Question on daughter's lost virginity

  • Thread starter Thread starter Irish_Girl_68
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
EasterJoy - you are taking posts out of context and without thinking about what I was actually saying. Your posts are ignoring a whole bunch of things I said, and taking things I said where they were never meant to go. I read the OP. I stick by what I said.
You did not answer her question, so I will repeat it:

You said you had issues with alcohol. What did your parents do to cause this? Or what is your reasoning for your issue that negates the ā€œwhole bunch of thingsā€ you said that tie parenting to a child’s action? (in a very direct sense)
 
I didn’t plan on posting in this thread again… But I think the needs to be said:

Mothers are not God. Mother are not even gods. Mothers are human being. Fathers are in the same boat as mothers. You cannot find perfection, with is reserved for God alone in either mothers or fathers, or even both of them together.

God made you and I, we are sinful despite that. God is with us everyday, and we are sinful despite that. We go to mass, we take part in the sacraments, we receive grace, do penance, we are sinful despite that. Only when we have passed through this vale of tears and are reborn with Him in heaven will that change.

If God’s being with us in this world cannot make us free of sin in this world, what hope do two human being have of making their child sin-free? We are weak, small, and loathsome compared to Him. It is foolish to look for perfection in any human being.

An effective parent knows what is going on in their child’s head. Mothers of young school aged children are very effective at parenting. They spend all day with the little one, talk to him, and play with him. But as children grow, something happens. Children talk to their parents less, and to their peers more, parents begin to no longer know every thought that enters their child’s head anymore. The child’s thoughts go from being concentrated almost exclusively on things that are easier to understand and predict, like the here-and-now and thinking about their own well-being and happiness, to more abstract concepts. If a child isn’t willing to communicate with their parents, for whatever real or imagined reason, there’s not much a parent can do beyond take their best guess, and that’s not fail-proof.
Great post. So true. We parents can kill ourselves wondering what we did or didn’t do to cause our children to choose to sin, but there is that element in all of us that is FREE to choose sin at any time, no matter what our parents do or say, don’t do, or don’t say. Again, Adam and Eve had no reason to sin, did they? But Eve listened to the serpent. Every one of us can listen to that serpent and it’s no different with our kids. Except today the serpent is everywhere, and he is relentless. He chases our kids through the media, through their friends, through even the schools we send them to.

God wants us to FREELY CHOOSE HIM, and sometimes that point only comes through sin and repentance. Maybe even most of the time. The parent wants to prevent all pain in the child’s life, that’s just normal. But no parent is perfect and mistakes happen, and each child has his or her own free will to sin.

We all do the best we can and we stay on our knees.
 
I feel the opposite way. You are overplaying what I meant anyway, just like EasterJoy did. Parenting =/= exact behaviour in all and every action.

But if you honestly believe that if you had, say, my parents you’d be the same person acting in the same way then… well I have lost hope in humanity.
You sad that you believed we can trace our actual behavior entirely to our parents. Your words, not mine. I was responding to that, it is an absurd statement.

What is funny is that you also said this:

ā€œBut I never made the sexual mistakes, just the alcohol ones. Why? Well, I am not sure but I know it has to do with my parentsā€

So you know your sins were due to your parents, but you have know idea what they did wrong, even though it concerns yourself. It must be hopeless to be a good parent, if everything our kids do is traced to us, but not even the kid can figure out how, even after the fact.
 
EasterJoy - you are taking posts out of context and without thinking about what I was actually saying. Your posts are ignoring a whole bunch of things I said, and taking things I said where they were never meant to go. I read the OP. I stick by what I said.
You said a lot of things. I will boil down the impression given:

OP: My daughter lost her virginity and worries how she will tell the man she hopes to marry. What might I say to her?

Chorus: God will forgive, if she is contrite. Assuming that she goes on to develop the habits of virtue necessary for marriage, and so will a good man.

Nec5: I didn’t have the problem your daughter has. I don’t know why people are dancing around something so obvious, but you do realize that kids with truly good parents are far less likely to have to face this problem, don’t you?

Chorus: That comment is insensitive, unfair, and doesn’t help. You cannot possibly be a parent. Who made you an expert?

**Nec5 **: Unfair? QUOTE: "…The people who accuse me of arrogance are the same ones who refuse to embrace their own responsibility as parents.

I don’t buy the ā€œgood parents often have bad kidsā€ argument. That’s a cop out. The ā€œgoodā€ parents were not ā€œgoodā€ at all. They may have been nice, but not effective parents.

This is the problem with parenting today. Most parents I know, of all ilks, really have no clue what their kids are doing. If someone like me suggests that they not let their kid do social things without knowledge beforehand, I’m called abusive,oppressive, or controlling. Then their kids end up pregnant or in trouble…"

Chorus: OK, now you’ve really gone over the top. You are out in left field, Nec5. Cut it out.

NewsTheMan: Why jump on him? Most truly good parents don’t have this problem! Look at me. If my parents had done a better job, the chances are much better that I wouldn’t have abused alcohol. The same with my friend who had sex outside of marriage. Besides, why jump all over us for having an intellectual discussion about the importance of good parenting?

Chorus: Again–insensitive, unfair, doesn’t help.

NewsTheMan: What? Why are you assuming my posts had anything to do with the OP? Let’s face it: People who are faithful parents will be successful parents. That is the way it works.

Me: Tell that to God the Father, I’m sure he’ll be happy to have you give him pointers.

We assume you think your comments apply to the OPs case because you are posting on the OPs thread! Stick to the topic and be charitable while you’re at it, if you don’t mind.

…

IOW, if you have something to say to the OP that might help her current situation, and you can do it in a sensitive manner, then by all means post it.

If you’re going to post broad criticisms on the general state of parenting and the degree to which your sins and the sins of your young peers might be laid at the feet of your parents, then please post somewhere else. Better yet, think twice, and just don’t post something like that. Considering that you have not posted a word of thanks to your parents for raising you as well as they did–oh, excuse me, you said, ā€œIt is hard to be a parent I am sure. But it is also hard to be a child.ā€, I’m sure your mom would find that touching–that would be the safest route, IMHO.

At any rate, I think the OP has her answer and you and Nec5 will either get the point of ā€œthe chorusā€, or you won’t. Do what you will with it.

I would still like you to ask yourself if you could look your parents in the eye and say, ā€œMom, Dad, my drunkenness is your fault. I am a failure because you failed me.ā€
 
The people who accuse me of arrogance are the same ones who refuse to embrace their own responsibility as parents.
You have never met a single poster on this board, have you? Yet you are going to stand before the throne of Heaven and pronounce that you know for a fact that all posters who believe you are exhibiting a profound lack of humility therefore ā€œrefuse to embrace their own responsibility as parentsā€.

It isn’t enough to say we are wrong in our opinion. You have judged us on works you had not seen and cannot know. How can that not be arrogant?

You don’t even know how many of us are parents. On top of that, for all you know, one of us has nine virginal daughters in the convent.
 
I know many families who have done everything right. Sound marriage, great faith, involved in their church and community. I mean, they are the textbook good family. No hidden issues, no reason for any of the kids to do anything rotten.

And yet, one or more of their kids has gone astray. Could be drugs, alcohol, getting pregnant, running away, whatever. The parents are broken-hearted, and question everything they ever did, yet they still have one or more kids who haven’t gone astray, so that is comforting, yet still confusing. Why did it ā€œtakeā€ with those kids, and it didn’t stick with the ones who strayed? Was the father of the Prodigal a bad father? Certainly not by his response to the prodigal’s return. He was fair to both of his sons, yet the one son took his inheritance and squandered it.

People who haven’t been there can’t judge. And it’s not all the parents’ fault. Do we take credit for everything they do right? We shouldn’t. And do we deserve condemnation for everything they do wrong? No.
 
Well, I don’t know about the rest of you. But I KNOW I was a much better parent before I had kids.šŸ˜‰

Now adays I just keep a ā€œtherapy jar.ā€ Everytime something happens that just makes your eyes pop out of your head I ad a few coins to the therapy jar. I figure I won’t send my kids out totally unprepared…

Ok, in all seriousness. Sure, parents screw up. It happens. Who is the best parent out there? Who knows? It may or may not be the parent of the kids that turned out ok. You hear of people that were horrifyingly abused. One kid turns to drugs and sex. The other decides to do the exact opposite. CEO of the next fortune 500. Church Going, loving father of 5 who makes time for soccer games.

You can even go so far to blame your parents for all your failings. They had a little somethin’ somethin’ to do with it. But there comes a point in your life you have to stand up and be a man or a woman all on your own. No one is looking at your parents now. Now is the time to take charge, and quit handing off your failings to someone else…

Now, we see here a young girl. 14. She blew it. We don’t know the exact circumstances. But what we do know. She’s 14, and she’s looking to take responsiblity NOW! Owning your mistakes at a young age has its own maturing qualities. AND… OMG! She turned to her mother. That means her mother has shown her daughter that even though she makes mistakes, she can still come home! And she can still trust her mother not to berate her her wrong doings… something she seems clearly aware of.

Mom… please don’t beat yourself up. I’m sure you did everything in your power to guide your daughter. And honestly, the fact that she has turned to you for help SCREAMS volumes. She made a mistake. She’s OWNING the mistake, and she recognizes you as someone who still might know a thing or two to teach her…

I think you’ve already guided her quite well. And I think as you continue to show her she is worth waiting for, she will fully realize that as well. Personally, I would warn her that there may be other men in her future that she thinks she can trust her heart with. And when she reveals this mistake, he may prove to her… he’s not the one. I think some men here have shown quite well that unforgiving men are a reality. But they aren’t the ONLY one’s out there. Nor should they be considered the only decent men left. It could turn into gut wrenching situation. So she needs to continue to learn that she is STILL valuable. And can still be a fantastic mother and wife. And she has a different experience that will help guide her in her parenting.

Wishing you the best in assisting her to a place of peace.
 
So its now an exclusive club? Come on, surely you aren’t using that line? That’s the same one that cafeteria catholics use when they disagree with contraception teachings. ā€œWell, they have no experience in that area what do they knowā€. And if you read carefully, I’m not condemning her skills.

Sure… but not really either. 45 minutes a day? Probably a lot more. But if you want to say this then you need to almost completely remove the role of the parent - not so? If in reality its 45 minutes then yeah parents have absolutely no influence! Then hey we might as well not mind if we are good parents or not right. I don’t mean to be sarcastic but I think you are being disingenuous.

Why should it be free from intellectual talk? In any case in my OP I didn’t actually speak about the OP. Sometimes the best way to get over pain is to intellectualise it and rationalise it. Sometimes it brings more pain, but eventually it helps to think it through. At least, that works for me - or will I get chastised for that too?

LASTLY - not once did I tell OP she has failed outright and deserves to be in pain. Not once.

I’m sorry, but OP recognizes that its a failure on her part, that’s why she is here. To say otherwise is hypocritical - because face it parents of CAF, you wouldn’t want to be in OP’s shoes. As much as you sympathise you are all glad that in some respect you cannot fully empathize. And I am the bad person? It boggles the mind.
It is like an exclusive club in a way. Guess what, when you become a father you are automatically enrolled. Its similar to if I went into a thread that a member suffered a miscarriage and I went on and on about how I thought she could have done things different or told her to just get over it when I’ve never experienced the pain and suffering of a miscarriage. Its similar to someone going into a thread and offering advice to someone that just lost their child, and that person responding may not have any children of their own or their children are alive and happy. I don’t respond to the pornography threads because I have no frame of reference or have experienced anybody having that addiction, by the grace of God. What good would any advice be in any thread that is talking about a very personal experience if I have never even seen that experience personally or second hand?

OP, I am not glad you are going through this situation with your daughter. But I am glad you have brought it up here at CAF. It has given me much to think about, whether my daughter will ever find herself in trouble. It will facilitate much discussion with her I am sure no matter what. I hope you are not afraid to post about the situation in the future if you feel the need to talk about it some more here at CAF. I will be praying for you and yours.
 
Now, we see here a young girl. 14. She blew it. We don’t know the exact circumstances. But what we do know. She’s 14, and she’s looking to take responsiblity NOW! Owning your mistakes at a young age has its own maturing qualities. AND… OMG! She turned to her mother. That means her mother has shown her daughter that even though she makes mistakes, she can still come home! And she can still trust her mother not to berate her her wrong doings… something she seems clearly aware of.

Mom… please don’t beat yourself up. I’m sure you did everything in your power to guide your daughter. And honestly, the fact that she has turned to you for help SCREAMS volumes. She made a mistake. She’s OWNING the mistake, and she recognizes you as someone who still might know a thing or two to teach her…

I think you’ve already guided her quite well. And I think as you continue to show her she is worth waiting for, she will fully realize that as well. Personally, I would warn her that there may be other men in her future that she thinks she can trust her heart with. And when she reveals this mistake, he may prove to her… he’s not the one. I think some men here have shown quite well that unforgiving men are a reality. But they aren’t the ONLY one’s out there. Nor should they be considered the only decent men left. It could turn into gut wrenching situation. So she needs to continue to learn that she is STILL valuable. And can still be a fantastic mother and wife. And she has a different experience that will help guide her in her parenting.

Wishing you the best in assisting her to a place of peace.
OP, I just wanted to chime in and say ā€œdittoā€ to all this. Your daughter cannot go back and change the past, but her actions now seem to show contrition and a true desire to live a virtuous life. That’s great. And the fact that she trusts you enough to discuss her thoughts with you now is wonderful.

Continue to reassure her and encourage her in leading a chaste life from this point forward. As this thread shows, there are indeed some unforgiving men out there – but if a man is not able to accept her past, then he is not the man for her. If she is called to the vocation of marriage, God has a man out there for her.

hugs to the both of you
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top