Question on daughter's lost virginity

  • Thread starter Thread starter Irish_Girl_68
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
My brother and I are one year apart. both grew up with the same parents, same rules, our parents knew what we were doing, same work ethic (on a farm), lots of joy in the house, discipline was always present, went to mass/confession regularly, said the family rosaries together, etc. etc. I think our parents did a great job. I have been blessed, he has gotten into trouble again and again. So how do you trace our different behavior to our parents?
I understand what you are trying to say. But its misguided. Effective parenting might mean different things even for siblings. Parents intuitively know this. My dad is calm with my sister because thats what she responds to, and he shouts at me, because that’s what I respond to. But we were both disciplined. These things you describe are very general, and we can never know the intricacies of the situation within the general. You responded to your parents great job, something didn’t quite click with your brother.

I’m not saying you are your parents’ “parenting”. But you are a product of it.
 
I quite frankly am very sorry I even started this thread.
:hug1: I’m sorry you’ve been getting some harsh feedback. 😦

NewsTheMan, yes, I was a bit glib with my simplistic “free will” reply. Of course parenting is of monumental importance and influence in a child’s life. No parent in their right mind denies that (especially here at CAF!). But even the best parenting does not somehow completely immunize a child from the possibility of ever sinning or ever making a mistake, even big ones. My kids are still young, but even at 3 years old, my DD definitely has a mind of her own. I can’t bend her to my will.

Locke is wrong. We are not a tabula rasa shaped solely by our experiences. That is readily apparent when one has children (which Locke, by the way, did not have ;)).

Maybe it takes having kids to really understand. 🤷
 
I am really sorry, but in my opinion you are over reacting. This thread is filled with white knights telling you what you want to hear and being absolute moral heroes. Give me a break. Every situation is different, every person is different. Nobody has the right to say “any man who cant accept sexual past is X Y and Z”.

I do feel for you, really, I do. But I agree with Nec5, and on my own I have certain views that may not sit pretty with you but that is life - and sometimes being a knight in shining armour telling you you are a sunflower doesn’t do good. It’s great that you are here saying you’ve done this and that, suffering etc - but I am sure your daughter has a different story to tell, and my advice then, is instead of trying to get a bunch of strangers to agree with you you speak to your daughter and go deep into your relationship.

What I find most interesting in your post is that you were perfectly happy speaking off-topic until now. Six pages in I don’t see my advice as particularly necessary or helpful, especially considering how divergent the thread has become.
I guess you missed my post back on page 4? But your advice as a young man and single would be very, very helpful. Offering parenting advice, when you have not had that experience, is not helpful at all. The OP certainly wasn’t looking for people to just agree with her, but I’m sure she wasn’t looking for people that have never had the experience of being a parent of a child that is in trouble to condemn her parenting skills either.
 
It is within the context of LIFE that we HAVE choice. And at the ages of 0-18 (mostly) our life is almost entirely our HOME.
That was true when I was a kid, and was probably true when you were a kid, but today’s kids spend the majority of their waking hours surrounded by their peers of the same age, and have very little contact with adults at all.

They’re on the school bus for an hour in the morning, and an hour in the evening, or at night; they’re in school for eight to ten hours, not just doing school-work, but also doing their school-mandated choir, band, drama, or sporting activity, and then, when they get home, they take a dinner plate upstairs and are locked in their rooms by themselves to do homework, play video games, connect with friends on FaceBook, and surf the Internet until bed time.

If they see their parents for more than 45 minutes a day, they’re probably being home-schooled - which isn’t really an option for most parents, especially in today’s economy.
 
I am really sorry, but in my opinion you are over reacting.
I would encourage you to try to really place yourself in the OP’s shoes. This is not some intellectual exercise; this is her life. There is a place for reasoned, dispassionate discussion on the subject of parenting and a parent’s role in the life of a child. A thread where someone in pain is seeking pastoral advice is not such a place.
 
Also, I want to add this.

Why are some of you so insistent that there has been an irredeemable failure? I have not said it. Parents fail in different areas. I said I got that. But its not the end all. It’s not a thing to get wildly emotional about.

The same people that would criticise me for not accepting your daughters past (not that I ever said such a thing) are the first ones to tell someone to “run” if their husband/boyfriend has a history of abuse/violence/drugs, but as soon as something like this comes up people invoke their sense of forgiveness and God’s love and how anybody who thinks otherwise is evil and rejecting God’s forgivenss etc.

Its crazy that I can be hated for (hypothetically) saying “sorry, I can’t accept your sexual past” but applauded for “sorry, I can’t accept your violent past”. The fact is that its never really that simple. I am a stranger on the internet and actually to be honest, I wouldn’t be able to accept it. Why? because I have no connection, and no need to connect. The way some speak its as if we are forcibly made to connect and love everybody and want to marry everybody and live a sunflower happy life. The point is that for the right person - and this goes for anything - history doesn’t and won’t matter. That’s why people with all sorts of pasts do find each other. So if I said, I can’t accept it, the reaction should be - well so what. That doesn’t make me bad, evil or judgemental. I am no more so than anybody else. It makes me particular - just like 99% of people are when choosing whether or not to marry someone.
 
I guess you missed my post back on page 4? But your advice as a young man and single would be very, very helpful. Offering parenting advice, when you have not had that experience, is not helpful at all. The OP certainly wasn’t looking for people to just agree with her, but I’m sure she wasn’t looking for people that have never had the experience of being a parent of a child that is in trouble to condemn her parenting skills either.
So its now an exclusive club? Come on, surely you aren’t using that line? That’s the same one that cafeteria catholics use when they disagree with contraception teachings. “Well, they have no experience in that area what do they know”. And if you read carefully, I’m not condemning her skills.
That was true when I was a kid, and was probably true when you were a kid, but today’s kids spend the majority of their waking hours surrounded by their peers of the same age, and have very little contact with adults at all.
They’re on the school bus for an hour in the morning, and an hour in the evening, or at night; they’re in school for eight to ten hours, not just doing school-work, but also doing their school-mandated choir, band, drama, or sporting activity, and then, when they get home, they take a dinner plate upstairs and are locked in their rooms by themselves to do homework, play video games, connect with friends on FaceBook, and surf the Internet until bed time.
If they see their parents for more than 45 minutes a day, they’re probably being home-schooled - which isn’t really an option for most parents, especially in today’s economy.
Sure… but not really either. 45 minutes a day? Probably a lot more. But if you want to say this then you need to almost completely remove the role of the parent - not so? If in reality its 45 minutes then yeah parents have absolutely no influence! Then hey we might as well not mind if we are good parents or not right. I don’t mean to be sarcastic but I think you are being disingenuous.
I would encourage you to try to really place yourself in the OP’s shoes. This is not some intellectual exercise; this is her life. There is a place for reasoned, dispassionate discussion on the subject of parenting and a parent’s role in the life of a child. A thread where someone in pain is seeking pastoral advice is not such a place.
Why should it be free from intellectual talk? In any case in my OP I didn’t actually speak about the OP. Sometimes the best way to get over pain is to intellectualise it and rationalise it. Sometimes it brings more pain, but eventually it helps to think it through. At least, that works for me - or will I get chastised for that too?

LASTLY - not once did I tell OP she has failed outright and deserves to be in pain. Not once.

I’m sorry, but OP recognizes that its a failure on her part, that’s why she is here. To say otherwise is hypocritical - because face it parents of CAF, you wouldn’t want to be in OP’s shoes. As much as you sympathise you are all glad that in some respect you cannot fully empathize. And I am the bad person? It boggles the mind.
 
I am really sorry, but in my opinion you are over reacting. This thread is filled with white knights telling you what you want to hear and being absolute moral heroes. Give me a break. Every situation is different, every person is different. Nobody has the right to say “any man who cant accept sexual past is X Y and Z”.

I do feel for you, really, I do. But I agree with Nec5, and on my own I have certain views that may not sit pretty with you but that is life - and sometimes being a knight in shining armour telling you you are a sunflower doesn’t do good. It’s great that you are here saying you’ve done this and that, suffering etc - but I am sure your daughter has a different story to tell, and my advice then, is instead of trying to get a bunch of strangers to agree with you you speak to your daughter and go deep into your relationship.
News, I didn’t ask anyone for any references or citations as to their expertise until Nec decided to start quoting Freud and rendered opinions on why this occurred. No one asked “Oh, gosh, WHY did this happen?” It doesn’t really matter. The eggs have been scrambled; there’s no putting them back in the shell. Given that “why” isn’t even germane to the conversation, I found it asinine that Nec took time delving into how parenting skills or a lack thereof may be responsible. Certainly he’s entitled to his opinion (as are you). But, be honest about it being just that: An opinion. Attempting to frame it an academically authoratative way without the clout to back it up is a bit foolish, no?

Academics aside, the fact neither of you has raised a child speaks for itself. I’ll let that stand on its own.

As for the knights in shining armor telling me what I want to hear…please, do tell, what is it I ‘want’ to hear? And the “bunch of strangers” you refer to; just exactly what are we all agreeing on? My original question asked how best to advise my daughter on a situation close to her heart. It had nothing to do with me or my parenting skills.

I remember when I was in college and thought I knew everything too. Boy, those were the days.
 
Sure… but not really either. 45 minutes a day? Probably a lot more.
In a different room of the same house, sure. Sleeping for eight hours in the same house, sure.

But this incident did not take place at home, with the parents in another room. (I hope!)

It most likely took place on school grounds, or at some point between home and school. Perhaps she unwisely accepted a ride from an older boy, and was driven somewhere. I would bet that she didn’t get home any later than she would have, if she had taken the bus and avoided the whole situation.

Why were her parents not there, protecting her? Answer: Parents can’t follow their kids around everywhere. You can tell and tell a kid about chastity, but kids will do what other kids pressure them to do, when there aren’t any parents or other adults around.
 
News, I didn’t ask anyone for any references or citations as to their expertise until Nec decided to start quoting Freud and rendered opinions on why this occurred. No one asked “Oh, gosh, WHY did this happen?” It doesn’t really matter. The eggs have been scrambled; there’s no putting them back in the shell. Given that “why” isn’t even germane to the conversation, I found it asinine that Nec took time delving into how parenting skills or a lack thereof may be responsible. Certainly he’s entitled to his opinion (as are you). But, be honest about it being just that: An opinion. Attempting to frame it an academically authoratative way without the clout to back it up is a bit foolish, no?

Academics aside, the fact neither of you has raised a child speaks for itself. I’ll let that stand on its own.

As for the knights in shining armor telling me what I want to hear…please, do tell, what is it I ‘want’ to hear? And the “bunch of strangers” you refer to; just exactly what are we all agreeing on? My original question asked how best to advise my daughter on a situation close to her heart. It had nothing to do with me or my parenting skills.

I remember when I was in college and thought I knew everything too. Boy, those were the days.
Ok I understand - but I was speaking with Nec and those who were speaking with him. Sorry your thread was derailed in that way, but it looked as if the conversation was going that way so I joined in.

I never attempted to frame my opinion as anything more.

I didn’t say I knew everything either. What is it - am I speaking as if I know everything or speaking with an opinion? It’s the latter, as you recognized, so there’s no need to talk down to me. Clearly neither of us know everything about parenting.
 
Nec5 - I didn’t want to join in but I see you are under attack. I am on your “side” buddy…

For example, I made “mistakes” too. But I never made the sexual mistakes, just the alcohol ones. Why? Well, I am not sure but I know it has to do with my parents. Conversely, my best friend has no alcohol related mistakes, but has a variety of sexual ones. Why? Again, he knows its parent related. At one point or another, at one time, I agree that we cannot trace our behaviour entirely to our parents (though, I believe in actual fact, we can) because then we’d probably go into some infinite series regressing until Adam and Eve. But at the age of childhood (0-18) I think parents play a monumental role…
You aren’t saying that your choice in favor of drunkenness is something to be laid at your parents feet, are you? Are you ten years old? Let us hope not. If you have reached the age of reason, grow up. Who are you to sit in judgment of your parents? I am assuming of course, that they did not give you permission to get drunk and that they did not furnish you with the alcohol. If you were forbidden, you were disobedient. Shall you give yourself permission to blame your disobedience on their choice to trust you too much? You can make excuses for yourself or you can be truly contrite. You cannot have both. Which have you chosen? If you have chosen contrition, then renounce the temptation to blame others for your sin. Let God judge your parents. May He never find you sitting in judgement of them. Honor your parents, rather, take responsibility for your own sins, and it will be pleasing to God, as I know you strive to be.

No one here has argued that pre-marital sex was not a grievous sin in anyone! The idea of the thread is to give comfort to a young woman who is repentant and fears that her sin will always be held against her, that she has ruined her chances that a man after the Lord’s heart would have her. Let me tell you, no good confessor would tell a woman who has turned from this sin that she is damaged goods who should not hope that a good man will ever want her. None would give the penitent permission to blame someone else, though, either! Any desire to torment or look down upon repentant sinners who have received absolution is from the devil! Renounce that desire!

If you have never committed a mortal sin, I hope you have given thanks, for it is only grace that keeps any of us from sin. If you believe you have no righteousness to call your own, how can you write as you do? Remember that in the Gospel, last Sunday, Luke pointed out that in the parable of the Pharisee and the tax collector “Jesus addressed this parable to those who were convinced of their own righteousness.” Rethink what you’ve been writing, lest you fall. If you are intent on virtue, the evil one will target you with the temptation to pride.

*The tax collectors and sinners were all drawing near to listen to him, but the Pharisees and scribes began to complain, saying, “This man welcomes sinners and eats with them.”

So to them he addressed this parable.
“What man among you having a hundred sheep and losing one of them would not leave the ninety-nine in the desert and go after the lost one until he finds it? And when he does find it, he sets it on his shoulders with great joy and, upon his arrival home, he calls together his friends and neighbors and says to them, ‘Rejoice with me because I have found my lost sheep.’ I tell you, in just the same way there will be more joy in heaven over one sinner who repents than over ninety-nine righteous people who have no need of repentance*.” Luke 15:7

Yes, that is right. There is more joy in heaven over ONE returned sinner than there is over ninety-nine who can claim to have never strayed. Ninety-nine to one…those are not proportions intended to inflate the ones who never fall, are they? Yet you have fallen, and you seem to still be inflated? How can this be?

But you are fond of St. Josemaria Escriva. Listen to him, then:
  1. "That critical spirit - granted you mean well - should never be directed toward your apostolate in which you work nor towards your bothers. In your supernatural undertakings that critical spirit - forgive me for saying it - can do a lot of harm. For when you get involved in judging the work of others, you are not doing anything constructive. Really you have no right to judge, even if you have the highest possible motives, as I admit. And with your negative attitude you hold up the progress of others.
    “Then” you ask worriedly "my critical spirit, which is the keynote of my character? Listen. I’ll set your mind at east. Take pen and paper. Write down simple and confidently- yes briefly - what is worrying you. Give the note to your superior, and dont think any more about it.
  2. “He is in charge and has he grace of state. He will file the note…or will throw it in the waste basket, And since your criticism is not gossip and you do it for the higherst motives, it is all the same to you.”
“Man, Listen! even though you may be like a child - and you really are one in the eyes of God - be a little less naive: don’t put your brothers “on the spot” before strangers.”

–quotes from the book THE WAY by St. Josemaria Escriva

Admonish sinners, that is a good work, but never forget compassion, lest you expose yourself to judgment, OK?
 
I didn’t say I knew everything either. What is it - am I speaking as if I know everything or speaking with an opinion? It’s the latter, as you recognized, so there’s no need to talk down to me. Clearly neither of us know everything about parenting.
Speaking down to you? Goodness. That shoe is rather tight when it’s on the other foot, isn’t it?
 
God was certainly what anyone would term a perfect parent - and look what happened to his kids!
 
I’m sorry, but OP recognizes that its a failure on her part, that’s why she is here. To say otherwise is hypocritical - because face it parents of CAF, you wouldn’t want to be in OP’s shoes. As much as you sympathise you are all glad that in some respect you cannot fully empathize. And I am the bad person? It boggles the mind.
No, you misread her first post (boldface mine):
CAF friends: I’ve had other threads on my daughter and her behavior. By the grace of God, she appears to be turning a corner. **She has failed a couple of times where boys are concerned and regrets this. She asked me the other day how she will deal with this fact when she meets a “good guy who maybe wants to marry me.” **She was 14 when she lost her virginity. Admittedly, a tough pill for many men to swallow. I’ve told her to give it to God, pray to Our Lady and it would take care of itself at the proper time.
I still feel like I failed her in terms of a correct answer. While I didn’t tell her this, my own thought is, a man of 30 might better understand, but I question how much any decent man in his late teens/early twenties might accept it (assuming she might meet marriage-appropriate men in college). **Any thoughts or advice? **
She is not here chasing a horse that is gone from the barn. Presumably, if her parenting needs adjustment on that front, she’s made those adjustments. At any rate, she’s not asking about that. She here because she wants help in how to encourage a repentant daughter who fears that her sin will always be held against her.

As for empathy, Our Father in Heaven is in the OP’s shoes. Is that good enough company for you? Perhaps you want to argue that there would probably have been no Prodigal Son, if that poor young man’s father hadn’t raised him to be so shallow, self-centered, and prone to drunkeness and sexual excess? I think the Lord’s story shows that he would beg to differ with you.
 
EasterJoy - you are taking posts out of context and without thinking about what I was actually saying. Your posts are ignoring a whole bunch of things I said, and taking things I said where they were never meant to go. I read the OP. I stick by what I said.
 
I didn’t plan on posting in this thread again… But I think the needs to be said:

Mothers are not God. Mother are not even gods. Mothers are human being. Fathers are in the same boat as mothers. You cannot find perfection, with is reserved for God alone in either mothers or fathers, or even both of them together.

God made you and I, we are sinful despite that. God is with us everyday, and we are sinful despite that. We go to mass, we take part in the sacraments, we receive grace, do penance, we are sinful despite that. Only when we have passed through this vale of tears and are reborn with Him in heaven will that change.

If God’s being with us in this world cannot make us free of sin in this world, what hope do two human being have of making their child sin-free? We are weak, small, and loathsome compared to Him. It is foolish to look for perfection in any human being.

An effective parent knows what is going on in their child’s head. Mothers of young school aged children are very effective at parenting. They spend all day with the little one, talk to him, and play with him. But as children grow, something happens. Children talk to their parents less, and to their peers more, parents begin to no longer know every thought that enters their child’s head anymore. The child’s thoughts go from being concentrated almost exclusively on things that are easier to understand and predict, like the here-and-now and thinking about their own well-being and happiness, to more abstract concepts. If a child isn’t willing to communicate with their parents, for whatever real or imagined reason, there’s not much a parent can do beyond take their best guess, and that’s not fail-proof.
 
I understand what you are trying to say. But its misguided. Effective parenting might mean different things even for siblings. Parents intuitively know this. My dad is calm with my sister because thats what she responds to, and he shouts at me, because that’s what I respond to. But we were both disciplined. These things you describe are very general, and we can never know the intricacies of the situation within the general. You responded to your parents great job, something didn’t quite click with your brother.

I’m not saying you are your parents’ “parenting”. But you are a product of it.
His severe bipolar syndrome has nothing to do with it, just his parents? Every parent knows that different kids need treated different ways. But to say that any person’s behavior can be traced to the parenting he received is absurd, in the extreme.

Kids have free will, they do things they are not supposed to do. My parents had strict rules against us drinking in high school, I ignored them more than once. Got caught once or twice, ignored them again after the consequences. Looking back, I don’t know how my parents could have done anything differently with respect to my beer drinking.
 
But to say that any person’s behavior can be traced to the parenting he received is absurd, in the extreme.
I feel the opposite way. You are overplaying what I meant anyway, just like EasterJoy did. Parenting =/= exact behaviour in all and every action.

But if you honestly believe that if you had, say, my parents you’d be the same person acting in the same way then… well I have lost hope in humanity.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top