will convert. :rolleyes: 🤷
 
I am a convert to Catholicism. I can just as easily leave as I came. So, if anyone can fully prove that the Catholic Church is wrong I will stop being Catholic. If anyone can prove that the Catholic Church is not what it claims to be then I will stop going to mass.
If you can “just as easily leave as I came”, I have to wonder why you bothered to “go” in the first place.
 
First, I posted this has a response to threads with such themes as, “prove Catholicism and I’ll convert”. These people do not actually go through with what they say. People give them valid reasons rich with logic. Then the OP will say it is not enough. Of course, the person had no intention of converting. So, I have posted a challenge to them. To Prove that Catholicism is wrong and I will stop going to mass. Or in other words no longer be catholic. I posted this in the non-Catholic religions section for the very reason someone mentioned about this being a catholic site. So, I would say truly why do people that do not believe in Catholicism or have a true interest in it frequent this site, and antagonize people? So, anyone who is up to the challenge only has to show that the Catholic faith does not have logical cohesiveness, or show a valid case of the Church contradicting itself on a matter of faith and doctrine. And hopefully people will see how ridiculous such threads are. Those of prove something and I will convert. :rolleyes: 🤷
sneaky poster-person 😉
 
I am a convert to Catholicism. I can just as easily leave as I came. So, if anyone can fully prove that the Catholic Church is wrong I will stop being Catholic. If anyone can prove that the Catholic Church is not what it claims to be then I will stop going to mass.
Converting back to being a protestant doesn’t mean you’ve joined the true church. Unless you turn to Jesus in faith, you’re on the wrong program.
 
I think everyone is missing the point of the thread. It is rather satirical. The OP is calling out all of the thread starters who claim that they will convert if they receive what they hold to be an acceptable explanation. But as you wade through those threads, explanation after explanation is deemed unworthy, and eventually, the OP stops participating in the thread.
This OP is making a comment on how silly all of those thread are, especially when those OPs do not read the posts and responses with an open mind, open heart, and a prayer to the Holy Spirit for guidance.
 
I am a convert to Catholicism. I can just as easily leave as I came. So, if anyone can fully prove that the Catholic Church is wrong I will stop being Catholic. If anyone can prove that the Catholic Church is not what it claims to be then I will stop going to mass.
Why would you do that? Or even put yourself in a position where that might be possible? Better to say, “If you can prove to me that my faith is wrong, I will still keep practicing my faith.”
 
Why would you do that? Or even put yourself in a position where that might be possible? Better to say, “If you can prove to me that my faith is wrong, I will still keep practicing my faith.”
I think you will find he/she is steadfast in his faith, as he/she, they are just issuing a challenge to certain people.
 
Why would you do that? Or even put yourself in a position where that might be possible? Better to say, “If you can prove to me that my faith is wrong, I will still keep practicing my faith.”
See post #13 and #15
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top