Really confused about Church Infallibility

  • Thread starter Thread starter wolfpup
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
W

wolfpup

Guest
I know that this questions has probably been asked a million times, but I am really confused.
How can we know the difference between an infallible dogma, a non-infallible doctrine? I understand what the differences are but it seems impossible to separate out at on a practical level which is which.
And then there is the fact that we must give religious assent to the teaching of the ordinary teaching of the magisterium rather than the assent of faith given to infallible dogma. And it seems that mistakes can be made in Papal letters and Ecumenical councils because only some of the teachings contained in them are infallible, some are apparently non-infallible doctrine.

If someone could give me a practical way of understanding, because right now I am completely confused. Basically what I am asking is: What teachings are Dogma and therefore will never change? What is doctrine and can it change, or be elevated to dogma, and how?

For example, is the teaching on contraception, trinity, incarnation all dogma? Can anyone point me to a doctrine that could change or even be dropped completly if defined further, and could the pope or a council make a mistake when pronouncing on these issues? Can a non-infallible doctrine be completley wrong?
 
I’ve been posting on Catholic forums for twenty years now and the answers seem to vary with time. To get a sense of everyone’s confusion, try reading this.
 
I know that this questions has probably been asked a million times, but I am really confused.
How can we know the difference between an infallible dogma, a non-infallible doctrine? I understand what the differences are but it seems impossible to separate out at on a practical level which is which.
And then there is the fact that we must give religious assent to the teaching of the ordinary teaching of the magisterium rather than the assent of faith given to infallible dogma. And it seems that mistakes can be made in Papal letters and Ecumenical councils because only some of the teachings contained in them are infallible, some are apparently non-infallible doctrine.

If someone could give me a practical way of understanding, because right now I am completely confused. Basically what I am asking is: What teachings are Dogma and therefore will never change? What is doctrine and can it change, or be elevated to dogma, and how?

For example, is the teaching on contraception, trinity, incarnation all dogma? Can anyone point me to a doctrine that could change or even be dropped completly if defined further, and could the pope or a council make a mistake when pronouncing on these issues? Can a non-infallible doctrine be completley wrong?
Church Doctrine is Dogma. It’s contained in the “Catechism of the Catholic Church, Second Edition” (dark green cover).
" The Catechism of the Catholic Church, which I have approved…and the publication of which I order by virtue of my Apostolic Authority, is a statement of the Church’s faith and of Catholic Doctrine, attested to or illumined by Sacred Scripture, the Apostolic Tradition, and the Church’s Magisterium. I declare it to be a sure norm for teaching the Faith and thus a valid and legitimate instrument for ecclesial communion." Pope John Paul II (pg 5, #3)

The Pope, is only infallable when speaking to the Universal Church on matters of Faith and Morals. He is not infallible in scientific, historical, political, philosophical, geographic or any other matters. (See “Catholicism for Dummies” by Frs. Trigilio and Brighenti for greater detail on this.)

CCC - " 891 The Roman Pontiff, head of the college of bishops, enjoys this infallibility in virtue of his office, when, as supreme pastor and teacher of all the faithful - who confirms his brethren in the faith he proclaims by a definitive act a doctrine pertaining to faith or morals. . . . The infallibility promised to the Church is also present in the body of bishops when, together with Peter’s successor, they exercise the supreme Magisterium," above all in an Ecumenical Council.
When the Church through its supreme Magisterium proposes a doctrine “for belief as being divinely revealed,” and as the teaching of Christ, the definitions “must be adhered to with the obedience of faith.” This infallibility extends as far as the deposit of divine Revelation itself. "

Yes, the teachings on the Trinity, Incarnation, and contraception are infalllible teachings.
(For appropriate spacing of children see: CCC in #2366 - 2369).
 
I know that this questions has probably been asked a million times, but I am really confused.
How can we know the difference between an infallible dogma, a non-infallible doctrine? I understand what the differences are but it seems impossible to separate out at on a practical level which is which.
And then there is the fact that we must give religious assent to the teaching of the ordinary teaching of the magisterium rather than the assent of faith given to infallible dogma. And it seems that mistakes can be made in Papal letters and Ecumenical councils because only some of the teachings contained in them are infallible, some are apparently non-infallible doctrine.

If someone could give me a practical way of understanding, because right now I am completely confused. Basically what I am asking is: What teachings are Dogma and therefore will never change? What is doctrine and can it change, or be elevated to dogma, and how?

For example, is the teaching on contraception, trinity, incarnation all dogma? Can anyone point me to a doctrine that could change or even be dropped completly if defined further, and could the pope or a council make a mistake when pronouncing on these issues? Can a non-infallible doctrine be completley wrong?
Rather than the secular Wikipedia explanations on infallibility, reference the last post on the CCC references as well as this Catholic Answers tract.

On the confusion of doctrines and dogmas, see post 2 from this past CAF thread. In short, all doctrines are official teachings, but the dogmas (doctrines revealed formally and divinely that are essential to the faith) must be held by the faithful. All dogmas are doctrines but not all doctrines are dogmas.

Doctrines can change a bit. For instance, the concept of limbo was taught for a time (doctrine) but not formally established. It doesn’t mean that the teachings were wrong, per se, but time allows the Church to gain clarity on some matters with additional study. This teaching does not have to be held by the faithful. The belief that there was one human parent set, Adam and Eve, was revealed by God via Scripture and, as dogma, cannot change.

The invocation of papal infallibility is done very, very rarely, as the tract should note.
 
Some theologians disagree on the infallibility of contraception.
 
All Church doctrine is also infallible.
Infallibility takes several forms, as the Catechism states
  1. The mission of the Magisterium is linked to the definitive nature of the covenant established by God with his people in Christ. It is this Magisterium’s task to preserve God’s people from deviations and defections and to guarantee them the objective possibility of professing the true faith without error. Thus, the pastoral duty of the Magisterium is aimed at seeing to it that the People of God abides in the truth that liberates. To fulfill this service, Christ endowed the Church’s shepherds with the charism of infallibility in matters of faith and morals. The exercise of this charism** takes several forms:** 851
    1785
  2. “The Roman Pontiff, head of the college of bishops, enjoys this infallibility in virtue of his office, when, as supreme pastor and teacher of all the faithful - who confirms his brethren in the faith he proclaims by a definitive act a doctrine pertaining to faith or morals… The infallibility promised to the Church is also present in the body of bishops when, together with Peter’s successor, they exercise the supreme Magisterium,” above all in an Ecumenical Council.[418] When the Church through its supreme Magisterium proposes a doctrine “for belief as being divinely revealed,”[419] and as the teaching of Christ, the definitions “must be adhered to with the obedience of faith.”[420] This infallibility extends as far as the deposit of divine Revelation itself.[421] † ©
  3. Divine assistance is also given to the successors of the apostles, teaching in communion with the successor of Peter, and, in a particular way, to the bishop of Rome, pastor of the whole Church, when, without arriving at an infallible definition and without pronouncing in a “definitive manner,” they propose in the exercise of the ordinary Magisterium a teaching that leads to better understanding of Revelation in matters of faith and morals. To this ordinary teaching the faithful “are to adhere to it with religious assent”[422] which, though distinct from the assent of faith, is nonetheless an extension of it.
Thus in 892, even though there is no definition, this ordinary teaching is one of the several forms of infallibility. Examples today are the Popes teaching on why God became man. The vast majority of Catholic scholars today say it was to open the gates of heaven. The Popes teach it was to free us from the slavery of sin. Thus they are teaching infallibly in their ordinary teaching.

Some posted
Doctrines can change a bit. For instance, the concept of limbo was taught for a time (doctrine) but not formally established.

Not so. The concept of limbo , for children, was either never taught clearly by the Church, or it is still never taught clearly today.
Church teachings can never change. Only the Pope and the few bishops in union with the Pope can authentically interpret the word of God handed down in Tradition or scripture. Not theologians.
 
Rather than the secular Wikipedia explanations on infallibility, reference the last post on the CCC references as well as this Catholic Answers tract.

On the confusion of doctrines and dogmas, see post 2 from this past CAF thread. In short, all doctrines are official teachings, but the dogmas (doctrines revealed formally and divinely that are essential to the faith) must be held by the faithful. All dogmas are doctrines but not all doctrines are dogmas.

Doctrines can change a bit. For instance, the concept of limbo was taught for a time (doctrine) but not formally established. It doesn’t mean that the teachings were wrong, per se, but time allows the Church to gain clarity on some matters with additional study. This teaching does not have to be held by the faithful. The belief that there was one human parent set, Adam and Eve, was revealed by God via Scripture and, as dogma, cannot change.

The invocation of papal infallibility is done very, very rarely, as the tract should note.
That is totally incorrect. Limbo for infants has NEVER been a Church doctrine. It was only ever a theological hypothesis. Catholics have never been obliged to accept it whereas we are obliged to accept all doctrines.
 
We must believe and adhere to everything in the “Catechism of the Catholic Church Second Edition” (dark green cover, first published in the USA in March 2000).

WHY ? ? ? — BECAUSE THE MAGISTERIUM OF THE CHURCH SAID SO. 👍

" ***The Catechism of the Catholic Church, which I have approved…and the publication of which I order by virtue of my Apostolic Authority, is a statement of the Church’s faith and of Catholic Doctrine,
attested to or illumined by Sacred Scripture, the Apostolic Tradition, and the Church’s Magisterium.
I declare it to be a sure norm for teaching the Faith and thus a valid and legitimate instrument for ecclesial communion." *** Pope John Paul II (pg 5, #3)

The Chairman of the Commission in charge of putting the CCC together was: Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger.

A couple of interesting definitions.

CCC - " 2089
Incredulity is the neglect of revealed truth or the willful refusal to assent to it.
Heresy is the obstinate post-baptismal denial of some truth which must be believed with divine and catholic faith, or it is likewise an obstinate doubt concerning the same; …
Schism is the refusal of submission to the Roman Pontiff or of communion with the members of the Church subject to him."
 
Thanks everyone, the material given has been really helpful.
Still, I find it hard to have “faith” in the Pope. I keep thinking “what if he makes a mistake”?
Say, for instance, that in a speech or papal document a doctrinal error is made - would this count against papal infallibility?
 
Thanks everyone, the material given has been really helpful.
Still, I find it hard to have “faith” in the Pope. I keep thinking “what if he makes a mistake”?
Say, for instance, that in a speech or papal document a doctrinal error is made - would this count against papal infallibility?
The papal infallibility is limited to specific circumstances and only to the topics of faith and morals. A pope can make a mistake during a speech. Just look at the comments from Benedict XVI on his own book “Jesus of Nazareth”, he clearly said that it was about his own reflections as an individual and it was not protected by papal infallibility.
 
I find it hard to have “faith” in the Pope. I keep thinking “what if he makes a mistake”?
May I suggest in all charity (I’m not poking fun of you or trying to be mean)—don’t worry about whether every single thing is technically infallible. You know it exists—for instance there is no debate in Catholicism on the Assumption, Trinity, Immaculate Conception, etc… So you don’t want to commit the sin of scrupulosity if you come across one that you are not sure is technically infallible. If you see a matter of faith and morals taught with consistency by the clergy, then worry not, and adhere to the teaching because it is worthy of belief. It is highly improbable that even the non-infallible teachings can be “wrong.” Such paranoia is typically characteristic of anti-Catholics who are trying to score a cheap hit against Catholics and make them question everything taught by the Church.* Kind of a devilish ploy, no doubt.

For instance, according to Dr. Ludwig Ott, the teaching that everyone has a guardian angels is not technically “infallible.” But it has been taught consistently by many priests and even referenced in Pope John Paul II’s Catechesis on the Angels. So what legitimate fear is there in assenting to the belief in guardian angels? But here’s more.

Take also the following example from Church teaching:*Religious submission of mind and of will must be shown in a special way to the authentic magisterium of the Roman Pontiff even when he is not defining… (Lumen Gentium, 25)*I also think it’s prudent to quote the late theologian Father William Most, who wrote on this issue when members of the Church are uncertain about this or that teaching:*How can anyone give any mental assent when there is not absolute certitude? In normal human affairs, we do it all the time. Suppose we are at table, and someone asks if a dish of food came from a can, and if so, was it sent to a lab to check for Botulism. It is true, routine opening of a can would not detect that deadly poison. Yet it is too much to check every can, and the chances are very remote, so much so that normal people do not bother about it - yet their belief takes into account a real but tiny possibility of a mistake. Similarly with a doctrine on this fourth level *. And further, the chances of error on this level are much smaller than they are with a can of food. Similarly, in a criminal trial, the judge will tell the jury they must find the evidence proves guilt beyond reasonable doubt. He does not demand that every tiny doubt be ruled out, even though it may mean life in prison or death.

If one should make a mistake* by following the fourth level of Church teaching, when he comes before the Divine Judge, the Judge will not blame him, rather He will praise him. But if a person errs by breaking with the Church on the plea that he knew better - that will not be easily accepted.In other words, is not God expecting you to have faith in His Church rather than scruple about the technical status of this or that teaching?

Even though they would consider the Bible “infallible” they themselves cannot get any consistency on what all the infallible teachings are or even the “essentials.”
 
…Take also the following example from Church teaching:*Religious submission of mind and of will must be shown in a special way to the authentic magisterium of the Roman Pontiff even when he is not defining… (Lumen Gentium, 25)*I also think it’s prudent to quote the late theologian Father William Most, who wrote on this issue when members of the Church are uncertain about this or that teaching:How can anyone give any mental assent when there is not absolute certitude? In normal human affairs, we do it all the time. Suppose we are at table, and someone asks if a dish of food came from a can, and if so, was it sent to a lab to check for Botulism. It is true, routine opening of a can would not detect that deadly poison. Yet it is too much to check every can, and the chances are very remote, so much so that normal people do not bother about it - yet their belief takes into account a real but tiny possibility of a mistake. Similarly with a doctrine on this fourth level *. And further, the chances of error on this level are much smaller than they are with a can of food. Similarly, in a criminal trial, the judge will tell the jury they must find the evidence proves guilt beyond reasonable doubt. He does not demand that every tiny doubt be ruled out, even though it may mean life in prison or death.

If one should make a mistake* by following the fourth level of Church teaching, when he comes before the Divine Judge, the Judge will not blame him, rather He will praise him. But if a person errs by breaking with the Church on the plea that he knew better - that will not be easily accepted.In other words, is not God expecting you to have faith in His Church rather than scruple about the technical status of this or that teaching?

*Even though they would consider the Bible “infallible” they themselves cannot get any consistency on what all the infallible teachings are or even the “essentials.”

Great reference to use in a catechism class, thanks! 👍
 
MarcoPolo:

Thanks for the advice. I think I understand now about infallibility. It is more about defining dogma than being someone who can only speak infallibly. It must be in the context of a definitive teaching.
 
Check tinyurl.com/2qon2 where you will find Ad Tuendam Fidem.

The CCC #88 (1997) clearly combines exactly with Pope John Paul’s Motu Proprio (= on his own authority) Apostolic Letter Ad Tuendam Fidem, 1998 (ATF), which requires the assent of divine and Catholic faith to believe (credenda sunt) dogmas (a category one truth) (Canon #750.1).

A category 2 truth requires the assent of ecclesial faith, as a secondary truth, “proposed definitively” (definitive proponuntur) to be “firmly embraced and held” (now Canon 750.2). In fact, the 1983 revision of Canon Law had replaced in #749.3 “dogmatically declared or defined” with “infallibly defined”, thus NOT expressing a limitation of infallibility to dogmas. ATF better enables Canon Law to apply to the understanding of infallibility with the Profession of Faith covering the two categories of infallible doctrine.

The category 3 truths are non-definitive (non-infallible) and require intellectual assent (“loyal submission of the will and intellect”, Vatican II, Lumen Gentium 25), not an assent of faith.

So you see that intellectual assent is mandated for non-infallible doctrine.

This reply is very useful:
**From EWTN Q&A: Answer by David Gregson on Nov-22-2002: **“You are correct in stating that the Pope exercises his charism of infallibility not only in dogmatic definitions issued, ex cathedra, as divinely revealed (of which there have been only two), but also in doctrines definitively proposed by him, also ex cathedra, which would include canonizations (that they are in fact Saints, enjoying the Beatific Vision in heaven), moral teachings (such as contained in Humanae vitae), and other doctrines he has taught as necessarily connected with truths divinely revealed, such as that priestly ordination is reserved to men.” [That last is the Apostolic Epistle *Ordinatio Sacerdotalis, from Blessed John Paul II].

In Casti Connubii of Pius XI, 1930, the doctrine against contraception, is also infallible.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top