Purgatory

  • Thread starter Thread starter FriendLiiFiRe
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
This is a very good topic and most Catholics do not understand the church’s teaching on this. Anyone in doubt should go back and re read the referenced catechism. Make no mistake about it Purgatory is very real. God’s justice as well as his mercy requires it.

The very sobering truth is a great many more souls probably go to hell than most people want to even think about. It’s profoundly fearful for most of us to even imagine - especially if we have lost a loved one and just don’t know if they made a good act of contrition at their last rights. That said there are no doubt enormous numbers of souls who go to purgatory too and hope remains! And this is where I think some of you need to change your perspective. Some here are mistaken to think that we don’t need to worry about purgatory since if we are in a state of grace we go straight to heaven. Not true! It is almost impossible to be in a pure state of grace unless one has the piety of a saint! We commit many daily venial sins through habits and behaviors that we often are not even aware of. Some mystics claim God will make all our unforgiven/unconfessed sins made plain to us in our last moments and it can be horrifying to imagine all that he sees that we never consider. This is why we should pray daily (e.g. morning and evening Act of Contrition or Miserere etc.) for forgiveness and to have the final opportunity to perform a perfect act of contrition before death. We should be anxious to routinely go to confession. But we should not be only centered on our own salvation! We also have an obligation to help more than just ourselves! We Catholics are baptised priest, prophet and kings. We have a Christian obligation to pray for and minister to those in this earth and especially to those poor souls who are in purgatory. The souls in purgatory may have no one else remaining on earth that even thinks of them or knows them to help them perfect themselves and satisfy the debt that God’s justice requires for forgiven sins. It can take hundreds and hundreds of our human life years to help some of these individuals pay that debt back to God. This is why the Church gives us abundantly rich spiritual gifts of the indulgences that can transcend time. These are approved by the Catholic Church. We should especially use these during All Souls and All Saints Day and the associated novenas and other special days. If we pray for somone already in paradise then God will apply our prayers to another family member, friend or some soul who can most benefit from our charitable act of mercy. Note that a FULL plenary indulgence is available to us Catholics on the special days and for certain indulgences! That means we can help a loved one’s should go straight to heaven and God at the instant we satisfy the indulgence (generally requiring that we be in a high state of grace after confession, receive communion and invoke the prayers or conditions of the particular indulgence). This is a profoundly eternal and special gift and power we Catholics have and we should use it often. In fact it is OUR DUTY to our loved ones and the minions of poor souls in purgatory to help them while we still have life. This is perhaps the most accessible and easy acts of charity that any Catholic can do. Reference: THE RACCOLTA of approved indulgences for more info. On the other side of the grace are the full heavenly body of saints and angels and loved heavenly Christian family who also pray for us here on earth. God has an amazing plan to get us home to him - but we have to exercise the gifts we have, cooperate and be dutiful and receptive to his saving grace and gifts.

A going away comment - God does not want us to come to him out of a fear of going to Hell or his Justice. He’d rather you come to him through love of Jesus and by the Divine Mercy. But since his Justice requires that he give Satan permission to take any soul that is is in a moral state of sin at the time of bodily death he would rather you come to him out of fear than not come at all.

And finally, I have to disagree with the well studied protestant who thought that the soul itself can die from mortal sin while the body is still alive. The Church teaches that no sin is so grave that it can not be forgiven by the divine mercy and power of Jesus. That means the soul can be cleansed or redeemed from any mortal sin up to the moment of death. After that, unless there is a hidden justice or mercy that is not yet revealed to the Church a soul goes to hell and is beyond the opportunity for redemption (not that is is not within God’s power to resurrect it - but he won’t since its lost the capacity for good and out of self pride, just like Satan, can no longer even conceive to ask for mercy ever again).

James
 
CentralFLJames

I used the wrong terminology. I did not mean to say that the soul dies. By spiritual death I mean separation from God’s grace until reconciliation.

The Catholic Church does teach that one who commits a mortal sin and dies without confession and reconciliation goes to hell. I mght add that the penance is not effective unless there is true forsaking fo the sin.

Many of my Catholic friends say that life here on earth is Purgatory. I tell them that is not what Pope Gregory taught in teh 6th century and that is not what the greatest Catholic theologians have taught over the centuries. I am merely discussing this from a historical perspedtivee as I enjoy reading church history books of all kinds.

We are still brothersrs in Christ.
 
I guess arguing over the theolgy of purgatory which is a hypothetical thesis is better than following the commandments of the Lord Jesus. If we obey the two commandments to love God with all our heart and to love our neighbors we are fullfilling the whole law as Jesus said. Who is it that cannot enter the kingdom of heaven? Those who break the law. And those who are not born again cannot fulfill the law without the help of the Holy Spirit. This is the point, not purgatory. Although, I do believe in the place of the dead, but I believe it is for those who failed to obey and live out their faith in Jesus. Now what happens to them, is God’s business and he will judge them with justice. I can not be the judge of that and in my opinion who else has the right either? We are all sinners and have fallen short of the glory of God. Jesus Christ death was a full atonement for our sins as scripture plainly says. And as Hebrews says, “There no longer remains a sacrifice for sins”, since Jesus death was the atoning work for the sins of man. The doctrine of purgatory contradicts the gospel message of Christ atoning death. I am not saying there is not a purgatory, but I think man made rules are to be avoided, especially when they contradict the work of Jesus Christ death for our sins. Also, if a person is truly born again, they will not WANT to sin and when they do sin they quickly repent and confess it. If someone does not have this attitude toward sin, then their salvation should be in question? Jesus came and taught so we could enter heaven, not purgatory. Lets talk about getting to heaven, instead of trying to get to purgatory…
 
CentralFLJames

I used the wrong terminology. I did not mean to say that the soul dies. By spiritual death I mean separation from God’s grace until reconciliation.

The Catholic Church does teach that one who commits a mortal sin and dies without confession and reconciliation goes to hell. I mght add that the penance is not effective unless there is true forsaking fo the sin.

Many of my Catholic friends say that life here on earth is Purgatory. I tell them that is not what Pope Gregory taught in teh 6th century and that is not what the greatest Catholic theologians have taught over the centuries. I am merely discussing this from a historical perspedtivee as I enjoy reading church history books of all kinds.

We are still brothersrs in Christ.
Well said Russel - you know your Catholicism better than most Catholics. Knowing all you do you really have the rational and spiritual insight to come into the full participation of Christ’s gifts and communion and convert!

Jim
 
1 Corinthians 3:15 says that we will be saved as by fire on our day of judgement.

Hebrews 12:23 says that there are just men made perfect in heaven, in addition to Angels, the first born in heaven, Jesus, etc. Just men made perfect are those who graduated from their purificaton in purgatory.

Matthew 18:30 - 35 talks about paying back our debts in prison, which is certainly not hell, but purgatory.

Peter even said that Jesus preached to the spirits in prison, in 1 Peter 3:19.

Matthew 5:25-26 talks about how we will not be released from prison until we have paid the last penny - That would be in purgatory.

Isaiah, as holy as he was, had to have his tongue purified by a burning coal before he could talk to the Lord in heaven (Isaiah 6:1-7). It was cleansed by a seraphim angel, which means “burning ones”. Why is that? Because God is fire - Remember Moses and the Burning Bush, The Israelites and God in the Pillar of fire, and the Holy Ghost coming to the apostles as tongues of fire?

The very throne of God is fire - See Daniel 7:9-10.

The bottom line is that purgatory is a purification of us, not a punishment. It is truly a gift from God, who said that nothing unclean shall enter heaven ( Rev 21:27). Who among us is perfectly clean enough to ever enter heaven?

And remember, even though our sins are forgiven in confession, there is still the temporal punishment due to us for those sins. Even David, after he was forgiven for murdering Uriah so that he could steal his wife, Bathsheeba, had to undergo the punishment of losing his firstborn son (2 Samuel 12:13-14).
 
Add to my last comment. We should trust in the gospel message of Jesus for our salvation. If we or our loved ones fail to obey it, then it is better to trust in the mercy of God, then to make our own conclusion of how a person is justified, this goes for theolgians and church leaders. Jesus condemned the Pharisees for this, so why would he not us if we assume how God judges.
 
This reply is for Thaddeus. If this is how you see it, why did we need Jesus to die for us? It clearly says his work was the FULL atonement for our sins. May we never undermine the work of the Lord Jesus for us. The old testament was before Jesus came and made the sacrifice for our sins. His work on the cross is more than we could ever know and will not be able to fully comprehend it until we are with Him in the kingdom.
 
withallmyheart - You are incorrect.

Paul says in Colossians 1:24

“Now I rejoice in my sufferings for your sake, and in my flesh I complete what is lacking in Christ’s afflictions for the sake of his body, that is, the church,”

Jesus’ sufferings were not complete, like you say. You and I still have to suffer for the sake of the Church, whether it’s here or in Purgatory.
 
Is Christ’s blood not pure enough to cleanse us of our sins and to purify our hearts? Christ alone is sufficient for us, He is the holy one who died for my and everyone sins. I trust His precious blood to be enough because of who HE is not because of who I am.
 
Yes, provided we suffer with him, like it says in Romans 8:17. Jesus’ sacrifice on the cross doesn’t mean that we don’t have to suffer too, alongside of him. What scripture are you getting that from?
 
Suffering in this world is part of carrying out our faith in the Lord. I truly believe this. We share in the sufferings of Christ for the sake of His kingdom to help others and what the unbelieving world might inflict on us. Your reply has to do with worldly suffering, not what I was talking about with purgatory.
 
I guess arguing over the theolgy of purgatory which is a hypothetical thesis is better than following the commandments of the Lord Jesus. If we obey the two commandments to love God with all our heart and to love our neighbors we are fulfilling the whole law as Jesus said. Who is it that cannot enter the kingdom of heaven? Those who break the law. And those who are not born again cannot fulfill the law without the help of the Holy Spirit. This is the point, not purgatory. Although, I do believe in the place of the dead, but I believe it is for those who failed to obey and live out their faith in Jesus. Now what happens to them, is God’s business and he will judge them with justice. I can not be the judge of that and in my opinion who else has the right either? We are all sinners and have fallen short of the glory of God. Jesus Christ death was a full atonement for our sins as scripture plainly says. And as Hebrews says, “There no longer remains a sacrifice for sins”, since Jesus death was the atoning work for the sins of man. The doctrine of purgatory contradicts the gospel message of Christ atoning death. I am not saying there is not a purgatory, but I think man made rules are to be avoided, especially when they contradict the work of Jesus Christ death for our sins. Also, if a person is truly born again, they will not WANT to sin and when they do sin they quickly repent and confess it. If someone does not have this attitude toward sin, then their salvation should be in question? Jesus came and taught so we could enter heaven, not purgatory. Lets talk about getting to heaven, instead of trying to get to purgatory…
Everyone one of us in while on this planet breaks God’s law daily - even the more devote Saints. The very earth we walk on is cursed as a consequence of the original human perfection we lost when committing the original act of disobedience in The Garden. No one can conform perfectly to the law while we live in an imperfect state no matter if we are born again in the Spirit or not. Only Jesus himself as true God and True perfected Man could ever maintain that state of purity (and we Catholics believe Mary did too by God’s divine protection of the Arc that bore his Son through divine pre-destiny) . You are correct that Jesus death was a full atonement for the sins of men who elected to avail themselves of God’s call to that redemptive grace and for those who God in his perfect omnipotence knew would have come to him if given the opportunity (another reason for purgatory - a place for conditionally good souls not given an opportunity for full choice). But there is absolutely NO contradiction in scripture in the Church’s doctrine on purgatory as you assert. There are dozens and dozens of scriptures that infer purgatory through the principals of revelation, rational insight and the conveyances of the Holy Spirit’s. Check out this website for info: Purgatory

We are “born again” into Christ at Baptism and perfected over our lives through the grace of Christ - not our own actions. Man can do nothing on his own to “earn” or purchase salvation or Heaven. It is pragmatically impossible for human beings living in an imperfect world to be in a perfect state of grace at every instant of their life; even if “born again”. The only time humanity is perfect is when he enters heaven since nothing impure can ever enter heaven. That is why so many people must go to purgatory unless they receive a perfect confession and gain access to God’s perfect Mercy and purification through Jesus salvic sacrifice and merit at or very near the time of death. Again, none of God’s children should want to commit sin - but all will commit some small or greater sin in moments of human weakness.

We talk about Purgatory not to de-focus on going to heaven but to convey the amazing grace and mercy that God grants us to get us home to him so that we do not commit the most grave and unforgivable sin against the Holy Spirit - and that is despairing and doubting Gods’ saving grace and dieing while being impenitence through that doubt (since that blasphemes and denies the power of the Holy Spirit).

Bottom line: We are all trying to get to Heaven and that requires admitting that we are sinners and seeking forgiveness daily as well as helping to the best we can those fellow sinners who have died in less than a perfect state of grace to also get to heaven. Being dutiful both to God (and participating in his plan for salvation) and our neighbors out of love is the very essence of “Charity”. Our Christian duty to love our neighbor does not end at death. That means we are commanded to also pray for those that need to satisfy God’s justice while they are being purified for entry into Paradise.

James
 
Revelation 21:27 says that nothing unclean shall enter heaven. Purgatory is the purifying action that makes us sinners clean. Even if we are forgiven for our sins in this life, the guilt remains, unless it is taken away by suffering, almsgiving, fasting, or personal sacrifice.
 
“There no longer remains a sacrifice for sins” Is what scripture says. Purgatory is not well defined enough in scripture for man to make his own conclusion to the mercy of God. We should trust in the mercy of God beyond what the gospel has told us that scripture is not clear on, not make up our own conclusions. Read my other postings. I would rather trust in God for the things not made clear to me that his judgement is enough, than make up my own or go by man’s opinion on the judgement of God. This is obeying God. We have to look within ourselves to see if we are truly trusting God or ourselves in these matters. God above all things, down to the very motive of our hearts. I agree that we all sin, but breaking the law everyday is not accurate. This contradicts the first letter of John which explains how a person knows they have salvation. Sin is willingly disobeying God and his law. We all have a sinful nature bent toward sinning because of the flesh. When I sin against the Lord out of my impatience toward another because I am fatiged or so on it is not because I willfully want to disobey the Lord it is because my flesh is weak. And when I do these things I ask the Lord to forgive me. But lets say I wanted to be unkind to someone and refuse to show them love because I did not like them, then that is willfully sinning against the law.
Christ’s precious blood should be enough for us as scripture says to purify us of our sins, not for any other reason than who CHRIST IS - the HOLY ONE who shed His blood for our sins. If we deem it is not and live our lives as if it is not, then maybe we should suffer for disdaining His precious blood. His blood purifies us and gives us a new heart that is willing to obey God rather than disobeying Him in our old way. If people do not feel this way in their hearts toward Christ and the Father then maybe they are not truly born again… Peter told us in his letter, “Be holy for your Father is holy.” But you say this is not possible? Christ made it possible for us.
Lets put aside our theolgy and speak the truth to one another from a pure heart through Christ.
 
withallmyheart - Your profile says that you are Catholic. That means that you believe what the holy Catholic Church teaches, if you are in full communion with the Church. You don’t get to make up your own rules and dogma if you are Catholic. That is what the Protestants do. To not believe what the Church teaches about purgatory means that you are a heretic.

Time to get with the program…
 
Thaddeus,
If Christ blood is not enough to make you clean or you live your life seeing his blood as not enough to purify your sins, then I can see how a person would have to suffer for this, not purified though because you did not feel on earth that it was enough, so why would it be elsewhere. Fire is the test of our faith in Jesus that purifies us and brings us into his likeness. We are tested with fiery trials to strengthen our faith in Jesus, not because it cleanses us from sin. Christ blood does that.
 
Thaddeus,
Pope Benedict himself said that purgatory is just a hypothetical thesis that was born in the medievil times.
 
Thaddeus,
Pope Benedict himself said that purgatory is just a hypothetical thesis that was born in the medievil times.
Oh wow! This is news to me.

Could you cite a reference for this quotation with? Something along the lines of when, where, how it was said? Maybe a newspaper article or a book title?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top