Quick Question 'bout Hell

  • Thread starter Thread starter TheNeutral
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

TheNeutral

Guest
Let’s say Middle-Class Joe-Bob becomes Billionaire Bob. Is BB now in grave danger? Jesus makes it immediately clear that He doesn’t like money, and it seems that if you strive to make a profit, The Father will disown you, or you’ll be hardwired to disown Him. (Matthew 6:24 // Luke 16:13). Can Billionaire Joseph Robert Wright Sr. be reconciled to Christ without obliterating all of His cash? I find this to be an interesting matter, as many Catholics seem to view any amount of money above 5-figures with caution. So, is getting a high enough net worth inherently immoral, or is there hope yet for the business tycoon?
 
I think you have to delineate between how a man makes his money, and what he does with it. Making money is a moral thing when one uses the talents and gifts God offers to offer to others goods and services that are needed and contribute to the well being and advancement of society.
What one does with great wealth is another story. Jesus does not condemn having nice things. (think of his response to the woman anointing him with expensive perfume). It is when one makes a God of possessions and “stuff” and ignores the real needs of others. There are many very wealthy men who have used their fortunes for the good of others. I live near Pittsburgh. We have many wonderful libraries, symphonies, institutions of learning and the arts and sciences that have come to us through the beneficence of men such as Andrew Carnegie, Andrew Mellon, Frick, and others that all are able to enjoy.
There is no clear cut objective yes or no answer to your question.
 
Money itself does not make one evil. It just gives the person a lot more temptations.

Remember the holy rich man who would not give up all his possessions and follow Christ. It is a lot easier for a person living under a bridge to do it. Money easily becomes an idol.

It is hard to be like Francis of Assisi who sold his possessions, quite a bit of his father’s possessions and his took off his clothes before going to work with the poor.
 
True. I 'd like to have millions and have the “problem” of what to do. I would like to think I would do the right thing. Jesus at once condemned the overly wealthy, but gave great approval to those who had much and did the right thing. It becomes a personal question.
 
There is hope for the business tycoon, but normally it’s much harder for the wealthy. The Patron saints of the Secular Franciscan Order, St.Elizabeth and St.Louis were a princess and a king. So most importantly it’s what one does with their money and power.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps this points to a middle ground:
‘Zaccheus stopped and said to the Lord, “Behold, Lord, half of my possessions I will give to the poor, and if I have defrauded anyone of anything, I will give back four times as much”’ - Luke 19:8
 
We also must remember the context of the story of the rich young man. The Gospels says that Christ saw the young man, loved him, and then told him to sell what he had, give it to the poor, and follow him. It was a personal command to the young man. Just as not everyone is called to make a religious Vow of Poverty, not everyone is called to this life.

Now, it is not necessarily true to say that Jesus doesn’t like money. It isn’t that he doesn’t like it, but rather he doesn’t care about it. Money has no impact upon salvation and is simply a tool of this world. The poverty of Christ is the attachment to things or money. Do not seek money for money’s sake. This is what Mt. 6:24 and Lk. 16:13 are trying to explain. Money is intended to be used. To what end that money is used is the real question. Billionaire Bob can live within his vocation by still keeping his money. It may be that Christ is calling Bob to provide jobs for many people through investments in companies or directly employing. I know of some very rich people (not necessarily billionaire, but close) who are some of the most spiritually poor people I know. They are generous to the poor and use their money for investment in start-up companies so they can expand and in turn hire more people or in direct ownership of failing companies to turn them around and allow their employees to keep their jobs. Inversely, I have met people who are below the poverty line who covet money only for the sake of having money. There people are spiritually richer than those financially blessed people I mentioned earlier.

Yes, it is harder to live a spiritually poor life when you have a great deal of money, but it can be done without giving away everything outright.
 
Well, just tell him to do his best I guess. Give some away. If this isn’t completely hypothetical and you want to give something away, I have a friend/fundraiser.

Some saints gave away their wealth at least
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top