Question on Islam -- round 5

  • Thread starter Thread starter Christos
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
You might consider training for a marathon with the free time you have left over.

I thought I was having a conversation with planten but his last post made me realise I am only providing the subject topic after which his ears turn deaf and he does all the talking. Absolutely hopeless.
 
J C, I did not under-estimate your complaint and I did not ignore it. You should be happy now after advising me.?
 
planten said:
**… Where is the Father? He is not on the Cross. Why is that? Do we understand that Father is also on the Cross? …
But still the catholics preach the verse “I and father are One.” How come?

… **
Click to expand...
Why are you asking questions about Christianity? You should be avoiding bringing up Christianity because if Christianity is some kind of measure to determine the truthfulness of Islam, then Islam is false because Christianity contradicts Islam. The subject of this thread is “Question on Islam – round 5”. As a Muslim, you should be answering questions about Islam instead asking questions about Christianity that have nothing to do with Islam.
 
planten said:
I had rightly complained that some catholics posters being very clever, tried to intentionally send extra-ordinarily long posts. When I tried to reply, the reply became too long and it was rejected by the system. I had the right to complain to the clever Catholic poster about it. And you have no right to avoid / underestimate my complaint.
Click to expand...
This post is both hilarious, sad, and absurd all at the same time. Hilarious because you claim it. Sad because you are making the claim at all. Absurd because you expect anyone to believe this. You destroy any legitimacy you have on this forum when you make such childish accusations which would make moon landing conspiracy nuts seem sane by comparison. It is also an insult to every Catholic on the forum that you would claim such a tactic exists.

The fact is no one is being “clever.” You have shown many times that it is you who avoid complaints by playing strawmen, logical fallacies, and acting like you have no comprehension of how internet posting works. If a post is too long then either quote what you need or post more than one post (as I have in the past). Do not accuse your opponent of some “catholic conspiracy” to keep you from responding. I feel sorry for the Muslims on this forum who otherwise engage Christians on an equal maturity level that they are forced to make posts alongside your own.
 
Hence why I’m amazed anyone enters into debate with him at all.
 
planten said:
**Moreover, black stone is not a man hanging on the cross. Nor is it any animal. Nor is it hanging in every muslims neck. Nor is it reverred as a God. There could be no comparison.

**
Click to expand...
Whuellll…why do all muslims pilgrimage go kissing the stone? Why do they have to fight for their way to the blackstone , forgetting that there are other people only to get the opportunity to kiss that black stone? Why do all of them bow to the blackstone, even all the people of the world? to say that u need the orientation doens’t imply that u need to kiss them. Why?

To say that it’s not hanging on the muslims neck is to be blind to see that the blackstone with the tent has been the symbol of many jihadist, even most of the islamic party in Indonesia use it as their logo.🤷
 
planten said:
**
I do not expect any one to accept my arguments because most of you are biased and prejudiced. …
**
Click to expand...
Everyone is biased and prejudiced to some extent. So … what else is new?
**
I had rightly complained that some catholics posters being very clever, tried to intentionally send extra-ordinarily long posts.
**
Click to expand...
Well, it’s all relative. Maybe it’s not that we’re so clever.
**
When I tried to reply, the reply became too long and it was rejected by the system. I had the right to complain to the clever Catholic poster about it. And you have no right to avoid / underestimate my complaint.
**
Click to expand...
You have no right to complain. You have never answered a single question about Islam/Mohammed. Whenever someone asks you about Islam/Mohammed, you always turn it back with a barrage of questions about Christianity/Jesus/St. Paul that have nothing to do with the thread topic, thus sabotaging the discussion in a ridiculous attempt to defend Islam/Mohammed. “If you can’t stand the heat, get out of the kitchen.”
 
Finally I understand, the problem is those clever Catholic posters. Now why didn’t I come up with that?
 
planten said:
**morning_star, I never said I do not believe in hadith. If I do not believe in hadith then I will not believe in bibleNT too because the bible is far below the standard of our hadith. Bible is a biography of Jesus and much smaller and not reliable. The Hadith is much more reliable.

However, as the bible is man made (not word of God) so the Hadith is also man made (not exact word of God). So I do not indulge too much in man made books.

Please note that Hadith has rules. Not all hadith are to be accepted without checking. But you have no rules or law about bible. Too bad.**
Click to expand...
Ah! So you believe in hadith?glad to know that;).So planten may I know what are these real pure hadiths(that you believe)?And you also deny the death penalty for the fornicators and apostates,that is supported by hadith…And I agree,indeed hadith is much more reliable than bible,so since now when you will be sick please eat/use **black cumin **instead of medicine.because Muhammed said it( black cumin) can heal every disease except death:rolleyes:,well you can drink camel’s urine too:thumbsup:.(So since hadiths are much more reliable so indeed you should follow them even as treatment:p)

Bukhari
Volume 7, Book 71, Number 592:
Code: 
Narrated Abu Huraira:
** I heard Allah’s Apostle saying, “There is healing in black cumin** for all diseases except death.”
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top