W
wolfpup
Guest
I know that this questions has probably been asked a million times, but I am really confused.
How can we know the difference between an infallible dogma, a non-infallible doctrine? I understand what the differences are but it seems impossible to separate out at on a practical level which is which.
And then there is the fact that we must give religious assent to the teaching of the ordinary teaching of the magisterium rather than the assent of faith given to infallible dogma. And it seems that mistakes can be made in Papal letters and Ecumenical councils because only some of the teachings contained in them are infallible, some are apparently non-infallible doctrine.
If someone could give me a practical way of understanding, because right now I am completely confused. Basically what I am asking is: What teachings are Dogma and therefore will never change? What is doctrine and can it change, or be elevated to dogma, and how?
For example, is the teaching on contraception, trinity, incarnation all dogma? Can anyone point me to a doctrine that could change or even be dropped completly if defined further, and could the pope or a council make a mistake when pronouncing on these issues? Can a non-infallible doctrine be completley wrong?
How can we know the difference between an infallible dogma, a non-infallible doctrine? I understand what the differences are but it seems impossible to separate out at on a practical level which is which.
And then there is the fact that we must give religious assent to the teaching of the ordinary teaching of the magisterium rather than the assent of faith given to infallible dogma. And it seems that mistakes can be made in Papal letters and Ecumenical councils because only some of the teachings contained in them are infallible, some are apparently non-infallible doctrine.
If someone could give me a practical way of understanding, because right now I am completely confused. Basically what I am asking is: What teachings are Dogma and therefore will never change? What is doctrine and can it change, or be elevated to dogma, and how?
For example, is the teaching on contraception, trinity, incarnation all dogma? Can anyone point me to a doctrine that could change or even be dropped completly if defined further, and could the pope or a council make a mistake when pronouncing on these issues? Can a non-infallible doctrine be completley wrong?