Questions and Opinions

  • Thread starter Thread starter NikitaRhea
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
N

NikitaRhea

Guest
I know the title of the new thread is vague at best, but literally I want to ask questions and get opinions from these questions. My first question is: Do you think that parents should enforce or lead their children to a certain vocation? My second question is: How would you make sure you in turn do not do the same thing?

Why I ask this is because I have experienced two types of parents.

One type is leading their children into the vocation of the religious life or priesthood. It is not a bad thing for a child to feel God calling them to become a religious or priest, but to expose them so much to one type of vocation only and never allow them to experience the other vocations. I learn of this type when I heard a women who goes to the same parish as I was saying she wished she never made her son learn how to swing dance because now he might be feeling that the priesthood might not be his calling. She literally explains that she wants all her children to be priests and religious.

The other type is the complete opposite, they are the ones who will pray for vocations into the priesthood and religious life, but add as a Friar I knew would say, “but not my kid”. I met a woman like that this past year, who was very upset the mention of her son might be discerning a vocation into the priesthood. She says, “He will not because I want grandkids”.

I feel that I am in open to whatever my children decide, if they wish to discern into the vocation of marriage, go for it, but if they wish to go into the priesthood and religious life I would go for it. But, I am worried that I might go into one extreme or the other when I do not want that at all. (Even though I do not have children yet)

Thank you for reading my ranting. God bless,
Nikita, OP
 
No, parents should not enforce a vocation they think up for their child. Vocations are handed from God, not from parents. For the same reason, leading is a poor idea, as far as my opinion is asked. And I’m happy that my father has finally quit throwing the seminary on me (for the record, I already have two secular jobs requiring degrees, the fact that I enjoy long coats, already speak Latin and things don’t work out with women is not conclusive). I guess it’s even messier when parents force their children to date so they wouldn’t think about the seminary or the convent.
 
I know the title of the new thread is vague at best, but literally I want to ask questions and get opinions from these questions. My first question is: Do you think that parents should enforce or leadguide their children to a certain vocation?yes! My second question is: How would you make sure you in turn do not do the same thing? Do what same thing?

Why I ask this is because I have experienced two types of parents.

One type is leading their children into the vocation of the religious life or priesthood. It is not a bad thing for a child to feel God calling them to become a religious or priest, but to expose them so much to one type of vocation only and never allow them to experience the other vocations. I learn of this type when I heard a women who goes to the same parish as I was saying she wished she never made her son learn how to swing dance because now he might be feeling that the priesthood might not be his calling. She literally explains that she wants all her children to be priests and religious.What she wants is beside the point. Few become religious and we need more!

The other type is the complete opposite, they are the ones who will pray for vocations into the priesthood and religious life, but add as a Friar I knew would say, “but not my kid”. I met a woman like that this past year, who was very upset the mention of her son might be discerning a vocation into the priesthood. She says, “He will not because I want grandkids”. For most people that means maybe they should have not used ABC so they had more odds for grandkids. 😃

I feel that I am in open to whatever my children decide, if they wish to discern into the vocation of marriage, go for it, but if they wish to go into the priesthood and religious life I would go for it. But, I am worried that I might go into one extreme or the other when I do not want that at all. (Even though I do not have children yet)No need to go to an extreme. Either they will be called or not. Our job is to help them discern the vocation as God wants…

Thank you for reading my ranting. God bless,
Nikita, OP
 
My first question is: Do you think that parents should enforce or lead their children to a certain vocation? My second question is: How would you make sure you in turn do not do the same thing?
The catechism tells parents:

2230 When they become adults, children have the right and duty to choose their profession and state of life. They should assume their new responsibilities within a trusting relationship with their parents, willingly asking and receiving their advice and counsel. Parents should be careful not to exert pressure on their children either in the choice of a profession or in that of a spouse. This necessary restraint does not prevent them - quite the contrary from giving their children judicious advice, particularly when they are planning to start a family.
 
I know the title of the new thread is vague at best, but literally I want to ask questions and get opinions from these questions. My first question is: Do you think that parents should enforce or lead their children to a certain vocation? My second question is: How would you make sure you in turn do not do the same thing?

Why I ask this is because I have experienced two types of parents.

One type is leading their children into the vocation of the religious life or priesthood. It is not a bad thing for a child to feel God calling them to become a religious or priest, but to expose them so much to one type of vocation only and never allow them to experience the other vocations. I learn of this type when I heard a women who goes to the same parish as I was saying she wished she never made her son learn how to swing dance because now he might be feeling that the priesthood might not be his calling. She literally explains that she wants all her children to be priests and religious.

The other type is the complete opposite, they are the ones who will pray for vocations into the priesthood and religious life, but add as a Friar I knew would say, “but not my kid”. I met a woman like that this past year, who was very upset the mention of her son might be discerning a vocation into the priesthood. She says, “He will not because I want grandkids”.

I feel that I am in open to whatever my children decide, if they wish to discern into the vocation of marriage, go for it, but if they wish to go into the priesthood and religious life I would go for it. But, I am worried that I might go into one extreme or the other when I do not want that at all. (Even though I do not have children yet)

Thank you for reading my ranting. God bless,
Nikita, OP
A parent should absolutely never lead/guide/push a child into either vocation. to do so is potentially sinful for the parent and could devastate the child. St alphonsus says that if the vocation chosen is not, in fact, that for which the child was created, the possibility of salvation nears impossibility since the graces God intended to give the person were contained (to a certain extent) within that vocation.

The proper thing to do is to have an open home where marriage and the religious life are equally valued. A vocational call is the only thing the saints have ever said may be licitly kept secret from the parents, in fact it is recommended!

FSC
 
Thank you all for responding to this post, I was hoping to get other views on this and not think it was just me. When the word “guide” is put in the question instead of push or lead, I still do not think you should guide them to one vocation or another, you should expose them to all the types of vocations that are part of the Church. Such as, Single Life (which my friend wishes more people would talk about), Religious Life, Priesthood, and Marriage.
 
Parents should not choose the vocation for their child. Vocation is a calling from God and confirmed by the Church. This is not an opinion - this is Church teaching.
 
Parents should not choose the vocation for their child. Vocation is a calling from God and confirmed by the Church. This is not an opinion - this is Church teaching.
I agree with this as well but it is worth noting that parents should talk of vocations, teach a child to pray to find their vocations and not belittle vocations. I have three daughters and would love if 1 or all of them became nuns, I would also love it if they all got married and had a gaggle of kids. Either way I am going to “guide” them to discern not their wants but God’s will.
 
Hi, and blessings to you!:harp:

I would say: forcing no, but certainly exposing them to the differing kinds of gifts, the uniqueness of each person, and having open discussions as they grow, all these would be fitting.

I might, for instance, mention to my Grand-daughter that each person contributes something special. Her Great- Great Aunt was a full time mother of five. She attended Mass each Sunday and was grateful for the Priest, whose homilies inspired her, and together with everyone, God was present for each person in the Holy Eucharist. In that parish were doctors, lawyers, (both male and female) and sometimes troubled people. God loves them all.

Being open and honest about the choices our children will face will surely help them make their own individual decisions later. :signofcross:

:angel1:The fact that you are concerned about going overboard already shows that you are a thoughtful and caring parent, so you’re sure to do just fine. Unfortunately, it’s the people who have agendas already planned out for their children who don’t realize they are limiting them.

The mother who insists she wants grandchildren, for example, might poison the mind of a young man who longs to be a priest.:highprayer: A dad who pushes a son or daughter into a particular vocation may find his child rebelling later.

There’s always the scripture that points out that all parts of the Body of Christ are interconnected and each one is needed.:harp: The hand cannot say to the foot, “I have no need of you.” So we know, the humbler parts of the Body of Christ are just as beloved as those that are often more celebrated and recognized, a Biblical thought that St. Therese of Lisieux embraced in her “Little Way.” :nun1:
 
I want to honestly say thank you for your wonderful reply. Thank you.
Hi, and blessings to you!:harp:

I would say: forcing no, but certainly exposing them to the differing kinds of gifts, the uniqueness of each person, and having open discussions as they grow, all these would be fitting.

I might, for instance, mention to my Grand-daughter that each person contributes something special. Her Great- Great Aunt was a full time mother of five. She attended Mass each Sunday and was grateful for the Priest, whose homilies inspired her, and together with everyone, God was present for each person in the Holy Eucharist. In that parish were doctors, lawyers, (both male and female) and sometimes troubled people. God loves them all.

Being open and honest about the choices our children will face will surely help them make their own individual decisions later. :signofcross:

:angel1:The fact that you are concerned about going overboard already shows that you are a thoughtful and caring parent, so you’re sure to do just fine. Unfortunately, it’s the people who have agendas already planned out for their children who don’t realize they are limiting them.

The mother who insists she wants grandchildren, for example, might poison the mind of a young man who longs to be a priest.:highprayer: A dad who pushes a son or daughter into a particular vocation may find his child rebelling later.

There’s always the scripture that points out that all parts of the Body of Christ are interconnected and each one is needed.:harp: The hand cannot say to the foot, “I have no need of you.” So we know, the humbler parts of the Body of Christ are just as beloved as those that are often more celebrated and recognized, a Biblical thought that St. Therese of Lisieux embraced in her “Little Way.” :nun1:
 
I agree with this as well but it is worth noting that parents should talk of vocations, teach a child to pray to find their vocations and not belittle vocations. I have three daughters and would love if 1 or all of them became nuns, I would also love it if they all got married and had a gaggle of kids. Either way I am going to “guide” them to discern not their wants but God’s will.
Yes, my fiance and I have discussed this countless times because we want to make sure we are understanding what we feel we are to be as parents to our future children (God willing we have children) and we have both agreed to make the home open to all vocations. Thank you for you reply.
 
Our plan is just to support our kids in whatever vocation they decide upon. One of our daughters, on her own, has spent a good portion of the year saying she wants to be “Marie Therese” and insisting on dressing like this:

(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)

I’d be thrilled if she’s a nun, but I’d also be thrilled if she’s called to another vocation, as long as she’s listening for God’s voice in her life. I do wonder if people think we push her in the direction of a vocation as a nun, since she was insisting on wearing this (and she demanded that all she wanted for her birthday was a “Holy Baby” dress, from the Holy Baby DVD series) but it’s been completely her own initiative.

I would think it would probably be more likely (for the majority of parents) that they’d be discouraging vocations because it isn’t seen as a valid option by many. I haven’t, at least in modern times, actually heard of anyone pushing their children to become religious.
 
I would think it would probably be more likely (for the majority of parents) that they’d be discouraging vocations because it isn’t seen as a valid option by many. I haven’t, at least in modern times, actually heard of anyone pushing their children to become religious.
I would like to say that you have a lovely little girl. I think for me it is the parish that I hear it more, but then again it is because it is a religious order-run parish. Which I do not mind at all, cause I am love my home parish :), but some of the parents there are one or the other that I mention above. But, like I said thank you for expressing your opinions.

God bless,
Ms. Nikita, OP
 
Seminaries and religious orders do not want candidates whose parents never let them consider they may have a vocation to marriage. They want candidates who were felt entirely free to pursue whatever call God asked of them, even if it wasn’t the vocation that Mom or Dad wanted. Think about it: Do you want a doctor who really wishes he could have been a chef or a pastor who believes he’s only a priest because he couldn’t stand to disappoint his mother?

This is what Pius XI had to say in his encyclical *Ad Catholici Sacerdotii *(1935):
"80. But the first and most natural place where the flowers of the sanctuary should almost spontaneously grow and bloom, remains always the truly and deeply Christian family. Most of the saintly bishops and priests whose “praise the Church declares,” owe the beginning of their vocation and their holiness to example and teaching of a father strong in faith and manly virtues, of a pure and devoted mother, and of a family in which the love of God and neighbor, joined with simplicity of life, has reigned supreme. To this ordinary rule of divine Providence exceptions are rare and only serve to prove the rule.

81. In an ideal home the parents, like Tobias and Sara, beg of God a numerous posterity “in which Thy name may be blessed forever,” and receive it as a gift from heaven and a precious trust; they strive to instill into their children from their early years a holy fear of God, and true Christian piety; they foster a tender devotion to Jesus, the Blessed Sacrament and the Immaculate Virgin; they teach respect and veneration for holy places and persons. In such a home the children see in their parents a model of an upright, industrious and pious life; they see their parents holily loving each other in Our Lord, see them approach the Holy Sacraments frequently and not only obey the laws of the Church concerning abstinence and fasting, but also observe the spirit of voluntary Christian mortification; they see them pray at home, gathering around them all the family, that common prayer may rise more acceptably to heaven; they find them compassionate towards the distress of others and see them divide with the poor the much or the little they possess.

82. In such a home it is scarcely possible that, while all seek to copy their parents, example, none of the sons should listen to and accept the invitation of the Divine Master: “Come ye after Me, and I will make you to be fishers of men.” Blessed are those Christian parents who are able to accept without fear the vocations of their sons, and see in them a signal honor for their family and a mark of the special love and providence of Our Lord. Still more blessed, if, as was often the case in ages of greater faith, they make such divine visitations the object of their earnest prayer.

83. Yet it must be confessed with sadness that only too often parents seem to be unable to resign themselves to the priestly or religious vocations of their children. Such parents have no scruple in opposing the divine call with objections of all kinds; they even have recourse to means which can imperil not only the vocation to a more perfect state, but also the very conscience and the eternal salvation of those souls they ought to hold so dear. This happens all too often in the case even of parents who glory in being sincerely Christian and Catholic, especially in the higher and more cultured classes. This is a deplorable abuse, like that unfortunately prevalent in centuries past, of forcing children into the ecclesiastical career without the fitness of a vocation. It hardly does honor to those higher classes of society, which are on the whole so scantily represented in the ranks of the clergy. The lack of vocations in families of the middle and upper classes may be partly explained by the dissipations of modern life, the seductions, which especially in the larger cities, prematurely awaken the passions of youth; the schools in many places which scarcely conduce to the development of vocations. Nevertheless, it must be admitted that such a scarcity reveals a deplorable falling off of faith in the families themselves. Did they indeed look at things in the light of faith, what greater dignity could Christian parents desire for their sons, what ministry more noble, than that which, as We have said, is worthy of the veneration of men and angels? A long and sad experience has shown that a vocation betrayed - the word is not to be thought too strong - is a source of tears not only for the sons but also for the ill-advised parents; and God grant that such tears be not so long delayed as to become eternal tears."
 
I would like to say that you have a lovely little girl. I think for me it is the parish that I hear it more, but then again it is because it is a religious order-run parish. Which I do not mind at all, cause I am love my home parish :), but some of the parents there are one or the other that I mention above. But, like I said thank you for expressing your opinions.

God bless,
Ms. Nikita, OP
Thank you for the compliment :).

We go to an EF Mass with an FSSP priest, so I would think that wouldn’t be that far off. Not that I’m saying I don’t believe it is like that some places. Just that it isn’t in many more (just in my experience from moving around), if that makes sense?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top