Questions (promises and excommunication)

[DMC12]

first, can promises to God be fulfilled in mortal sin? like how our obligation of attending Mass on sundays is.

I have this doubts about exco mmunication, can a person be excomunnicated by using the morning after pill? was sometime the using of condoms a cause for it (my bro told me but i think it never has), does saying something like that extramarital sex is not bad can it be considered heresy?

 

[SybilMolly]

I don’t understand your first question but to your second, yes. The morning after pill is wrong, birth control is wrong, condemns are wrong. Premartial sex is also wrong.

 

[ClearWater]

first, can promises to God be fulfilled in mortal sin? like how our obligation of attending Mass on sundays is.

Could you rephrase the question?

I have this doubts about exco mmunication, can a person be excomunnicated by using the morning after pill?

I believe excommunication is automatic in the case of abortion, and the morning after pill is a form of abortion. The person excommunicates herself from the Church, if I understand it correctly.

as sometime the using of condoms a cause for it (my bro told me but i think it never has),

Not sure of question.

does saying something like that extramarital sex is not bad can it be considered heresy?

Condoning sin is wrong, but I’m not sure what it would be, technically.

 

[DMC12]

well, the first question, is about if lets say that you promise to God to go to certain Church certain day or before certain date, and you go but while being in mortal sin, did you fulfill the promise, or because doing it in state of mortal sin, it was not valid.

and about the second one, is that if usage of condoms was sometime ago a cause for excommunication?

and the third one is that if saying something like that extramarital sex (or another sin) is not sinful can be considered to be a heresy.

 

[TRH1292]

Abortion brings automatic excommunication, not condoms.

And: "“Heresy is the obstinate post-baptismal denial of some truth which must be believed with divine and catholic faith, or it is likewise an obstinate doubt concerning the same;”

And; "Incredulity is the neglect of revealed truth or the willful refusal to assent to it. "

 

[rhona]

Jesus said we are to deny ourselves and follow Him , this means abstinence from the world and all its desires and a total obedience to Jesus which is obedience to the Father…
the true Christian life is the ascetic life…as Jesus taught
as true children of God we are called to a holy life , it is God Himself who confirms us His child…
That is why Rome slaughter the true believers, they were the prophets and apostles of God…they received the light and knew the truth…and that truth comes direct from God…

remember many disciples deserted Jesus…very few will make it to the cross with him…they are the few in each generation that will ever find God…as Moses and all the prophets of the Bible

most certainly the Gospel is not about the married life but rather the renunciation of it , so that the seeking of God can be fulfilled, and you may receive your salvation…which is the knowledge of the Father…just as Paul did
that is why he said the married cannot please God…all true followers of Jesus will never marry…they keep themselves pure in obedience to God