
I really hoped this would not just descend into a working vs SAHM thread. That debate has been done to the death already.
Judging by the lack of gentlemen commenting on this thread (

it’s okay - you can join in!) it seems women are their own harshest critics. Maybe the real problem is that we worry too much about what others might think and read too much into throwaway comments.
For example, when I was single, I still loved to cook and eat well. A married colleague once looked in my lunchbox and said, “I don’t know why you bother when it’s just you!” I let that observation really upset me, because I chose to read into it that Mrs. Worthy-Married was suggesting I didn’t deserve to eat well because I was single.
A few other comments I had as a singleton that I can now snigger at, but actually upset me at the time:
- I took in a rescue-dog - “Well, I suppose he’s company for you!”
- I made regular trips away as a volunteer with search and rescue - “Well, if you had a family, you couldn’t do that!”
- I got engaged - “Well - I bet your mother is relieved!”
I admit,I fell about laughing at that one right in front of the lady who said it!!
The thing is, whatever path we choose in life, whether we actually have much of a choice or not, mean-spirited and thoughtless individuals exist who find it impossible to say, “well done” or “good for you” if they can get some observation in about the way you choose to live first.
On the flip side, there are articles like the ones I originally described, where the women involved

rolleyes:I feel like a broken record now) came accross as so self-congratulatory and smug when all they had done was take advantage of the company’s felxible working options. What is more, there was a real current of ‘it was right for
me’. For the record, if a lady had written, “I went back to work when my child was 6 months old and I found that the time I spent with my little boy / girl became more precious and I think, more rewarding for
both of us” then that shows some acknowledgement that the writer is part of a family unit and taking responsibility for the life she and her husband have chosen to bring into the world.
I don’t believe any scenario for the working / non-working mother demands more or less respect just because of the situation itself: in all cases, surely it’s about how the woman in question makes the best of it and does all she can to ensure her children’s welbeing is not compromised?
I do firmly believe that if you have children, they are your (and your husband’s) responsibility and I make no apology for holding the view that compromising one’s career plans or lifestyle aspirations should be a given
if that is what is required to ensure you child receives
the best care you can provide.

Of course, the nub of that is, “the best care you can provide” and this is a very personal concept. For some, it means SAHM and for others, it doesn’t! However, once we start playing at ‘worthier than thou’ it just makes everyone feel judged and miserable.
I still maintain - and always will - that the best way to celebrate IWD is not by presenting smug & selfish as the way forward for women because that is precisely how the women I am refering to came accross. They certainly do exist and there are a good number in the UK. If you don’t believe me - take a look at Mail Online sometime