Purpose in Suffering from a Catholic Perspective

  • Thread starter Thread starter onegirlinchrist
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
O

onegirlinchrist

Guest
Hi All,

I’m investigating Catholicism and really enjoying the journey thus far!

I was intrigued by a comment I came across by a Catholic, something about how one’s personal suffering can help those in Purgatory. In general, Catholics seem to have a unique way of understanding “taking up one’s cross.” They seem to see patiently bearing suffering as a way of imitating Jesus, and it has a redemptive value.

In my Mormon childhood, suffering was generally seen as something you could mostly avoid if you were obedient and “chose the right.” Oh sure, church officials talked about suffering being an unavoidable part of life, potentially a source of character growth…and yet there was the tacit understanding that if one made all the right choices, somehow things would be pretty darn good. There’s a “good life” out there Christ wants you to have if you’d only choose “the right.” This is probably just a Prosperity Gospel. In Evangelical Protestantism, I felt a similar vibe. If you’d just hold on and trust in the Lord, He would redeem you from your circumstances, things happen for a reason, just hang in there and wait for your triumph.

While I know that God does want us to enjoy as much peace and abundance in this life as possible, as an evangelical I did start to feel like I was demanding things of God all the time, instead of, well…taking up my cross.

Further, I’ve found that much of “contentment” boils down to expectations. In a Prosperity Gospel context, one is always expecting God to show up and fix everything. If things are not fixed, one can’t help but get impatient because one assumes that God can and will fix everything.

Honestly, I’m weary of placing all these demands of God. While a prosperity gospel is tantalizing, it’s actually spiritually exhausting. After all, suffering just seems to be part of life, impossible to eradicate.

Am I right that Catholics are more accepting of suffering as “just part of our condition?” And is it true that Catholics find some redemption in in it, whereas the Prosperity Gospel folks are eager to hop/leap/skip over it, the idea being that God is in the victory, and not in the dark valleys?

Thanks!
 
Hi All,

I’m investigating Catholicism and really enjoying the journey thus far!

I was intrigued by a comment I came across by a Catholic, something about how one’s personal suffering can help those in Purgatory. In general, Catholics seem to have a unique way of understanding “taking up one’s cross.” They seem to see patiently bearing suffering as a way of imitating Jesus, and it has a redemptive value.

In my Mormon childhood, suffering was generally seen as something you could mostly avoid if you were obedient and “chose the right.” Oh sure, church officials talked about suffering being an unavoidable part of life, potentially a source of character growth…and yet there was the tacit understanding that if one made all the right choices, somehow things would be pretty darn good. There’s a “good life” out there Christ wants you to have if you’d only choose “the right.” This is probably just a Prosperity Gospel. In Evangelical Protestantism, I felt a similar vibe. If you’d just hold on and trust in the Lord, He would redeem you from your circumstances, things happen for a reason, just hang in there and wait for your triumph.

While I know that God does want us to enjoy as much peace and abundance in this life as possible, as an evangelical I did start to feel like I was demanding things of God all the time, instead of, well…taking up my cross.

Further, I’ve found that much of “contentment” boils down to expectations. In a Prosperity Gospel context, one is always expecting God to show up and fix everything. If things are not fixed, one can’t help but get impatient because one assumes that God can and will fix everything.

Honestly, I’m weary of placing all these demands of God. While a prosperity gospel is tantalizing, it’s actually spiritually exhausting. After all, suffering just seems to be part of life, impossible to eradicate.

Am I right that Catholics are more accepting of suffering as “just part of our condition?” And is it true that Catholics find some redemption in in it, whereas the Prosperity Gospel folks are eager to hop/leap/skip over it, the idea being that God is in the victory, and not in the dark valleys?

Thanks!
The sun rises and the rain falls on the good and bad alike. We can never predict what’s around the corner: only that God will be there in it no matter what happens.
 
Necessary suffering can be an act of righteousness. Too many people pass on the GREAT rewards, either in this life or better yet in the World to Come, that can be had if only they were clever (holy) enough to transform it into a righteous sacrifice.
 
Yep.

What kind of relationship you have if you’re asking/insisting KNOWING X will be forthcoming to u from God - it would be a one-sided, selfish, and if we have our way… a very disordered way of life in- store for us.

We’re in a Relationship with God. A return on our part in our lives is necessary for a relationship. Our relationship with Him should not dependent on if we get what we want, when we want it and in the way we want it…you are already acknowledge this.

All pain, suffering etc comes from sin. It was NOT part of Gods will for us…we chose it and we continually choose it when we sin. Gods plan for us was to have us in a paradise specifically created to our liking and to hand everything over to us to rule over His created order with no pain, death, hardship. When adam and eve sinned - chose to mistrust the All-Loving God…mistrust became a reality in all our lives. When Jesus came to save mankind - He lifted our eyes back to the truth…the truth of who God is, that He is not meticulously counting sins …He’s a God who knows us through and through and WILLS to pour Himself out (it’s His nature as God). He also …by becoming man…sanctified being human again.

So - we as Catholics say … we live in a fallen world (due to OUR mistake)…but God sent a redeemer to atone for what has been done and to forever leave that atoning door open. Even though the world is fallen…the people within are redeemed…and can thereby use all around them to justify, grow, heal, atone, etc etc.

God could have saved the world in a number of ways…including snapping His fingers…why did He choose the most brutal form of public capital punishment?

To show the depth of His love, to show how awful and serious sin is (if the murder of Christ is the remedy…how bad must the poision be? ) . In the end…love requires action.

So too from us - His bride. We’re part of His body (if we die with Him we too shall reign with Him).

God always takes the bad, the ugly and turns it into something beautiful! The cross (Christ’s and therefore ours) …is a chance to simply offer your whole self over to the one you love!

That is the point of the cross.

When you see a catholic wearing a crucifix around their neck…think of it as a wedding band between them and Christ.

The cross is sooo paramount in the life of a Catholic because in it we see the depth of the love of our bridegroom for us and we are called…“take up your cross and follow me” …to follow Him daily to return our love back! If there is no return …you can’t call what we have to Him a relationship.

God bless!

Michael
 
Suffering is valuable when we offer it up in union with our Lord Jesus Christ, for love of Him.

It purifies us and makes us more like Him.
 
Catholics believe that, when we sin, we merit not only eternal punishment (in the case of mortal sins, that is), but also temporal punishment. Temporal punishment is fulfilled by limited suffering, and can either be satisfied on earth or in purgatory. God either causes or allows everything that happens, so we should take advantage of the suffering He allows us to do penance, merit good for others (i.e. fellow men or souls in purgatory), or merit the granting of a specific intention (e.g. the conversion of Russia). Of course, we must always unite our sufferings to those of Christ for them to have any value whatsoever.

I’m reminded of an exclamation made by St Teresa of Ávila when she was thrown from her horse: “Lord, if this is how You treat Your friends, it is no wonder that You have so few!”
 
The OP talks about Suffering** : Am I right that Catholics are more accepting of suffering as “just part of our condition?”**

I have no idea.
I think that if someone is Suffering anyway, that he should accept that Suffering.
If not, then a person will be both Suffering, AND Angry because he doesn’t want to accept that Suffering.
This would be counter-productive.
It is much better to accept things the way they are (even if you ALSO choose to work to stop that Suffering from occurring).

And, "is it true that Catholics find some redemption in in it."

Sure, and most Protestants do too.
Certainly most Christians do not go searching for things to suffer about.
It reminds me of an old saying : Thin is IN … but, Fat is where it’s AT.
And, many people feel that if you have had to Suffer, that you have more Compassion for others who are Suffering.

And, finally** : “whereas the Prosperity Gospel folks are eager to hop/leap/skip over it, the idea being that God is in the victory, and not in the dark valleys.”**

Sure, and if certain people can avoid ALL of their Suffering, good for them.
Although, I have noticed that many people who claim they NEVER Suffer much, are the same people who bull-doze over others, and cause Suffering in others.
So, in a Way, they give it Away. Here, take some Suffering, you’ll like it.
 
Hi All,

I’m investigating Catholicism and really enjoying the journey thus far!

I was intrigued by a comment I came across by a Catholic, something about how one’s personal suffering can help those in Purgatory. In general, Catholics seem to have a unique way of understanding “taking up one’s cross.” They seem to see patiently bearing suffering as a way of imitating Jesus, and it has a redemptive value.

In my Mormon childhood, suffering was generally seen as something you could mostly avoid if you were obedient and “chose the right.” Oh sure, church officials talked about suffering being an unavoidable part of life, potentially a source of character growth…and yet there was the tacit understanding that if one made all the right choices, somehow things would be pretty darn good. There’s a “good life” out there Christ wants you to have if you’d only choose “the right.” This is probably just a Prosperity Gospel. In Evangelical Protestantism, I felt a similar vibe. If you’d just hold on and trust in the Lord, He would redeem you from your circumstances, things happen for a reason, just hang in there and wait for your triumph.

While I know that God does want us to enjoy as much peace and abundance in this life as possible, as an evangelical I did start to feel like I was demanding things of God all the time, instead of, well…taking up my cross.

Further, I’ve found that much of “contentment” boils down to expectations. In a Prosperity Gospel context, one is always expecting God to show up and fix everything. If things are not fixed, one can’t help but get impatient because one assumes that God can and will fix everything.

Honestly, I’m weary of placing all these demands of God. While a prosperity gospel is tantalizing, it’s actually spiritually exhausting. After all, suffering just seems to be part of life, impossible to eradicate.
Excellent insights here.
Am I right that Catholics are more accepting of suffering as “just part of our condition?”
Well this is a tricky question. Certainly the Church teaches that we should be accepting our our suffering but I don’t know if I can say “Catholics are more accepting of suffering”. Kind of depends on the strength of the individual.
I know that you are primarily asking about teachings, but the way the question is worded prompted my answering this way.
And is it true that Catholics find some redemption in in it,
Yes - the Catholic teaching is that suffering can be “offered up” - accepted as part of God’s will and purification of us. But one must recognize it and endure it with a right attitude.
whereas the Prosperity Gospel folks are eager to hop/leap/skip over it, the idea being that God is in the victory, and not in the dark valleys?
Truthfully I don’t know a lot about the “prosperity Gospel” but from what I have been able to gather - this seems a good description. It’s one of the things that makes the prosperity gospel so dangerous. People can easily lose their faith when things do not go right.

Peace
James
 
Hi again onegirlinchrist 🙂

I believe these short booklets will answer all of your questions.

These books range from roughly around 20 - 40 pages each and they have deepened me in the One Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church in many ways. (they all contain the Roman Catholic Imprimatur which assures the reader that nothing therein is contrary to Catholic faith, morals or teachings).

Books on the Passion
The Passion - loveandmercy.org/Eng-TP-Reg.pdf
The Stations of The Cross - loveandmercy.org/Eng-SOC-Reg.pdf
From Sinai to Calvary - loveandmercy.org/Eng-FSC-Reg.pdf
I Have Given My Life for You - loveandmercy.org/Eng-IHG-Reg.pdf

For more Information on these booklets with messages from Christ in them, please read this - youshallbelieve.com/A-plea-to-humanity.pdf

And for more of the miracles in relation to Catalina and her writtings please watch this - Science Tests Faith - youtube.com/watch?v=-kuxEJXgGSI

And here are some more that are just as good, however they are not focused as much on the topic of Christ’s Cross, but they are just as good!

Books on the Eucharist
The Holy Mass - loveandmercy.org/Eng-HM-Reg.pdf
In Adoration - loveandmercy.org/Eng-IA-Reg.pdf

Books on Spiritual Testimonies & Devotions
Divine Providence - loveandmercy.org/Eng-DP-Reg.pdf
My Broken Christ Walks Over the Waters - loveandmercy.org/Eng-MBC-Reg.pdf
Praying the Rosary - loveandmercy.org/Eng-PR-Reg.pdf
The Visible Face of the Invisible God - loveandmercy.org/Eng-VF-Reg.pdf

I believe there are so many graces that are lost by ignoring or skimming over the cross of Christ.

“If you turn devoutly to the wounds and precious stigmata of Christ, you will find great comfort in suffering, you will mind but little the scorn of men, and you will easily bear their slanderous talk.” - Extract from the book ‘Imitation of Christ’ by Thomas A Kempis
Extract from the book From Sinai to Calvary:
From Sinai to Calvary - loveandmercy.org/Eng-FSC-Reg.pdf

Jesus said: **“Contemplate this scene, My beloved, and learn that My own cannot march through life without a cross. 4) “Go and tell the world what you are learning and, if they want to silence you, shout even louder. Do this for the sake of the power of the love that unites you to Me, which is as united as these two pieces of wood that form an instrument of salvation for all of humanity.
  1. “Tell the consecrated souls that the cross that they wear, is not only to adorn their chests or identify them superficially with Me. First they must gird themselves with the cross and learn to “make themselves comfortable” on it instead of running away from it. Tell them they cannot long for Tabor, if they have not first passed through Golgotha. It is here on the Cross where they will learn charity, humility, poverty of spirit and temperance in all acts of their lives. 6) “Assure them that I give proof and testimony that, the devil can be easily defeated from the experience of the cross. Contemplate Me: I am a true Man, in whom the flesh manifests its limitations, and true God, in demonstrating the relentless force of Agape Love.
  2. “Pray for those who do not know of sufferings, for it is certain that they are not among My own…Observe these two condemned ones who flank Me and meditate on the ways that men carry their crosses. 8) “Some carry it with rage, with bitterness, amidst much grief. He who carries a cross in similar circumstances and with those sentiments, carries for sure a cross, which has no sense because instead of drawing him closer, it pushes him away from Me. Usually that is the cross of those who refuse to understand the meaning of suffering, which takes on supernatural dimensions. That is the cross of the thief at My left, it is the cross which will always be heavy and will never be able to redeem.
  3. “Dismas, on My right, accepts his cross with resignation and even with dignity; he assumes it at first because he has no other recourse. But suddenly, when he recognizes Me and knows that I Am the Son of God, he accepts that cross, acknowledging himself as a sinner, and asking that through it, Mercy remembers him. 10) “Finally, you have Me here in front of you, embracing My redeeming Cross to teach all of you to carry yours. I invite you to be co-redeemers with Me, making reparation for your own sins and those of all mankind. Know that this way of carrying the cross is reflected in your conduct, when before you are difficulties and pains and through them you draw closer to Me and you profit from them to give testimony before men. When you embrace your cross, you can feel that the only thing you desire is strength, because the thirst for souls consumes you." **
Here I believe Jesus shows the two ways that men and women carry their crosses. Our crosses are inevitable, we will all have to carry them at some stage in our life, (e.g. Death) some heavier than others, but I certainly know which cross I will prefer to carry, and that is Dismas’ cross, humbly recognising himself as a sinner and asking that though his sufferings, mercy remembers him. It’s in this way of carrying the cross that warrented such a reply from our lord *“I promise that today you will be with me in paradise.” *and allowed the condemned theif on the right side of Jesus to steal paradise - Luke 23:26-43

Please continue to next post -
 
Jesus Speaks about His Suffering and Death:
Matthew 16:21-23

21 From then on, Jesus began telling his disciples what would happen to him. He said, “I must go to Jerusalem. There the nation’s leaders, the chief priests, and the teachers of the Law of Moses will make me suffer terribly. I will be killed, but three days later I will rise to life.”

22 Peter took Jesus aside and told him to stop talking like that. He said, “God would never let this happen to you, Lord!”

23 Jesus turned to Peter and said, “Satan, get away from me! You’re in my way because you think like everyone else and not like God.”
It is Satan in the book of Job that tells God that the only reason Job loves him is because he avoids the cross, Satan say’s “Wait until he is faced with the cross and he will curse you to your face.”

C.S. Lewis writes a good piece in his book ‘Screwtape Letters’ where the senior devil, Screwtape, writes to his junior tempter, Wormwood, about how to lead a human astray.

Do not be deceived, Wormwood. Our cause is never more in danger than when a human, no longer desiring, but still intending, to do our Enemy’s will, looks round upon a universe from which every trace of Him seems to have vanished, and asks why he has been forsaken, and still obeys. - Screwtape

On the cross we make reparations for our own sins and those of all mankind, we share in Christ’s redemptive sacrafice, and in his Glory. The Devil can be easily defeated through the experience of the cross and Christ gives us the God given strength to survive it.
Extract from the book From Sinai to Calvary:
From Sinai to Calvary - loveandmercy.org/Eng-FSC-Reg.pdf

**you can see and understand with greater ease, why human suffering makes sense when it is endured for love’s sake, desiring to fulfill the Divine Will. And it is that the greatest pain, as intense as it may be, does not diminish the joy in the heart of those who sweeten themselves with the greatest Love. **
Extract from the book From Sinai to Calvary:
From Sinai to Calvary - loveandmercy.org/Eng-FSC-Reg.pdf

**5) “As you can see, it seems that it had not been enough to have passed through this world doing good to everyone. I went all the way to the extreme of love. I gave life to that which I had preached previously: ‘No one has greater love than the one who gives his own life for his friends.’ And I also gave Mine for My enemies, for those who were crucifying Me…
  1. “It is precisely because of that boundless love which, in the midst of My unfathomable suffering, I did not lose confidence in My Father. But rather, I was being overcome by immense joy in knowing that I was fulfilling His Will and, thus, demonstrating My Love for Him and for all mankind.”**
Extract from the book From Divine Providence:
Divine Providence - loveandmercy.org/Eng-DP-Reg.pdf

During my prayers on the 23rd, the Lord, knowing that I was feeling very much alone, spoke to me and said: **2) “My beloved, here I am, responding to your call. However, not even for an instant have I abandoned you… You are seemingly alone but I am with you. 3) “Think of My anguish in the garden; I felt alone. 4) “Are you afraid? So was I. 5) “Do you need to talk to someone? Talk to Me. 6) “Do you need a hand to caress you? Here are Mine. 7) “Do you need a shoulder on which to cry? Do so on Mine and I will dry your tears with My kisses… Your tears will blend with Mine. I am not indifferent to your sufferings.
  1. “Do you need someone’s company to pray with you? Here you have My Saints and My Angels… Offer Me your patience in this life of exile and, thus, each time that I come looking for you, you will be free of grief and able to enjoy great interior peace. **
Please continue to next post -
 
Extract from the book From Divine Providence:
Divine Providence - loveandmercy.org/Eng-DP-Reg.pdf

On the 29th day the Lord told me: **“Gold is tested in the burning crucible. Everything that all of you are living is necessary for growth… I love you very much. Believe it and love Me more. Even if you think that you are incapable of loving more, continue to exert yourself in that for love is like a rubber container that expands, with the only difference being that the container never explodes, it is refined until it becomes noble material.” **
  1. Later He continued: **4) “My desire is for every soul to be holy so it may come to Me at the moment of its death and remain in the Kingdom that the Father has prepared for it from all eternity. However, I desire to purify that soul even on earth, so that, as much as possible, it not be necessary to purge that which remained to be cleansed in life. That is why when a person is well disposed and desires to know Me, to love Me, to make Me known and to be purified on earth, I do my work as a potter and shape that clay, sometimes adding some more water to refine the mass, other times hitting or squeezing the mass to soften it, and when it is ready, I cook it in the burning oven of the virtues, in order to make that piece soft to the touch, shiny and worthy to be presented and offered to a King.” **
  2. Even though I was certain of having seen my mother’s journey towards the Throne of the Lord, I kept wondering if her soul had to expiate for a time in Purgatory… It was then that the Lord told me: **6) “Why do you allow the devil to sow doubts in your mind? Trust and pray… None of you will understand until you are on this side, but even if you are almost certain (as I have revealed to certain souls) that your deceased ones are already enjoying Paradise, continue praying for them because in this way you complete what they lacked or increase what the souls of other persons close to you presented in their hands when they appeared before Me. 7) “When I said, ‘Come to Me all you who are burdened or tired…’ I also said it to you. Many things, which I allow or send, you sometimes find silly or unjust. Faith has to teach all of you that I plan everything for good. Remember that the soul, who maintains its peace and faith in the face of adversity, has the right to expect My Love and its benefits.” **
Extract from the book My Broken Christ Walks Over the Waters:
My Broken Christ Walks Over the Waters - loveandmercy.org/Eng-MBC-Reg.pdf

Do you know, my friend, why sometimes our Cross becomes intolerable? Do you know why it can end up becoming desperation and suicide? Because in that circumstance our Cross is a Cross alone, with no Christ, and we can only tolerate a Cross when it carries a Christ on its arms. A lay Cross without the blood or the love of God is absurd. It is senseless. So, I have an idea. I have a Christ without a Cross, and you perhaps have a Cross without Christ. Both are incomplete.

My Christ does not rest because He is missing His Cross. You cannot bear your Cross because it is missing Christ. Why do you not give your empty Cross to Christ tonight? You have a Cross by itself, empty, freezing cold, black, senseless. I understand you. To suffer like that is something irrational and I do not comprehend how you have been able to tolerate it for so long. You have the remedy in your hands… Come on, give me that Cross of yours. Give it to me. I give you in exchange this Christ without rest and without a Cross. Take it, it is yours. Give Him your Cross. Take my Christ. Put them together. Nail them, embrace them and everything will be different.

My broken Christ rests on your Cross. Your Cross becomes softer with my Christ on it. We have found a Cross. Ours, which happens to be that of Christ’s…
He giveth more grace when the burdens grow greater,
He sendeth more strength when the labors increase;
To added affliction He addeth His mercy;
To multiplied trials, His multiplied peace.

When we have exhausted our store of endurance,
When our strength has failed before the day is half done,
When we reach the end of our stored resources,
Our Father’s full giving has only begun.

His love has no limit; His grace has no measure.
His power no boundary known unto man;
For out of His infinite riches in Jesus,
He giveth, and giveth, and giveth again!
  • Annie Johnson Flint
John 16:33:
33 I have told you this, so that you might have peace in your hearts because of me. While you are in the world, you will have to suffer. But cheer up! I have defeated the world.
I hope I have helped (sorry for the length of my post, I just really wanted to share all of this with you).

God Bless

Thank you for reading
Josh
 
Hi All,

I’m investigating Catholicism and really enjoying the journey thus far!

I was intrigued by a comment I came across by a Catholic, something about how one’s personal suffering can help those in Purgatory. In general, Catholics seem to have a unique way of understanding “taking up one’s cross.” They seem to see patiently bearing suffering as a way of imitating Jesus, and it has a redemptive value.

In my Mormon childhood, suffering was generally seen as something you could mostly avoid if you were obedient and “chose the right.” Oh sure, church officials talked about suffering being an unavoidable part of life, potentially a source of character growth…and yet there was the tacit understanding that if one made all the right choices, somehow things would be pretty darn good. There’s a “good life” out there Christ wants you to have if you’d only choose “the right.” This is probably just a Prosperity Gospel. In Evangelical Protestantism, I felt a similar vibe. If you’d just hold on and trust in the Lord, He would redeem you from your circumstances, things happen for a reason, just hang in there and wait for your triumph.

While I know that God does want us to enjoy as much peace and abundance in this life as possible, as an evangelical I did start to feel like I was demanding things of God all the time, instead of, well…taking up my cross.

Further, I’ve found that much of “contentment” boils down to expectations. In a Prosperity Gospel context, one is always expecting God to show up and fix everything. If things are not fixed, one can’t help but get impatient because one assumes that God can and will fix everything.

Honestly, I’m weary of placing all these demands of God. While a prosperity gospel is tantalizing, it’s actually spiritually exhausting. After all, suffering just seems to be part of life, impossible to eradicate.

Am I right that Catholics are more accepting of suffering as “just part of our condition?” And is it true that Catholics find some redemption in in it, whereas the Prosperity Gospel folks are eager to hop/leap/skip over it, the idea being that God is in the victory, and not in the dark valleys?

Thanks!
Here is what suffering done in the right spirit may accomplish:

make satisfaction for my sins.

make satisfaction for the sins of others, especially their indifference.

draw blessings down on my loved ones.

assist the suffering souls in purgatory.

gain grace against temptations.

obtain the conversion of sinners.

procure graces for my special intentions.

grow closer to Jesus Christ.

And here is Father Hardon with an excellent and great explaination of suffering:

therealpresence.org/archives/God/God_035.htm

May God bless and keep you. May God’s face shine on you. May God be kind to you and give you peace.
 
Yep.

What kind of relationship you have if you’re asking/insisting KNOWING X will be forthcoming to u from God - it would be a one-sided, selfish, and if we have our way… a very disordered way of life in- store for us.

We’re in a Relationship with God. A return on our part in our lives is necessary for a relationship. Our relationship with Him should not dependent on if we get what we want, when we want it and in the way we want it…you are already acknowledge this.

All pain, suffering etc comes from sin. It was NOT part of Gods will for us…we chose it and we continually choose it when we sin. Gods plan for us was to have us in a paradise specifically created to our liking and to hand everything over to us to rule over His created order with no pain, death, hardship. When adam and eve sinned - chose to mistrust the All-Loving God…mistrust became a reality in all our lives. When Jesus came to save mankind - He lifted our eyes back to the truth…the truth of who God is, that He is not meticulously counting sins …He’s a God who knows us through and through and WILLS to pour Himself out (it’s His nature as God). He also …by becoming man…sanctified being human again.

So - we as Catholics say … we live in a fallen world (due to OUR mistake)…but God sent a redeemer to atone for what has been done and to forever leave that atoning door open. Even though the world is fallen…the people within are redeemed…and can thereby use all around them to justify, grow, heal, atone, etc etc.

God could have saved the world in a number of ways…including snapping His fingers…why did He choose the most brutal form of public capital punishment?

To show the depth of His love, to show how awful and serious sin is (if the murder of Christ is the remedy…how bad must the poision be? ) . In the end…love requires action.

So too from us - His bride. We’re part of His body (if we die with Him we too shall reign with Him).

God always takes the bad, the ugly and turns it into something beautiful! The cross (Christ’s and therefore ours) …is a chance to simply offer your whole self over to the one you love!

That is the point of the cross.

When you see a catholic wearing a crucifix around their neck…think of it as a wedding band between them and Christ.

The cross is sooo paramount in the life of a Catholic because in it we see the depth of the love of our bridegroom for us and we are called…“take up your cross and follow me” …to follow Him daily to return our love back! If there is no return …you can’t call what we have to Him a relationship.

God bless!

Michael
A very beautiful summary of the faith which gives me much to think about. Thanks for taking the time. 🙂
 
Catholics believe that, when we sin, we merit not only eternal punishment (in the case of mortal sins, that is), but also temporal punishment. Temporal punishment is fulfilled by limited suffering, and can either be satisfied on earth or in purgatory. God either causes or allows everything that happens, so we should take advantage of the suffering He allows us to do penance, merit good for others (i.e. fellow men or souls in purgatory), or merit the granting of a specific intention (e.g. the conversion of Russia). Of course, we must always unite our sufferings to those of Christ for them to have any value whatsoever.

I’m reminded of an exclamation made by St Teresa of Ávila when she was thrown from her horse: “Lord, if this is how You treat Your friends, it is no wonder that You have so few!”
Truly, a hilarious but also also thought provoking quote! The idea of suffering being a way of meriting good for others is a rather novel concept, I’m not aware of coming across it in other traditions. I like it, because it gives purpose to what can otherwise feel or seem meaningless. Thanks for the explanation.
 
The OP talks about Suffering** : Am I right that Catholics are more accepting of suffering as “just part of our condition?”**

I have no idea.
I think that if someone is Suffering anyway, that he should accept that Suffering.
If not, then a person will be both Suffering, AND Angry because he doesn’t want to accept that Suffering.
This would be counter-productive.
It is much better to accept things the way they are (even if you ALSO choose to work to stop that Suffering from occurring).

And, "is it true that Catholics find some redemption in in it."

Sure, and most Protestants do too.
Certainly most Christians do not go searching for things to suffer about.
It reminds me of an old saying : Thin is IN … but, Fat is where it’s AT.
And, many people feel that if you have had to Suffer, that you have more Compassion for others who are Suffering.

And, finally** : “whereas the Prosperity Gospel folks are eager to hop/leap/skip over it, the idea being that God is in the victory, and not in the dark valleys.”**

Sure, and if certain people can avoid ALL of their Suffering, good for them.
Although, I have noticed that many people who claim they NEVER Suffer much, are the same people who bull-doze over others, and cause Suffering in others.
So, in a Way, they give it Away. Here, take some Suffering, you’ll like it.
Baha in light of my huge Italian dinner tonight, “Thin is IN…but fat is where it’s at!” 👍
 
Excellent insights here.

Well this is a tricky question. Certainly the Church teaches that we should be accepting our our suffering but I don’t know if I can say “Catholics are more accepting of suffering”. Kind of depends on the strength of the individual.
I know that you are primarily asking about teachings, but the way the question is worded prompted my answering this way.

Yes - the Catholic teaching is that suffering can be “offered up” - accepted as part of God’s will and purification of us. But one must recognize it and endure it with a right attitude.

Truthfully I don’t know a lot about the “prosperity Gospel” but from what I have been able to gather - this seems a good description. It’s one of the things that makes the prosperity gospel so dangerous. People can easily lose their faith when things do not go right.

Peace
James
Thanks for that. The idea of suffering being “offered up” is one I really, really like. I am weary of picking doctrines just because I “like” them (i.e. it gets tiring being Protestant and struggling over how to interpret this or that.) But this is a concept that resonates. Dealing with suffering with dignity and acceptance and not endlessly waiting on the Lord to “fix” things is important methinks for emotional and spiritual health.

It finally hit me the other day that, because God has given others free will, I will necessarily have to endure the sinful actions of other people. There are circumstances in my life that I’d love to see “fixed,” but I see now that God would have to violate the free will of offending people involved in order to “fix” the situation. The Evangelical (Calvinist) model I hearken from heavily emphasizes the sovereignty of God in such a way that it is implied that all will work out for the good of the believer. Now, Catholics would not disagree. Insofar as suffering produces character growth and merits eternal rewards, etc. However, there is the flavor in evangelical protestantism that, due to God’s sovereignty, something BETTER than what you can conceive of is waiting 'round the corner if you’ll just hang on.

Starting to think that, nice as that sounds, Christianity doesn’t work that way. Jesus Christ Himself was crucified, after all! It isn’t a picnic down here. Instead of religion being this balm and salve, maybe it’s more like, “Quit complaining, there’s work to do.”
 
Excellent insights here.

Well this is a tricky question. Certainly the Church teaches that we should be accepting our our suffering but I don’t know if I can say “Catholics are more accepting of suffering”. Kind of depends on the strength of the individual.
I know that you are primarily asking about teachings, but the way the question is worded prompted my answering this way.

Yes - the Catholic teaching is that suffering can be “offered up” - accepted as part of God’s will and purification of us. But one must recognize it and endure it with a right attitude.

Truthfully I don’t know a lot about the “prosperity Gospel” but from what I have been able to gather - this seems a good description. It’s one of the things that makes the prosperity gospel so dangerous. People can easily lose their faith when things do not go right.

Peace
James
He giveth more grace when the burdens grow greater,
He sendeth more strength when the labors increase;
To added affliction He addeth His mercy;
To multiplied trials, His multiplied peace.

When we have exhausted our store of endurance,
When our strength has failed before the day is half done,
When we reach the end of our stored resources,
Our Father’s full giving has only begun.

His love has no limit; His grace has no measure.
His power no boundary known unto man;
For out of His infinite riches in Jesus,
He giveth, and giveth, and giveth again!
  • Annie Johnson Flint
I hope I have helped (sorry for the length of my post, I just really wanted to share all of this with you).

God Bless

Thank you for reading
Josh
What an incredible resource, that was exactly what I needed to read/hear. Thank you. As I was reading, I thought: “that is true Christianity.” That is the aspect of Christianity that I am so unfamiliar with–taking up one’s cross–but that increasingly I think lies at the very heart of the matter. I think that’s the meat of the faith. And, somehow, it explains so much about life. Everything starts to make more “sense” somehow when seen through the lense of enduing the cross, with Christ’s help of course. As explained before, previous faith traditions heavily emphasized a direct correlation between good actions and prosperous results. Not always explicitly, but it was tacitly understood, and very much in the religious culture. I feel that this approach set me up with a false idea of who Christ is and what my relationship with Him should look like, and what the Christian journey should feel like. It even presented me with a false paradigm of what life itself is all about (getting one’s own piece of the pie). And I suffered a sense of disorientation as life stopped being the bowl of cherries I thought it would be due to my “right” choices. I can not begin to state how damaging the “prosperity gospel” is. It’s a big mirage, a lie that keeps people from directly engaging with reality. It also creates an endless, “I can’t wait until God fixes this” attitude. Needless to say this kind of thinking generates a tremendous amount of self-pity and narcissism.

And thus we see the importance of correct doctrine. If people are taught that “choosing Christ” = temporal prosperity, can we blame them for getting overly preoccupied with their personal happiness? After all, their happiness is supposedly the gauge of how strong they are in Christ. So if things are not great, they must have frustrated God in some way. Or they just need to wait and wait until He finally decides to take action. It’s a mindset that isolates one from the suffering world in a selfish little bubble.

Thanks for the resources you shared which can point me in the right direction!
 
Here is what suffering done in the right spirit may accomplish:

make satisfaction for my sins.

make satisfaction for the sins of others, especially their indifference.

draw blessings down on my loved ones.

assist the suffering souls in purgatory.

gain grace against temptations.

obtain the conversion of sinners.

procure graces for my special intentions.

grow closer to Jesus Christ.

And here is Father Hardon with an excellent and great explaination of suffering:

therealpresence.org/archives/God/God_035.htm

May God bless and keep you. May God’s face shine on you. May God be kind to you and give you peace.
Cool! I will read it. This is a uniquely Catholic view of suffering and I am so drawn to it. Thank you.
 
Just started reading.

“The Passion of Jesus teaches us in a concrete way that in the Christian life we must be able to accept suffering for the love of God. This is a hard, repugnant lesson for our nature, which prefers pleasure and happiness; however, it comes from Jesus, the Teacher of truth and of life, the loving Teacher of our souls, who desires only our real good. If He commends suffering to us, it is because suffering contains a great treasure.”

See, that’s how I want to grow. That’s the concept other faith traditions have not taught me to squarely face and embrace! “Repugnant” is just the word. Looks great so far, thank you!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top