Question for those who homeschool or who's children homeschool

  • Thread starter Thread starter gmarie21
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
G

gmarie21

Guest
Okay, so today I am feeling a bit insecure and well, jealous and/or competitive. My mom read me an email about an award my nephew (my brother’s son) has received, one where he has graduated from fourth grade math and is progressing to fifth grade math (my nephew is 7 and in second grade - and thank goodness his school is allowing him to advance, something I was afraid wouldn’t happen for him, he is very book smarts and learns things quickly like my dad who has a near photographic memory). I have another nephew (my step-sister’s son) who also has received plenty of awards from school that my mom has proudly shared. I know that she has shared the books my daughter reads with my uncle (who is the leader of a Great Books club), but no one else that I am aware. And I have never heard my mom sharing anything regarding homeschooling with others (even my brother) nor has my dad (who has shared my nephew’s accomplishments - but then again my dad doesn’t brag about anyone who’s work doesn’t “impress” him). I love and strongly believe in homeschooling but must be honest that due to the nature of homeschooling that there isn’t as much in the way of “awards” to brag about and we just naturally progress in subject matter, not really have a month’s long break as is the case for brick and mortar school children. If you have felt this way, how did you address it within yourself? I am happy for my nephew, I just wish that other things would be acknowledged not just brains. But then again, that’s life, compassion is not always celebrated within family unless an award accompanies it.
 
Hi There,

I agree with you and how academic intelligence is seen as more important! Unfortunately, some talents and gifts are NOT valued and given the importance that they deserve 😦

One of my children is very talented in the arts(drama, piano, visual arts). Thanks to homeschooling, she is able to spend time in all her endeavors. My other child is very academic smart and “measurable”. However, Our Lord has given them both such different gifts and I am sure it is like that with your child.

What I usually do is thank OUr Lord for the gift of homeschooling in our family where my child’s special gifts are nurtured and praised! When I talk to relatives/friends, I always emphasize the many blessings that we have received from our Lord and the freedoms that we have access to and how my child has been able to grow in his/her specific talent year by year. I usually invite friends and family to recitals and plays. In my son’s case, I will share how well he has done on various projects and national testing, etc.

Most important, they see faith, virtue, good manners, character and behavior that improve year by year.

Whenever comparisons arise, I immediately go into gratitude mode and try to look at each of our blessings and I also pray for the people involved as well. Pray that all children are treasured, loved and that all parents see their accomplishments 🙂

Blessings to you,
 
What a great opportunity to focus on intrinsic motivation rather than extrinsic.
 
We opted to not have our children graded at all through the charter school. Several children in DS’s karate class regularly present report cards and are rewarded with patches recognizing their academic achievements. DS hasn’t had that, though he does perform well academically. Thankfully, he hasn’t let the disappointment get to him and he has been repeatedly recognized for his excellent attitude in that class (most of the kids eventually devolve into typical behavior for young children but he is more consistent in maintaining a serious attitude).

Just teach them that outward accolades are unimportant. All that matters is what is inside.
 
We opted to not have our children graded at all through the charter school. QUOTE]

I don’t understand what this means. A teacher has assess students’ progress in order to know if the student is ready to go on to more difficult material or if they need more time on the previous skills. Are you saying that you have opted not to have the teacher tell you how your child is doing? Or are you saying that the teacher describes your son’s progress using a different method other than the traditional letter grade?
 
I used to make announcements at family dinners about my children’s achievements. They don’t give out awards for being a great wife, or mother either. Mostly you just get critisized. Take time to acknowledge how wonderful your parents are. 🙂 Everybody enjoys encouragement on doing the right thing.
 
Okay, so today I am feeling a bit insecure and well, jealous and/or competitive. My mom read me an email about an award my nephew (my brother’s son) has received, one where he has graduated from fourth grade math and is progressing to fifth grade math (my nephew is 7 and in second grade - and thank goodness his school is allowing him to advance, something I was afraid wouldn’t happen for him, he is very book smarts and learns things quickly like my dad who has a near photographic memory). I have another nephew (my step-sister’s son) who also has received plenty of awards from school that my mom has proudly shared. I know that she has shared the books my daughter reads with my uncle (who is the leader of a Great Books club), but no one else that I am aware. And I have never heard my mom sharing anything regarding homeschooling with others (even my brother) nor has my dad (who has shared my nephew’s accomplishments - but then again my dad doesn’t brag about anyone who’s work doesn’t “impress” him). I love and strongly believe in homeschooling but must be honest that due to the nature of homeschooling that there isn’t as much in the way of “awards” to brag about and we just naturally progress in subject matter, not really have a month’s long break as is the case for brick and mortar school children. If you have felt this way, how did you address it within yourself? I am happy for my nephew, I just wish that other things would be acknowledged not just brains. But then again, that’s life, compassion is not always celebrated within family unless an award accompanies it.
I would think that while homeschooling you would have even greater opportunity to brag about your child’s accomplishments because you experience them first hand. If all a parent has to go on is a report card, they can say, “Well, Junior got an “A” again!” but unless they are really involved in what goes on in class, they might not know about the really creative story their child wrote or the hard work they did on a science experiment or that they got a perfect score on their long division test. As a homeschool parent, you can proudly email the story to grandma and anyone else you want to show it to. Of course, if you think your child really would benefit for a blue ribbon, there are certainly contests such as science fairs, spelling bees, and history fairs that you could enroll your child.
 
destinationimagination.org/

This is a really neat program that challenges kids to work in small teams to complete tasks that require research, planning, creativity, and teamwork. I think it’s an awsome program for homeschool kids to be involved in. Actually, I think it’s an awsome program for all kids.

PS- and your child’s team can win awards.

PPS- and scholarships.
 
I can appreciate your feelings as I home school my son has Down syndrome, so not only does he not get public school awards, he doesn’t progress at the same speed as even typical students. But he works very hard and deserves the usual “pats on the back.”

The way we addressed it is to set our own occasional goals - maybe 2 or 3 a year for our son to work towards and have a suitable prize or certificate or both to celebrate his accomplishment.

One year he most desperately wanted a Disney Scene-it Game. At the same time we were really struggling with the times tables. So we bought the game, placed it our of reach but in sight of school and promised him this much desired prize would be his when he had passed his times tables. Now, this was a bit scary. Week after week, month after month we struggled together. But after 9-1/2 months of work, our son did indeed get the prize. We took a picture of him holding the prize and the certificate we created on the computer to recognize his accomplishment. We emailed, facebooked and snail mailed that picture to all friends and relatives from whom we normally rec’d the same type of thing from their kids in regular school.

The phone calls, emails and facebook posts congratulating our son were lovely, and they did much to show him that his accomplishments counted, too. And when acquaintances asked us and my son how “school is going”, it gave us bragging rights, “oh, Sam is doing so well, he just won a multiplication table award that he worked on for many months – we are so proud!!”

We’ve taken pictures of our son holding especially good art pieces, or science projects and even karate and sports pics (Phys Ed!).

As for the heart thing - I try to keep my eyes and heart not on my son’s accomplishments compared to his peers, but his accomplishments in face of his own abilities and hard work. That is most likely how God judges all of us, no?
 
SonCatcher;10407220:
We opted to not have our children graded at all through the charter school.
I don’t understand what this means. A teacher has assess students’ progress in order to know if the student is ready to go on to more difficult material or if they need more time on the previous skills. Are you saying that you have opted not to have the teacher tell you how your child is doing? Or are you saying that the teacher describes your son’s progress using a different method other than the traditional letter grade?
It is an independent study charter school. We teach the kids and tell the education specialist (instead of a teacher) know once per month how they are doing. They have everything they need to issue grades, if requested, but we did not opt for this since we did not consider outward signs as necessary (the kids are picking this one up). They only allow this option for K-8.

For the record, we are transferring the oldest to a “traditional” school and were required to furnish a report card. The specialist was able to provide one within a day.
 
It is an independent study charter school. We teach the kids and tell the education specialist (instead of a teacher) know once per month how they are doing. They have everything they need to issue grades, if requested, but we did not opt for this since we did not consider outward signs as necessary (the kids are picking this one up). They only allow this option for K-8.

For the record, we are transferring the oldest to a “traditional” school and were required to furnish a report card. The specialist was able to provide one within a day.
I love this!
 
I love this!
It works out for us but there are potential drawbacks. Since the charter school is funded by the state, they only provide secular materials (we buy religious materials on our own).

That’s not a big deal but others might see not being able to use Seton Math as a major intrusion.
 
Many schools give awards for every little thing… when everyone gets an award, who is really outstanding? No one.

Our county schools use a bizarre grading scale for math. If you get 17/34 on the 7th grade final exam (17/34 = 50%, right?), your ‘score’ is a 65 and you pass. No joke.

I used to work with kids who were out of school for social, emotional and physical reasons. I had to give a 7th grade boy his final. His math teacher sent me the test and the ‘grading scale’. When I asked her if I was reading it correctly, she said the teachers HAVE to go by that even though they don’t agree.

They also have to follow ‘pacing guides’ that tell them what to teach and when. I asked if they could keep working with kids who didn’t understand. Nope, follow the guide and move on to the next topic.

Be grateful you can work at your child’s pace and keep at until he/ she really gets it.
 
Hello GMarie 🙂

I have several thoughts to share, actually 🙂 First of all, I think it’s important to look at the concept of awards, and what they signify. Awards and other forms of accolades are a species of recognition, and, more specifically, of affirmation, so let’s talk about that. Affirmation is an inherent need in human beings. We need to know that we are good and worthy of love. That we are both valuable and valued. It’s essential to our emotional development, and is a need that stays with us all our lives, although it changes as we go through life stages.

When we are very young, the primary means of affirmation comes from our parents. They (would ideally) affirm us in many ways: when they praise us, when they tell us we are good/smart/beautiful/athletic/brave, when they tell us we did an excellent job, or that they are proud of our effort, when they place our photograph on the wall, when they hang our artwork on the refrigerator, when they trust us enough to give us responsibility, when they audibly thank God for us, when they notice us doing something good, when they look on and smile approvingly at us, when they hug and kiss us, when they spend time with us, when they actively listen to us, and on and on and on. As we mature, the need for affirmation does not disappear, although it takes different forms. We still need recognition that what we do is good and valuable and worthwhile, and more importantly, that we are good and valuable and worthwhile. So where does adult affirmation come from? Well, some of it can still come from our parents perhaps, but most of it branches out to the people whom we interact with daily. For those who are married, one’s spouse is often a good provider of affirmation. For those in the workforce, whether paid or volunteered, the admiration and reliance on one by one’s colleagues, or the recognition and gratitude from one’s clients can be a good source of affirmation. Close family members and friends also help with affirmation. (And, of course, it can also come from within us, and also from the knowledge of the God who knows us to the very fiber of our being and loved us into existence. I am not attempting to diminish the profound importance of these last two, but it does not negate the fact that we still have a very real need for affirmation from our fellow human beings.)

Home-schooling moms and stay-at-home moms are often excellent at affirming their own children, but as for themselves, well, often they receive little-to-no recognition, and their work is (at least ostensibly) undervalued. I think it is very important for you to remember that, if your children’s love cups are full, then societal awards are superfluous for them. Good things, yes, but not essential. The one who may need that extra boost of affirmation might just be you. Cultivate that, if that is the case. It’s one of the best things you can do for your children. We need to receive affirmation as well as give it. Cultivate friendships, and join a homeschooling group if you aren’t already active in one. Other home-schooling moms are your colleagues in a sense, and you can support each other like no one else can! Also, I have known home-schooling groups to offer their own academic awards with science fairs and real cap and gown graduations, which are just a lot of fun! Feel free to shoot me a pm if you’re ever bored 🙂 I’m always happy to exchange ideas with new friends.

Also, it may help to remember that academic prowess and IQ are not the sole determinants of life success and happiness. Indeed, one of the best things you can do for your children to help ensure their happiness and success is to prepare them emotionally for life, to give them the tools they need to succeed! I am speaking not only of the emotional intelligences (self-awareness, self-control or mood-management, self-motivation, empathy, and relationship skills), but also of the many emotional competencies which contribute to our success and sense of well-being (for example, developing traits such as optimism, confidence, and resiliency). Because you are a home-schooling mom, you are in a very unique position to cultivate these life skills in your children, so hold your head high 👍

Regarding feelings of jealousy, (I’m not sure that you necessarily have it, but since you asked) this is how I handle it when it occasionally crops up. My spiritual director told me that if we struggle with a particular kind of sin, one of the best things we can do to is to cultivate the opposite virtue. For thoughts of jealousy, this means that I ask that God will bless that person much more than they have already been blessed. This practice opens the heart wide open and blows any feeling of jealousy right out of the water. (I’m not kidding–it knocks jealousy’s socks right off! If you can do this, you’ve won the battle, and that actually makes you feel good!)

Finally, if you think your children would really benefit from hearing their grandmother affirm them, and you have such a relationship with your mom where you can do so, you could potentially ask for her help in affirming your children. This would need to be done very sensitively and diplomatically, avoiding anything that might sound like criticism or blame. (For example, something like this might do the trick: “Mom, I think such and such child could use an extra boost for her self-esteem. I’m doing my best to affirm her, but I think some outside praise would really go a long way with her. Can you help me out?” Grandmothers can be great that way!

Good luck, and God bless you 🙂
 
Part of our homeschooling has always involved “outside the classroom” activities. Many of these activities give you the chance to earm awards and such. We’ve had great fun and success with 4H. Our county even has a 4H club for homeschoolers. If your county doesn’t have one then talk with the extension agent about starting one. Through 4H my kids have competed and won on the county, district, and state level in things such as speech, photography, woodworking, sewing, dog showing, etc. We’ve also done sports, dancing, and theater outside of class. All of these things help to provide a well rounded education and give your child a chance to shine, just like his or her cousins.
 
Thank you everyone for your replies. You have given me a lot to reflect on.
 
Personally I would say that the biggest award you should desire for your kids is the salvation provided by God.

As a former atheist who had everything in life, except God, I guess I know what really makes a difference when it comes to living a fulfilling, meaningful and happy life. There is no true happiness in life without faith, and no man-given award can compensate for that.

It is important to educate your kids the best way you can, but your most important challenge in this world will be by far to keep them in the faith. It’s a crazy world with often twisted values, and it is easy to get lost and focus in the wrong stuff as a parent.

Don’t bother too much about other parents bragging about their kids accomplishments. Truth is, all accomplishments in this world actually belong to God, so there is no reason to inflate our own ego with compliments all the time.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top