@Peeps I don’t know whether the situation is hugely different in the United States, but the distinction that you draw between teenagers who have and have not enjoyed the benefits of a classical education seems rather stark.
I am lucky to live and work in Cambridge, where we have one of the most famous universities in the world. 52% of students at Cambridge attended private schools or grammar schools; 48% attended non-selective state schools. The number of non-selective state schools which offer a classical education is vanishingly small. At best, a handful of students may have the opportunity to learn rudimentary Latin and to read some classical texts in translation. Even when one considers the private schools and grammar schools, the state of classical education is not much better. Of course, there are the great public schools, such as Eton, Harrow, Winchester, Westminster, and St Paul’s, but these are by no means representative. At most private schools and grammar schools, Latin is compulsory for perhaps one year. Therefore, the vast majority of students in those schools will receive no more than one year of Latin and no Greek at all. Indeed, in the whole of England and Wales, the number of students studying Greek through to leaving school at 18 stands at around 250 per year. My point is that here in Cambridge we have over 20,000 students, who are among the brightest young people in the country, if not the world, and perhaps 500 or 1,000 of them are classically educated.
As I say, the situation may be different in the United States. It may be that it is as stark as you say. Perhaps there is one cohort of young people who have enjoyed the benefits of a classical education and another which comprises barely functional human beings.
As a PS to the OP, I would also mention:
- The Post Follows Katharine Graham, publisher of The Washington Post, as she is required to make a heroic decision while standing virtually alone.
- Spotlight Somewhat similar to The Post in that it is about a newspaper uncovering crime and corruption on a vast scale. The journalists involved do not quite stand alone, but they do have to stand up to powerful institutions and fight for the truth to come out.