Padre Pio was deceived by the devil who posed as his spiritual director and he believed him Is Padre Pio a fake. There are people who are deceived by the devil, who believe in what they are doing and manifest spiritual phenomena through the devil are they fakes even though they are unknowingly deceived. They are deceived but they are not aware of it. I can even imagine their innocence due to ignorance. To me fake implies the intention to deceive, and I don’t think these people actually intend to deceive anyone, but they are deceived. the paranormal phenomena is real, I know this for a fact. that’s why the spirit of discernment is needed to test the spirits. St Ignatius explains some of these tests. Why would he have to do this if these pychics were fake. Explain what you mean by fake I get the impression that you imply that they know they are deceiving, I may be wrong The charlatans are such people, they have the intent to deceive for money.eg: