Question on what Pope Francis said about air conditioning

  • Thread starter Thread starter ChibiViolet
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Pope Francis would hopefully be comfortable in my house for dinner. 68 degrees year round…If he needs a sweater I would happily provide HH with one.

Pope Francis is not the first elderly person to weigh in on what the thermostat is set at…😃
 
I don’t think he was making an absolute judgment, simply pointing out that businesses try to create demand for things that aren’t always necessary and which may unnecessarily use energy.

For example, my grandparents and parents and their neighbors didn’t have any air conditioning for most of their lives where they lived and they were just fine. I’m guessing this was probably Pope Francis’ experience growing up. Now, everyone in the neighborhood has it and uses it all summer, night and day. What changed? It’s either gotten hotter (global warming?) or a market for it was developed and it has simply become more popular.

I say this as someone who uses air conditioning, but tries to limit it when I can for selfish reasons–ie my electric bill.😊
 
Pope Francis would hopefully be comfortable in my house for dinner. 68 degrees year round…If he needs a sweater I would happily provide HH with one.

Pope Francis is not the first elderly person to weigh in on what the thermostat is set at…😃
“What, you’re hot?” lolol
 
I come from a part of the country that was well behind the rest of it technologically, and am an older person besides. i well remember what it was like without air conditioning.
Well, I’ll admit the banks had AC, but that was about it.

It’s liveable, but a long way from being present. Outside, it’s not bad at all. You get used to it. Inside, it’s tough. I remember how women in offices had a bottle of cologne in their desk drawer with which to wipe their faces and necks. Men had these shoes on which only the toe and heel were leather. The rest of the shoe was woven straw of some kind. Mens’ dress shirts were unbelievably thin, and were sort of silky. And electric fans were ubiquitous, of course. Women wore dresses so light they HAD to wear slips underneath them. And, of course there were the hand-held cardboard fans in church with the funeral home’s name on them.

People sat outside in the evening until their houses cooled off enough to sleep in. This part of the country is classified “subtropical humid” and the “humid” part sure is true…until about mid-July. After that, the heat really isn’t unpleasant because the air is so dry. But it was social too. People walked around in the evening and talked to the people sitting in their yards.

It’s liveable without AC. But I don’t think it’s very efficient. When people are too hot, they don’t function very well, spend too much time fanning themselves, going outside to get some relief, etc. Probably costs the economy more than the cost of AC.
 
***:extrahappy:I bet’cha King David had servants to fan him, when he sat on his throne. ***
 
He seems to identify air-conditioning a one of the factors contributing to environmental degredation. But that is his personal opinion, it is not Catholic moral teaching.

Interpret it for yourself. There was a time when there was no air conditioning, our home never had it until after I left. So people can live without it, but there is no doubt that it makes life more tolerable in harsh climates. In certainly saves lives. One can also argue that it has a positive impact on provided goods and services to the poor who do not have air conditioning. Of course one can give up air conditioning as a means of showing solidarity with the poor, one can even take the dollars saved and contribute to charitable institutions like Peter’s Pence or Aid to the Chuch in need. I would classify this as being a questin of prudential judgment. You don’t have to give up air conditiioning, but you might exercise charity by giving it up and following the suggestions above.

Linus2nd
Agreed.

When I read that passage yesterday I thought “Bet there’ll be at least one air conditioning thread on CAF!” 😃

We can definitely get spoiled on it, and as a menopausal gal, sorry for the TMI, I am in that category. :coolinoff: But there are some days I can deal with the heat better than others. I do know elderly folk who grew up in places such as Mexico and who point out, rightly, that they got along fine without AC.

It would be commendable if we who are privileged to have AC would try to help those in parts of the world where heat is a terrible and dangerous cross people have to bear, such as those parts of India where many died recently. It would also behoove everyone to make sure air conditioners, fans, etc. are energy-efficient and don’t contribute to a lot of waste and disposal problems when they no longer run. :twocents:
 
What constitutes “self-destructive” appearing air-conditioning use? When does air-conditioning become a “harmful habit”?
The Pope is describing the trap of a positive feedback loop.

Demand for energy → more CO2 → warmer climate → need for AC → more need for energy due to AC → even more CO2 → even warmer climate → need for even more AC → …

Basically, you cannot “solve” the global warming issue by installing AC, because AC actually makes global warming worse!
 
It would be commendable if we who are privileged to have AC would try to help those in parts of the world where heat is a terrible and dangerous cross people have to bear
Except that this heat killing people is caused by you running your AC.
 
The Holy Father never lived in AZ or
TX.
AZ and TX will be unpopulated in 100 years. The entire civilization there is based on non-renewable sources of water and energy. Once these run out, game over.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top