Questions for people who have knowledge on "evolution"...

  • Thread starter Thread starter AmandaB
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

AmandaB

Guest
Ok, so I am currently in school to become a Medical Lab Technician. My current course is Anatomy and Physiology…as you can imagine a lot of questions have come up in my mind!!! As I have been going through all the complex and fascinating body systems and how they work, it has made my belief in God even stronger…THEN the bad part. It seems from physical proof in our bodies that we have evolved. Most likely from an aquatic state. This is of course in contradiction to what we believe as Catholics. How can this be explained??? There is no doubt that we have evolved…from what exactly I can not say, but if it is true that we were aquatic, then that means we evolved from a fish and not Adam and Eve!!! I’m not saying I don’t believe in Adam and Eve by the way!! It’s just that I’m really confused! Anybody with extensive knowledge in this field would really be helpful!!! Thank you so much!
 
One can accept evolution and the Catholic faith. The Church has stated this. As long as you recognize that God is the one behind it it all, and that it has a purpose, it is alright. I’m pretty sure that’s correct. If I’m wrong, well, heck, I just can’t do right anymore it seems.
 
Ok, so I am currently in school to become a Medical Lab Technician. My current course is Anatomy and Physiology…as you can imagine a lot of questions have come up in my mind!!! As I have been going through all the complex and fascinating body systems and how they work, it has made my belief in God even stronger…THEN the bad part.** It seems from physical proof in our bodies that we have evolved. Most likely from an aquatic state.** This is of course in contradiction to what we believe as Catholics. How can this be explained??? There is no doubt that we have evolved…from what exactly I can not say, but if it is true that we were aquatic, then that means we evolved from a fish and not Adam and Eve!!! I’m not saying I don’t believe in Adam and Eve by the way!! It’s just that I’m really confused! Anybody with extensive knowledge in this field would really be helpful!!! Thank you so much!
I would like to see this physical proof! :confused: Evolution implied a “from” and a “to”. If the “from” is defined as “most likely” then you do not have a proof, you have a conjecture.
 
I too don’t see any problems rectifying some form of evolution with the scripture. When God made man did he do an abracadabra and a puff of smoke, or did he use the forces of the universe he created to direct the forming through a complex process that he never could have explained aptly to our early Scripture authors?
 
I too don’t see any problems rectifying some form of evolution with the scripture. When God made man did he do an abracadabra and a puff of smoke, or did he use the forces of the universe he created to direct the forming through a complex process that he never could have explained aptly to our early Scripture authors?
That’s what I believe, BUT in the scripture it clearly states that he made humans like US…so how could Adam and Eve have evolved into some sort of creature (aquatic or not) from which we then evolved??? And have lived through the dinosaurs and all that stuff??? Not to mention our tailbones show that we once had tails…I wouldn’t think Adam and Eve had tails??? If anyone can explain THAT or try to, it would be really helpful!!!
 
I’m NOT an expert, but it seems entirely possible to me that God created the universe and life itself via a process of nature that He created FIRST. In this way, God could indeed have created the stars (light) first, planetary systems next, formed the Earth (and who knows what else) into seas and land masses, induced the first spark of life and engaged it with the influences that becan to change it into may different forms…

The fact that our biology shares much in common does not necessarily refute the idea that God created humanity alone among creatures of the Earth in His image and likeness. Indeed, the “dust” that God used to shape Adam may have been lesser, earlier life forms into which God breathed that specialness that marks us as created in His image and likeness. The fact that Adam may have had a biological father of a lesser species would make him no less a special creation of God. All IMO, of course.

Where people get hung up is in failing to recognize the boundaries. Science cannot ever answer questions of WHO and WHY? Science is a superb servant to humanity in answering questions of WHAT, WHERE, WHEN and HOW? But when people try to give science jurisdiction over WHO and WHY questions, science becomes a tyrranical master. (read Michael Crichton’s summary of the eugenics movement at the end of his novel ‘State of Fear’ for what happens when the ‘scientific method’ is given free reign outside its legitimate jurisdiction.

The correlary, actually, is that it is not the jurisdiction of theology to answer questions of WHAT, WHERE and HOW (aside from cases of explicit revelation and even then one must be careful not to assume too much). Genesis is poetic description of the Who and Why questions of creation. God is rather too smart to give us literal head starts in matters of science and technology when we already tend to develop those areas faster than we mature in their safe use!

God Bless!
 
Ok, so I am currently in school to become a Medical Lab Technician. My current course is Anatomy and Physiology…as you can imagine a lot of questions have come up in my mind!!! As I have been going through all the complex and fascinating body systems and how they work, it has made my belief in God even stronger…THEN the bad part. It seems from physical proof in our bodies that we have evolved. Most likely from an aquatic state. This is of course in contradiction to what we believe as Catholics. How can this be explained??? There is no doubt that we have evolved…from what exactly I can not say, but if it is true that we were aquatic, then that means we evolved from a fish and not Adam and Eve!!! I’m not saying I don’t believe in Adam and Eve by the way!! It’s just that I’m really confused! Anybody with extensive knowledge in this field would really be helpful!!! Thank you so much!
First of all, JPII declared that evolution does not contradict the Bible. The reason being that even if God used evolution and allowed man to evolve from fish eventually that life had a beginning somewhere – at some point we went from no life on earth to life on earth. Then, if you accept evolution, the species evolved and at some later point, when man had sufficiently evolved God imparted the human soul into the bodies that had been prepared by evolution. So, believing in evolution is not a challenge to the faith.

On the other hand, I would recommend you read Michael Behe. He is a molecular biologist who examines some of the systems you will be studying (like the clotting system) and explains a concept of irreducible complexity.

Basically this concept states the following. First, evolution requires that we evolved by taking little tiny step after little tiny step coming from single celled organisms to the complex life forms we see on the planet today. Second, there are incredibly complex systems, and the microscopic level, that complex organisms rely on to survive which had to come into existence in one fell swoop because the individual pieces offer no benefit, and often times offer a detriment, to survival. Therefore, we have systems which could not have evolved and must have been created. Thus, naturalistic evolution is impossible.

Behe makes such a strong case that his arguments are, nearly, single handedly responsible for Anthony Flew going from being one of the most outspoken atheistic philosophers to being an agnostic but affirming that some type of creative force is at work in the universe.

If you have some more specific questions I’ll be happy to answer them. I recommend that first you read Darwin pn Trial and then Darwin’s Little Black Box.
 
That’s what I believe, BUT in the scripture it clearly states that he made humans like US…so how could Adam and Eve have evolved into some sort of creature (aquatic or not) from which we then evolved??? And have lived through the dinosaurs and all that stuff??? Not to mention our tailbones show that we once had tails…I wouldn’t think Adam and Eve had tails??? If anyone can explain THAT or try to, it would be really helpful!!!
Our tailbone proves no such thing. Our tailbone merely indicates that we may have once had a tail. Speciation does not happen until the ancestor cannot reproduce with the descendant. A tail would not create this because there are still people born today with tails who can procreate with other humans that have no tail.

The only thing that would prove we once had a tail is an unbroken fossil record of the evolutionary trail that included beings with tails and this we do not possess.
 
If you have some more specific questions I’ll be happy to answer them. I recommend that first you read Darwin pn Trial and then Darwin’s Little Black Box.
I’m taking you up on that! 😉

I’ve never understood science-(English major in college, working on advanced degree in it) NEVER. I’ve been tempted to buy the books you mentioned, but would it even be worth it if you, and I mean this pretty literally, know nothing about science and am not that interested in it?
 
I’m NOT an expert, but it seems entirely possible to me that God created the universe and life itself via a process of nature that He created FIRST. In this way, God could indeed have created the stars (light) first, planetary systems next, formed the Earth (and who knows what else) into seas and land masses, induced the first spark of life and engaged it with the influences that becan to change it into may different forms…
Even taking natural evolution this far does not explain the Cambrian explosion which evolution is still at a loss to explain.
 
I’m taking you up on that! 😉

I’ve never understood science-(English major in college, working on advanced degree in it) NEVER. I’ve been tempted to buy the books you mentioned, but would it even be worth it if you, and I mean this pretty literally, know nothing about science and am not that interested in it?
The first book, Darwin on Trial, is not a science book at all. It is written by a trial attorney who simply demonstrates that Darwinistic Evolution is not a foregone conclusion and that is it still, or at least should still be, open to debate.

The second book, Darwin’s Black Box, is more scientific. While it does go into scientific explanations of the processes discussed the book, correctly, states itself that it is not important to understand, grasp, or even remember every details of the science – what is important is to understand how incredibly complex the science is and that these processes needed to be created wholesale and not by evolutionary means. Additionally, the book is written on the popular, and not the textbook, level. That being said, if you have trouble understanding stuff in the books feel free to PM me and I’ll help you clear it up.
 
The first book, Darwin on Trial, is not a science book at all. It is written by a trial attorney who simply demonstrates that Darwinistic Evolution is not a foregone conclusion and that is it still, or at least should still be, open to debate.

The second book, Darwin’s Black Box, is more scientific. While it does go into scientific explanations of the processes discussed the book, correctly, states itself that it is not important to understand, grasp, or even remember every details of the science – what is important is to understand how incredibly complex the science is and that these processes needed to be created wholesale and not by evolutionary means. Additionally, the book is written on the popular, and not the textbook, level. That being said, if you have trouble understanding stuff in the books feel free to PM me and I’ll help you clear it up.
Thank you my friend. I may take you up on that. The first one, Darwin on Trial, seems more interesting.
 
“Irreduceable Complexity” is a terrible argument from a scientific viewpoint and rightly earns disdain in most quarters. The author starts with a preconceived notion (natural process evolution didn’t happen) and seeks examples that seem to support that notion. The fundamental mistake here is that he is taking his religious convictions and applying them to the HOW question. This is the fatal error that ALWAYS ends up embarrassing well meaning defenders of God and revelation in general.

The fact that we do not currently have any explanation for how a complex biological system could have evolved naturally does NOT automatically mean that there must have been a miraculous suspension of the ordinary laws of nature that explains it. If we accepted this reasoning every time we have been stumped in history, we’d still be trying to treat the sick and dying by examining “the humors.”

“Intelligent Design” arguments like this are a setup for failure on an epic level. Don’t build your house on the sand. God didn’t reveal all his methods, just his intent. Don’t try to make revelation into a catch-all magic history and science textbook. It isn’t intended to BE that. It’s the same mistake the Parisees made when they conspired against Jesus. They were so married to their own erroneous interpretation of the Messiah prophecies that they killed the Messiah rather than letting go of their bad assumptions (they assumed they knew HOW Messiah would save Israel and would tolerate no alternative explanation, even from God!).
 
Even taking natural evolution this far does not explain the Cambrian explosion which evolution is still at a loss to explain.
This still sounds dangerously close to the idea that "if science can’t explain it fully, right here, right now, then the only alternative is supernatural intervention and suspension of the “ordinary” laws of nature.

It is just as supernatural and just as orthdox catholicism to believe that God could create the entire universe precisely the way He wanted it by creating a natural system that would eventually produce it. The system of nature itself is the supernatural creation. I believe this is called the argument of intelligibility, which is a big step above the ideas called “intelligent design.”

Thus, there is no real tension between a catholic biologist and an atheistic one unless the atheist “sins” against the scientific method and attempts to argue there is no WHO behind the laws of nature.
 
I too don’t see any problems rectifying some form of evolution with the scripture. When God made man did he do an abracadabra and a puff of smoke, or did he use the forces of the universe he created to direct the forming through a complex process that he never could have explained aptly to our early Scripture authors?
I believe life came into being not with abracadabra and a puff of smoke. But rather God saying, let the land produce every creature according to its kind, and it happened. and God took a rib from Adam to make Eve.

Many things are a test of faith and trust in God. We should believe in miracles like raising the dead, healing the blind, the lame, changing a staff into a snake, virgin birth, and the miracle of creation.

Blessings

Eric
 
This is my understanding of these types of books: that they dispel not the notion that species evolved, but the notion that species evolved totally by chance and that therefore God does not exist.

The way I see it is that the *only *question vis a vis evolution is whether materialist (a-theistic) evolution is true. Since materialistic evolution is a ridiculous concept, flouting even the laws of science, the point then becomes completely moot, since if the world was created, we will never have proof of how it was done.

The problem in these types of discussions is that atheist proponents of the theory of evolution tend to conflate the two meanings of the word. Here they will talk about materialist evolution, there about mere evolution. The overall impact of their explanations of evolution is that God, being unnecessary now that we have an alternative belief, does not exist, and we can be free from those moral strictures which we do not like.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top