Really confused needing some help

  • Thread starter Thread starter jet100
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Excuse me, please, I respectfully disagree.
Considering the state of religious life today
and the fact that jett is not yet a Catholic
and is very vey young, it seems far more likely
that her notions of today re any future vocation
are related to her youthful imaginings and desires.

I’ve read many many of her posts in her public profile.
While it’s wonderful that there is a certainty in her that her desire
is to serve God in the best possible way, it’s much too soon - considering
her age, her upbringing, her history and her mixed feelings that any
of us should be willing to confirm a religious.

Before a full conversion there is no one in any community of Sisters
who would or could offer the encouragement of a religious vocation.
This young woman has moved through a number of churches.
Her family opposes her spiritual life in every way.

After conversion, after her entry into the Catholic Church,
there is unlimited time available for her to consider choices about “vocation.”
You make me sound crazy. I haven’t moved through a bunch of churches. Its common in the protestant denomination to change churches when you move out of town… Methodist and presbyterian is very similar…
I know that I can’t join a order until i’m way into my 20s. I still openly discern this possibly in my life. You are talking like i’m unstable… If I had my choice right now I would gladly go down to my catholic parish and start RCIA classes. I don’t have that choice. I’m trapped in my home… I can’t go where I want to go, or go to town if I feel like it. I am in the middle of nowhere. Closes catholic church is 40mins away and its all back roads rural land. you can’t walk or take a taxi…
Ive had 6years of intense bible study. My Grandfather was a gideon missionary… He did wonderful work.
I know you are being brutually honest. But please don’t make ideas about me that makes people think i’m unable or crazy to be thinking these dreams.
They didn’t just pop in my mind. I didn’t ask to be different and have this calling to become catholic and the idea of a nun. I’ve been so afraid of it for many years. I’ve just been finally brave enough to accept it.
I truly believe this is a gift from god 🙂
 
Nineteen is not too young to be thinking about the religious vocation. It’s a good age to be thinking about vocation. St. Therese of Lisieux became a nun at the age of 15 and felt her call to the religious life many years before. I think she felt her call to the religious vocation at the age of 9, something like that. My grandparents got married in their late teens and lived a happy marriage all the way to today. The religious vocation is as serious as marriage. Successful religious discernment can happen that young, though obviously Jet100 isn’t even going to be allowed to join an order for three years after her Confirmation, so she’ll have plenty more time to think about it.

According to the Center for Applied Research in the Apostolate at Georgetown University, 2% of all consecrated men and women religious are under the age of 20. And that’s people who are already religious who are that young. Pastors often encourage teenagers to think about the possibility of a religious vocation, and every religious order I’ve looked at in my own personal vocation search has said that 24 or 25 is a wonderful age to join an order. Seeing as Jet100 is almost 20 now and one has to wait for 3 years after Confirmation before the Church allows a person to join an order, she’s doing fine.

Pope Benedict XVI said to the youth at Malta, “In this Year for Priests, I ask you to be open to the possibility that the Lord may be calling some of you to give yourselves totally to the service of his people in the priesthood or the consecrated life. Your country has given many fine priests and religious to the Church. Be inspired by their example, and recognize the profound joy that comes from dedicating one’s life to spreading the message of God’s love for all people, without exception.” He encouraged them to be open to the religious life. He didn’t think they were too young to be thinking about such things.

Thinking and planning for what one is going to do with one’s life is completely fine at any age. I agree that teenage years are young to be deciding such things, in general, but that doesn’t mean one shouldn’t be thinking about them and discerning :). And Jet100 is a young adult, not a young teen like Therese of Lisieux was (though Therese followed Christ’s will truly in her vocation search).

There’s a lot of variety amongst the different religious orders. Some are doing better than others.

I don’t see the relevance of that. Why should their enmity to Catholicism have a bearing on her vocation?

I don’t know anything about this. But if she has feelings like that, they are something for her and her priest to deal with, and she has years ahead of her to do so before she’d be accepted into a formation program. I’m not in a position to make any judgment on her mindset based on this.

It’s fine for people of any age to be thinking about what they want to do with their life. Thinking about it and making final decisions are two different things.

So do many people on their way into conversion. I fully agree with you about the importance of faith formation and becoming better informed at this stage, as I said in my last post. This is very important.

Anyway, these are just my thoughts on the matter, and they are what I believe, though I know I might be wrong.
Lief, I figured you’d respond. Good.
I also figured you’d mention Therese of Lisieux. Fine.

The issue for jett is not (only) becoming better “informed.”
The greater issue is becoming “formed” in the Catholic faith.

Therese was raised in the Catholic faith by parents who are now been beatified.
catholicnewsagency.com/news/parents_of_st._therese_of_lisieux_to_be_beatified_in_france/

I can and do recommend that jett learn much about Therese of Lisieux.
Then jett’s own life and history as a Catholic is better embraced as it grows.

Yes, I have read many of jett’s previous posts.
Her life has been filled with great turmoil.
Any authority within the Church would recommend that
she take plenty of time to grow in faith and stability
before she undertake the challenges of discerning any vocation.
 
My Mom is anti catholic, but she loves God and Jesus… She’s a christian and raised in a strict protestant home. She just is close minded when it comes to the catholic church… She isn’t a devoted christian, like I am… She prefers to keep her faith hidden… I was raised with a strict christian upbringing. It may have not been catholic faith like everybody elses. But I do have good morals, and I know my bible. Thats why i’m having this conversion of the heart to the catholic church…
 
My Mom is anti catholic, but she loves God and Jesus… She’s a christian and raised in a strict protestant home. She just is close minded when it comes to the catholic church… She isn’t a devoted christian, like I am… She prefers to keep her faith hidden… I was raised with a strict christian upbringing. It may have not been catholic faith like everybody elses. But I do have good morals, and I know my bible. Thats why i’m having this conversion of the heart to the catholic church…
I have no doubt at all that you love God and live a good life.
My point is this: when you are a Catholic, THEN take a look at vocation.

Also, you might appreciate the life of St. Edith Stein, another convert and Carmelite nun.
 
I think that if God has placed a desire for religious life in your heart, there’s nothing wrong with thinking about it before you become Catholic. As you said, the reason you’re not Catholic yet is because of your family situation, which is totally understandable. God knows the road upon which He’s leading you, and if He’s placed a desire to be a nun in your heart, there must be a reason for this, even if it’s just to bring you closer to Him. Of course discerning a vocation takes time, but I don’t think it’s wrong to think about it before your conversion… I did too. God bless 🙂
 
I feel called to religious life for my love for God. I’ve always been so in love with him, I would write love letters to him. talk to him all day, I love going to church and worshiping him, I love working for him, and I love dedicating my whole life to the church and him.

Marriage life. I would love to have the white picket fence, babies, catholic home, my own garden, a little house in town, I would be able to keep my job, be near my family and work in my parish.
These are the beautiful sides of both vocations, and they are very real. Just don’t forget the other side. In religious life you have to deal with loneliness, boredom, clashing personalities, work that may not suit you, spiritual dryness… In marriage, there are arguments with your spouse, dirty floors, poopy diapers, bills you can’t pay, kids sick at 3 a.m., and so on.

Be sure to be realistic when you think of both vocational possibilities. Take your time and listen for God.

Betsy
 
These are the beautiful sides of both vocations, and they are very real. Just don’t forget the other side. In religious life you have to deal with loneliness, boredom, clashing personalities, work that may not suit you, spiritual dryness… In marriage, there are arguments with your spouse, dirty floors, poopy diapers, bills you can’t pay, kids sick at 3 a.m., and so on.

Be sure to be realistic when you think of both vocational possibilities. Take your time and listen for God.

Betsy
Ahhhhh - YES.
Thank you, betsy
 
These are the beautiful sides of both vocations, and they are very real. Just don’t forget the other side. In religious life you have to deal with loneliness, boredom, clashing personalities, work that may not suit you, spiritual dryness… In marriage, there are arguments with your spouse, dirty floors, poopy diapers, bills you can’t pay, kids sick at 3 a.m., and so on.

Be sure to be realistic when you think of both vocational possibilities. Take your time and listen for God.

Betsy
Wow. I have been married for over eleven years and now I am wondering about being married. Holy moly! You make both vocations sound incredibly horrible. Jet, even the worse day of marriage is the best day of my life. I can only hope that had I pursued a religious vocation, then I would feel the same way. Life, and your vocation, is what you make it. I don’t think you are crazy either. Just take a deep breath and listen for God. I’ll keep you in my prayers.
 
There’s nothing wrong with thinking about a religious vocation before one converts, especially if one’s conversion is being postponed for reasons outside one’s control. Are we young folks not allowed to think about our futures? 🤷 We just have to be patient and open to God’s will and remember it is ultimately in His hands.

And jet, I don’t think you sound crazy. I can identify a lot with your story. A difficult childhood and young adulthood can lead to emotional instability, but it doesn’t always and it shouldn’t be assumed that someone is unstable just because they’ve suffered. And nothing gives better stability than a strong faith.

Don’t give up, God is leading you. Please pray for me and I will pray for you, too.
 
I have two more years of Nursing school. I want to become a medical missionary before I decide to join a order. I want to work with a catholic mission group… I want to help the poor and suffering.

the priest is a hermit who runs Our Lady shrine. He emails me and calls me. I tell him everything and he guides me well… dear friend to my heart.

ourladyofsouthcarolina.net/

thats the shrine in my town he runs 🙂
that’s wonderful that you found a good priest to guide you!! 🙂
There’s nothing wrong with thinking about a religious vocation before one converts, especially if one’s conversion is being postponed for reasons outside one’s control. Are we young folks not allowed to think about our futures? 🤷 We just have to be patient and open to God’s will and remember it is ultimately in His hands.

And jet, I don’t think you sound crazy. I can identify a lot with your story. A difficult childhood and young adulthood can lead to emotional instability, but it doesn’t always and it shouldn’t be assumed that someone is unstable just because they’ve suffered. And nothing gives better stability than a strong faith.

Don’t give up, God is leading you. Please pray for me and I will pray for you, too.
I agree with this 🙂 and often God uses our past or a difficult childhood to lead us closer to Him. I know He did this with me too.

God bless
 
Wow. I have been married for over eleven years and now I am wondering about being married. Holy moly! You make both vocations sound incredibly horrible. Jet, even the worse day of marriage is the best day of my life. I can only hope that had I pursued a religious vocation, then I would feel the same way. Life, and your vocation, is what you make it. I don’t think you are crazy either. Just take a deep breath and listen for God. I’ll keep you in my prayers.
If you read the OP’s description of both religious life and marriage, you will find two idealized, romanticized descriptions of life, neither of which include any difficulties at all. Surely, each vocation has moments like those, hopefully many of them. But every light has a shadow, and these vocations also have dark times. I wouldn’t want Jet to go into either of them with her eyes closed, only to be shocked when reality hits.
 
If you read the OP’s description of both religious life and marriage, you will find two idealized, romanticized descriptions of life, neither of which include any difficulties at all. Surely, each vocation has moments like those, hopefully many of them. But every light has a shadow, and these vocations also have dark times. I wouldn’t want Jet to go into either of them with her eyes closed, only to be shocked when reality hits.
re bolded above: yes, completely agree - and
therefore, my caution re necessary maturity.
 
I want to close this thread. I don’t like someone saying I lack maturity.I have a learning disbility and I can’t help that I come off slow or inmature in my post. My writing skills are very poor and I can’t help it.so please don’t judge me for my writing… I’ve had to grow up alot in my life… Yes I know about spiritual dryness, loneliness and pain… I have bear so much pain in my life. I wouldn’t wish it on anybody else… All my suffering has brought me to Jesus and the church… I don’t have a choice right now about converting. I have converted of the heart but not offically. I won’t be able to make it offical for some time…Yes I do have a reality check everyday when people tell me the catholic church is cult, or nun are mean and no fun… It shows how ignorant people are about stuff… I pray for them thats all I can do.
So I have had my fair share of reality checks… I know both marriage life and religious life are hard and sometimes not fun… But I trust God and i’m patiently waiting on him…

Caterina. I am closing this post, because all I get is negative words… I am tired of getting my feelings hurt by your post. It makes it sound like you make me unstable,crazy and very unwelcoming to the catholic faith… God bless! I will pray for you…
 
I want to close this thread. I don’t like someone saying I lack maturity.I have a learning disbility and I can’t help that I come off slow or inmature in my post. My writing skills are very poor and I can’t help it.so please don’t judge me for my writing… I’ve had to grow up alot in my life… Yes I know about spiritual dryness, loneliness and pain… I have bear so much pain in my life. I wouldn’t wish it on anybody else… All my suffering has brought me to Jesus and the church… I don’t have a choice right now about converting. I have converted of the heart but not offically. I won’t be able to make it offical for some time…Yes I do have a reality check everyday when people tell me the catholic church is cult, or nun are mean and no fun… It shows how ignorant people are about stuff… I pray for them thats all I can do.
So I have had my fair share of reality checks… I know both marriage life and religious life are hard and sometimes not fun… But I trust God and i’m patiently waiting on him…

Caterina. I am closing this post, because all I get is negative words… I am tired of getting my feelings hurt by your post. It makes it sound like you make me unstable,crazy and very unwelcoming to the catholic faith… God bless! I will pray for you…
Look. You are over-personalizing this.
I’m 64 yrs old. I think EVERY 19 yr-old is immature.
Doesn’t that make perfect sense to you?

It has NOTHING to do with slamming you.
A 19 yr-old, male or female, is very young and quite immature.
That is my humble (and informed) opinion.

PS - I’ve been praying for you too.
 
Hi,
I’m always loved God so much. I want complete intimacy with him and I love him so much!! He’s my life and constant. I feel like marrying wouldn’t be fulfilling my vocation to him or serving him enough.
I’m in love with two men and I don’t know what to do 🙂 two persons who mean the world to me…

Please help and explain this to me,

Cameron
Hey. PLEASE believe me when I tell you that marriage, done right, as a sacrament with God as the center of your lives brings you SO MUCH closer to God than you could ever imagine. The love you have for your husband IS your love for God because God brought that wonderful man into your life and feels that love withyou both and eventually withyour children.
When I went to Catholic school, I was informed by a teacher that almost all young (Catholic) girls at some point want to become nuns. I did. Why wouldn’t we? God is SO far beyond any mere man… right? Yes.
BUT. The super-cool thing about marriage is you CAN have your cake and eat it too. The only real potential issue is that in marriage, yes God comes first, but then your FAMILY comes next; this supercedes church and volunteer activities often, but that is God’s plan.
The most comforting thought you may have is that whichever you choose, God will turn it to the good.
God be with you AND your family.
 
I want to close this thread. I don’t like someone saying I lack maturity.I have a learning disbility and I can’t help that I come off slow or inmature in my post. My writing skills are very poor and I can’t help it.so please don’t judge me for my writing… I’ve had to grow up alot in my life… Yes I know about spiritual dryness, loneliness and pain… I have bear so much pain in my life. I wouldn’t wish it on anybody else… All my suffering has brought me to Jesus and the church… I don’t have a choice right now about converting. I have converted of the heart but not offically. I won’t be able to make it offical for some time…Yes I do have a reality check everyday when people tell me the catholic church is cult, or nun are mean and no fun… It shows how ignorant people are about stuff… I pray for them thats all I can do.
So I have had my fair share of reality checks… I know both marriage life and religious life are hard and sometimes not fun… But I trust God and i’m patiently waiting on him…

Caterina. I am closing this post, because all I get is negative words… I am tired of getting my feelings hurt by your post. It makes it sound like you make me unstable,crazy and very unwelcoming to the catholic faith… God bless! I will pray for you…
PS - in regard to your own life, clearly it’s been very stressful. Unusually stressful.
Any religious community would tell you to “take your time” in considering vocations.
 
PS - in regard to your own life, clearly it’s been very stressful. Unusually stressful.
Any religious community would tell you to “take your time” in considering vocations.
She HAS to take her time because she is unable to convert immediately and will then have a waiting period of at least a couple years before she can enter religious life. So why do you feel the need to keep telling her that? There is absolutely nothing wrong with her thinking and praying about her vocation now. And I really wish you would stop using the whole “you’ve had such a hard life therefore you must be incapable of making decisions” tone.

Sorry for prolonging the thread against the OP’s wishes …
 
She HAS to take her time because she is unable to convert immediately and will then have a waiting period of at least a couple years before she can enter religious life. So why do you feel the need to keep telling her that? There is absolutely nothing wrong with her thinking and praying about her vocation now. And I really wish you would stop using the whole “you’ve had such a hard life therefore you must be incapable of making decisions” tone.

Sorry for prolonging the thread against the OP’s wishes …
Yes, I’m sorry you’re doing that too.

I’m saying she is very young. She is.
The greater issue is youth.
Another issue is difficulties in her life.

Those are two BIG issues.
Check it out with any Novice Mistress.
 
Hi! 👋
I want to say that I support Cam’s vocation 100%. I’m in discernment to religious life too. She is my best friend and I know that she wants to become Catholic. I want to say that through my discernment I can see that this to vocations involve sacrifice. But at the end, according to the love we have provided, this can lead us to eternal life. Discerning a vocation isn’t easy it consists of much prayer and being with God.
I disagree with the negative comments. Remember that God made us in His image and likeness. He has a purpose in life with each of us. It is true that the convent / monastery with your requirements and take a test that the person who wishes to enter. The most important thing is that the person has a vocation, the desire to serve the Lord.
We had a lot of examples that youth isn’t lost. Is true many teens don’t like go to church but we are a lot we go. And also participate on youth groups or another good activities. But the media rarely talk about positive things unfortunately. Being young doesn’t necessarily mean do bad things.

Please pray for our discernment and for the for the sake of youth.

God bless you all!

Lilli 😉

anunslife.org
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top