I’m a middle aged Catholic who has returned to the Church after many years lapsed. My question is this: Is it inherently sinful to seek out the priest at my parish who I believe will be easiest on me given the fact that it’s been 30 years since my last confession? I feel like i’m a youngster again and am avoiding the “tough priest” at my old parish. Please advise
I am a lay person, so I can’t truly answer this question as a priest or bishop would. I would advise, though, that you talk to the priest you are most comfortable with to talk to. You may see this as being the “easy” one, but, most likely, given your desire to come back and the honesty in your post, you are talking about the one you are most comfortable with.
I would not just show up in confession, by the way. I think you need to get in touch with him and have a sit down meeting about your situation. Tell him from your heart, where you are. Tell him how you feel. Tell him your worries. Listen to what he has to say. Follow his advice.
Then, at the time of your Confession, do a fearless inventory of your life since your last Confession. Contemplate all that you have done, and why you did it. Share this with him in the confessional. After receiving Absolution, make sure to move everything aside in your life to complete your Penance.
After Confession, take Communion … all is well!
I’ll say some prayers for ya!