Reformed Catholic = Calvinist

  • Thread starter Thread starter mrs_abbott
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

mrs_abbott

Guest
I have recently been in debate with a reformed Catholic that says he’s a Calvinist?
Is there a difference?
Also, he’s VERY well-versed in church history and thinks that the Church of Rome is corrupt and deceitful. How do I counter that?
I can post some things that he has said to me, if that would help more. I’m just not a good apologist when someone is more knowledgable on history and such than I am. 😦
 
Here’s one of his responses:

I oppose Romanism, like I do all false religions trying to claim to be Christian, when they are deceivers for the same reason as Paul did when he opposed the false prophets and deceivers of his day. Out of love for God and His Truth, out of love for the sheep of Christ and out of love for those who are trapped in the darkness of the cult of Roman Catholicism.

If you want more, I can get more responses from him.
 
I have recently been in debate with a reformed Catholic that says he’s a Calvinist?
“Reformed Catholic” is one way that traditional, historically minded, high-church Calvinists often refer to themselves (some non-Calvinist Protestants do as well). It can mean a lot of things, but basically it means that they see themselves in continuity with the historic Christian faith before the Reformation. They argue that the Reformation was a needed reform *within *the historic Catholic Church, which Rome unfortunately rejected. As a Reformation scholar, I know a lot of folks who take this view. I would be happy to address any specifics this guy raised.

I’m an Anglican, and we can perhaps make the “Reformed Catholic” claim better than most. But that’s another issue, since this guy is not Anglican! And I’m suspicious of the general category of “reform.” It usually turns out to be a cure that’s worse than the disease. But that’s another issue again!

Edwin
 
Here’s one of his responses:

I oppose Romanism, like I do all false religions trying to claim to be Christian, when they are deceivers for the same reason as Paul did when he opposed the false prophets and deceivers of his day. Out of love for God and His Truth, out of love for the sheep of Christ and out of love for those who are trapped in the darkness of the cult of Roman Catholicism.

If you want more, I can get more responses from him.
That’s just rhetoric. What are his substantive points?

This is by the way much harsher than the language I usually hear from folks who call themselves “Reformed Catholic.” But as I said the term can mean a lot of things. Try to get some substance. Just what does he mean by Catholic? How does he see the relationship of his tradition to pre-Reformation Christianity? If he thinks “Roman Catholicism” is so completely false, how does he view medieval Christianity? How about the Church Fathers? You can point him to the Reformed church historian Philip Schaff, who argues that in many ways the common belief and practice of 4th-century Christianity was worse (with regard to issues like saint veneration) than the official teaching of the Council of Trent.

Edwin
 
Here’s his biography of his religious travels:

*Some 12 years ago, when God yanked me out of the fires of hell, regenerated my stone heart, reconstituted my self serving, unwilling will to being willing to believe, trust, love and obey Christ, I became immersed in Scripture, like a man dying of thirst in a desert who comes across a bottomless well of refreshing, life sustaining cool water.

Also, having once been a philosophy student in college, and always interested in world religions, as well as being a life long student of history, I was aware of the various groups claiming to be THE representative of Christ, claiming to be preaching and teaching the truth, one of them being Roman Catholicism, as well as Episcopalians, Eastern and Russian Orthodox, Protestants, including Lutherans, Calvinists, Baptists and Methodists, but also including other sects such as Mormons, Oneness Pentecostals, Jehovah’s Witnesses, etc.

Understanding that the consequences of what one believes are of an eternal nature, I wanted to know just who, or which group was continuing in the Gospel and doctrines preached and taught by Christ, the Apostles and the earliest Christians.

Now, understand this clearly for it is important.

At that time, I was objectively looking for which was right, and it did not matter which one. At the time I was attending a non-denominational congregation and had no firm commitment to it, and if anything, actually challenged them on some things they taught which were not in agreement with the Scriptures.

So, along with my Biblical studies, I also became immersed in studying the history of the early church, a topic I still find fascinating and encouraging, as well as began reading and studying the writings and teachings of the early church fathers, beginning with those who were the direct disciples of the Apostles themselves.

You see, I wanted to know if what groups were claiming were true or not, and whether they were in alignment with the Scriptures, and the doctrines and practices of those earliest Christians. I wanted to know the truth of the matter.

Now, getting to the point as it pertains to Roman Catholicism.

Considering the claims of Rome since the medieval period forward, that carried dire, eternal consequences if not agreed with, according to Rome, I took it very, very seriously, for if what Rome claimed was true, and it was indeed the one, true church, with rejection of it and the pope and Roman Catholic dogmas meaning eternity in hell, again I took very seriously and wanted to be absolutely sure, without any hint of any doubt whatsoever, whether Rome’s teachings, practices and claims were true or not.

I was determined that if they proved to be true, that I would join the Roman Catholic church.

If they proved not to be true, then I would not.

So, after many years of diligent, concentrated, laborious study and being open to whatever the evidence led to, whichever way it led, it became indisputably clear, based on the evidence, that the Roman Catholic church began deviating from the Christianity of the Bible, that which was preached and taught by Jesus, the Apostles and the early Church during the middle ages, and as error crept in, which begat more error, which expotentially grew into rank heresies, and as the Roman church became a religious/political system with it’s popes and clergy being consumed by personal power, that by the time of the Lateran IV Council, Roman Catholicism had devolved into a totally separate religion from Christianity.

I truly wish that had not been the case, but the facts are the facts.

If you would like to discuss some of the details using this function, rather than on the boards, so that the boards are not cluttered with our personal discussions and questions you will have that are off topic for the threads, I would be most open to that, and would welcome the opportunity to do so.

Again, it was my quest for the truth that led me to thorughly investigate all the claims of all the various groups, and not just Roman Catholicism, but since this board is about Roman Catholicism, there is no need to discuss the others.*
 
That’s just rhetoric. What are his substantive points?

This is by the way much harsher than the language I usually hear from folks who call themselves “Reformed Catholic.” But as I said the term can mean a lot of things. Try to get some substance. Just what does he mean by Catholic? How does he see the relationship of his tradition to pre-Reformation Christianity? If he thinks “Roman Catholicism” is so completely false, how does he view medieval Christianity? How about the Church Fathers? You can point him to the Reformed church historian Philip Schaff, who argues that in many ways the common belief and practice of 4th-century Christianity was worse (with regard to issues like saint veneration) than the official teaching of the Council of Trent.

Edwin
He gave me this website:
www.monergism.com

He said this website is what he believes.
 
Yes, I’ve seen that website before. It makes sense that this would be his alignment. But one can’t go about responding to a whole website!

Edwin
Read post #5 and let me know what you think. 🙂
 
So, after many years of diligent, concentrated, laborious study and being open to whatever the evidence led to, whichever way it led, it became indisputably clear, based on the evidence, that the Roman Catholic church began deviating from the Christianity of the Bible, that which was preached and taught by Jesus, the Apostles and the early Church during the middle ages, and as error crept in, which begat more error, which expotentially grew into rank heresies, and as the Roman church became a religious/political system with it’s popes and clergy being consumed by personal power, that by the time of the Lateran IV Council, Roman Catholicism had devolved into a totally separate religion from Christianity.
*
I see. So Aquinas, Francis of Assisi, Julian of Norwich, Jean Gerson, Thomas A Kempis–all not Christians in his view? (I have no illusions that he likes Julian of Norwich, but since I love her dearly I will not insult her by leaving her out.) What about Wycliffe and Hus? After all, while they differed with particular points of late medieval Catholic teaching, they were rooted in that teaching and did not reject it as a completely different religion. What about reformers such as Erasmus, Contarini (the real one–it’s my alias because I admire him), Sadoleto, or Pole in Luther’s own time? What about Luther and the other Reformers themselves? If “Roman Catholicism” had been for 300 years a completely separate religion, how did they go about reconstituting the true religion? Why didn’t they think that was what they were doing? (They thought they were reforming a seriously deformed Church, not starting anew something that had been dead for 300 years.) Why didn’t they get baptized, if the religion into which they were baptized as infants was not in fact Christianity?

Don’t get me wrong–I know that there were elements of what many of the Reformers did that implied that the “old religion” was something different from true Christianity. That’s one of my problems with the Reformation–I think Protestantism tries to have its cake and eat it too. Those of us who want to emphasize the continuities between the Reformation and what preceded need to answer a parallel set of questions. But the position that concerns us here is the position that the Reformation was the revival of a “true Christianity” that had vanished in the 13th century.

Of course, he may argue that it hadn’t entirely vanished. Then he needs to be pressed to point out where it was, and to demonstrate that the groups in question really taught what he regards as “true Christianity.”

Also, the whole notion that someone can engage in religious inquiry with a complete openness to following wherever the evidence leads is a silly one. We always bring a set of perspectives and preconceptions to such an inquiry. Failure to be honest about what those preconceptions are makes your argument completely unconvincing. Of course, he won’t agree with this–he will think it’s postmodern relativism (as do many Catholics on this forum, no doubt). But in fact I’m not a relativist–I follow Alasdair MacIntyre in this regard. I believe that there is an eternal truth outside ourselves, but I don’t think we ever approach that truth neutrally.

Edwin
 
I see. So Aquinas, Francis of Assisi, Julian of Norwich, Jean Gerson, Thomas A Kempis–all not Christians in his view? (I have no illusions that he likes Julian of Norwich, but since I love her dearly I will not insult her by leaving her out.) What about Wycliffe and Hus? After all, while they differed with particular points of late medieval Catholic teaching, they were rooted in that teaching and did not reject it as a completely different religion. What about reformers such as Erasmus, Contarini (the real one–it’s my alias because I admire him), Sadoleto, or Pole in Luther’s own time? What about Luther and the other Reformers themselves? If “Roman Catholicism” had been for 300 years a completely separate religion, how did they go about reconstituting the true religion? Why didn’t they think that was what they were doing? (They thought they were reforming a seriously deformed Church, not starting anew something that had been dead for 300 years.) Why didn’t they get baptized, if the religion into which they were baptized as infants was not in fact Christianity?

Don’t get me wrong–I know that there were elements of what many of the Reformers did that implied that the “old religion” was something different from true Christianity. That’s one of my problems with the Reformation–I think Protestantism tries to have its cake and eat it too. Those of us who want to emphasize the continuities between the Reformation and what preceded need to answer a parallel set of questions. But the position that concerns us here is the position that the Reformation was the revival of a “true Christianity” that had vanished in the 13th century.

Of course, he may argue that it hadn’t entirely vanished. Then he needs to be pressed to point out where it was, and to demonstrate that the groups in question really taught what he regards as “true Christianity.”

Also, the whole notion that someone can engage in religious inquiry with a complete openness to following wherever the evidence leads is a silly one. We always bring a set of perspectives and preconceptions to such an inquiry. Failure to be honest about what those preconceptions are makes your argument completely unconvincing. Of course, he won’t agree with this–he will think it’s postmodern relativism (as do many Catholics on this forum, no doubt). But in fact I’m not a relativist–I follow Alasdair MacIntyre in this regard. I believe that there is an eternal truth outside ourselves, but I don’t think we ever approach that truth neutrally.

Edwin
I will ask him these questions and then get back to you. 😉
 
I have recently been in debate with a reformed Catholic that says he’s a Calvinist?
Is there a difference?
Also, he’s VERY well-versed in church history and thinks that the Church of Rome is corrupt and deceitful. How do I counter that?
I can post some things that he has said to me, if that would help more. I’m just not a good apologist when someone is more knowledgable on history and such than I am. 😦
LOL, I know just who you are talking about. A guy named Kevin Johnson, right?

That “reformed Catholic” title is used by a very small group of people, and it is more for shock value than any genuine and historical terminology. They are Calvinists. The guy who runs that blog does go on anti-Catholic rants, but he does so under the guise of “scholarship.” He is into Church history (and working towards advanced degrees in that field), but his opinions are still very biased and he is not so up to date on theology.

Dave Armstrong on his blog has dealt with a lot with Johnson.
 
LOL, I know just who you are talking about. A guy named Kevin Johnson, right?

That “reformed Catholic” title is used by a very small group of people, and it is more for shock value than any genuine and historical terminology. They are Calvinists. The guy who runs that blog does go on anti-Catholic rants, but he does so under the guise of “scholarship.” He is into Church history (and working towards advanced degrees in that field), but his opinions are still very biased and he is not so up to date on theology.

Dave Armstrong on his blog has dealt with a lot with Johnson.
I don’t know what his real name is but his screen name is Saint_Iguanas and he’s not on the Catholic Answers Forums, that I know of, at least not under that screen name.
 
LOL, I know just who you are talking about. A guy named Kevin Johnson, right?
I think there are more people of this way of thinking than you recognize.
That “reformed Catholic” title is used by a very small group of people,
Relatively small compared to all the Christians in the world, but it is a term used by quite a few thoughtful Protestants.
and it is more for shock value than any genuine and historical terminology.
You are not being fair here. At least not to those who use the term as a whole. Not even to Johnson, I think. The person being described in this thread sounds like a more typical ultra-conservative Calvinist than most of the folks I’ve heard describe themselves this way.

Edwin
 
The person being described in this thread sounds like a more typical ultra-conservative Calvinist than most of the folks I’ve heard describe themselves this way.

Edwin
Me too! That’s why I brought the info on here because I can’t keep up with him and all of his knowledge. :o
 
I don’t know what his real name is but his screen name is Saint_Iguanas and he’s not on the Catholic Answers Forums, that I know of, at least not under that screen name.
OH! That is someone different. I know who that is, from CARM.

That guy is more about cheap shots than actual discussion, most of his “responses” consist of a single sentence bashing the Church. I have taken him on multiple times, on all sorts of issues, and he doesn’t get very far before he starts his insults.
 
You are not being fair here. At least not to those who use the term as a whole. Not even to Johnson, I think. The person being described in this thread sounds like a more typical ultra-conservative Calvinist than most of the folks I’ve heard describe themselves this way.

Edwin
I was talking about a specific individual, Johnson. I have read some of his stuff and he is highly selective when it comes to history, and he uses the term “reformed Catholic” as an attempt to make his position sound more historical than it is.

But you are correct, there are some groups who are not using it it off the cuff and are more the high church reformed Anglican type.
 
OH! That is someone different. I know who that is, from CARM.

That guy is more about cheap shots than actual discussion, most of his “responses” consist of a single sentence bashing the Church. I have taken him on multiple times, on all sorts of issues, and he doesn’t get very far before he starts his insults.
Yes, that is him. He is VERY insulting with his words and his overall demeanor isn’t impressing me much, despite my efforts to be charitable in our discussions. 😦
So you’ve had no luck with him either? :o
 
So you’ve had no luck with him either? :o
Not much at all. One thing I have learned is that you just have to let people like that talk and just ignore them. Don’t get drawn in with their insults or cheap shots and stick with discussions with those open to discussion.
 
Here’s his biography of his religious travels:

*Some 12 years ago, when God yanked me out of the fires of hell, regenerated my stone heart, reconstituted my self serving, unwilling will to being willing to believe, trust, love and obey Christ, I became immersed in Scripture, like a man dying of thirst in a desert who comes across a bottomless well of refreshing, life sustaining cool water.

Also, having once been a philosophy student in college, and always interested in world religions, as well as being a life long student of history, I was aware of the various groups claiming to be THE representative of Christ, claiming to be preaching and teaching the truth, one of them being Roman Catholicism, as well as Episcopalians, Eastern and Russian Orthodox, Protestants, including Lutherans, Calvinists, Baptists and Methodists, but also including other sects such as Mormons, Oneness Pentecostals, Jehovah’s Witnesses, etc.

Understanding that the consequences of what one believes are of an eternal nature, I wanted to know just who, or which group was continuing in the Gospel and doctrines preached and taught by Christ, the Apostles and the earliest Christians.

Now, understand this clearly for it is important.

At that time, I was objectively looking for which was right, and it did not matter which one. At the time I was attending a non-denominational congregation and had no firm commitment to it, and if anything, actually challenged them on some things they taught which were not in agreement with the Scriptures.

So, along with my Biblical studies, I also became immersed in studying the history of the early church, a topic I still find fascinating and encouraging, as well as began reading and studying the writings and teachings of the early church fathers, beginning with those who were the direct disciples of the Apostles themselves.

You see, I wanted to know if what groups were claiming were true or not, and whether they were in alignment with the Scriptures, and the doctrines and practices of those earliest Christians. I wanted to know the truth of the matter.

Now, getting to the point as it pertains to Roman Catholicism.

Considering the claims of Rome since the medieval period forward, that carried dire, eternal consequences if not agreed with, according to Rome, I took it very, very seriously, for if what Rome claimed was true, and it was indeed the one, true church, with rejection of it and the pope and Roman Catholic dogmas meaning eternity in hell, again I took very seriously and wanted to be absolutely sure, without any hint of any doubt whatsoever, whether Rome’s teachings, practices and claims were true or not.

I was determined that if they proved to be true, that I would join the Roman Catholic church.

If they proved not to be true, then I would not.

So, after many years of diligent, concentrated, laborious study and being open to whatever the evidence led to, whichever way it led, it became indisputably clear, based on the evidence, that the Roman Catholic church began deviating from the Christianity of the Bible, that which was preached and taught by Jesus, the Apostles and the early Church during the middle ages, and as error crept in, which begat more error, which expotentially grew into rank heresies, and as the Roman church became a religious/political system with it’s popes and clergy being consumed by personal power, that by the time of the Lateran IV Council, Roman Catholicism had devolved into a totally separate religion from Christianity.

I truly wish that had not been the case, but the facts are the facts.

If you would like to discuss some of the details using this function, rather than on the boards, so that the boards are not cluttered with our personal discussions and questions you will have that are off topic for the threads, I would be most open to that, and would welcome the opportunity to do so.

Again, it was my quest for the truth that led me to thorughly investigate all the claims of all the various groups, and not just Roman Catholicism, but since this board is about Roman Catholicism, there is no need to discuss the others.*
If he were any better at saying nothing with a multiplicity of words, he’d be a lawyer (and I can say that because I am one).

He tells you he studied diligently. Studied which books? Under whom? Who graded his progress? What degree did he earn?

He tells you he examined all the evidence. What evidence, exactly? What constituted “examination?” What qualifies him to examine anything? Who reviewed his findings?

He told you he discovered Catholicism to be “false.” What credientials does he have that you should find persuasive? What exactly did he “discover” to be false? How did he “discover” this? What makes his opinion better than yours?

He’s given you a heap of conclusions without any specific information.
 
Honestly, when you really think about it, why would you waste time debating with someone like this? Just let him know that he does not, in your opinion, reflect the love of Christ and you don’t trust him. Talk is cheap - see my signature.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top