N
Norseman82
Guest
I did not read this post in its entirety.That actually made me laugh
I think her question to me (that I didnāt articulate well) was more along the lines of āhow muchā to tell a future spouse. My own thought is that she is absolutely required to divulge she isnāt a virgin, but the other details (the age) are not necessary. That said, I recall a priest in college telling a group of students that even that basic admission was not necessary; if someone was living a chaste life, he/she did not have to tell a future spouse he/she was not a virgin. He qualified this by saying that the sin must have been forgiven in the Confessional and that there must be no possibility of disease, etc. I donāt know where he got this idea or if it was just his own opinion. I remember thinking at the time that doing such a thing would be a grave unfairness to a future spouse.
I do agree that itās not a pressing matter for her at the moment, but she seems genuinely bothered by this. I wanted to advise her as honestly and wisely as possible. Thank you all for your thoughts.
A priest should not be advising people to lie, as he is leading others to sin. In fact, there was a thread recently about a man who wondered if his own marriage was invalid because his wife lied about her virginity status knowing it was a deal-breaker and he found out many years later she wasnāt. If she cannot avoid the question, she should just tell the truth and accept whatever outcome results.