Question on daughter's lost virginity

  • Thread starter Thread starter Irish_Girl_68
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I did not do anything at that severe level. Sleeping around is not a “stupid thing”. It’s pretty major stuff kind of like doping or stealing cars.

It is also a reflection on parenting if you’re going to play the age angle.
Wow. What a profoundly arrogant and stupid thing to say.

Nec5, do you know anything of my household or the religious instruction of my children? Are you an expert in child psychology or adolescent development? If you can truthfully answer yes to either or those, please let me know. I’d be happy to hear you out.

As a devout Catholic, I have wept more tears than I care to count over all of this.Thanks for adding to the guilt and shame I already feel. It’s really appreciated.
 
Norseman, I don’t take offense to what you’ve said. The concept of temporal punishment for sin is absolutely a valid point. I don’t, however, intend to beat my daughter over the head with this; she feels bad enough. I am not going to encourage her to live in defeat and despair over any sin, sexual or otherwise. I don’t have a decent answer to this for her; but I’ve advised her that with prayer, God will lead her to the right one. And, as others have pointed out, it isn’t something she needs to immediately worry about. When the time comes, I am confident the Lord will handle it for her.

As to the priest’s comments so many years ago, I don’t disagree with you on that point, either. How can a priest encourage someone to sin? Oddly enough, this came from an older, very conservative priest. I think his take was more that if the sin was forgiven, it was forgiven. Anyone (even a potential spouse) asking you to divulge sins that were left in the Confessional in essence was trying to “play God” and judge you for something that had already been forgiven. If I remember correctly, he said absolute honesty wasn’t critical because the question shouldn’t be asked in the first place. Again, his only qualifier was the person had to be disease free and have no children (forgot that part earlier). I didn’t agree with his thinking then and still disagree with it now. I can’t see defrauding a potential spouse like that as being OK – if the question doesn’t come up, fine. Otherwise, I do think it needs to be answered honestly.
Thanks. I think we’re on the same page. I’m not telling you to beat her over the head with it (I realize that things like tone and facial expressions can be hard to gauge over the internet). I guess if I had a daughter (I don’t have any, except for a girl cocker spaniel) in the same boat as yours I would simply try to make her feel relaxed and try to tell her in a calm soothing voice that if “the talk” comes up, do not lie; if he can’t handle it, he can’t handle it; this is simply a case of incompatibility, and instead of raining a stink that it would be best to “drop it” and move on, and even though she is still facing (and may always face) the consequences of her earlier actions, there may be males in the same boat as her who have also turned their life around and may be able to relate to her better. I would not bring up the “temporal suffering” part unless she turned the conversation to a theological bent , although I definitely would not let her badmouth the guy like I’ve seen some posters write in some of the posts in this thread.

And then, after all is said and done, I would offer her a hug or a shoulder to cry on.
 
I did not do anything at that severe level. Sleeping around is not a “stupid thing”. It’s pretty major stuff kind of like doping or stealing cars.

It is also a reflection on parenting if you’re going to play the age angle.
Holy cow. Make sure your ankles don’t explode when falling off a horse that high.

A 14 year old with raging hormones and a weak moment is like grand theft auto? Really?

This post makes you sound the adult that is still bitter about your time when you were 14. Don’t project your judgement on some other 14 year old, or her mother. Sheesh.
 
Crystalina Evert lost her virginity at the age of 15, eventually broke up with him, and had “other relationships”. Since 2003, shes been the wife of Jason (Evert), and theyre chastity crusaders! So: Crystalina can speak from experience.

Google them; and youll find a heap of info thatll help your daughter; and put both of you at peace.
eg:

catholic.com/seminars/evert.asp
youtube.com/watch?v=NBiqbo14yH4&feature=related
youtube.com/watch?v=YA2LweuCxCo&feature=related
amazon.com/Theology-Body-Teens-Student-Workbook/dp/1932927867

The whole of the 13-part “The Pure Life” is worth getting. It covers a hell of a lot of ground.
Bad luck about the lousy music!

ewtn.com/vondemand/audio/file_index.asp?SeriesId=7093&pgnu=2

It should be available in its entirety somewhere in video format; but i didn`t find it.
 
I did not do anything at that severe level. Sleeping around is not a “stupid thing”. It’s pretty major stuff kind of like doping or stealing cars.

It is also a reflection on parenting if you’re going to play the age angle.
If only it were that simple. Good parents have kids who never make mistakes, and bad parents raise kids you are ne’r-do-wells.

We all have free will, and exercise it from a very early age.
 
Are you sure it was consensual and not sexual assault? That may be something she is ashamed to tell you if it’s the truth. Most sexual assault happens by people that the victim knows. It strikes me that 14 is awfully young to be assigning this kind of moral responsibility for her choices. Isn’t that under the age of consent in many places? Those laws of consent are there for a reason. It is b/c children are too young to consent to sexual activity b/c they don’t fully understand what they are doing.

There is also a grey area between rape and consensual sex where she is pressured into sex in a way that she finds difficult to refuse. If she had been 20 or so, she might have had the strength of mind to refuse it, but at 14 it’s hard, which is a reason why laws about the age of consent exist in many places. Children/young teenagers are often too immature to understand what they are doing.

It is true that the younger the age at the loss of virginity, the more likely it was involuntary. That may be a possibility that needs to be discussed though it would be difficult. How much older than she was, was the guy she slept with? If her age or older that is not as much of a concern as if he was a lot older. However I’m still not sure I would consider the sex fully voluntary, whether there was any coercion involved or not, b/c she was too young to really realize what she was doing, in my opinion.
 
Are you sure it was consensual and not sexual assault? That may be something she is ashamed to tell you if it’s the truth. Most sexual assault happens by people that the victim knows. It strikes me that 14 is awfully young to be assigning this kind of moral responsibility for her choices. Isn’t that under the age of consent in many places? Those laws of consent are there for a reason. It is b/c children are too young to consent to sexual activity b/c they don’t fully understand what they are doing.

There is also a grey area between rape and consensual sex where she is pressured into sex in a way that she finds difficult to refuse. If she had been 20 or so, she might have had the strength of mind to refuse it, but at 14 it’s hard, which is a reason why laws about the age of consent exist in many places. Children/young teenagers are often too immature to understand what they are doing.

It is true that the younger the age at the loss of virginity, the more likely it was involuntary. That may be a possibility that needs to be discussed though it would be difficult. How much older than she was, was the guy she slept with? If her age or older that is not as much of a concern as if he was a lot older. However I’m still not sure I would consider the sex fully voluntary, whether there was any coercion involved or not, b/c she was too young to really realize what she was doing, in my opinion.
Really good point. I suspect that a LOT of sex between minors is at least somewhat coercive, if not by the individuals, then by this over-sexualized culture that we’ve allowed to take root. And it’s not just the boys who are pressuring for sex - I can tell you that girls can be very aggressive going after boys, very much like the wanton woman in Proverbs.
 
I did not read this post in its entirety.

A priest should not be advising people to lie, as he is leading others to sin. In fact, there was a thread recently about a man who wondered if his own marriage was invalid because his wife lied about her virginity status knowing it was a deal-breaker and he found out many years later she wasn’t. If she cannot avoid the question, she should just tell the truth and accept whatever outcome results.
Did the man ask his bride to be if she were a virgin? Did he want to know how many there had been? Did they remain celibate until their wedding day, Was he a virgin? When he found out many years later, did it make a difference? Did they stay married?
 
Really good point. I suspect that a LOT of sex between minors is at least somewhat coercive, if not by the individuals, then by this over-sexualized culture that we’ve allowed to take root. And it’s not just the boys who are pressuring for sex - I can tell you that girls can be very aggressive going after boys, very much like the wanton woman in Proverbs.
To address this point…there was no physical force, but I do believe mental coercion was applied. That having been said, my daughter has been taught that premarital sexual activity of any kind (not limited to just intercourse) is a mortal sin. I do believe she is morally culpable for her actions.

I hate bringing this into it because it sounds conceited or boastful, but if I had to speculate “what” prompted much of this to take place, it’s because her physical appearance generates a lot of attention. She’s tall, well developed and appears older than she is. She’s 15 but could easily pass for 18 or 19. This brings with it a lot of male interest. She doesn’t always know how to respond and often seems embarrassed by it. My husband and I are fully aware of this. Thus, we are very careful about what she may or may not wear and instruct her on how she’s supposed to behave around members of the opposite sex. We also encourage a focus on what’s “inside”: Intelligence, good morals, kindess, etc.

Unfortunately, however, her looks are combined with very poor common sense and a lot of naivete. She trusts people very easily and always has, even from a very young age. This certainly isn’t limited to just boys. She’s made friends with girls who are not always kind or good to her.
 
To address this point…there was no physical force, but I do believe mental coercion was applied. That having been said, my daughter has been taught that premarital sexual activity of any kind (not limited to just intercourse) is a mortal sin. I do believe she is morally culpable for her actions.

I hate bringing this into it because it sounds conceited or boastful, but if I had to speculate “what” prompted much of this to take place, it’s because her physical appearance generates a lot of attention. She’s tall, well developed and appears older than she is. She’s 15 but could easily pass for 18 or 19. This brings with it a lot of male interest. She doesn’t always know how to respond and often seems embarrassed by it. My husband and I are fully aware of this. Thus, we are very careful about what she may or may not wear and instruct her on how she’s supposed to behave around members of the opposite sex. We also encourage a focus on what’s “inside”: Intelligence, good morals, kindess, etc.

Unfortunately, however, her looks are combined with very poor common sense and a lot of naivete. She trusts people very easily and always has, even from a very young age. This certainly isn’t limited to just boys. She’s made friends with girls who are not always kind or good to her.
She may need some kind of therapy/pastoral counseling. I’ve heard that abuse, or being taken advantage of by other people, can happen b/c of someone’s good qualities. Someone who is beautiful, or naive, or trusting can be a target for all kinds of people, from abusers to people who just use the person or lean on him or her too much b/c they take advantage of kindness. She may need to be more discerning about who to trust or will have more trouble by being used.

I don’t know how much older the guy was, if he was older, and what you mean by mental coercion. To me that could be anything from rape to giving in b/c of just not wanting to hurt someone’s feelings. Rape doesn’t require physical force. Sometimes the threats are verbal and they are done to induce enough fear that the victim realizes there is no way to leave, so physical force is not applied. But other times it isn’t rape and someone who is naive gives in, in a moment of weakness out of being a people-pleaser, and doesn’t even want to be doing it.

It sounds like you’ve been teaching her how to protect herself and she’s having trouble with that, maybe b/c she gets a lot of attention. That sounds frustrating. People who are unusually attractive, which it sounds like she might be, often need some kind of help in dealing with it, from what I hear not having that problem myself, so that they don’t get used or taken advantage of b/c of it. It’s like someone with any unusual gift like intelligence, a specific talent or sports ability. They need to be in control of how they use their gifts. With being naturally kind and good looking, a lot of people may want to be in her life who are not good for her, and she might need some help figuring out how to politely discourage these people. Someone like me who is more average-looking never got that attention in the first place so it wasn’t a problem. I had this issue a little bit b/c I think many people do growing up, but I’ve heard with attractive people especially when young it can be a problem.

Someone I met who was really beautiful got a lot of compliments for it and she just said thanks, but beauty is fleeting and there are many other aspects of life to appreciate. That was a good way of acknowledging the compliment without getting caught up in discussions about her attractiveness, I thought, and it gave her some control. I think she tried to avoid or not engage much with the few people who kept bringing it up, who tended not to be nice people anyway.
 
To address this point…there was no physical force, but I do believe mental coercion was applied. That having been said, my daughter has been taught that premarital sexual activity of any kind (not limited to just intercourse) is a mortal sin. I do believe she is morally culpable for her actions.

I hate bringing this into it because it sounds conceited or boastful, but if I had to speculate “what” prompted much of this to take place, it’s because her physical appearance generates a lot of attention. She’s tall, well developed and appears older than she is. She’s 15 but could easily pass for 18 or 19. This brings with it a lot of male interest. She doesn’t always know how to respond and often seems embarrassed by it. My husband and I are fully aware of this. Thus, we are very careful about what she may or may not wear and instruct her on how she’s supposed to behave around members of the opposite sex. We also encourage a focus on what’s “inside”: Intelligence, good morals, kindess, etc.

Unfortunately, however, her looks are combined with very poor common sense and a lot of naivete. She trusts people very easily and always has, even from a very young age. This certainly isn’t limited to just boys. She’s made friends with girls who are not always kind or good to her.
I was like your DD, I blossomed early, at 14 I looked about 18 or 19 and had a lot of boys interested in me in not pure ways. 😦

I honestly think I must have had a very strong Guardian Angel when it came to chastity…because me being naive in my teens I did put myself in the near occasion of sin, and the only logical explanation on how they did not become actual occasions of sin is because my Guardian Angel protected me.:nunchuk:

Prayers for your daughter and for her broken heart. I honestly think nothing is harder than being a 15 year old girl. :(😦
 
Norseman, I don’t take offense to what you’ve said. The concept of temporal punishment for sin is absolutely a valid point. I don’t, however, intend to beat my daughter over the head with this; she feels bad enough.
I think Norseman’s advice is great if she encounters a situation where this becomes an obstacle in some future relationship. No need to trouble her now with such a prosepect.
 
Unfortunately, however, her looks are combined with very poor common sense and a lot of naivete. She trusts people very easily and always has, even from a very young age. This certainly isn’t limited to just boys. She’s made friends with girls who are not always kind or good to her.
My heart goes out to her. Remind her that she is a good, kind, beautiful girl. Her mistake is forgiven and behind her.

Teach her that, sometimes, it’s not wrong to be rude. Sometimes, you just have to walk away from a situation, even if someone’s feelings might appear to be hurt. There are boys and girls that she should simply not be friends with, because of the fact that they will try to take advantage of her kind and generous nature. Not everyone is kind and good - some people take joy in hurting others. She has to avoid those people. She can’t be worried about hurting their feelings, if they try to hurt her in any way. She might have to be rude to them. It’s okay to be rude to them. Better to lose their false friendship, than her own eternal soul.
 
She may need some kind of therapy/pastoral counseling. I’ve heard that abuse, or being taken advantage of by other people, can happen b/c of someone’s good qualities. Someone who is beautiful, or naive, or trusting can be a target for all kinds of people, from abusers to people who just use the person or lean on him or her too much b/c they take advantage of kindness. She may need to be more discerning about who to trust or will have more trouble by being used.

I don’t know how much older the guy was, if he was older, and what you mean by mental coercion. To me that could be anything from rape to giving in b/c of just not wanting to hurt someone’s feelings. Rape doesn’t require physical force. Sometimes the threats are verbal and they are done to induce enough fear that the victim realizes there is no way to leave, so physical force is not applied. But other times it isn’t rape and someone who is naive gives in, in a moment of weakness out of being a people-pleaser, and doesn’t even want to be doing it.

It sounds like you’ve been teaching her how to protect herself and she’s having trouble with that, maybe b/c she gets a lot of attention. That sounds frustrating. People who are unusually attractive, which it sounds like she might be, often need some kind of help in dealing with it, from what I hear not having that problem myself, so that they don’t get used or taken advantage of b/c of it. It’s like someone with any unusual gift like intelligence, a specific talent or sports ability. They need to be in control of how they use their gifts. With being naturally kind and good looking, a lot of people may want to be in her life who are not good for her, and she might need some help figuring out how to politely discourage these people. Someone like me who is more average-looking never got that attention in the first place so it wasn’t a problem. I had this issue a little bit b/c I think many people do growing up, but I’ve heard with attractive people especially when young it can be a problem.

Someone I met who was really beautiful got a lot of compliments for it and she just said thanks, but beauty is fleeting and there are many other aspects of life to appreciate. That was a good way of acknowledging the compliment without getting caught up in discussions about her attractiveness, I thought, and it gave her some control. I think she tried to avoid or not engage much with the few people who kept bringing it up, who tended not to be nice people anyway.
This is great advice. OP, you may have taught your daughter that premarital sex is immoral, but I don’t think our society gives enough weight to the mental coercian aspect of premarital sex and just how abusive it really can be. It can be just as damaging as physical force and even more so because its not something that is apparent, such as a bruise. Its very difficult to even talk about for some victims because it becomes a case of “he said, she said”. I worry from your description if her self worth is really damaged and if she’ll end up “settling” for a guy that doesn’t value her worth, someone that isn’t decent because she doesn’t think she deserves to be treated for the beautiful woman she is becoming, both inside and out.
 
Well, my wife was far from a virgin (not promiscuous by any means) when I met her. However, I wasn’t even considering becoming Catholic at that time.

Looking back at it, even now, I’m 100% sure that I would still want to marry her. Even if I was Catholic then, I think I would have still married her without question.

I knew after the 1st date that I would marry her, though I waited 6 months to ask her because I was a chicken.

The bottom line is that most people, even most Catholics, wouldn’t be too put off by it if they were truly interested in her.

The more faults you have (to a point), the greater the love you will have when you marry someone who loves you inspite of your faults.

I knew my wife’s faults but it didn’t matter because the rest of her makeup was so a perfect match for me.

You’re never going to meet someone that will meet all of the requirements on your list for a life time partner. If you think you have, then you are probably kidding yourself.

If she’s a good, faithful Catholic from here on out I highly doubt she will have too much trouble finding a husband some day.

The only concern you have is if she continues with an immoral life, because you tend to attract those of like kind.
 
CAF friends: I’ve had other threads on my daughter and her behavior. By the grace of God, she appears to be turning a corner. She has failed a couple of times where boys are concerned and regrets this. She asked me the other day how she will deal with this fact when she meets a “good guy who maybe wants to marry me.” She was 14 when she lost her virginity. Admittedly, a tough pill for many men to swallow. I’ve told her to give it to God, pray to Our Lady and it would take care of itself at the proper time.

I still feel like I failed her in terms of a correct answer. While I didn’t tell her this, my own thought is, a man of 30 might better understand, but I question how much any decent man in his late teens/early twenties might accept it (assuming she might meet marriage-appropriate men in college). Any thoughts or advice?
I lost my virginity at 15. It took me awhile to get my act together, but eventually I became chaste and at 21, I met a 23-year-old Catholic man who had been chaste his whole life. He loved ME, understood that my past mistakes were part of what made me “ME,” and has not once made me feel like I was less worthy of his love because of my past sins. While the first couple years of our marriage were bumpy, we just celebrated our 4th anniversary and love each other more every day. Your daughter CAN have a happy healthy marriage if she consciously makes better choices for herself. I would encourage her to do some “light counseling” to work through WHY she had sex, what her expectations are for a future healthy sexual relationship, etc. I was not proactive about dealing with the issues that lead to premarital sex, which is part of why the first couple years of our marriage were bumpy. My heart goes out to your daughter–I remember feeling like I was damaged goods at that age–please let her know that she CAN choose to live a good life and there IS a good man out there who will love her. 🙂
 
Irish Girl,

If the young man was significantly older than your daughter, 19 or older, I strongly urge you to at least look into pressing charges. She needs to know that an older man who takes advantage of a young girl is a criminal. Also, PLEASE get your daughter into therapy. It can help her process what happened with her desire for chastity and equip her to say “no” and enforce her own boundaries better in the future.

I was “coerced” in college (I was older than her). It was horrible, I didn’t want it, I hated it, and I felt ashamed because of it, and I still do to this day, almost 10 years later. I felt like it was all my fault, a horrible secret I had to keep. I very very very rarely speak of it ever, especially in person. My self-respect took a horrible hit because of it. I felt that I had deserved that, and that I didn’t deserve anything good or healthy, it took me a long time to get over that. Younger teenage girls may have a harder time coping with things than I did.

I’m sure you don’t want your daughter to go through that, please consider getting her into therapy with someone who specializes in teenage girls who were taken advantage of. She could probably use someone trained who she can confide in to help her make sense for herself of what happened, and hopefully help her reconcile a one-time incident with what her real goals for herself are (chastity), so she can be less vulnerable to coercion in the future.

My experience may be different than your daughter’s: I wasn’t physically able to defend myself although I tried (he was bigger than me and I had a severe migraine, he said he was Catholic and was supposed to just be bringing me food so I didn’t have to venture out into the bright sun because my roommates weren’t around). But, like her, I had been raised strongly Catholic, so some of it may be of use to you. I’m sure you only want what’s best for your daughter.
 
CAF friends: I’ve had other threads on my daughter and her behavior. By the grace of God, she appears to be turning a corner. She has failed a couple of times where boys are concerned and regrets this. She asked me the other day how she will deal with this fact when she meets a “good guy who maybe wants to marry me.” She was 14 when she lost her virginity. Admittedly, a tough pill for many men to swallow. I’ve told her to give it to God, pray to Our Lady and it would take care of itself at the proper time.

I still feel like I failed her in terms of a correct answer. While I didn’t tell her this, my own thought is, a man of 30 might better understand, but I question how much any decent man in his late teens/early twenties might accept it (assuming she might meet marriage-appropriate men in college). Any thoughts or advice?
I wanted to drop a line or two to you, to ease your concern and let you know there is always a happy ending!
A few years back, I lost my virginity to a jerk 5-years-older than I was. I wasn’t allowed to date until 16, and 16 had come and gone and I had never dated anyone, or been asked out by anyone until my senior year of high school and I thought this was my chance to have my “Hollywood fantasy boyfriend”…wrong.
It was TERRIBLE! Worst decision of my life! I learned from it, I went to confession, I came back to God and about 2 weeks after the guy no longer talked to me, the love of my life came along. When we met he was 20 and I was 18. We dated for 3 years and are getting married in 1 month at the age of 21 and 23! We had rough times, like when I told him that I lost my virginity, it took him a few days but he came around and loves me more than ever.
I’m telling you this so you know, your daughter really isn’t alone, and there is light at the end of the tunnel. God’s will be done, and if it is his will, he will lead your daughter to a great guy who will love her no matter what has happened! Don’t fret, my mom was in your position once before. Things happen for a reason, even if it sucks!
God Bless,
Hope this helped!
 
I hate to break it to all of you, but parenting determines most of the big deal stuff that kids do. Traumatic external events also enter into it(kidnapping, rape, etc).
The generational curse is indeed real and was acknowledged long before Freud (though he did apply some scientific elements to strengthen it).

The people who accuse me of arrogance are the same ones who refuse to embrace their own responsibility as parents.

I don’t buy the “good parents often have bad kids” argument. That’s a cop out. The “good” parents were not “good” at all. They may have been nice, but not effective parents.

This is the problem with parenting today. Most parents I know, of all ilks, really have no clue what their kids are doing. If someone like me suggests that they not let their kid do social things without knowledge beforehand, I’m called abusive,oppressive, or controlling. Then their kids end up pregnant or in trouble.

I hate to break it to the relativists here but if you are a parent and your motto is “punishment=time out” or “be home by curfew”, then you’re not raising your kid. The world is raising your kid.
 
I hate to break it to all of you, but parenting determines most of the big deal stuff that kids do. Traumatic external events also enter into it(kidnapping, rape, etc).
The generational curse is indeed real and was acknowledged long before Freud (though he did apply some scientific elements to strengthen it).

The people who accuse me of arrogance are the same ones who refuse to embrace their own responsibility as parents.

I don’t buy the “good parents often have bad kids” argument. That’s a cop out. The “good” parents were not “good” at all. They may have been nice, but not effective parents.

This is the problem with parenting today. Most parents I know, of all ilks, really have no clue what their kids are doing. If someone like me suggests that they not let their kid do social things without knowledge beforehand, I’m called abusive,oppressive, or controlling. Then their kids end up pregnant or in trouble.

I hate to break it to the relativists here but if you are a parent and your motto is “punishment=time out” or “be home by curfew”, then you’re not raising your kid. The world is raising your kid.
I find it very interesting how you completely ignore the option of “good parents, good kid, kid makes mistake”.

Lets just say the OP is a good mother, and does not subscribe to any of the silly generalizations you are making. Are you saying that it would then be impossible for her daughter to have pre-marital sex? Or, are you saying that once she did, the daughter became a bad daughter, and the parents became bad parents?

If you were a parent, which I dont think you are, you are saying you would prevent all examples of bad behavior, lest you be a failure?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top