RCC interprets 2 Cor 5 17:20 incorrectly

  • Thread starter Thread starter onetimeposter
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
You’re dead wrong on this one. Not surprising that you have left the Catholic faith, you apparently don’t know it well enough to practice it to begin with, which makes gullible enough to be deceived by well meaning people with Bibles. Have a look at My Testimony.
Then you might want to reconsider your beliefs after reading the following articles on my blog. “I Find No Sacraments In the Bible” he said.

Catholic Confession
**Of course he’s dead wrong - he’s not even a Catholic Christian. By his posting you can see he knows very little about the Catholic Faith. **
 
**Of course he’s dead wrong - he’s not even a Catholic Christian. By his posting you can see he knows very little about the Catholic Faith. **
No, its much more revealing than that. From his posting its pretty clear that he does not respect scripture as inspired and I really question if he is Christian at all.

James
 
I praise God for you onetimeposter! The truth is in the scriptures, God’s word and a mighty sword.
Yes indeed. Scripture tells us that God’s word, both apostolicly spoken, written and authoritatively taught is truth. And we have here quite recently a case where that same scripture tells us in Matthew 13:13-14:
  • Therefore speak I to them in parables: because they seeing see not; and hearing they hear not, neither do they understand. And in them is fulfilled the prophecy of Esaias, which saith, By hearing ye shall hear, and shall not understand; and seeing ye shall see, and shall not perceive:*
and in Luke 10:16:
The one who listens to you (ed: Bishops of the Apostolic Church) listens to Me, and the one who rejects you rejects Me; and he who rejects Me rejects the One who sent Me."

James
 
Many non-catholics have this issue with reconciliation because they cannot “bear their own cross” and face the humiliation of confessing their sins to another person. They would rather pray in private to Jesus, it is indeed much easier.

I think THAT is the real reason non-catholics use “the ministry of reconciliation” as an excuse to leave the Catholic Church. It’s not easy or convenient. Same thing with other reasons for leaving: “staying married isn’t convenient”, “purgatory isn’t as fun as heaven”, “having to remain faithful for salvation is long and boring”, “I need assurance of salvation or its not worth my time”, “works are embarrassing, inconvenient, and/or difficult, so we just need faith”, etc.
 
Many non-catholics have this issue with reconciliation because they cannot “bear their own cross” and face the humiliation of confessing their sins to another person. They would rather pray in private to Jesus, it is indeed much easier.

I think THAT is the real reason non-catholics use “the ministry of reconciliation” as an excuse to leave the Catholic Church. It’s not easy or convenient. Same thing with other reasons for leaving: “staying married isn’t convenient”, “purgatory isn’t as fun as heaven”, “having to remain faithful for salvation is long and boring”, “I need assurance of salvation or its not worth my time”, “works are embarrassing, inconvenient, and/or difficult, so we just need faith”, etc.
I think you are correct for a majority of cases. Catholicism is not “easy” since we do not believe that salvation is easy - that is until one transforms their selves and lives and makes it habitual. What is most ironic to me is that there are some very intelligent and mature people with PhDs etc. who leave the Church but simply refuse to turn their own objective eye to themselves to see that they are simply doing the “easy thing”. And most of these same people would agree without thinking for an instant that objectively speaking, in anything in life, in general “the easy thing” is usually the precisely wrong thing to to. Yet they choose to ignore the natural tell tale signs and go about life not at all concerned that there are consequences - eternal consequences.

James
 
I think you are correct for a majority of cases. Catholicism is not “easy” since we do not believe that salvation is easy - that is until one transforms their selves and lives and makes it habitual. What is most ironic to me is that there are some very intelligent and mature people with PhDs etc. who leave the Church but simply refuse to turn their own objective eye to themselves to see that they are simply doing the “easy thing”. And most of these same people would agree without thinking for an instant that objectively speaking, in anything in life, in general “the easy thing” is usually the precisely wrong thing to to. Yet they choose to ignore the natural tell tale signs and go about life not at all concerned that there are consequences - eternal consequences.

James
Yes that true… But the fundamentalist’s response to this is that its not in THEIR bible. Or they will use one irrellevant verse to kinda-sorta talk about it.

Imagine if Jesus was this way. He would have just ascended to heaven instead of dying on a cross! Imagine how hard THAT was!
 
Originally Posted by myredeemerlives
I praise God for you onetimeposter! The truth is in the scriptures, God’s word and a mighty sword.
Unfortunately, you do not know how to wield that sword
 
II Corinthians 5:17 “Therefore if any man be in Christ he is a new creature: old things are passed away; behold, all things are become new.”

There is a qualification to becoming a new creature or creation, and that is “if any man be in Christ”. So the key here is to “be in Christ”. How are you to become “in Christ”? You are in Christ when you believe that Jesus Christ is the Son of God, begotten of the Heavenly Father, born of a virgin, and through His death on the cross, the price for your sins were paid for in full. Then in believing this, you repent to the Father God, in His Son “Jesus name”, and accept the blood of Christ that was shed on the cross for the full payment of your sins.

II Corinthians 5:18 “And all things are of God, Who hath reconciled us to Himself by Jesus Christ, and hath given to us the ministry of reconciliation;”

Once you are reconciled to Christ, everything that God gives you to make your new life is given for the sake of your ministry to others of Jesus Christ. Notice that there is a qualification to those that are reconciled to God, and that is that they have done their reconciling by Jesus Christ. You are the one that makes the move for the reconciliation, and you do that through your repentance of your sins.

This doesn’t mean that God is going to reconcile everything in the world to Him, but only those that come to the Father by the way as He prescribed, and that way is by faith, through God’s grace and our repentance to the Father in Jesus name. Jesus Christ is our only credentials before the throne of God.

II Corinthians 5:19 “To wit, that God was in Christ, reconciling the world unto Himself, not imputing their trespasses unto them, and hath committed unto us the world of reconciliation.”

II Corinthians 5:19 “To wit, that God was in Christ, reconciling the world unto Himself, not imputing their trespasses unto them, and hath committed unto us the world of reconciliation.”

You must believe in the written Word of God [to wit], that God was in Christ. Remember John 10:30; “I and My Father are One.” Jesus said in verse nine of that chapter; “I am the door: by Me if any man enter in, he shall be saved, and shall go in and out, and find pasture.” God is in Jesus because the two are one, and only in and through the sacrificial blood of Jesus Christ is there reconciling back to God.

You come into all the promises that are written in the Word of God, when you are reconciled back to God.

II Corinthians 5:20 “Now then we are ambassadors for Christ, as though God did beseech you by us: we pray you in Christ’s stead, be ye reconciled to God.”

The Corinthians became ambassadors for Christ when they heard the good news through Paul and those that were with him and believed. You became an ambassador for Christ through the one that taught you, and brought you to the understanding of God’s love and His Word. When God creates a new creature in you, He also created a new ambassador for Himself. We fulfill our duties as Christ’s ambassadors every day of our life, while we are in this flesh body, and following the path that Jesus Christ has taught us to live.

Bible Study by Roger Christopherson
 
Unfortunately, you do not know how to wield that sword
Shhhh! You are tipping him off. I was imagining he had the pointy end facing the wrong direction and through an accident of serendipity was just about to do the honorable thing and fall on his own sword while thinking he was knighting himself. 😃

James
 
II Corinthians 5:17 “Therefore if any man be in Christ he is a new creature: old things are passed away; behold, all things are become new.”

There is a qualification to becoming a new creature or creation, and that is “if any man be in Christ”. So the key here is to “be in Christ”. How are you to become “in Christ”? You are in Christ when you believe that Jesus Christ is the Son of God, begotten of the Heavenly Father, born of a virgin, and through His death on the cross, the price for your sins were paid for in full. Then in believing this, you repent to the Father God, in His Son “Jesus name”, and accept the blood of Christ that was shed on the cross for the full payment of your sins.

II Corinthians 5:18 “And all things are of God, Who hath reconciled us to Himself by Jesus Christ, and hath given to us the ministry of reconciliation;”

Once you are reconciled to Christ, everything that God gives you to make your new life is given for the sake of your ministry to others of Jesus Christ. Notice that there is a qualification to those that are reconciled to God, and that is that they have done their reconciling by Jesus Christ. You are the one that makes the move for the reconciliation, and you do that through your repentance of your sins.

II Corinthians 5:19 “To wit, that God was in Christ, reconciling the world unto Himself, not imputing their trespasses unto them, and hath committed unto us the world of reconciliation.”

You must believe in the written Word of God [to wit], that God was in Christ. Remember John 10:30; “I and My Father are One.” Jesus said in verse nine of that chapter; “I am the door: by Me if any man enter in, he shall be saved, and shall go in and out, and find pasture.” God is in Jesus because the two are one, and only in and through the sacrificial blood of Jesus Christ is there reconciling back to God.

You come into all the promises that are written in the Word of God, when you are reconciled back to God.

II Corinthians 5:20 “Now then we are ambassadors for Christ, as though God did beseech you by us: we pray you in Christ’s stead, be ye reconciled to God.”

The Corinthians became ambassadors for Christ when they heard the good news through Paul and those that were with him and believed. You became an ambassador for Christ through the one that taught you, and brought you to the understanding of God’s love and His Word. When God creates a new creature in you, He also created a new ambassador for Himself. We fulfill our duties as Christ’s ambassadors every day of our life, while we are in this flesh body, and following the path that Jesus Christ has taught us to live.

Bible Study by Roger Christopherson
 
The notion of a “common sense” understanding of Scripture is one of the greatest evils to afflict modern Christianity. I strongly recommend Mark Noll’s *America’s God *for a historical study of how this played out in 19th-century American Christianity, particularly his chapter on the slavery debate. He shows that antislavery Christians were crippled in their attempt to show that the Bible did not really support slavery, because their nuanced arguments (more accurately, the nuanced arguments produced by some antislavery writers) looked like attempts to explain away the “common sense” interpretation of Scripture. Now, with some historical distance, it seems obvious to most of us that the Bible did not condone the kind of race-based chattel slavery practiced by 19th-century Southerners. But at the time, “common sense” appeared to point toward a proslavery position.

The problem is that “common sense” is always shaped by cultural attitudes, in ways that it’s almost impossible to see at the time. That is why we need to pay attention to the tradition of the Church–it is, as Chesterton put it, the only thing that frees us from the degrading slavery of being children of our times. And the dreadful irony is that we are most enslaved to the spirit of the age when we claim to be following a common-sense approach that frees us from all presuppositions.

Edwin
Ed. Ya rock my world, buddy.

Just wanted to say…

😃

SK
 
**Does it? Really?

The Catholic Church believes that “Only God forgives sin.”

When a penitent person asks God for forgiveness, his (or her) sins are immediately forgiven.

Catholics also believe that when someone sins they not only hurt their relationship with God, they also injure the entire church, the body of Christ.

Jesus said, “I will give you the keys to the kingdom of heaven. Whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven; and whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven.” (Matthew 16:19)

And when he had said this, he breathed on them and said to them,“Receive the holy Spirit. Whose sins you forgive are forgiven them, and whose sins you retain are retained.” (Luke 20:22-23)

Oral confessing of sins is recommended over and over in both the Old and New Testaments:
  • James 5:16
  • Acts 19:18
  • Matthew 3:5-6
  • Mark 1:5
  • 1 Timothy 6:12
  • 1 John 1:9
  • Numbers 5:6-7
  • Nehemiah 9:2
  • Sirach 4:26
The Sacrament of Penance and Reconciliation with a priest ordained in the name of Jesus Christ not only reconciles the sinner to God but with the entire church, including you and me.

Remember all sacraments are encounters with God. This sacrament is a healing encounter between God and the penitent.

For more information, see the Catechism of the Catholic Church, section 1422 and following:
usccb.org/catechism/text/pt2s…**
 
Here’s a good analogy that deals with something doesn’t have to be literally true in order to still be a real truth…I’ve picked this up from Marcus Borg.
Stop. Freeze frame.

Onetime, if you subscribe to the Jesus Seminar, it’s no wonder you’re no longer Catholic. This explains everything.

There are so many things wrong with the Jesus Seminar - just from a logical standpoint - it’s hard to know where to begin in addressing them.

Don’t be a victim, Onetime, of popular stupidity (or, more charitably put, “popular culture.”) Silly theories will come and ridiculous theories will go - they always have and always will - but Jesus Christ is the same, yeserday, today, forever, according to the scriptures which you apparently feel need to be voted on in order to be proved “true”?

Don’t fall victim to man’s desire to re-create God in his own image, to tell God how life is going to be lived, rather than allowing the opposite. If you truly do believe in God as a reality at this point (not as a nice, reassuring mental construct that is only real in one’s own mind), I encourage you as your brother in the human race to spend a good deal of time in prayer about the matter and ask Him to guide you into all truth. In the end - I promise - you’ll be very, very glad you did.

You’re in my prayers.

SK
 
Stop. Freeze frame.

Onetime, if you subscribe to the Jesus Seminar, it’s no wonder you’re no longer Catholic.
One can think that Marcus Borg makes some good arguments without “subscribing to the Jesus Seminar.” I think this is a mistaken approach–you are attacking his sources rather than addressing the argument.

Edwin
 
Originally Posted by **onetimeposter **
We agree to disagree. I know what the text clearly says, your Church tells you what they believe the text says.

This debate can go no further.

Of course it can’t go further. You refuse to allow the Church to interpret ITS OWN SCRIPTURES!
 
Onetimeposter,
It seems you may have dropped out of this discussion because it doesn’t seem to be going anywhere. However, I hope this is not the case.

Let me start off by saying I disagree with you, however, I would like to explain why.

I think it is a mistake to isolate the passage we are using from the rest of the second letter of Paul to the Corinthians and from the first as well. The passage you cited, however, if taken in the context with the whole of 2 Cor actually become of secondary importance to what Paul is trying to express.

Hopefully, from your studies of Paul, you know that especially with the Corinthian community Paul was continously justifying himself. It seems in Corinth some held he was not a true Apostle and others began to doubt his word because of his repeated promises to return to them but failed to do so. In other words Paul was always on the defensive with this Church.

Here in 2 Cor, if you study whole letter, Paul is again proclaiming not only his right and the authenticity of his Apostleship, but also the sincerity of his love for them. And here is where the verse in question comes into play. Paul, by writing what he did, was, again, providing evidence of his authority as a True Apostle - on equal basis with “The Twelve”. The activity he list are activities of the Twelve, and, for our discussion, seems to be accepted by the Church at Corinth without question. In other words Paul is telling the Corinthian community, “Look, I am an Apostle, just like Cephas and James, I have the same powers as they - powers they recieved from Christ Himself and Powers I too receive directly from Christ as well. Therefore I am an Apostle. But the real important thing is you know my love for you by all I suffered for you.” Of coarse this is a paraphrase but it is built upon the whole context of 2 Cor and 1Cor as well.

But for our discussion, as I wrote above, what Paul wrote about apostolic act was accepted, by the Corinthians, as authentic acts of the Church. So the question was not whether or not the Church had the power and authority to performed the actions Paul mentions, the question was about a particular individual or individuals, having the right tpo performed such acts.

This is why the Church can used the passage from 2 Cor in regards to the Sacrament of Reconciliation. Again, it was not a question of the Church’s authority and power, it was a question of an individual’s authority to do these specific acts of the Church.

However, again, if you or anyone for that matter, isolate this verse from the whole context of 2 Cor, it is almost impossible to see the reason how and why the Church uses this among its many scriptural references.
 
Onetimeposter,
It seems you may have dropped out of this discussion because it doesn’t seem to be going anywhere. However, I hope this is not the case.
It isn’t…the moderators are reviewing his account. He can’t post. Check his username.
 
People don’t like confessing to a priest because they are lazy… and don’t want to go see the priest on saturday afternoon and wait in line to confess.

They rather sit at home and watch tv or play video games…

Only makes since that people would want to justify their posistion of not going to confession because they don’t want to admit their own laziness…

The OP of this thread has a bad bible… I’m not even sure what version he is using…, but because of sola scriptura that anyone can read the bible reguardless of education or laguage and see the truth, has lead to many translations that have been “dummied” down so that people who arn’t properly educated can understand…

This then being the Word of God, makes these dummied down translations infallible even though they conflict with each other in various passages.

At the rate the bible keeps changing it, will only be a matter of 100-200 years before the Word of God is completely distorted and impossible to understand fully, then it will be placed on the selfs with the other fiction books.

The only thing that will exist will be the Church and the actual Sacred Scripture, and its interpretation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top