Question on Sunday Obligation

  • Thread starter Thread starter BigMichael
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Unfortunately Saturday hours are usually the same (though not always) so that would also not generally be an option. Thank you for your reply though it’s much appreciated.
You are very welcome Michael.

I love food trucks and think you food truckies do a great service. One of Melbournes’s favorite spots is that gathering near Tulla where many wait for arrivals. The icecream truck is great in summers. Its just across from the retired cup winners.

What are you studying?

Have a blessed and merry Christmas.
 
Last edited:
He mentioned Sunday hours but not Saturday hours, which is why I asked him this question.
That’s not correct. In post #2 the Op was asked:
Is Saturday evening anticipation Mass an option or a late Sunday evening near your college?
The Op then directly answered LumineDiei in post #5:
Thank you for your reply. Unfortunately I work on a food truck that regularly goes 2-3 hours out of Melbourne for events so my days usually go from 6.00am-9.00pm at best by the time I get back so I generally can’t get to any masses if I choose to work that day.
You’re question about Saturday mass wasn’t until post# 14, after the Op answered that he cannot attend.
 
I’m currently doing a Bachelor of Arts majoring in Philosophy with one semester left, after that I’ll be doing a Masters of Teaching (Secondary). Merry Christmas to you too.
 
I am 75 yrs old and have fatigue and depression as well as early Parkinsons. When I go to Mass it is an effort and my energy is depleted for the day. If I miss Mass then I go to confession. I stay at home most of the time. If I could go to Mass during the week it would make all the difference. Should I ask a Priest?
 
Yes, please speak to your parish priest. My guess is that due to your illnesses he may grant you a dispensation from the Sunday obligation.
 
Last edited:
God is God on the other six days of the week isn’t He? How many days per week did Jesus attend church? Don’t get me wrong, this is an important aspect of our lives. Going to church can help us build a relationship with God and get our minds centered on what’s right. However, you also need to eat, and God understands that. If you are allowing these missed church days to let yourself slip from the presence of God, then yeah, it’s a sin. However, if you are still keeping with the ritual of building that one on one experience with God, you have to understand that He’s right there at work with you.
No offense, but since you identify yourself as Pentecostal, I don’t think you should be giving advice on a Catholic forum without immediately making it clear that you are not Catholic.
 
Last edited:
I am 75 yrs old and have fatigue and depression as well as early Parkinsons. When I go to Mass it is an effort and my energy is depleted for the day. If I miss Mass then I go to confession. I stay at home most of the time. If I could go to Mass during the week it would make all the difference. Should I ask a Priest?
You can go to mass on any day of the week you are able. It is always beneficial.

Our obligation is to attend Mass on Sundays and holy days. However, if you are ill or infirm and cannot go on a specific Sunday or Sundays or holy day(s)— or if you depend on others for transportation and they cannot take you on Sunday— you are excused from the obligation. No dispensation needed.

Daily mass cannot substitute for the Sunday obligation, but daily mass has its own graces to give when you are able to attend.
 
The difference is that Catholics have an obligation to attend mass on Sunday.
Please respect our beliefs on this site.
 
Last edited:
What does it matter if I’m Catholic, Pentecostal, or any other religion? Aren’t we all striving for the same thing, which is Heaven? Man cannot provide forgiveness of any kind, only God has the ability to do that. Since God is a God of grace and mercy, missing a Sunday because of important obligations doesnt mean you’re going to go to Hell.

What will this man be missing if he misses a service? Don’t confine God to the halls of a church. I believe that all denominations are invited into Heavan provided they do their best. You shouldnt bring up my religious base, although you are probably meaning that I “don’t understand” Catholic practices. On that note I will say, there is only one way to Heaven and that is confessing our sins and that Jesus Christ is Lord of our life. No man can provide penance, only God.

Jesus removed the third party of the High Priest when He died on the cross. Dont get me wrong, I’m not saying you should miss church, I’m merely pointing out that as long as you are upholding the beliefs and standards of a true Christian (not catholic, not pentecostal) you will make it to Heaven.
Christ only established one Church and that was the Catholic Church. He entrusted it with the Deposit of Faith and gave it the authority to teach in matters of faith and morals. All Church teachings are backed by the full authority of God.
He did not found any other Churches.
 
Last edited:
probably meaning that I “don’t understand” Catholic practices
And one of the rules you agreed to when registering on this forum was:

Non-Catholics are welcome to participate but must be respectful of the faith of the Catholics participating on the board.

As @Irishmom2 stated, Catholics are obligated to attend Mass on Sundays. Your views on Church attendance are contrary to what the Catholic Church teaches.
 
Last edited:
What does it matter if I’m Catholic, Pentecostal, or any other religion?
It matters because a Catholic is asking about the Catholic mass obligation, which is a matter of Catholic Church law, which Catholics are bound to follow.

Your answer was not an appropriate response to the specific question being asked, since you are not familiar with Church law nor Catholic’s obligations under the law, exceptions to the law, etc.
Since God is a God of grace and mercy, missing a Sunday because of important obligations doesnt mean you’re going to go to Hell.
No one said anyone was going to hell.
What will this man be missing if he misses a service?
Again, this is a function of your lack of understanding of Catholic theology.

This isn’t a “service” it is the Mass. and what the person will be missing is the fruit of the mass— the Eucharist.

Moreover, when one is able to attend and deliberately fails in their obligation, they have committed an act that is grave matter.
Dont get me wrong, I’m not saying you should miss church, I’m merely pointing out that as long as you are upholding the beliefs and standards of a true Christian (not catholic, not pentecostal) you will make it to Heaven
Not exactly.
 
You don’t get to tell Catholics how they fulfill their obligations. For Catholics, what you are saying is just wrong. You are entitled to believe whatever you want, but to give your opinion when a Catholic asked a question with a right or wrong answer is not helpful. Your feelings are not what matter.
 
Last edited:
What does it matter if I’m Catholic, Pentecostal, or any other religion? Aren’t we all striving for the same thing, which is Heaven?
It matters because this forum is “Catholic Answers”, its purpose is to answer questions about the Catholic faith, and the question being asked in this thread is specifically from a Catholic asking about his Catholic Mass obligation. What some non-Catholic might think or advise is not on point to the thread discussion, and your offering advice without making it clear you’re a non-Catholic is misleading if not outright dishonest. We have a continuing problem on here with non-Catholics giving wrong advice to people seeking a Catholic answer. Please don’t contribute to the problem.
 
Would you please just stop?
If you want to discuss whatever point you are trying to make, you should go start your own opinion thread.
 
Catholic law? What about Biblical law? Scriptural law?
Catholics are obligated to both divine and ecclesial law. This isn’t an either/or proposition. It’s both/and.

You, as a non-Catholic, are not bound by Church law.
the Eucharistic, is that the presence of God for Catholics?
The Eucharist is the body, blood, soul and divinity of Jesus.
For me, going to church is getting close to God in a spiritual way. However, this can be attained at home or anywhere. I do understand Catholicism has rituals and blessings that I do not know about and I am admitting this…
Yes the Catholic understanding of ecclesia is different from yours. Moreover, the Mass is not simply a service and you cannot DIY it at home.
If you believe in God and He is your Savior, you’re going to Heaven…no matter where you go to church.
I reject “once saved always saved” theology. It is not compatible with Christ’s teaching nor Paul’s teaching in his Epistles. It’s not biblical.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top