Real Presence and Protestants

  • Thread starter Thread starter Questionhaver
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
(Edited)

We all know it doesn’t matter what denomination one belongs to. They all each the same truth.
 
That’s right! Come on guys and let’s play nice. We all know it doesn’t matter what denomination one belongs to. They all each the same truth.
Don’t we wish it was all the “same truth”. Too bad that the original Reformers almost immediately started infighting and arguing among themselves (e.g. Luther, Zwingli and Calvin) and broke into major sects. Those original divisions made Protestantism splinter into so many downstream independent hydras’ heads of “truth” its almost impossible for Catholic evangelists/missionaries and apologists to be effective in a general approach.
 
Don’t we wish it was all the “same truth”. Too bad that the original Reformers almost immediately started infighting and arguing among themselves (e.g. Luther, Zwingli and Calvin) and broke into major sects. Those original divisions made Protestantism splinter into so many downstream independent hydras’ heads of “truth” its almost impossible for Catholic evangelists/missionaries and apologists to be effective in a general approach.
True enough bona fides. True enough! 👍

It is interesting how most of all main line Protestantism sort of melted into one big pot of gooey liberalism where the “I’m O.K., you’re O.K.” attitude is pretty much accepted by all except when it come to the Catholics, of course.
 
Wow…and if I said such a thing about a Catholic Church how long would my post be up? Stay classy. I hope at least some of the Catholics here find that post as insulting as I do. I really, REALLY don’t want to believe that these sentiments of most Catholics.
Consider that the person to whom your addressing signs his/her posts with the following:
I’m a hardcore Catholic. I believe everything the Church teaches without question.
Since the Catholic Church unquestionably teaches charity, respectfulness, love of neighbor, and since Vatican II issued a declaration on Ecumenism (which minimally suggests good will toward Protestants), an unquestioning Catholic is duty-bound to treat Protestants accordingly.

I wouldn’t worry for a second that this individual represents most Catholics in this forum, much less most Catholics in general. That said, I think a more charitable interpretation can be given to his original comparison of Protestant churches to barns.

In fact, s/he is correct that there is “nothing sacred” within our churches in the traditional, Catholic understanding of “sacred.” Not only is there no tabernacle with an enduring Eucharistic presence, there are no “sacramentals,” such as holy water. Most Protestant churches do not have images, side altars, statues, burning candles and other things that give a church a certain “sacredness.”

If you walk into many Protestant churches, there’s often a stage, musical instruments, rows of chairs, a projector screen and a lot of other things that have the feel of an auditorium. So from a traditional, Catholic perspective, I can see how he/she might have come to the conclusion that there often isn’t anything more sacred in Protestant churches than we’d find in the average barn.

The real issue is whether or not that’s a legitimate gripe. I think there is a good argument to be made for making our places of worship more prayerful and more sacred. But I also think there’s reason to suppose that much of what you see in typical Catholic Churches is simply residual paganism. Far more important (to me anyway) are the people in those churches. Are they sacred or not? Are their hearts worshipping the Living God, or someone/something less than God?
 
But I also think there’s reason to suppose that much of what you see in typical Catholic Churches is simply residual paganism.
I was pretty much with you until you said this. Perhaps you don’t realize how incredibly insulting that is, if it matters.
 
I was pretty much with you until you said this. Perhaps you don’t realize how incredibly insulting that is, if it matters.
Strongly concur - this was “over the top” with comparison to the original venial offense which was certainly a tad insensitive (but not inaccurate in his assertions if the Protestant place of prayer was vacant). That’s a shame since he made some good points.

In spite of this inflammatory comment this person does make a highly valid argument. Certainly any building that has newly baptised Christians praying in it are in a high state of grace while they are present. That makes the Protestant place of assembly worthy of respect while occupied by Christians in a state of grace. We can also assume that there are bibles present - but I don’t think that fact really extends “holiness” to the entire church. If that were the case public libraries would be “holy” for having bibles in them along with the smut in the adult reading sections; which seems absurd. Protestant churches are not formally consecrated to the Lord in the same formal way as a Catholic Church is (apostolic blessing by a bishop) nor in the same manner as is the newly baptized Christian consecrated to The Lord.

Catholic Churches are consecrated and also contain the real-presence of Christ in the tabernacle so they are indeed holy irrespective of being vacant of humans or not. They also contain at least some small relic of a saint in the altar - which is also holy during the few days before Easter Vigil around Good Friday when the Eucharist is removed from the tabernacle. Many Catholic will make the sign of the cross in veneration to the Eucharist when they walk past the Church or drive past it and gain a partial indulgence for that small act of respect.

BF
 
A protestant church deserves the same respect you’d show a barn. There’s nothing in it that’s holy, sacred, or deserves any respect.
How does this attitude foster unity in any way? Protestants are not your enemy. They are your brothers and sisters in Christ. You should be in deep despair that they are not in full communion with us and not push them farther away. Pray for them don’t insult them.
 
A protestant church deserves the same respect you’d show a barn. There’s nothing in it that’s holy, sacred, or deserves any respect.
Several others already responded well, but this is just rude. True, there’s no sacramental presence of Christ in a Protestant place of worship. But they do still, generally, worship the same God we worship, even though they sadly lack the Sacraments. So we should at least be reasonably respectful of that. Of course, that does not include genuflecting to nothing!

As a side note, I know the OP asked about Protestants, who as it as already been said, do not have the sacramental presence of Christ, and most have no tabernacle at all (aside from high church Anglicans, maybe a few others). But if you were to ever visit an Orthodox Church - they certainly do have valid sacraments, including the sacramental presence of Christ present in their tabernacle. I wouldn’t receive their sacraments because of the schism, but I would certainly reverence Christ present sacramentally in some way.
 
In Germany, Lutherans and Catholics have in many cases shared the same church buildings, altars and all for over 100 years. So where does that leave us? I know Lutheran craftsman built the Catholic church near my hometown and Catholics met in our Lutheran Church after a fire, using our altar, Sunday School rooms, etc. for a month or more.
 
I was pretty much with you until you said this. Perhaps you don’t realize how incredibly insulting that is, if it matters.
Mea culpa. My intent was not to insult but rather to argue that some of what makes for the “sacredness” of Catholic Churches (assuming a more traditional notion of “sacredness”) is, in my opinion, of pagan origin (or at least influence.) If that insults you, well, there’s not much I can do about that, as it is my opinion.

It’s also my opinion that much of the decor in Evangelicalism is simply, well, tacky. And I’m sure that will offend some of my own too. (But it’s true!)

Back to the paganism, thing. If you take the perspective of an outsider looking in (into a Catholic Church) and what you see is some or all of the following, what might you conclude?
  1. A building modeled after temples to pagan gods in terms of their architectural layout.
  2. Statues to saints mounted on side alters, with votive candles in front of them, and kneelers.
  3. Vestments, vessels, and other objects that seem to have clearer antecedents in Roman religion (paganism–that word again!) than the Jewish priesthood of the Old Testament.
  4. Churches named after saints, titles of clergy adapted from the pagan clergy.
In other words, there are a lot of pagan antecedents in the decor of the typical Catholic Church that would look, at least to an outsider, like “residual paganism.” You can choose to let that observation offend you, or you can rebut it and explain why the seemingly pagan similarities are merely a “coincidence” or are a legitimate “Christianization” of those pagan elements.

I never argued that because there is residual paganism in Catholicism that it is therefore illegitimate. But if there is, then an argument needs to be made to justify the inclusion of those pagan customs/ideas etc.

A similar debate is going on within Catholic circles with respect to Eastern form of meditation. Can a Catholic practice Zen and still be Catholic? Can a Catholic strip yoga from its Hindu world-view and simply use the stretches for physical exercise? These are all questions worth asking in my opinion.

Let’s put it this way. If the time machine (from another thread) could transport a pagan from, say, late fourth century Rome to one of the churches below, which do you think s/he would find to be more like “Rome sweet Rome”?

A.
http://www.traveljournals.net/pictu...angelist-catholic-church-kilkenny-ireland.jpg

or

B. 高校生のニュージーランド留学費用相場|憧れのニュージーランド留学

Both images are problematic to me, but especially the top one.

Pax Christi
 
Over a dozen posts have been removed from this thread.

Please get back on topic and remain there and maintain the highest level of Christian charity.
 
Luther believed in the Real Presence, Zwingli and Calvin did not but instead claimed consecration to be merely symbolical.
If ever they did believe in real presence, their explanations are not “real” at all. Reality involves both the physical, spiritual and temporal senses. When present, always present.
Now, is there a Real Presence in protestant Churches even though they don’t believe in it or is transubstantation denied to heretic churches?
First, transubstantiation is for all. The problem is that it only happens through a valid priest (or of course, bishop). That is, valid because of the “laying of hands” and can be traced back to the Apostles themselves.

If any of the protestant churches can produce a proof that there is an unbroken physical (laying of hands) link between the present pastors and the Apostles, then they can effect transubstantiation.

I have no knowledge whether they can effect, no matter how hard they try, transubstantiation because their pastors simply has no power to ask for the Holy Spirit to make the matters the real Body and Blood of the Lord – and permanently until they decay or are digested.

As to the first part of the question: There is no real presence because they cannot effect it. This is the reason why most protestants demand a “spiritual” presence (or even simply symbolic presence) because they can’t. It was only with the catholic Church that Eucharistic miracles were recorded.
I’m trying to figure out whether I should pay the usual deferences while in there.
Because of the negative answer on the above, I believe there is need for you to genuflect or show any reverence to their “host” or bread, or crakers. I also believe that a catholic has no business in “sharing” with their meal. For a catholic, eating their “blessed” crakers or “meal” is like eating with the pagan’s sacrifices. We can only eat the Body and drink the Blood of our Lord who is the everlasting Lamb of God – the true sacrifice.

Do not eat their sacrifices. It is a sign of you being one of them.

Of course, you may just be there as a guest, as one of the post recommended. It is important that you at least respect them. If they force you to eat or drink their sacrifices, stay calm and just say, “thank you but i’m not allowed to take it.” Of course, you can dine with them later – but not during the “holy sacrifice.”
 
=geekborj;6820593]
First, transubstantiation is for all. The problem is that it only happens through a valid priest (or of course, bishop). That is, valid because of the “laying of hands” and can be traced back to the Apostles themselves.
If any of the protestant churches can produce a proof that there is an unbroken physical (laying of hands) link between the present pastors and the Apostles, then they can effect transubstantiation.
Some Northern European Lutherans can, and many Anglicans can with the “Dutch touch”. In addition, the are some ELCA pastors with Anglican “hands” (dutch touch), and also the ALCC, whose orders are considered valid but irregular.
It is more conmplicated than just “hands”. The issue also goes to form as well. GKC is well versed at this stuff, much more so than I am.
I have no knowledge whether they can effect, no matter how hard they try, transubstantiation because their pastors simply has no power to ask for the Holy Spirit to make the matters the real Body and Blood of the Lord – and permanently until they decay or are digested.
This generally states the Catholic position.
As to the first part of the question: There is no real presence because they cannot effect it. This is the reason why most protestants demand a “spiritual” presence (or even simply symbolic presence) because they can’t. It was only with the catholic Church that Eucharistic miracles were recorded.
This does not, to my understanding. Those Protestants who claim a spritual or symbolic presence do not do so because Rome denies their orders, they do so because they (mistakenly) believe it.
Eucharistic miracles are not the Catholic Church’s central premise on who can actually confect. To my knowledge, PNCC, Old Catholics, and the Orthodox can confect, not because they have Eucharistic miracles, but becase they have valid orders, in the opinion of Rome.
Because of the negative answer on the above, I believe there is need for you to genuflect or show any reverence to their “host” or bread, or crakers.
Or show any reverence?
I also believe that a catholic has no business in “sharing” with their meal. For a catholic, eating their “blessed” crakers or “meal” is like eating with the pagan’s sacrifices.
I shall compare your statement with that of Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger, who says,
"Even a theology oriented to the concept of succession, such as that which holds in the Catholic and in the Orthodox church, need not in any way deny the salvation-granting presence of the Lord in a Lutheran Lord’s Supper."
Clearly he doesn’t view it as a “pagan sacrifice”.

A Catholic should respect his/her communion’s requirement that they not receive at a Lutheran (or other Protestant) Eucharist.
Of course, you may just be there as a guest, as one of the post recommended. It is important that you at least respect them.
I would agree, and the reverse should also be true. I would suggest, whether inention or not, that your “pagan sacrifice” comment conflicts with your call for respect.
If they force you to eat or drink their sacrifices, stay calm and just say, “thank you but i’m not allowed to take it.” Of course, you can dine with them later – but not during the “holy sacrifice.”
Why would you even think someone would “force” another to participate? :rolleyes:

Jon
 
Are you asking whether you should apply the Catholic devotion of genuflecting in a Protestant Church? There is nothing (no-one) in a Protestant Church to genuflect before–there is no tabernacle holding the body and blood of Christ…
Code:
Tabernacles are common in Anglican and Lutheran churches, along with a red candle or lantern to mark the presence of consecrated bread. I grew up in the Episcopal church and every church I was a member of had a tabernacle.
The question of whether protestant communion bread is Christ was never a problem for me when I was Episcopal, because I was taught that it was, after the prayer of consecration. I’m a recent convert to the Catholic church and now it is problem for me. I know that somehow God used the Eucharist in the Episcopal church to bring me to Him, but now I hearing that God was not present ?? How is it that a protestant baptism in the name of the Trinity is considered valid, and a protestant wedding is considered valid, but not the Eucharist?

Just trying to understand…:confused:
 
"Even a theology oriented to the concept of succession, such as that which holds in the Catholic and in the Orthodox church, need not in any way deny the salvation-granting presence of the Lord in a Lutheran Lord’s Supper."
Clearly he doesn’t view it as a “pagan sacrifice”.
Well no…it isn’t a sacrifice at all (unless you count the nominal loss incurred in the production of the bread and wine). However, for a Catholic to participate in a Lutheran Lord’s Supper would indeed be like participating in a pagan sacrifice, because a Catholic does not hold the same faith in respect to the Eucharist that the Lutheran does. In the same way, a Catholic does not believe that bulls sacrificed to Zeus propitiate him, and so participating in such a sacrifice would be a denial of his own faith. Religious dishonesty is the most serious kind.
 
Well no…it isn’t a sacrifice at all (unless you count the nominal loss incurred in the production of the bread and wine). However, for a Catholic to participate in a Lutheran Lord’s Supper would indeed be like participating in a pagan sacrifice, because a Catholic does not hold the same faith in respect to the Eucharist that the Lutheran does. In the same way, a Catholic does not believe that bulls sacrificed to Zeus propitiate him, and so participating in such a sacrifice would be a denial of his own faith. Religious dishonesty is the most serious kind.
51.The ecumenical discussion has shown that these two positions must no longer be regarded as opposed in a way that leads to separation.
prounione.urbe.it/dia-int/l-rc/doc/e_l-rc_eucharist.html

While we are not yet able to join at the altar and share the chalice, I suspect our continuing our brief dialogue will not further that goal, shared by our communions.

Jon
 
The fact is that the Catholic Church teaches that Lutherans (not speaking of those in Scandinavia that have maintained it), do not have valid orders, and therefore no valid Eucharist. So, you should by all means follow the teachings of the Catholic Church if the church you are visiting is Lutheran. It is the same advice I would give a Lutheran visiting a Catholic church, even though we recognize the validity of Catholic orders and sacrament. When visiting, show respect and obey the requests of the host church (and your own) when a guest. Good manners, and the goal of eventual reconcilation between our communions, are best met that way.

While the teachings of the Catholic Church remains, there has been much movement over the last few decades between Rome and Lutheranism on this subject, noted in these two articles. They may or may not help you in your question, but the are interesting reading on the subject, and hold hope for the future.

usccb.org/seia/koinonia.shtml

prounione.urbe.it/dia-int/l-rc/doc/e_l-rc_eucharist.html

It is in the first document that I first saw the quote from Cardinal Ratzinger that is in my signature.

Jon
Well said Jon,
Good to bump into you here again. Hope all is well with you !
 
The fact is that the Catholic Church teaches that Lutherans (not speaking of those in Scandinavia that have maintained it), do not have valid orders, and therefore no valid Eucharist. So, you should by all means follow the teachings of the Catholic Church if the church you are visiting is Lutheran. It is the same advice I would give a Lutheran visiting a Catholic church, even though we recognize the validity of Catholic orders and sacrament. When visiting, show respect and obey the requests of the host church (and your own) when a guest. Good manners, and the goal of eventual reconcilation between our communions, are best met that way.

While the teachings of the Catholic Church remains, there has been much movement over the last few decades between Rome and Lutheranism on this subject, noted in these two articles. They may or may not help you in your question, but the are interesting reading on the subject, and hold hope for the future.

usccb.org/seia/koinonia.shtml

prounione.urbe.it/dia-int/l-rc/doc/e_l-rc_eucharist.html

It is in the first document that I first saw the quote from Cardinal Ratzinger that is in my signature.

Jon
I have heard of some teachings of some Anglican and/or Lutheran that have tried to maintain the succession but since even in these areas the CC has said it is a gray area at best it is best to assume no succession. I do hope for the Future and unity.
 
prounione.urbe.it/dia-int/l-rc/doc/e_l-rc_eucharist.html

While we are not yet able to join at the altar and share the chalice, I suspect our continuing our brief dialogue will not further that goal, shared by our communions.

Jon
No need to be so pessimistic!

Anyway, the use of term “separation” is a little vague in the document you quoted. Regardless, if they mean that the differing views we have regarding the Eucharist no longer stand in the way of our communing together, the most I can say is that the Catholic Church has not saw fit to reflect that opinion in her laws.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top