Question on daughter's lost virginity

  • Thread starter Thread starter Irish_Girl_68
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
That actually made me laugh šŸ™‚

I think her question to me (that I didn’t articulate well) was more along the lines of ā€œhow muchā€ to tell a future spouse. My own thought is that she is absolutely required to divulge she isn’t a virgin, but the other details (the age) are not necessary. That said, I recall a priest in college telling a group of students that even that basic admission was not necessary; if someone was living a chaste life, he/she did not have to tell a future spouse he/she was not a virgin. He qualified this by saying that the sin must have been forgiven in the Confessional and that there must be no possibility of disease, etc. I don’t know where he got this idea or if it was just his own opinion. I remember thinking at the time that doing such a thing would be a grave unfairness to a future spouse.

I do agree that it’s not a pressing matter for her at the moment, but she seems genuinely bothered by this. I wanted to advise her as honestly and wisely as possible. Thank you all for your thoughts.
I did not read this post in its entirety.

A priest should not be advising people to lie, as he is leading others to sin. In fact, there was a thread recently about a man who wondered if his own marriage was invalid because his wife lied about her virginity status knowing it was a deal-breaker and he found out many years later she wasn’t. If she cannot avoid the question, she should just tell the truth and accept whatever outcome results.
 
Any guy who actually takes issue with it is insecure. If a guy meets and falls in love with a woman, and is prepared to walk away or change his heart from finding out his love is not a virgin, he is truly self centered and lacking in self confidence.

There was a thread about a married man not to long ago who found out his wife of 20 or 30 years was not a virgin, and the commentary on that thread was horrible. How people are so cold and shallow I do not know.

If you make big deal out of it, then your daughter will think its a big deal, and it will become a source of anxiety for her. Let it go. If she sees you are over it, and you are clear that any guy should not blink at the idea, then she will be fine. If you wring your hands, so will she.
However, you may want to tell her that there are consequences for her actions, and that if a guy can’t handle her past, she is going to have to accept it as a consequence and should offer it up as part of her temporal punishment. That is part of repentance and accepting responsibility for one’s actions and so may take on the value of expiation. Additionally, if she does run into a few situations where it caused her to lose a guy, then she may be able to be an example to other women and deter them from making a ā€œmistakeā€ before it’s too late.

Now, if the male is not a virgin himself, then he is in no position to lecture.
This is just evil. Or at least very cruel. For the love of God don’t have any daughters. This comment would make me bet you have none.
 
This is just evil. Or at least very cruel. For the love of God don’t have any daughters. This comment would make me bet you have none.
I see you are not Catholic, so you may not be aware that the concept of temporal punishment/consequences is not evil but in fact a Catholic Church teaching (admittedly, one that we don’t hear about a lot these days, except maybe in traditional circles). However, my comments are not meant to be cruel, but rather to help her prepare her daughter for the day that such a rejection may occur so she is not devastated.

People reject one another on all types of reasons, some of which have nothing to do with something that they have done, like the families they were born into; if anything is evil, that should be.
 
A decent man will love your daughter regardless of any failings. I’m sure he will come with his own… just different ones, or perhaps the same. She just needs to be honest.
Yes I dated a couple of women who lost their virginity early and some with many partners, it depends on the guy. Most guys have failed at numerous things too, if 2 people really want to build a good life together they need to realize that no one is perfect and to be able to forgive past sins.

Joe
 
I think her question to me (that I didn’t articulate well) was more along the lines of ā€œhow muchā€ to tell a future spouse. My own thought is that she is absolutely required to divulge she isn’t a virgin, but the other details (the age) are not necessary. That said, I recall a priest in college telling a group of students that even that basic admission was not necessary; if someone was living a chaste life, he/she did not have to tell a future spouse he/she was not a virgin. He qualified this by saying that the sin must have been forgiven in the Confessional and that there must be no possibility of disease, etc. I don’t know where he got this idea or if it was just his own opinion. I remember thinking at the time that doing such a thing would be a grave unfairness to a future spouse.
Wow. I really can’t believe a priest said that. I do not think that anyone should disclose the details of one’s past sins (what age, with whom, etc.), but I do think that people have an obligation to their spouse to disclose if they are not virgins. I have watched how much damage a revelation that one’s spouse is not a virgin can cause if it is learned after marriage. As my mother always said, truth will out eventually. Best to tell the truth up front.

As to the OP’s daughter – there are plenty of men who will be able to judge your daughter for the lovely young woman she is/will become, and not be scared off by her past. Encourage her that she is not, by any means, a lost cause… There are good men out there who will love her.
 
I see you are not Catholic, so you may not be aware that the concept of temporal punishment/consequences is not evil but in fact a Catholic Church teaching (admittedly, one that we don’t hear about a lot these days, except maybe in traditional circles). However, my comments are not meant to be cruel, but rather to help her prepare her daughter for the day that such a rejection may occur so she is not devastated.

People reject one another on all types of reasons, some of which have nothing to do with something that they have done, like the families they were born into; if anything is evil, that should be.
Norseman, I don’t take offense to what you’ve said. The concept of temporal punishment for sin is absolutely a valid point. I don’t, however, intend to beat my daughter over the head with this; she feels bad enough. I am not going to encourage her to live in defeat and despair over any sin, sexual or otherwise. I don’t have a decent answer to this for her; but I’ve advised her that with prayer, God will lead her to the right one. And, as others have pointed out, it isn’t something she needs to immediately worry about. When the time comes, I am confident the Lord will handle it for her.

As to the priest’s comments so many years ago, I don’t disagree with you on that point, either. How can a priest encourage someone to sin? Oddly enough, this came from an older, very conservative priest. I think his take was more that if the sin was forgiven, it was forgiven. Anyone (even a potential spouse) asking you to divulge sins that were left in the Confessional in essence was trying to ā€œplay Godā€ and judge you for something that had already been forgiven. If I remember correctly, he said absolute honesty wasn’t critical because the question shouldn’t be asked in the first place. Again, his only qualifier was the person had to be disease free and have no children (forgot that part earlier). I didn’t agree with his thinking then and still disagree with it now. I can’t see defrauding a potential spouse like that as being OK – if the question doesn’t come up, fine. Otherwise, I do think it needs to be answered honestly.
 
If it were me, I’d tell her to make a vow of staying chaste, and of reclaiming her lost innocence. I realize she can’t grow her hymen back, but she can train herself to think and act like the virgin she would like to be. Have her pray especially to Mary. But she shouldn’t get too obsessed with this right now, provided she has gone to confession and been absolved. If she truly regrets her loss of virginity, that should keep her safe when the offer of sex comes up again.

Unfortunately, she may regret her early loss of virginity the rest of her life, it’s something you can’t go back and undo. It’s just one of those things we have to bear in life, our mistakes sometimes have very far-reaching consequences that we may not understand at the time. I’m not talking about constant, paralyzing regret, but the heartfelt wish that she had stayed pure for her husband.
Well said! :clapping:
 
If it were me, I’d tell her to make a vow of staying chaste, and of reclaiming her lost innocence. I realize she can’t grow her hymen back, but she can train herself to think and act like the virgin she would like to be. Have her pray especially to Mary. But she shouldn’t get too obsessed with this right now, provided she has gone to confession and been absolved. If she truly regrets her loss of virginity, that should keep her safe when the offer of sex comes up again.

Unfortunately, she may regret her early loss of virginity the rest of her life, it’s something you can’t go back and undo. It’s just one of those things we have to bear in life, our mistakes sometimes have very far-reaching consequences that we may not understand at the time. I’m not talking about constant, paralyzing regret, but the heartfelt wish that she had stayed pure for her husband.
I think this is the best response so far. šŸ‘
 
Any guy who actually takes issue with it is insecure.
And any guy for whom that fact does not create just a bit of a pause is naive.

Actions are the outward and obvious sign of character. This is why we are told that we will know the ā€œgood people/Christiansā€ by their fruits.

This daughter is not necessarily evil or rotten. Her actions since then will prove most useful in evaluating her character.

If a guy meets her and falls in love, he would be wise to spend some time making sure. She should do the same about the guy as well. Lots of communication on both sides would be in order.

It’s amazing how many people today don’t read actions as a sign of character. Then the person in question does something harmful again, and people are shocked. Character creates action. The two are linked.
 
Norseman, I don’t take offense to what you’ve said. The concept of temporal punishment for sin is absolutely a valid point. I don’t, however, intend to beat my daughter over the head with this; she feels bad enough. I am not going to encourage her to live in defeat and despair over any sin, sexual or otherwise. I don’t have a decent answer to this for her; but I’ve advised her that with prayer, God will lead her to the right one. And, as others have pointed out, it isn’t something she needs to immediately worry about. When the time comes, I am confident the Lord will handle it for her.
Absolutely! Yes, there may be consequences to this that she may face in the future, as to any sin one can commit, but I think right now helping your daughter see how God forgives her 100% through confession (consequences may occur, but her sin is 100% forgiven) and how she can be strong from now on, and be a shinning example of virtue, would be a good path to take. If a man seeking a wife virtuous in the area of chastity/purity meets a young lady who, when young did slip (probably immature and possibly not thinking of the consequences at the time), but was strong enough to not give up or falter again despite this slipup and has lived a chaste life ever since, he should be able to appreciate her virtue. Sure, some men may not feel ready to deal with this in a spouse, not being a virgin, (no need to bring this up now), but some men may not feel ready to deal with a woman taller than them or a woman that wants to live on the other side of the US or whatnot. Maybe she doesn’t feel like she could deal with a man that wants to live in a different country etc. This does not change that there are many good men out there that, though it may pain them to know the past, have seen how she has profoundly changed and can appreciate the woman she has turned into. She can definitely work on that virtue and become virtuous in that area, living a chaste life from now on, and meet a decent young man seeking a chaste young woman that will be able to appreciate her virtue. Slipping up when one is young and then staying chaste afterwards is very different to leading a sexually active life and not being able to stay chaste for an extended period of time.
 
I realize she can’t grow her hymen back, but she can train herself to think and act like the virgin she would like to be.
A little off topic, but I just wanted you to know that it can easily break through sports, horseback riding, running… ect. That was a bad example to use on your part unless you were speaking metaphorically.
 
The male virgins are in the minority, but they are there.

However, you may want to tell her that there are consequences for her actions, and that if a guy can’t handle her past, she is going to have to accept it as a consequence and should offer it up as part of her temporal punishment. That is part of repentance and accepting responsibility for one’s actions and so may take on the value of expiation. Additionally, if she does run into a few situations where it caused her to lose a guy, then she may be able to be an example to other women and deter them from making a ā€œmistakeā€ before it’s too late.

Now, if the male is not a virgin himself, then he is in no position to lecture.
And if a guy can’t handle her one ā€œindescretionā€ from years before he met her, he’s not the kind of guy worth marrying!
 
Slipping up when one is young and then staying chaste afterwards is very different to leading a sexually active life and not being able to stay chaste for an extended period of time.
This is 100% true.

The evil(or maybe sadly realistic?) part of me wants to mention Freud and how our upbringing and past actions are the best indicators of future behavior, but it is possible to change.
 
This is 100% true.

The evil(or maybe sadly realistic?) part of me wants to mention Freud and how our upbringing and past actions are the best indicators of future behavior, but it is possible to change.
If she was sleeping around at the age of 30, you’d have a point, but she was only 14.

Most of us did stupid things at the age of 14, that we haven’t repeated.
 
If she was sleeping around at the age of 30, you’d have a point, but she was only 14.

Most of us did stupid things at the age of 14, that we haven’t repeated.
Like liking Leonardo DiCaprio! šŸ˜›

I hope that what I did in college would not be held against me (I’m 29 now). And it is possible to change, bu the desire has to come from within. If it wasn’t possible to change, then why bother at all?
 
If she was sleeping around at the age of 30, you’d have a point, but she was only 14.

Most of us did stupid things at the age of 14, that we haven’t repeated.
I did not do anything at that severe level. Sleeping around is not a ā€œstupid thingā€. It’s pretty major stuff kind of like doping or stealing cars.

It is also a reflection on parenting if you’re going to play the age angle.
 
Now we know it’s all over for you. There can be no redemption on that one. All over.:cool:
I know. 😦 God doesn’t forgive bad taste.

Oh wait, since I’m condemned anyway, I can be bad! eats whole pie in one sitting
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top