P
PeaceInChrist
Guest
The heresies refuted prior to the Reformation were refuted with good cause. You can even read the councils and Church fathers that wrote against the heresies. Tell me, how do you determine which of the early heresies was true and which was not? For instance, was Christ created or begotten? Is He man and God, or just God? Is God a Trinity or does He appear in different forms? Now, if you side with the Catholic Church on these issues, then why not on others? They were all determined in councils and with the support of the Roman bishop.May I add that when reading scripture and it seems different to current teaching, it may have been “thought of” earlier than with reformers of 1500’s. Some things were challenged in 8-9th century by Catholics, some in 12,13 th century, some in 4th century etc.It is a good generalization that the big reformation happened 1500s but I doubt you will take on everything they challenged. But bits and pieces of “questions” is what may come your way, that have been around way before 1500’s. For sure if you ask, you will get an answer. Pretty much everything has already been discussed down thru the ages with recorded answers,from both sides of any issue. A good Catholic abides by the churches final decree on the matter. BUT,as I was once told, the bigger issue is not to study the bible, but let the bible study you.“Show me Lord if there be any wicked way in me, but gently ,lest I am blown away” .This is quite a universal challenge for all believers.
How do you as an individual determine selectively which doctrine is inspired and which is not, when the oldest and surest form of determining doctrine (the Biblical council) has come to so many Truths, Truths that even Protestants agree with?
The people who said Christ was not man but only God, that He was created and not begotten, that God is not a Trinity, along with all others who opposed the Church, felt they were guided by the Spirit and that they could interpret truth better than the collective Church and Roman Vicar. What makes you different than them?