At the end of the day you can always take a very practical approach to it. I firmly believe that everyone needs a clearly-articulated world view in order to feel rooted and confident.
Does Catholicism offer a world view that allows you to feel rooted and confident? If so, I think you have found some truth here, and are sort of looking for things to disagree with (in other words, protesting too much).
By the way, I’m guilty of this myself. I’m down to the really niggly things that bug me about Catholicism, and those are the things that are keeping me from converting.