Rape Victims And St. Maria Goretti

  • Thread starter Thread starter Starsweeper
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

Starsweeper

Guest
I actually really love this saint, but Catholics really need to readjust the way they see the events surrounding St. Maria Goretti’s life and death. Often held up as an example of purity, many prayers state that she chose to die rather than lose her “virginal purity”. But this is warped because the facts are that she was a little (11 year old) girl that was being forcibly raped and then murdered by a 22 year old man. Not only did she not consent to his advances, but she even if she had, it still would have been rape. And to imply that rape victims are somehow “impure” or not virginal is just flat out wrong, twisted and not Christian (nor does it reflect the teachings of the Catholic Church). Allessandro could have easily raped her, and there would have been nothing she could do about it. The bottom line is, there is no possible way for Maria to have sinned under the circumstances, nor could she have given consent. Thus her “purity” was never and is never the issue. What happened to Maria is 100 percent Allessandro’s fault, and he would tell you as much. I can’t even find a prayer to her that doesn’t include references to her having died defending her chastity and this one is pretty typical-

Saint Maria Goretti, strengthened by God’s grace,** you did not hesitate, even at the age of eleven, to sacrifice life itself to defend your virginal purity**. Look graciously on the unhappy human race that has strayed far from the path of eternal salvation. Teach us all, and especially our youth, the courage and promptness that will help us avoid anything that could offend Jesus. Obtain for me a great horror of sin, so that I may live a holy life on earth and win eternal glory in heaven. Please intercede for me in obtaining the favor I now ask. Amen

The real lesson to be learned from Maria’s short life and death is one of extreme forgiveness and love. Even as she was being murdered she was concerned for the soul of her attacker. She forgave Allessandro on her deathbed. Even after death she appeared to him, came back for him, and helped him to accept the mercy Christ had for him and reform his life. The image of Allessandro and Maria’s mother as friends is an almost perfect illustration of the limitless love and forgiveness Christ has for us and how we should behave towards one another. We just passed her feast day, and I can’t think of a better way to honor her legacy than to bring the focus back on forgiveness and avoid making rape victims feel anything but love and support.
 
I think the Church emphasizes the purity of St. Maria Goretti not to denigrate victims of rape, but to reach as many young people as possible before they act in ways they will later regret. But I’m sure she is a strong patroness for victims of sexual violence as well. St. Maria Goretti, pray for us.
 
Saint Maria Goretti is one of the best examples of forgiveness and love.
 
I actually really love this saint, but Catholics really need to readjust the way they see the events surrounding St. Maria Goretti’s life and death. Often held up as an example of purity, many prayers state that she chose to die rather than lose her “virginal purity”. But this is warped because the facts are that she was a little (11 year old) girl that was being forcibly raped and then murdered by a 22 year old man. Not only did she not consent to his advances, but she even if she had, it still would have been rape. And to imply that rape victims are somehow “impure” or not virginal is just flat out wrong, twisted and not Christian (nor does it reflect the teachings of the Catholic Church). Allessandro could have easily raped her, and there would have been nothing she could do about it. The bottom line is, there is no possible way for Maria to have sinned under the circumstances, nor could she have given consent. Thus her “purity” was never and is never the issue. What happened to Maria is 100 percent Allessandro’s fault, and he would tell you as much. I can’t even find a prayer to her that doesn’t include references to her having died defending her chastity and this one is pretty typical-

Saint Maria Goretti, strengthened by God’s grace,** you did not hesitate, even at the age of eleven, to sacrifice life itself to defend your virginal purity**. Look graciously on the unhappy human race that has strayed far from the path of eternal salvation. Teach us all, and especially our youth, the courage and promptness that will help us avoid anything that could offend Jesus. Obtain for me a great horror of sin, so that I may live a holy life on earth and win eternal glory in heaven. Please intercede for me in obtaining the favor I now ask. Amen

The real lesson to be learned from Maria’s short life and death is one of extreme forgiveness and love. Even as she was being murdered she was concerned for the soul of her attacker. She forgave Allessandro on her deathbed. Even after death she appeared to him, came back for him, and helped him to accept the mercy Christ had for him and reform his life. The image of Allessandro and Maria’s mother as friends is an almost perfect illustration of the limitless love and forgiveness Christ has for us and how we should behave towards one another. We just passed her feast day, and I can’t think of a better way to honor her legacy than to bring the focus back on forgiveness and avoid making rape victims feel anything but love and support.
She is a wonderful example of forgiveness. She did resist him and his advances and as you point out, he still could have forced himself on her and yes, she certainly would not be at fault. She died because she bled to death. she had improper medical care and was too far from any hospital living in an isolated community. In some ways, her mother was at fault because Maria’s dying father warned the mother to leave the town because he was concerned about Allessandro and his possible designs on Maria. That doesn’t excuse what happen. There are a number of “martyrs” of purity, saints that died defending their own moral integrety and refusing to let their bodies by violated by someone else. Saints like these do not mean that they are some how better than those that actually do suffer from rape. The are examples of courage and resistence to rape and being used physically by someone else. I’ve seen testimonies from rape victims on how Saints like Maria Goretti have help them heal and eventually forgive their attackers.
 
but Catholics really need to readjust the way they see the events surrounding St. Maria Goretti’s life and death.
If you are implying there needs to be a patron saint that actually was raped to help comfort victims, then I agree with you. However, I do not agree that Catholics need to change their views. The teachings of the Church are infallible and she DID died saying no to sex. She would rather die than have sex. Honestly, for the era in which she was living, most women probably married in their teens.

She is a great example to give people courage to not have pre-marital sex
 
I actually really love this saint, but Catholics really need to readjust the way they see the events surrounding St. Maria Goretti’s life and death. Often held up as an example of purity, many prayers state that she chose to die rather than lose her “virginal purity”. But this is warped because the facts are that she was a little (11 year old) girl that was being forcibly raped and then murdered by a 22 year old man. Not only did she not consent to his advances, but she even if she had, it still would have been rape. And to imply that rape victims are somehow “impure” or not virginal is just flat out wrong, twisted and not Christian (nor does it reflect the teachings of the Catholic Church). Allessandro could have easily raped her, and there would have been nothing she could do about it. The bottom line is, there is no possible way for Maria to have sinned under the circumstances, nor could she have given consent. Thus her “purity” was never and is never the issue. What happened to Maria is 100 percent Allessandro’s fault, and he would tell you as much. I can’t even find a prayer to her that doesn’t include references to her having died defending her chastity and this one is pretty typical-

Saint Maria Goretti, strengthened by God’s grace,** you did not hesitate, even at the age of eleven, to sacrifice life itself to defend your virginal purity**. Look graciously on the unhappy human race that has strayed far from the path of eternal salvation. Teach us all, and especially our youth, the courage and promptness that will help us avoid anything that could offend Jesus. Obtain for me a great horror of sin, so that I may live a holy life on earth and win eternal glory in heaven. Please intercede for me in obtaining the favor I now ask. Amen

The real lesson to be learned from Maria’s short life and death is one of extreme forgiveness and love. Even as she was being murdered she was concerned for the soul of her attacker. She forgave Allessandro on her deathbed. Even after death she appeared to him, came back for him, and helped him to accept the mercy Christ had for him and reform his life. The image of Allessandro and Maria’s mother as friends is an almost perfect illustration of the limitless love and forgiveness Christ has for us and how we should behave towards one another. We just passed her feast day, and I can’t think of a better way to honor her legacy than to bring the focus back on forgiveness and avoid making rape victims feel anything but love and support.
I agree with you completely and have always felt this way about this wonderful saint. She is not a saint primarily because she died defending herself from rape. She is a saint because she showed heroic virtue in her forgiveness of her attacker and her concern for his salvation, even while she was dying from the wounds that he inflicted.
 
I agree with you completely and have always felt this way about this wonderful saint. She is not a saint primarily because she died defending herself from rape. She is a saint because she showed heroic virtue in her forgiveness of her attacker and her concern for his salvation, even while she was dying from the wounds that he inflicted.
Why can’t she be known for doing both?
 
I think it would be great if someone did a “retelling” of her story - not changing the facts, but pointing out the cultural differences between then and now, and making it clear that she did display “heroic” virtue but that as the OP pointed out, she was not at fault no matter what might have happened. Also there’s a lot of good lesson that’s timely today about how Alessandro got his evil ideas from porn (which was probably a lot tamer than today’s porn, idk) and admitted as much when he repented.

In other words, tell the story as a way of letting abuse victims know Maria would be on their side, and that her experience was exceptional and so was Alessandro’s. Then maybe she could be a patron for victims with less “baggage” of some kind of perfectionistic expectations for resistance attached . . . does that make sense?
 
Many who were rape victims, in our society and even our churches, are taught the least little failing in protesting or fighting adds guilt. Rape victims are bombarded with messages that they must have really wanted it or really consented or something. I remember my own experiences - I froze in panic and did not really fight or protest. Basically just disassociated, I wasn’t really in reality and responding to what is going on. For the longest time I thought, and others often confirmed, that meant nothing wrong had happened.

That’s the trouble. St. Maria Goretti is so much the example of the “perfect” rape victim that is often used in society to tell victims that what happened wasn’t really rape. Women in churches may even get the message, it would have been better to die rather than have your virginity ruined. That they sinned in giving in to a stronger attacker rather than fighting. Is that the message we want to be sending?
 
+JMJ+
That’s the trouble. St. Maria Goretti is so much the example of the “perfect” rape victim that is often used in society to tell victims that what happened wasn’t really rape. Women in churches may even get the message, it would have been better to die rather than have your virginity ruined. That they sinned in giving in to a stronger attacker rather than fighting. Is that the message we want to be sending?
No. It is this:

Nothing makes a man unclean “from the outside”; no “material” dirtiness makes a man impure in the moral sense. … Moral purity has its wellspring exclusively in man’s interior: it comes from the heart.

…we should not think that the essence of virginity lies merely in bodily intactness.

Pope John Paul II, Love and Responsibility

In other words, rape is rape, it is not sex. Rape kills something inside a woman or man as surely as Alessandro Serenelli’s knife did St Maria Goretti.

Therefore, in God’s eyes, rape victims are as virginaly pure as St. Maria Goretti. And we do know that our God is a God who raises the dead.

God love you DarkLight.
 
+JMJ+

No. It is this:

Nothing makes a man unclean “from the outside”; no “material” dirtiness makes a man impure in the moral sense. … Moral purity has its wellspring exclusively in man’s interior: it comes from the heart.

…we should not think that the essence of virginity lies merely in bodily intactness.

Pope John Paul II, Love and Responsibility

In other words, rape is rape, it is not sex. In God’s eyes, rape victims are as virginaly pure as St. Maria Goretti.
That may not be the intended message, but the way her story is told it is the message that comes across. It is not as simple as you think - if a girl is not perfect in her resistance she is certain to be told she was not perfect in her heart either, that she did not struggle enough or cry out because she did not value her purity highly enough.
 
+JMJ+
That may not be the intended message, but the way her story is told it is the message that comes across. It is not as simple as you think - if a girl is not perfect in her resistance she is certain to be told she was not perfect in her heart either, that she did not struggle enough or cry out because she did not value her purity highly enough.
I never said it is as simple or as easy, DarkLight: I have a friend who was gangraped for three days and almost died. I know her struggles with sadness, grief, and guilt. But as I had lovingly yet firmly told her, it is none of her fault, no matter what went through her mind in those days, and I would fight anyone who said otherwise. Her counselor and all her other friends said that too.

The problem is that our churches are poorly catechized right now and make these stupid assumptions instead of knowing their religion, using their noggins and trying to put themselves of their parishioners’ shoes. All I can do is light a candle for anybody and everybody I meet instead of cursing the darkness.

BTW, check my previous post, I added some things there. God bless.
 
Many who were rape victims, in our society and even our churches, are taught the least little failing in protesting or fighting adds guilt. Rape victims are bombarded with messages that they must have really wanted it or really consented or something. I remember my own experiences - I froze in panic and did not really fight or protest. Basically just disassociated, I wasn’t really in reality and responding to what is going on. For the longest time I thought, and others often confirmed, that meant nothing wrong had happened.

That’s the trouble. St. Maria Goretti is so much the example of the “perfect” rape victim that is often used in society to tell victims that what happened wasn’t really rape. Women in churches may even get the message, it would have been better to die rather than have your virginity ruined. That they sinned in giving in to a stronger attacker rather than fighting. Is that the message we want to be sending?
Dark light,
I am so sorry about happen to you. I pray and hope that God continues to heal you. There is no excuse for what happen to you and even though you froze and didn’t fight back, you are not at fault.
 
For those that feel that because they were raped that there isn’t a saint for them, I’ve read that there is some thinking that St. Joan of Arc may have been raped while in prison awaiting her trial and final execution. There is some thinking that she switched back to wearing her armor due to being raped. Although the official stance is that she died a virgin, there is some thought she may have been violated in prison.
 
Maria Goretti was very virtuous and courageous to protest against Allessando so that he would not go to hell and so that her virginity would remain preserved. For her great love (and forgiveness) and for her great love of holy purity I commend her. God bless you.
 
this is no commentary on whether or not St Maria’s story should be shared etc, I am just sharing my experience as a young person hearing her story.

I was sexually abused as a child, and upon learning of St Maria felt I had done very wrong and should likewise have fought (even unto death). I was a young child when the abuse began and didn’t understand what was happening, or even what “purity” meant as far as the faith went.

Nor was fighting even unto death an option. It was a family issue, not an outside attack, but of course these details and differences were lost on me. I thought she was a saint because she was willing to die to protect her purity, end of story, and that I was a miserable sinner who was complicit in sin because I did not fight unto death to protect my purity.

It was not explained to us the importance of her forgiving her attacker etc, and I never understood that forgiving those who harmed me and praying for them was a virtuous act, in deed I wondered if forgiving them made me even more complicit.

When sharing her story, I think it is very important that the whole story be shared, the real reason for her canonization be explained, and the fact that not all who are rape and sexual abuse victims have the option of doing what she did for any number of reasons.

This was the case with many saint’s stories I heard as a child, the sensationalistic parts were shared, but not the faith parts. I was led to believe people were sainted for doing all sorts of odd things, it was more like Ripley’s believe it or not than lessons of faith.
 
A martyr is a saint who dies for the faith of for some virtue. St. Maria Goretti died to preserve the virtue of purity and so died a virgin martyr. If she did not protest when Allessandro was attempting to rape her, she would not have died a saint, though she still could have died a virgin. God bless you.
 
A martyr is a saint who dies for the faith of for some virtue. St. Maria Goretti died to preserve the virtue of purity and so died a virgin martyr. If she did not protest when Allessandro was attempting to rape her, she would not have died a saint, though she still could have died a virgin. God bless you.
The reason I say this is if Maria Goretti gave into the passion of fear she would have compromised her faith and her holy purity, and would not have died a saint. God bless you.
 
This is more of a question that a I have every time I hear the story of St. Maria Goretti.

Why did Alesondro have too stab her repeatedly with the knife? He was a big, young, strong man at the time who was used to physical farm work. From what I understand of St. Maria Gorretti, she was a fourteen year old girl…not even fully matured and she is always depicted as a young girl. I am sure she was physical strong from hard work too but not nearly as strong or as big, or as developed as her rapist. My question is why did her rapist stab her repeatedly? He could have easily just physically overpowered her and forced himself on her and raped her. Why didn’t he do that and instead stabbed her reapetedly and then leaveing her for dead?

The only conclusion I have been able to come up with is because he wanted her to be a willing partaker in having sex with her. When he could not convince her he was so angry with her that he then stabbed her repeatedly. He was trying to rape her my force throuh intimidation and threats not by physically over powering her and when he could not convince her of it was when he snapped.

Does anyone else have a better or more clear understanding of why he didn’t just physcicaly overpower her to rape her but instead overpowered her to stab her to death?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top