Questions for Catholics in mixed/interfaith marriages (seeking support/insight/fellowship)

  • Thread starter Thread starter dilleachta
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

dilleachta

Guest
Hello,

It’s been on my heart that I should seek contact with other Catholics who are married to Protestants or other non-Catholic (or non-Christian) spouses.

I would like to ask some questions about your experiences with certain matters and insight regarding your faith differences in the marriage.

Please let me know if you are open to private messaging about this- I would greatly appreciate it. Otherwise, please feel free to share your experience/insight in general!

Thank you!
 
Hello,

It’s been on my heart that I should seek contact with other Catholics who are married to Protestants or other non-Catholic (or non-Christian) spouses.

I would like to ask some questions about your experiences with certain matters and insight regarding your faith differences in the marriage.

Please let me know if you are open to private messaging about this- I would greatly appreciate it. Otherwise, please feel free to share your experience/insight in general!

Thank you!
Salutations
My parents, God rest their souls, we’re a mixed marriage. My Dad was Methodist Episcopal. Mom Catholic. The Catholic Church was 2 blocks away and being Catholic was easy and a treasure. Dad was allowed to be God parent for one of my nieces because he raised us Catholic. I ended being the cheese that stood alone. I married an Irish Catholic.
He doesn’t go to mass. The scandals did him in.
It’s hard to recall that evil was in the first church w Judas. But that was his destiny. It was our lesson to always look up in worship, not side to side. BUT, it was our lesson w the scandals to be alert with all activities in which we place our children.Nothing, NOTHING in which we place our children is to be a babysitter. We must be involved to know our priests and leaders. The BLT killer was a deacon in his church. Cheerful, aren’t I. Sorry, the things in the world in these last days are horrible. Catholics do not have a monopoly on scandals. We’ve had children molested in Protestant churches around here.
Back to mixed marriages. CHRISTIAN TO Christian should be no problem. Though some churches teach Catholicism is a cult. Now, it can be so bad, the Protestant wouldn’t marry you if you were Catholic,
If we are Christians, it is a few parables or verses that divide us. We have extra Deuterconical books that the Protestants didn’t keep. They didn’t think they were Holy Spirit inspired and we did. I showed a Baptist ministers wife, Wisdom chapter 3, and she used it in her memorial pamphlet when he died. I don’t think he turned over in his grave. He suffered w cancer and it talks of being tested in the fires and were proven to be pure gold…then, more praise for the victory.
Mt grandfather had to convert to marry my grandmother. He hated Catholics after that. His kids all went to Catholic school and mass but he would break rosaries if he found them. I did get a brave priest to visit him in the hospital when he was dying.
I heard from the nurses, there was no fighting or profanity heard. I didn’t live there to recheck w priest.
Jewish mixed can be respectible. First I’d cherish his worship form, as it was Jesus’s. I’d learn to cook Kosher. In Thessalonians, I think, it says,“THE KINGDOM OF GOD IS WITHIN YOU.” THe Jews don’t realize they are ISRAEL. They are looking for a perfect, red Bull as a sign of the Messiah coming. It is a politician who will bring peace between Israel and Palestine. MY PEACE I GIVE YOU, MY PEACE I LEAVE YOU. Israel already has peace, if they accept Jesus as Yeshua Hamishshia.
But each spouse has the right to worship our God in their format. Can’t give percent of conversions, but they do happen.
Satanism and Wiccan, surely no Christian would align themselves with them
Islam is difficult for many reasons, some cultural,i.e. male dominance. If kid’s get too Westernly, a Dad killed his 2 teenage daughters as honor killings.
The Catholic would be asked to convert.
So, it depends on the individuals. My daughter was raised Catholic. When her husband was killed in Iraq in 2007, she became an atheist. If there was a God, He would have saved him.
Point here, 2 people marry, everything aligned as church would want, and life’s circumstances change their hearts. POOF!! Then, pray. best to not be unequally yoked. But return to previous sentence about change w lifes journey. PM ME.
THAT’S ALL I GOT.
in Christ’s love
Tweedlealice
 
Hello,

It’s been on my heart that I should seek contact with other Catholics who are married to Protestants or other non-Catholic (or non-Christian) spouses.

I would like to ask some questions about your experiences with certain matters and insight regarding your faith differences in the marriage.

Please let me know if you are open to private messaging about this- I would greatly appreciate it. Otherwise, please feel free to share your experience/insight in general!

Thank you!
My wife is Jewish… anytime you would like to PM me or ask public questions, please feel free (obviously, I will see PMs faster than public posts).

God Bless
 
I married my spouse, who was partially raised Lutheran and partially nothing, I myself had fallen away from the Catholic church. About 5 years into our marriage I felt called back to the church. There are definitely challenges that we face. You are welcome to ask me questions, either in PM or on the public forums.
 
I’m the non-Catholic in the relationship, so if you ever have questions that you’d like seen from the other point of view, I’m available.
 
Don´t know anything about protestants, but I am married to an Orthodox
which has challenges of its own.
If this is relevant for you, you are welcome to send me a PM.
 
I married my husband when we were both no longer practicing Protestants. I converted to the Catholic church after we were married. He was, at the time, very supportive. He still is, although maybe not as “very” as he used to be. He isn’t opposed to me being Catholic or raising the kids Catholic.

Sometimes he struggles with me needing to attend mass every week. He’s fine with me raising the children Catholic.

Feel free to PM me with specific questions, or I’d probably be happy to answer most in the public forum, might help someone else.
 
Sometimes he struggles with me needing to attend mass every week.
Not to pry, and with apologies anyway, but how about focusing on showing him (showing is usually better than telling) how it doesn’t harm him, doesn’t detract from your time together (especially if that seems to be the issue)? Sending some prayers your way. Notably through ex-Protestant saints. 😉
 
Not to pry, and with apologies anyway, but how about focusing on showing him (showing is usually better than telling) how it doesn’t harm him, doesn’t detract from your time together (especially if that seems to be the issue)? Sending some prayers your way. Notably through ex-Protestant saints. 😉
He works during the week and we have two small children, it does take from our time together. Because our children are young and I am not physically or mentally capable of keeping them both behaving (while pregnant) during mass, they stay with him (our church does not offer nursery).

Besides finding other (paid) childcare during Mass, or recruiting someone else to go with me and help me with the children, and somehow being in two places at once, it does take time from him and he feels put out to have to watch the kids by himself (although I watch them by myself all the time as a SAHM).
 
This is close to my heart… I married a protestant wife and she and her family were against Catholics. Needless to say, virtually every issue important to the church is a struggle to convey the importance. It tough no doubt.
 
The needing to go to mass every week can be very awkward. For example if we are staying over for a weekend it can cause problems when I insist on disappearing for several hours on Sunday to go to mass, especially when it clashes with the host’s plans for that day. We were supposed to be spending the Easter weekend with in laws but have decided to go home Saturday night because they don’t have a local Catholic Church.
 
The needing to go to mass every week can be very awkward. For example if we are staying over for a weekend it can cause problems when I insist on disappearing for several hours on Sunday to go to mass, especially when it clashes with the host’s plans for that day. We were supposed to be spending the Easter weekend with in laws but have decided to go home Saturday night because they don’t have a local Catholic Church.
I can relate to this… when we are visiting my in-laws or if they are visiting us, my wife makes me sneak out of the house to run errands or attend Mass Saturday or Sunday night without letting my in-laws know where I’m going because she fears a conversation.

I go partially along with it, but I tell my wife that if they straight up ask me where I went that I will tell the truth.
 
I am a practicing cradle Catholic and my husband was raised Presbyterian but is now pretty much an atheist. It takes a lot of patience and mutual respect. He has said that he “wishes he could believe”- I pray every day for his conversion. 😃

You’re welcome to PM me!
 
I can relate to this… when we are visiting my in-laws or if they are visiting us, my wife makes me sneak out of the house to run errands or attend Mass Saturday or Sunday night without letting my in-laws know where I’m going because she fears a conversation.

I go partially along with it, but I tell my wife that if they straight up ask me where I went that I will tell the truth.
In my case I don’t hide it but is awkward. My non-Catholic Christian friends and in laws don’t really get why I cant just go to church with them, I seem demanding and judgemental to them for insisting on a Catholic mass as their church isn’t good enough. 😦
 
Hi All, I am Catholic my wife is protestant, we where married 26 yrs ago in the Catholic Church. We respect each others Faith. Her and I have been looking for a “Bible study” for couples that we can do as a evening home study to help us both grow in our faith(s). Each night before sleep (While in bed) I will say a audio Rosary and then do my Compline.(i’m forming to be a novice Oblate of St. Benedict) She will be snuggled up next to me reading a book or social media an she asked one day if there was something out there with a mix of Catholic & protestant faiths that we could together as a couple after I do my night Prayers??
I’m having no luck finding anything…😦 Any help would be great!!
Oh, I did suggest the Rosary together and thats not an option she is open to(Yet, I Pray!!)
With Peace, Prayers and Thanx,
Morty
 
Does a Jewish marriage need to be officiated by an Orthodrox Jewish Rabbi in order for the marriage to be valid according to the Catholic Church?

I have a relative (Catholic) who married a Jewish man in a civil ceremony.

She seems to think that since his first marriage (Jewish) to a Jewish woman was not officiated by an Orthodrox Jewish Rabbi, that marriage is not valid. My relative would like to be married in the Catholic Church.

Hopefully I’m not confusing.
 
Does a Jewish marriage need to be officiated by an Orthodrox Jewish Rabbi in order for the marriage to be valid according to the Catholic Church?

I have a relative (Catholic) who married a Jewish man in a civil ceremony.

She seems to think that since his first marriage (Jewish) to a Jewish woman was not officiated by an Orthodrox Jewish Rabbi, that marriage is not valid. My relative would like to be married in the Catholic Church.

Hopefully I’m not confusing.
Let me first state that I’m flat out guessing, but given as the Church recognizes natural marriages I can’t think of a reason that the Catholic Church would hold a Jewish wedding that wasn’t an Orthodox Jewish wedding to be invalid. Indeed, I’d guess that would make most Jewish weddings world wide invalid.

Additionally, that’s likely a Jewish jurisdictional matter, not a Catholic one. The Catholic church has rules that apply to its own members that can make an otherwise valid marriage invalid, but only because it has such jurisdiction. For example, a baptized Catholic could not marry in a Methodist ceremony without approval from the Catholic Church, and hence (based on my understanding, which may be in error) the wedding would be invalid, but we certainly don’t regard all Methodist marriages as invalid.

I suspect that’s similar to what you are asking here. Maybe Orthodox Jews would regard such a marriage as invalid (I have no idea) but I’m pretty sure the Catholic Church would recognize it, assuming that everything else about it was valid.
 
To the original OP, I"m in a mixed marriage, as a recent post demonstrating one of the difficulties here with that and my frankly making a major stupid error (crisis now passed) demonstrates. You can message me or post, either one, fwiw, even if I’m only to serve as a bad example.
 
Let me first state that I’m flat out guessing, but given as the Church recognizes natural marriages I can’t think of a reason that the Catholic Church would hold a Jewish wedding that wasn’t an Orthodox Jewish wedding to be invalid. Indeed, I’d guess that would make most Jewish weddings world wide invalid.

Additionally, that’s likely a Jewish jurisdictional matter, not a Catholic one. The Catholic church has rules that apply to its own members that can make an otherwise valid marriage invalid, but only because it has such jurisdiction. For example, a baptized Catholic could not marry in a Methodist ceremony without approval from the Catholic Church, and hence (based on my understanding, which may be in error) the wedding would be invalid, but we certainly don’t regard all Methodist marriages as invalid.

I suspect that’s similar to what you are asking here. Maybe Orthodox Jews would regard such a marriage as invalid (I have no idea) but I’m pretty sure the Catholic Church would recognize it, assuming that everything else about it was valid.
Thank you, Yeoman. I thought she was mistaken. I also told her that she should contact her diocese for correct info.
 
Hi All, I am Catholic my wife is protestant, we where married 26 yrs ago in the Catholic Church. We respect each others Faith. Her and I have been looking for a “Bible study” for couples that we can do as a evening home study to help us both grow in our faith(s). Each night before sleep (While in bed) I will say a audio Rosary and then do my Compline.(i’m forming to be a novice Oblate of St. Benedict) She will be snuggled up next to me reading a book or social media an she asked one day if there was something out there with a mix of Catholic & protestant faiths that we could together as a couple after I do my night Prayers??
I’m having no luck finding anything…😦 Any help would be great!!
Oh, I did suggest the Rosary together and thats not an option she is open to(Yet, I Pray!!)
With Peace, Prayers and Thanx,
Morty
What about the Chaplet of Divine Mercy? This version by Trish Short starts with a Catholic Priest praying, then with Pentecostal leading the first decade, a member of the AME Church leading a decade, then Trish Short (Catholic revert) leading the 3rd decade, and then all 3 leading the 4th and 5th decades.

m.youtube.com/watch?v=p5TGfisOKMM

Also, the Compline is almost entirely praying with scripture. Perhaps you could try doing that together?

God Bless!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top