Question for ex-protestants that converted to Catholicism?

  • Thread starter Thread starter ejp123
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
E

ejp123

Guest
What was missing from your protestant faith but found it in Catholicism? Thx, Eric
 
Authority. Protestantism began to feel like a buffet line to pick and choose beliefs based on what some man had decided was true or not.
 
What was missing from your protestant faith but found it in Catholicism? Thx, Eric
Authority, for one.

As a Protestant, it was tiring trying to figure out what was true about certain things. Sure, there was some agreement among varying authors and pastors, but since no one really answered to a higher authority and could just write any old book, it was difficult trying to figure out what was right and wrong. When I realized Jesus had established his church on Peter, and that led to the Catholic church, it was a relief to know that if I had a question about something, I had an authority to go to that a) knew what they were talking about, b) had the authority to do so, and c) were protected by God Himself from teaching error.

There were some other things, but this was probably one of the biggest things that was missing for me.
 
I’m still a protestant but looking at converting at the moment. There are a number of things that attract me to the Catholic Church. Authority is one of them, Jesus authority to establish the Church and also the historical importance of it. Also, I want to be part of a global community of Christians with the same values, not one divided group limited to my own country. I also strongly admire the fact that the Catholic Church has a definitive set of values that it sticks to, preaches and speaks out on. I have always in particular admired the amount of speaking out Catholics do for the defence of our unborn brothers and sisters, I think it is just so important that as much as possible is done to convince people of the need to preserve innocent life. So in short, authority, values, and presence.
 
Authority, for one.

As a Protestant, it was tiring trying to figure out what was true about certain things. Sure, there was some agreement among varying authors and pastors, but since no one really answered to a higher authority and could just write any old book, it was difficult trying to figure out what was right and wrong. When I realized Jesus had established his church on Peter, and that led to the Catholic church, it was a relief to know that if I had a question about something, I had an authority to go to that a) knew what they were talking about, b) had the authority to do so, and c) were protected by God Himself from teaching error.

There were some other things, but this was probably one of the biggest things that was missing for me.
This is exactly how I felt.
 
Authority. Protestantism began to feel like a buffet line to pick and choose beliefs based on what some man had decided was true or not.
This is a good analogy for me. Coming from a non-denominational church, after a pastor leaves and a new one comes in, church doctrine changes accordingly. I guess it wouldn’t be as bad in a mainline protestant church.

I kept asking protestant pastors, “How can I obtain “salvation?”” I couldn’t get a reasonable answer and even was accused of trying to (i’m not sure what the word he used was) test one pastor. I wasn’t. I was only seeking answers to questions that I’ve had for a long time.

I know I know, confess with your mouth and believe in your heart… Me: but what if I stop believing? Them: Then you never truly believed. Me: Surly people can really truly believe and then later on stop believing. I’ve seen it happen. It’s happened to me in a way.

I knew there had to be more. I believe The Catholic Church is where the Holy Spirit has led me.
 
It is not really that something was missing. It is that I didn’t KNOW that I had been born on the WRONG SIDE!!! I started reading (prompted by a STRONG supernatural impulse to do so) and FOUND OUT that I had this “edited” version of Christianity. That was not only edited but twisted.
And when I say “edited”, it was edited BY MAN. HOW ARROGANT for man to think that he could edit (improve/make better) the Truth as presented by Christ.
I just didn’t know!!!
I thank God just about every day for letting me KNOW…and leading me away from all that messed up version of “Christianity.”
That partial version.
That twisted version.
That incomplete and twisted version.
 
Authority, absolutely. Also, lack of Sacred Tradition. As I became more of a student of history, the more I began to research the ancient Church and the times before the Reformation. As someone else said, most Protestants act like that between 90 A.D. and the Protestant reformation that there was no Church!
 
Also, I didn’t even know Mary before. Now I really really know her. And love her. And feel sort of ANGRY that that was kept from me. She is my mother! And has been sooooooooooo wonderful. How great it would have been to have her in my life 20 years ago!!!
To have her role edited out is just…SATANIC and disgusting.
POOOOOOOR little children being brought up to not have her and to not know her. IT is AWFUL and disgusting.
I feel soooooooooo fortunate. But what about the others, who may never know her. ??
So sad. More than sad. Horrible.
 
If you had asked this questioned the day before I was received into full communion in the Church I would have said nothing. I believed and I sill do that the Holy Spirit called me to convert. The day after I would say that I now have a fullness of faith that I didn’t have before.
 
In addition to truth, there is also a depth of truth. Altho I was baptized Catholic, I was not raised Catholic, so when I became interested in Christianity, I just went to the most convenient church. Eventually, there just seemed to be something missing–*in addition to what the other posters have said, *there is also a *depth *to the teachings of the Church. There is the Truth, there is the completeness of the Truth, and there is a depth of truth–it’s like Catholic teachings reach down into the hidden parts of humanity and teach about that part of us, a lot, and with great detail.

The Fullness of the Faith, it’s called, but it’s like an overflowing rather than merely full.
 
The churches i attended in the past were Protestant. I was only a visitor. It definitely felt like something was missing, and at one i went to for a few months, anyone could take communion, including visitors. I didn’t think that was proper, even before i considered becoming Catholic.

My conversion won’t be official for awhile, as RCIA starts soon.
 
The churches i attended in the past were Protestant. I was only a visitor. It definitely felt like something was missing, and at one i went to for a few months, anyone could take communion, including visitors. I didn’t think that was proper, even before i considered becoming Catholic.

My conversion won’t be official for awhile, as RCIA starts soon.
Welcome Home!
 

  1. *]Legitimacy. Every Protestant sect began (in most cases) with one man suddenly deciding he knew better than the previous fifteen hundred years of saints and scholars. That’s a ***crushing ***burden of proof.
    *]Apostolic succession. I expect my students to respect the authority of my substitute because it is my authority, held vicariously.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top