Y
YosefYosep
Guest
What exactly is the sin that occurs when one receives the Eucharist in mortal sin? Why is it considered a mortal sin to receive in a state of mortal sin?
It’s considered an act of desecration. It’s as if one threw the Eucharist on the ground.What exactly is the sin that occurs when one receives the Eucharist in mortal sin? Why is it considered a mortal sin to receive in a state of mortal sin?
If a wife is on the pill or is using an IUD and has no intention of stopping, is it a sacrilege for her to receive the Eucharist? Is it a sacrilege for the husband if he agrees to her using ABC? Don’t the majority of American Roman Catholic families use ABC?It is the sin of sacrilege. You are desecrating the Body of Christ when you receive Him in a state of serious sin.
Don’t even go there with this topic to an internet forum…a trusted priest or spiritual directors is who you should address this to, so you can not only get a good answer, but also appropriate spiritual advice and counseling.If a wife is on the pill or is using an IUD and has no intention of stopping, is it a sacrilege for her to receive the Eucharist? Is it a sacrilege for the husband if he agrees to her using ABC? Don’t the majority of American Roman Catholic families use ABC?
We don’t know. I know couples who were sterilized because they didn’t know better, then when they found out had great remorse, even to the point of looking into a vasectomy reversal. We can’t judge our brothers and sisters in the pews, and it’s not good for us to judge them. We all have our faults and challenges.Don’t the majority of American Roman Catholic families use ABC?
We don’t? You don’t trust any of the polls that have been taken on this subject? In a poll taken on August 11, 1993, 82 percent of Catholics said one can use artificial birth control “and still be a good Catholic.”We don’t know.
There are practicing Catholics and there are non-practicing Catholics.If a wife is on the pill or is using an IUD and has no intention of stopping, is it a sacrilege for her to receive the Eucharist? Is it a sacrilege for the husband if he agrees to her using ABC? Don’t the majority of American Roman Catholic families use ABC?
That is different from saying that we don’t know if a majority of American or European married Roman Catholics use ABC.Personally I don’t care to advertise the fact that 80 or 90% of Catholic couples have no problem with birth control …
Well you don’t unless you have interviewed the majority of Catholics in America and Europe.That is different from saying that we don’t know if a majority of American or European married Roman Catholics use ABC.
Since when has random sampling been thought to be nonsense by the scientific community?Well you don’t unless you have interviewed the majority of Catholics in America and Europe.
Many polls are nonsense because they speak to few people (maybe a couple of thousand) which does not mean the majority. Also, many polls are done by people with an anti-Catholic agenda.
In short you cannot state as a fact what you claim to know.
Why are you derailing this thread? The question at hand has to do with receiving the Eucharist while in the state of mortal sin. It’s not about judging who is in any state of sin nor is it about polls and stats.Since when has random sampling been thought to be nonsense by the scientific community?