Receiving Communion Question

  • Thread starter Thread starter MainBrain
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

MainBrain

Guest
I have not gone to confession in some time. I am due.
Since it’s Easter Sunday I am bringing my family to Mass. I am not going to receive Holy Communion since I have not gone to confession. What should I do in this circumstance? Should I remain seated or should I go up and cross my arms on my chest, bow my head, and abstain from receiving the Sacrament? And what is behind that practice?
Thank you.
 
You should remain seated in the pew and make a spiritual act of Communion when the priest receives Communion.
 
It,s so sad to hear that you haven,t gone to confession ,that you won,t be able receive
Jesus who we will receive on,Easter Sunday .I would say to stay in your seat, and pray the pray,that people who can,t go up receive Communion.
I will pray, that you repent ,and that Jesus will bring you closer,s too him.
 
remain kneeling & pray while those who can, do receive communion

but you’ll’ve had to have gotten up from the kneeler & be seated while people return to their seats after having had received communion
 
I have not gone to confession in some time. I am due.
Since it’s Easter Sunday I am bringing my family to Mass. I am not going to receive Holy Communion since I have not gone to confession. What should I do in this circumstance? Should I remain seated or should I go up and cross my arms on my chest, bow my head, and abstain from receiving the Sacrament? And what is behind that practice?
Thank you.
If you go to the priest, yes you can receive a Blessing. Only a priest or a Deacon can do this. Better than nothing and you can still make a Spiritual Communion in your pew. Ask Our Lord to come into your heart Spiritually and help you be more faithful. Also if your family is not going to receive, maybe it would be better to stay setting so they won’t get confused and follow you, unless they are in the State of Grace. Or if you explain the Blessing. The Sunday after Easter is Divine Mercy Sunday, so if you can go to Confession the week before and receive Communion on that Sunday, there will be many graces waiting for you. Many Churches have a special Divine Mercy Mass on that Sunday also. God Bless, Memaw
 
Stay in the people. Pray . Be at peace. There are many people who don’t receive for whatever reason.
 
I have not gone to confession in some time. I am due.
Since it’s Easter Sunday I am bringing my family to Mass. I am not going to receive Holy Communion since I have not gone to confession. What should I do in this circumstance? Should I remain seated or should I go up and cross my arms on my chest, bow my head, and abstain from receiving the Sacrament? And what is behind that practice?
Thank you.
This is really a question that admits of no universal answer on the Internet. In Europe, you would be welcomed and even encouraged to come forward for a blessing. In reading and talking with the American bishops, there are some dioceses where the bishop has forbidden the giving of individual blessings. There are other dioceses, such as New York City, where it is tolerated but not encouraged with any enthusiasm and is limited to a cleric imparting the blessing. There are other dioceses where the Extraordinary Ministers are specifically directed by the bishop to also give a blessing.

The diocesan bishop is the moderator of the liturgy for his diocese. I know the dubium on this issue was submitted many years ago to the Holy See. In fact, I also know a number of bishops were asking if we could have a resolution to this at the time of the Synod on the Eucharist in 2005…the request was even put into the lineamenta. Who knows? One day it may be answered.

It would be wholly inappropriate for me to offer any critique of these three very diverse approaches, since the decision is the bishop’s. If you are not motivated to seek an individual blessing, you should feel perfectly comfortable to stay in your place. If, on the other hand, you wish to receive a blessing when others go forward for Communion, I would encourage you to inquire beforehand what is the prescription (or proscription) that governs this matter for your diocese. It would only take a moment before Mass to ask the priest or deacon (Can one come forward for a blessing at Communion time?)…the answer will likely be a very simple “yes” or “no”.
 
This is really a question that admits of no universal answer on the Internet. In Europe, you would be welcomed and even encouraged to come forward for a blessing. In reading and talking with the American bishops, there are some dioceses where the bishop has forbidden the giving of individual blessings. There are other dioceses, such as New York City, where it is tolerated but not encouraged with any enthusiasm and is limited to a cleric imparting the blessing. There are other dioceses where the Extraordinary Ministers are specifically directed by the bishop to also give a blessing.

The diocesan bishop is the moderator of the liturgy for his diocese. I know the dubium on this issue was submitted many years ago to the Holy See. In fact, I also know a number of bishops were asking if we could have a resolution to this at the time of the Synod on the Eucharist in 2005…the request was even put into the lineamenta. Who knows? One day it may be answered.

It would be wholly inappropriate for me to offer any critique of these three very diverse approaches, since the decision is the bishop’s. If you are not motivated to seek an individual blessing, you should feel perfectly comfortable to stay in your place. If, on the other hand, you wish to receive a blessing when others go forward for Communion, I would encourage you to inquire beforehand what is the prescription (or proscription) that governs this matter for your diocese. It would only take a moment before Mass to ask the priest or deacon (Can one come forward for a blessing at Communion time?)…the answer will likely be a very simple “yes” or “no”.
A lay person cannot give a Blessing the same as a priest or deacon could. If they do it would only be such as a parent gives a child etc. Not an official Blessing. Catholic answers speaker says it should not be done at all by a layperson. We are not to try to take over a priests work. God Bless, Memaw
 
A lay person cannot give a Blessing the same as a priest or deacon could. If they do it would only be such as a parent gives a child etc. Not an official Blessing. Catholic answers speaker says it should not be done at all by a layperson. We are not to try to take over a priests work. God Bless, Memaw
I have every confidence that the Catholic Answers Forum would not oppose the directive of His Excellency, the Bishop of Saint Petersburg in the United States, and all his brother bishops who have made determination of what Extraordinary Ministers of the Eucharist are permitted to do and not permitted to do in their own diocese. I trust that Catholic Answers would affirm such directives from diocesan bishops who are using their proper and ordinary authority to govern the liturgy and its execution for the territory of their own respective dioceses.
*Blessing by an Extraordinary Minister of Holy Communion

Question: Can an Extraordinary Minister of Holy Communion (EMHC) give a blessing to a person who comes to them in the communion line with arms crossed?

Answer: The answer is yes.*
dosp.org/worship/wp-content/uploads/sites/28/Can-an-Extraordinary-Minister-of-Communion-give-a-blessing.pdf
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top