O
onegirlinchrist
Guest
Hi All,
I’m investigating Catholicism and really enjoying the journey thus far!
I was intrigued by a comment I came across by a Catholic, something about how one’s personal suffering can help those in Purgatory. In general, Catholics seem to have a unique way of understanding “taking up one’s cross.” They seem to see patiently bearing suffering as a way of imitating Jesus, and it has a redemptive value.
In my Mormon childhood, suffering was generally seen as something you could mostly avoid if you were obedient and “chose the right.” Oh sure, church officials talked about suffering being an unavoidable part of life, potentially a source of character growth…and yet there was the tacit understanding that if one made all the right choices, somehow things would be pretty darn good. There’s a “good life” out there Christ wants you to have if you’d only choose “the right.” This is probably just a Prosperity Gospel. In Evangelical Protestantism, I felt a similar vibe. If you’d just hold on and trust in the Lord, He would redeem you from your circumstances, things happen for a reason, just hang in there and wait for your triumph.
While I know that God does want us to enjoy as much peace and abundance in this life as possible, as an evangelical I did start to feel like I was demanding things of God all the time, instead of, well…taking up my cross.
Further, I’ve found that much of “contentment” boils down to expectations. In a Prosperity Gospel context, one is always expecting God to show up and fix everything. If things are not fixed, one can’t help but get impatient because one assumes that God can and will fix everything.
Honestly, I’m weary of placing all these demands of God. While a prosperity gospel is tantalizing, it’s actually spiritually exhausting. After all, suffering just seems to be part of life, impossible to eradicate.
Am I right that Catholics are more accepting of suffering as “just part of our condition?” And is it true that Catholics find some redemption in in it, whereas the Prosperity Gospel folks are eager to hop/leap/skip over it, the idea being that God is in the victory, and not in the dark valleys?
Thanks!
I’m investigating Catholicism and really enjoying the journey thus far!
I was intrigued by a comment I came across by a Catholic, something about how one’s personal suffering can help those in Purgatory. In general, Catholics seem to have a unique way of understanding “taking up one’s cross.” They seem to see patiently bearing suffering as a way of imitating Jesus, and it has a redemptive value.
In my Mormon childhood, suffering was generally seen as something you could mostly avoid if you were obedient and “chose the right.” Oh sure, church officials talked about suffering being an unavoidable part of life, potentially a source of character growth…and yet there was the tacit understanding that if one made all the right choices, somehow things would be pretty darn good. There’s a “good life” out there Christ wants you to have if you’d only choose “the right.” This is probably just a Prosperity Gospel. In Evangelical Protestantism, I felt a similar vibe. If you’d just hold on and trust in the Lord, He would redeem you from your circumstances, things happen for a reason, just hang in there and wait for your triumph.
While I know that God does want us to enjoy as much peace and abundance in this life as possible, as an evangelical I did start to feel like I was demanding things of God all the time, instead of, well…taking up my cross.
Further, I’ve found that much of “contentment” boils down to expectations. In a Prosperity Gospel context, one is always expecting God to show up and fix everything. If things are not fixed, one can’t help but get impatient because one assumes that God can and will fix everything.
Honestly, I’m weary of placing all these demands of God. While a prosperity gospel is tantalizing, it’s actually spiritually exhausting. After all, suffering just seems to be part of life, impossible to eradicate.
Am I right that Catholics are more accepting of suffering as “just part of our condition?” And is it true that Catholics find some redemption in in it, whereas the Prosperity Gospel folks are eager to hop/leap/skip over it, the idea being that God is in the victory, and not in the dark valleys?
Thanks!