Fr. I agree that his wasn’t the way to do things. But one of the reasons he had nobody, was that he made confession seem unnecessary. When he reiterated, almost weekly, how much God loves us and forgives us everything, but never once mentioned the need for repentance and confession, he made it seem like that sacrament had fallen by the wayside and was an old fashioned thing.
On the other hand, the Pastor who reinstated scheduled confession, made a point of stressing the importance of the sacrament.
We had about 15 years of Advent and Lent Penitential services with General Absolution. The church was full for those. Then, after an ad limina visit, our Bishop ordered that General Absolution not be used at those services.
The next service once again saw a full church, but, once they were told they had to go to private confession to get absolution, attendance dropped off sharply. Today a Penitential Service might draw a dozen or so from a parish of 1500. And perish the thought that the examination of conscience at one of those services actually mention sins against the 10 commandments, rather than ask touchy-feely questions about respecting the environment and wasting natural resources.